Electrical Stimulation In Spinal Cord Injury

  Adobe Reader Version  

Allison G.T., Singer K.P., and Marshall R.N. (1996) Transfer movement strategies of individuals with spinal cord injuries. Disabil. Rehabil. 18, 35-41.
Abstract: The ability to transfer in tetraplegia is a focal point of rehabilitation. Many factors have been associated with independence in transferring, yet the majority of these are anecdotal reports. The purpose of this paper is to report preliminary findings of the study of movement strategies of individuals with spinal cord injury attempting a long sitting transfer. Analyses were made from the lateral and posterior views. Pattern recognition techniques show two distinct movement strategies in both views. These were a lift and forward flexion technique from the lateral perspective and a translatory and rotatory technique when viewed from behind. It would seem that the posterior view provides more discriminative information. It is recommended that intervention techniques, such as Functional Electrical Stimulation or orthotic devices be developed within fundamental motion analysis constructs to optimize functional outcome

Ashley E.A., Laskin J.J., Olenik L.M., Burnham R., Steadward R.D., Cumming D.C., Wheeler G.D. (1993) Evidence of autonomic dysreflexia during functional electrical stimulation in individuals with spinal cord injuries. Paraplegia 31, 593-605.

Ayas N.T., McCool F.D., Gore R., Lieberman S.L., and Brown R. (1999) Prevention of human diaphragm atrophy with short periods of electrical stimulation. Am. J. Respir. Crit Care Med. 159, 2018-2020.
Abstract: We determined whether prolonged complete inactivation of the human diaphragm results in atrophy and whether this could be prevented by brief periods of electrical phrenic nerve stimulation. We studied a subject with high spinal cord injury who required removal of his left phrenic nerve pacemaker (PNP) and the reinstitution of positive- pressure ventilation for 8 mo. During this time, the right phrenic nerve was stimulated 30 min per day. Thickness of each diaphragm (tdi) was determined by ultrasonography. Maximal tidal volume (VT) was measured during stimulation of each diaphragm separately. After left PNP reimplantation, VT and tdi were measured just before the resumption of electrical stimulation and serially for 33 wk. On the previously nonfunctioning side, there were substantial changes in VT (from 220 to 600 ml) and tdi (from 0.18 to 0.34 cm). On the side that had been stimulated, neither VT nor tdi changed appreciably (VT from 770 to 900 ml; tdi from 0.25 to 0.28 cm). We conclude that prolonged inactivation of the diaphragm causes atrophy which may be prevented by brief periods of daily phrenic nerve stimulation

Bajd T., Gregoric M., Vodovnik L., and Benko H. (1985) Electrical stimulation in treating spasticity resulting from spinal cord injury. Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil. 66, 515-517.
Abstract: To study the efficacy of electrical stimulation in treating spasticity of six spinal cord injured patients, transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) was applied to the dermatomes belonging to the same spinal cord level as the selected spastic muscle group. Spasticity was assessed in knee extensors by a pendulum test in which the knee joint angle of a swinging lower leg was recorded with an electrogoniometer. TENS was found to produce a noticeable decrease of spasticity in three of the patients, but had little effect on the others

Bajd T., Kralj A., Turk R., Benko H., Sega J. (1989) Use of functional electrical stimulation in the rehabilitation of patients with incomplete spinal cord injuries.  J Biomed Eng 11, 96-102.

Bajd T., Kralj A., and Zefran M. (1993) Unstable states in four-point walking. J. Biomed. Eng 15, 159-162.
Abstract: The presently utilized walking patterns in paraplegic subjects with complete spinal cord injury (SCI) are compared by the help of graphic representations. Improved four-point gait assisted by functional electrical stimulation (FES) and crutches is proposed by introducing unstable states into the walking sequence. The unstable states are defined as passive phases of walking where the centre of mass (COM) is gravity driven in the direction of progression. The unstable state is described by a simple inverted pendulum model. Kinematic measurements of the unstable state were performed in normal and paraplegic subjects

Bajd T., Munih M., and Kralj A. (1999) Problems associated with FES-standing in paraplegia. Technol. Health Care 7, 301-308.
Abstract: Prolonged immobilization, such as occurs after the spinal cord injury (SCI), results in several physiological problems. It has been demonstrated that the standing posture can ameliorate many of these problems. Standing exercise can be efficiently performed by the help of functional electrical stimulation (FES). The first application of FES to a paraplegic patient was reported by Kantrowitz in 1963. It was later shown by our group that standing for therapeutic purposes can be achieved by a minimum of two channels of FES delivered to both knee extensors. The properties of the stimulated knee extensors (maximal isometric joint torque, fatiguing, and spasticity) were not found as sufficient conditions for efficient standing exercise. According to our studies, the ankle joint torque during standing is the only parameter which is well correlated to the duration of FES assisted standing. For good standing low values of the ankle joint torque are required. To minimize the ankle joint torque the lever belonging to the vertical reaction force must be decreased. Adequate alignment of the posture appears to be the prerequisite for efficient FES assisted and arm supported standing exercise. Some patients are able to assume such posture by themselves, while many must be aided by additional measures. At present, surface stimulation of knee extensors combined with some appropriately "compliant shoes" looks to be adequate choice

Bajzek T.J. and Jaeger R.J. (1987) Characterization and control of muscle response to electrical stimulation. Ann. Biomed. Eng 15, 485-501.
Abstract: The maintenance of upright posture in neurologically intact human subjects is mediated by two major nervous pathways. The first, leading from the cerebral cortex through the spinal cord to motor neurons, activates muscles which produce postural movements. The second, leading from various sensory organs to higher centers, provides sensory feedback regarding the postural state. The path through the spinal cord is no longer intact in victims of spinal cord injury and loss of normal control of muscle activity results. Functional neuromuscular stimulation (FNS) has been shown as a feasible method for obtaining muscle contraction in paraplegics and has been proposed as a means for control of antero-posterior sway to make upright posture possible for these individuals. Before muscle can be controlled through the use of FNS, the response of muscle to electrical stimulation must be understood. In past studies, linear control theory has been applied to the analysis of this response and to the testing of various controllers. The aim of this study was to demonstrate some control issues in FNS using linear control theory, as it applies to electrical stimulation of muscle for stabilization of posture. The linearity of the muscle response was improved through closed-loop control using pole compensation techniques. The excess phase shift of the system due to the time delay in the muscle response, however, limits the ability to increase the open-loop gain in order to obtain improved performance. A suggestion for further study is the application of this methodology for uses in posture control

Baldi J.C., Jackson R.D., Moraille R., and Mysiw W.J. (1998) Muscle atrophy is prevented in patients with acute spinal cord injury using functional electrical stimulation. Spinal Cord. 36, 463-469.
Abstract: Severe muscle atrophy occurs rapidly following traumatic spinal cord injury (SCI). Previous research shows that neuromuscular or 'functional' electrical stimulation (FES), particularly FES-cycle ergometry (FES-CE) can cause muscle hypertrophy in individuals with chronic SCI (> 1 year post-injury). However, the modest degree of hypertrophy in these already atrophied muscles has lessened earlier hopes that FES therapy would reduce secondary impairments of SCI. It is not known whether FES treatments are effective when used to prevent, rather than reverse, muscle atrophy in individuals with acute SCI. This study explored whether unloaded isometric FES contractions (FES-IC) or FES-CE decreased subsequent muscle atrophy in individual with acute SCI (< 3 months post-injury). Twenty-six subjects, 14-15 weeks post- traumatic SCI, were assigned to control, FES-IC, or FES-CE against progessively increasing resistance. Subjects were involved in the study for 3 or 6 months. Total body lean body mass (TB-LBM), lower limb lean body mass (LL-LBM), and gluteal lean body mass (G-LBM) were determined before the study, and at 3 and 6 months using dual energy X-ray absorptiometry (DEXA). Controls lost an average of 6.1%, 10.1%, 12.4%, after 3 months and 9.5%, 21.4%, 26.8% after 6 months in TB-LBM, LL-LBM and G-LBM respectively. Subjects in the FES-IC group consistently lost less lean body mass than controls, however, only 6 month G-LBM loss was significantly attenuated in this group relative to the controls. In the FES-CE group, LL-LBM and G-LBM loss were prevented at both 3 and 6 months, and TB-LBM loss was prevented at 6 months. In addition, FES-CE significantly increased G-LBM and LL-LBM after 6 months of training relative to pre-training levels. Within the control group, there was no significant relationship between LL-LBM loss (3 and 6 months) and the number of days between injury and baseline measurement. In summary, this study shows that FES-CE, but not FES-IC, training prevents muscle atrophy in acute SCI after 3 months of training, and causes significant hypertrophy after 6 months. The magnitude of differences in regionalized LBM between controls and FES-CE subject raises hopes that such treatment may indeed be beneficial in preventing secondary impairments of SCI if employed before extensive post-injury atrophy occurs

Baratta R.V. and Solomonow M. (1992) The dynamic performance model of skeletal muscle. Crit Rev. Biomed. Eng 19, 419-454.
Abstract: Applications of electrical stimulation to the nerve or muscles associated with a defunct limb joint due to stroke or spinal cord injury are a viable means of restoring a certain level of functional movement to the patient. In this article, the currently acceptable physiology of motor control is outlined and used as a criterion for electrophysiological and biomechanical performance evaluation of contemporary electrical stimulation strategies used by various systems attempting to duplicate such motor control in an effort to restore meaningful limb function. Strategies associated with surface, nerve, intramuscular, and reflex stimulation are critically reviewed with special reference to voluntary sensory motor control of a limb joint rather than an isolated muscle

Barbeau H., Norman K., Fung J., Visintin M., and Ladouceur M. (1998) Does neurorehabilitation play a role in the recovery of walking in neurological populations? Ann. N. Y. Acad. Sci. 860, 377-392.
Abstract: This review demonstrates that neurorehabilitation approaches, based on recent neuroscience findings, can enhance locomotor recovery after a spinal cord injury or stroke. Findings are presented from more than 20 clinical studies conducted by numerous research groups on the effect of locomotor training using either body weight support (BWS), functional electrical stimulation (FES), pharmacological approaches or a combination of them. Among the approaches, only BWS-assisted locomotor training has been demonstrated to have a greater effect than conventional or locomotor training alone. However, when study results were combined and weighted for the number of subjects, the results indicated that there is a gradient of effects from small changes with the immediate application of FES or BWS to larger changes when locomotor training is combined with FES or BWS or pharmacological approaches. The findings of these studies suggest that these neurorehabilitation approaches do play a role in the recovery of walking in subjects with spinal cord injury or stroke. Several factors contribute to the potential for recovery including the site, etiology, and chronicity of the injury, as well as the type, duration, and specificity of the intervention and whether interventions are combined. Furthermore, how these neurorehabilitation approaches may take advantage of the plasticity process following neurological lesion is also discussed

Barstow T.J., Scremin A.M., Mutton D.L., Kunkel C.F., Cagle T.G., and Whipp B.J. (1995) Gas exchange kinetics during functional electrical stimulation in subjects with spinal cord injury. Med. Sci. Sports Exerc. 27, 1284-1291.
Abstract: We examined the kinetics of VO2, VCO2, and VE following the onset of unloaded leg cycling, and in recovery, in six patients with spinal cord injury (SCI). Exercise was produced by functional electrical stimulation (FES) of the quadriceps, hamstrings, and gluteal muscles. End-exercise VO2 (1.03 +/- 0.16 l.min-1), VCO2 (1.20 +/- 0.22 l.min-1) and VE (41 +/- 10 l.min-1) were elevated compared to values typically seen in healthy ambulatory subjects performing similar unloaded cycling. Mean response times for the on transients (MRTon) were both long and variable across subjects for VO2 (165 +/- 62 s), VCO2 (173 +/- 58 s), and VE (202 +/- 61 s). Recovery kinetics showed much less intersubject variability, and for five of six subjects were faster than the equivalent exercise MRT for all three variables (MRToff for VO2 of 103 +/- 28 s, VCO2 136 +/- 20 s, and VE 144 +/- 34 s), but P > 0.05 for all three. Size of the O2 deficit (1.96 +/- 0.90 l) and end-exercise lactate (7.05 +/- 1.65 mmol.l-1) were similar to values reported for healthy sedentary subjects performing maximal voluntary exercise, but the end-exercise heart rate (102 +/- 16 bpm) was lower than expected for this intensity of exercise. In conclusion, FES-induced unloaded cycling leads to exaggerated responses of pulmonary gas exchange and long time constants in patients with SCI. The delayed kinetics may be due in part to a blunted increase in heart rate in addition to severe deconditioning

Barstow T.J., Scremin A.M., Mutton D.L., Kunkel C.F., Cagle T.G., and Whipp B.J. (1996) Changes in gas exchange kinetics with training in patients with spinal cord injury. Med. Sci. Sports Exerc. 28, 1221-1228.
Abstract: We examined the ability of patients with spinal cord injury to undergo adaptations to chronic exercise training (cycle ergometry) invoked by functional electrical stimulation (FES) of the legs. Nine such patients performed incremental and constant work rate exercise before and after exercise training. Exercise sessions averaged 2.1 +/- 0.4/wk, and consisted of 30 min/session of continuous FES recumbent cycling with increasing work rate as tolerated. Peak VO2 and peak work rate significantly improved with training. Peak VO2 was significantly correlated with peak heart rate both before and after training (r = 0.97 pre and 0.85 post, P < 0.01 for both). The time course of the VO2, VCO2 and VE responses to constant-load exercise (unloaded cycling) and in recovery (mean response time MRT) were very long prior to training, and became significantly faster following training. However, there was no correlation between percentage improvement in either MRTon or MRToff for VO2 and the percentage increase in peak VO2. Exercise tolerance in these patients with spinal cord injury appears to be a direct function of the ability to increase heart rate. Further, exercise training can elicit significant improvements in both exercise tolerance and in gas exchange kinetics, even when performed only twice per week. However, these improvements may be accomplished by different mechanisms

Barstow T.J., Scremin A.M., Mutton D.L., Kunkel C.F., Cagle T.G., and Whipp B.J. (2000) Peak and kinetic cardiorespiratory responses during arm and leg exercise in patients with spinal cord injury. Spinal Cord. 38, 340-345.
Abstract: STUDY DESIGN: A paired comparison of the peak and submaximal responses of oxygen uptake and heart rate in patients with spinal cord injury (SCI) performing voluntary arm cycle exercise and functional electrical stimulation (FES) leg cycling exercise. OBJECTIVES: To test if the blunted heart rate response and slower rate of adjustment of oxygen uptake seen in patients with SCI performing FES leg cycle exercise are also characteristic of arm exercise in these patients. METHODS: Eight paraplegics performed incremental and constant work rate (CWR) exercise with the legs and arms. Mean response times (MRT) for Vo2 during exercise (on) and in recovery (off) were calculated from the breath-by- breath Vo2 profile. RESULTS: Peak heart rate was higher during incremental arm exercise, and uncorrelated with that observed during incremental FES leg cycling. For the same increase in Vo2, constant work rate arm exercise was associated with faster (and normal) Vo2 kinetics, greater increase in heart rate, and lower end-exercise blood lactate, compared to FES leg cycling. CONCLUSIONS: The consistently higher peak heart rate and Vo2, and faster Vo2 kinetics, for voluntary arm compared to FES leg cycle exercise suggest no intrinsic dysfunction of heart rate control in these paraplegics. Rather, these data suggest that during FES leg cycling the changes seen are due to some characteristic specific to the injury, such as reduced muscle mass and/or deconditioning of the remaining muscle. SPONSORSHIP: This research was supported by The Department of Veterans Affairs, Rehabilitation Research and Development Project #B603-RA. Spinal Cord (2000) 38,

Bauchet L., Segnarbieux F., Martinazzo G., Frerebeau P., and Ohanna F. (2001) [Neurosurgical treatment of hyperactive bladder in spinal cord injury patients]. Neurochirurgie 47, 13-24.
Abstract: OBJECTIVES: We report long-term results of posterior sacral root rhizotomies in combination with Finetech-Brindley anterior sacral root stimulators implanted intradurally in 20 spinal cord injury patients. MATERIAL: and methods: The 14 female and 6 male patients included 14 paraplegics and 6 tetraplegics. All of them initially presented hyperactive bladder, detrusor-sphincter dyssynergia, recurrent urinary tract infection and performed (self) intermittent catheterization. Prior to implantation, an intrathecal test using bupivacaine was performed to confirm the compliances of the bladder. The main indication for implantation was persistent urinary incontinence refractory to medical therapy. RESULTS: After implantation the mean follow-up was 4,5 years. In all, 18 patients used the stimulator alone for bladder emptying and 18 patients were completely continent. The mean bladder capacity increased from 190 ml preoperatively to 460 ml after the operation. The mean residual urinary volume was reduced from 90 ml to 25 ml. No changes were noted by renal isotopic scanning in upper urinary tracts of patients. In 1 patient, a second extradural implant was performed. DISCUSSION: This article also include an overview of a) the different available sites where application of electrical stimulation results in a detrusor contraction, b) the benefits and disadvantages of the sacral posterior rhizotomy, c) selective stimulation techniques that allow selective detrusor activation by sacral root stimulation. CONCLUSION: Sacral anterior root stimulation combined with sacral posterior rhizotomy is a valuable method to restore bladder functions in spinal cord injured patients suffering from hyperactive bladder refractory to medical therapy

Bauman W.A., Spungen A.M., Adkins R.H., and Kemp B.J. (1999) Metabolic and endocrine changes in persons aging with spinal cord injury. Assist. Technol. 11, 88-96.
Abstract: Persons with spinal cord injury (SCI) have secondary medical disabilities that impair their ability to function. With paralysis, dramatic deleterious changes in body composition occur acutely with further adverse changes ensuing with increasing duration of injury. Lean mass, composed of skeletal muscle and bone, is lost and adiposity is relatively increased. The body composition changes may be further exacerbated by associated reductions in anabolic hormones, testosterone, and growth hormone. Individuals with SCI also have decreased levels of activity. These body composition and activity changes are associated with insulin resistance, disorders in carbohydrate and lipid metabolism, and may be associated with premature cardiovascular disease. Although limited information is available, upper body exercise and cycle ergometry of the lower extremities by functional electrical stimulation (FES) have been reported to have a salutary effect on these body composition and metabolic sequelae of paralysis. Perhaps other innovative, externally mediated forms of active exercise of the paralyzed extremities will result in an increased functional capacity, metabolic improvement, and reduction of atherosclerotic vascular disease

BeDell K.K., Scremin A.M.E., Perell K.L., Kunkel C.F. (1996) Effects of functional electrical stimulation-induced lower extremity cycling on bone density of spinal-cord injured patients. Am J Phys Med Rehabil 75, 29-34.

Belanger M., Stein R.B., Wheeler G.D., Gordon T., and Leduc B. (2000) Electrical stimulation: can it increase muscle strength and reverse osteopenia in spinal cord injured individuals? Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil. 81, 1090-1098.
Abstract: OBJECTIVE: To study the extent to which atrophy of muscle and progressive weakening of the long bones after spinal cord injury (SCI) can be reversed by functional electrical stimulation (FES) and resistance training. DESIGN: A within-subject, contralateral limb, and matching design. SETTING: Research laboratories in university settings. PARTICIPANTS: Fourteen patients with SCI (C5 to T5) and 14 control subjects volunteered for this study. INTERVENTIONS: The left quadriceps were stimulated to contract against an isokinetic load (resisted) while the right quadriceps contracted against gravity (unresisted) for 1 hour a day, 5 days a week, for 24 weeks. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Bone mineral density (BMD) of the distal femur, proximal tibia, and mid-tibia obtained by dual energy x-ray absorptiometry, and torque (strength). RESULTS: Initially, the BMD of SCI subjects was lower than that of controls. After training, the distal femur and proximal tibia had recovered nearly 30% of the bone lost, compared with the controls. There was no difference in the mid-tibia or between the sides at any level. There was a large strength gain, with the rate of increase being substantially greater on the resisted side. CONCLUSION: Osteopenia of the distal femur and proximal tibia and the loss of strength of the quadriceps can be partly reversed by regular FES-assisted training

Benzel E.C., Barolat-Romana G., and Larson S.J. (1988) Femoral obturator and sciatic neurectomy with iliacus and psoas muscle section for spasticity following spinal cord injury. Spine 13, 905-908.
Abstract: The treatment of severe refractory spasticity following spinal cord injury may raise challenging therapeutic problems. Classical approaches involve various types of myelotomies, rhizotomies and intrathecal injections of neurolytic substances. Alternative approaches include percutaneous rhizotomies and, more recently, the possible use of electrical stimulation of the spinal cord. Certain cases, however, may not be amenable to commonly accepted techniques. An operative technique is presented which involves a suprapubic incision for an infraperitoneal approach to a femoral and obturator neurectomy and an incision of the iliacus and psoas muscles bilaterally. This may be followed, when indicated, by a bilateral infragluteal section of the sciatic nerves. This technique offers a viable surgical alternative to the treatment of spasticity following spinal cord injury in cases where other traditional methods are contraindicated or have failed

Betz R., Boden B., Triolo R., Mesgarzadeh M., Gardner E., and Fife R. (1996) Effects of functional electrical stimulation on the joints of adolescents with spinal cord injury. Paraplegia 34, 127-136.
Abstract: Nineteen adolescent subjects with complete spinal cord injuries resulting in paraplegia or tetraplegia participated in a functional electrical stimulation (FES) program consisting of computerized, controlled exercise and/or weight bearing. The effects of stimulated exercise and standing/walking on the lower extremity joints were prospectively studied. Plain radiographs and MRIs were obtained prior to and following completion of the exercise and standing and walking stages. In addition, the joints of five subjects were studied with synovial biopsies, arthroscopy, and the analysis of serum and synovial fluid for a 550 000 dalton cartilage matrix glycoprotein (CMGP). Pre- exercise joint abnormalities secondary to the spinal cord injury improved following the stimulation program. None of the subjects developed Charcot joint changes. Upon standing with FES, one subject with poor hip coverage prior to participation developed hip subluxation which required surgical repair. No other detrimental clinical effects occurred in the lower extremity joints of subjects participating in an FES program over a 1-year period

Betz R.R., Mulcahey M.J., Smith B.T., Triolo R.J., Weiss A.A., Moynahan M., Keith M.W., and Peckham P.H. (1992) Bipolar latissimus dorsi transposition and functional neuromuscular stimulation to restore elbow flexion in an individual with C4 quadriplegia and C5 denervation. J. Am. Paraplegia Soc. 15, 220-228.
Abstract: A bipolar latissimus dorsi transposition was performed on a 17-year-old male patient with a C4 spinal cord injury and complete peripheral denervation at C5. Electrical stimulation of the paralyzed but excitable latissimus dorsi provided elbow flexion that could not be achieved with the paralyzed and denervated elbow flexors. The muscle was attached from the coracoid to the ulna allowing the elbow to be flexed with the forearm and wrist maintained in the neutral position. Following a 6-week immobilization period, the transposed muscle was exercised daily with intramuscular stimulation to increase both strength and endurance. By the fourth month after surgery, the subject could control elbow flexion proportionally with contralateral shoulder elevation using a shoulder position transducer. Functionally, the subject was able to use the neuroprosthetic system to bring his hand to his mouth and feed himself with the aid of a universal cuff and a support to stabilize the shoulder

Bhambhani Y., Tuchak C., Burnham R., Jeon J., and Maikala R. (2000) Quadriceps muscle deoxygenation during functional electrical stimulation in adults with spinal cord injury. Spinal Cord. 38, 630-638.
Abstract: STUDY DESIGN: Cross-sectional study comparing healthy subjects with age and gender matched subjects with spinal cord injury (SCI, injury levels from C5 to T12). OBJECTIVES: To compare the acute cardiorespiratory responses and muscle oxygenation trends during functional electrical stimulation (FES) cycle exercise and recovery in the SCI and healthy subjects exercising on a mechanical cycle ergometer. SETTING: Seven volunteers in each group participated in one exercise test at the Rick Hansen Center, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Canada. METHODS: Both groups completed a stagewise incremental test to voluntary fatigue followed by 2 min each of active and passive recovery. Cardiorespiratory responses were continuously monitored using an automated metabolic cart and a wireless heart rate monitor. Tissue absorbency, an index of muscle oxygenation, was monitored non- invasively from the vastus lateralis using near infrared spectroscopy. RESULTS: The healthy subjects showed significant (P<0.05) increases in the oxygen uptake (VO2), heart rate (HR) and ventilation rate (VE) from rest to maximal exercise. The SCI subjects showed a twofold increase in VO2 (P>0.05), a threefold increase in VE (P<0.05) and a 5 beats/min increase in HR (P>0.05) from the resting value. The SCI subjects demonstrated a lesser degree (P<0.05) of muscle deoxygenation than the healthy subjects during the transition from rest to exercise. Regression analysis indicated that the rate of decline in muscle deoxygenation with respect to the VO2 was significantly (P<0.05) faster in the SCI subjects compared to healthy subjects. CONCLUSIONS: FES exercise in SCI subjects elicits: (a) modest increases in the cardiorespiratory responses when compared to resting levels; (b) lower degree of muscle deoxygenation during maximal exercise, and (c) faster changes in muscle deoxygenation with respect to the VO2 during exercise when compared to healthy subjects

Blight A.R. (1986) Motor evoked potentials in CNS trauma.  Cent. Nerv. Syst. Trauma 3, 207-214.
Abstract: The evolving techniques of motor evoked potential (MEP) monitoring are reviewed here with reference to their application in clinical and experimental CNS trauma, and with particular relevance to spinal cord injury. Transcutaneous electrical stimulation of the motor cortex for analysis of descending pathways has been developed over the past 6 years in a number of centers. It has now been greatly augmented by the introduction of magnetic stimulation technology. The MEP offers a valuable insight into the physiological status of motor tracts within the spinal cord and is applicable to conscious patients, intraoperative monitoring, and animal studies. It is seen as complementary to somatosensory evoked potential monitoring rather than an alternative or replacement for it. The chief limitations of the technique, common to all evoked potential methods, are the restricted information content, and the need for rigorous electrophysiological interpretation of the resulting signals, if meaningful diagnostic data are to be extracted

Block J.E., Steinbach L.S., Friedlander A.L., Steiger P., Ellis W., Morris J.M., and Genant H.K. (1989) Electrically-stimulated muscle hypertrophy in paraplegia: assessment by quantitative CT. J. Comput. Assist. Tomogr. 13, 852-854.
Abstract: To identify the magnitude of muscle hypertrophy following electrically stimulated exercise in paraplegic subjects, we used quantitative CT (QCT) of the midthigh prior to and following 6 weeks of bicycle ergometry. Three patients who had suffered acute spinal cord injury were examined in this pilot investigation. Average absolute changes in muscle cross-sectional area by QCT were determined to be 10.6 cm2 (p = 0.042) at a distal site located 100 mm above the tibial plateau and 18.8 cm2 (p = 0.019) at a more proximal site (175 mm). Expressed as a percentage increase, these changes were likewise found to be significant. When the total thigh musculature was segmented into anterior and posterior regions, significant increases were observed only among the anterior muscle groups at both the distal and the proximal sites. Muscle hypertrophy as determined by standard anthropometric techniques at 200 mm above the patella was not found to be significant. We conclude that QCT is a valuable technique for discerning changes in muscle size during fitness training and that, in our population, it was capable of differentiating specific muscle compartment hypertrophy secondary to electrical stimulation

Bogey R.A., Perry J., Bontrager E.L., Gronley J.K. (2000) Comparison of across-subject EMG profiles using surface and multiple indwelling wire electrodes during gait. J Electromyogr Kinesiol 10:255-259.

Bonaroti D., Akers J., Smith B.T., Mulcahey M.J., and Betz R.R. (1999) A comparison of FES with KAFO for providing ambulation and upright mobility in a child with a complete thoracic spinal cord injury. J. Spinal Cord. Med. 22, 159-166.
Abstract: This study compared functional and physiologic measures of ambulation and upright mobility with functional electrical stimulation (FES) versus knee-ankle-foot-orthoses (KAFO) in an 11-year-old boy with a T- 10 level spinal cord injury. The child was a limited community ambulator with bilateral KAFO and loftstrand crutches. The FES system consisted of percutaneous intramuscular electrodes controlled by a portable stimulator and thumbswitch, an AFO for ankle and foot support, and loftstrand crutches. The subject used a swing-through gait pattern with both modes of mobility. The Functional Independence Measure scoring system and time to completion were used to compare performance in 6 standardized activities: donning, high transfer, inaccessible toilet transfer, ascend/descend stairs, and floor-to-standing transfer. Ten repeated measures were performed for each mode. Physiologic measures included energy expenditure, postural stability using forceplates, and a Functional Standing Test (FST). The subject performed all 6 mobility activities independently with FES and KAFO. In 4 of 6 activities, there was a trend toward faster times with FES, but this was not statistically significant. Toilet transfers and stair descent were performed significantly faster with KAFO. There was no difference in completion times on the activities of the FST. Measures of postural sway suggested that the subject was more stable with KAFO during quiet standing, while the modes were equal during a dynamic activity (raising arm for functional use). Energy expenditure results revealed no significant difference in oxygen cost per meter but a significantly higher oxygen consumption rate per minute for FES. Ambulation with both modes was performed at levels consistent with strenuous exercise. Maximum ambulation distances were relatively equal while the subject's velocity was significantly faster with FES. Of note, the subject reported ceasing ambulation during maximum distance trials due to general fatigue when using FES and due to shoulder pain with KAFO ambulation. For this subject, FES provided a means of performing upright mobility tasks independently, comparable with that of KAFO, while providing a faster ambulation velocity and a potential means of cardiovascular training

Bradley M.B. (1994) The effect of participating in a functional electrical stimulation exercise program on affect in people with spinal cord injuries. Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil. 75, 676-679.
Abstract: Functional electrical stimulation (FES) is a technology that is increasingly being used in the acute and post rehabilitation of people with spinal cord injuries. Though there has been considerable interest in the potential psychological effects of FES, little research has been done in this area. This study examined the effect of participation in an FES exercise program on affect in 37 persons with spinal cord injury. The effect of the subjects' expectations is also examined. Results indicate significant changes in negative affective status but no significant changes in positive affect. In particular, the results show increases in depression and hostility in subjects in the treatment group who had unrealistic expectations for the FES program. It is important to identify and monitor FES participants who have unrealistic expectations

Brindley G.S. (1994) The first 500 patients with sacral anterior root stimulator implants: General description. Paraplegia 32, 795-805.

Brissot R., Gallien P., Le Bot M.P., Beaubras A., Laisne D., Beillot J., and Dassonville J. (2000) Clinical

experience with functional electrical stimulation-assisted gait with Parastep in spinal cord-injured patients. Spine 25, 501-508.
Abstract: STUDY DESIGN: Clinical evaluation of the Parastep method, a six-channel transcutaneous functional electrical stimulation device, in spinal cord- injured patients. OBJECTIVES: To investigate the motor performances of this new technique regarding energy expenditure and to evaluate its advantages and limitations, especially in social activities involving ambulation. METHODS: This study was conducted in 15 thoracic spine- injured patients. The lesion was complete except in two patients. The gait ability and the functional use were judged clinically. Energy cost was evaluated from heart rate, peak oxygen uptake, and lactatemia. RESULTS: Thirteen patients completed the training (mean: 20 sessions) and achieved independent ambulation with a walker. The mean walking distance, without rest, was 52.8 +/- 69 m, and the mean speed was 0.15 +/- 0.14 m/sec. One patient with incomplete lesion, who had been nonambulatory for 8 months after the injury, became able to walk without functional electrical stimulation after five sessions. The follow-up was 40 +/- 11 months. Five patients pursued using functional electrical stimulation-assisted gait as a means of physical exercise but not for ambulation in social activities. The patients experienced marked psychological benefits, with positive changes in their way of life. In three subjects, a comparison of physiologic responses to exercise between a progressive arm ergometer test and a walking test with the Parastep (Sigmedics, Inc., Northfield, IL) at a speed of 0.1 m/sec was performed, showing that the heart rate, the peak oxygen uptake, and lactatemia during gait were close to those obtained at the end of the maximal test on the ergometer. CONCLUSIONS: In spite of its ease of operation and good cosmetic acceptance, the Parastep approach has very limited applications for mobility in daily life, because of its modest performance associated with high metabolic cost and cardiovascular strain. However, it can be proposed as a resource to keep physical and psychological fitness in patients with spinal cord injury

Bruninga K., Riedy L., Keshavarzian A., and Walter J. (1998) The effect of electrical stimulation on colonic transit following spinal cord injury in cats. Spinal Cord. 36, 847-853.
Abstract: The effect of direct electrical stimulation on colinic transit and manometric recordings following spinal cord injury were assessed in five adult male cats. Intra-colonic catheters were surgically placed, stimulating electrodes were sutured to the colonic serosa and a laminectomy with spinal cord clamping at a T4 level was done to induce spinal cord injury (SCI). Twenty radiopaque markers were inserted through an intra-colonic catheter located 1 cm distal to the cecum and were monitored with daily fluoroscopy as a measure of colonic transit. Transit measurements were compared before SCI, after SCI and after SCI with electrical stimulation of 40 pps, 1 ms, and 0-50 mA. Colonic transit following SCI was significantly prolonged (P<0.05) when compared to the transit before SCI. Electrical stimulation following SCI improved colonic transit to values not significantly different from those before SCI. Spontaneous colonic phasic motor activity was similar both before and after SCI. Manometric defection patterns were also observed to be similar before SCI and after SCI with electrical stimulation. Based on our scoring criteria, the most frequent response to electrical stimulation was an abdominal contraction. These findings demonstrate that colonic transit is prolonged following SCI and that direct electrical stimulation of the colon following SCI improves colonic transit in an animal model

Buchanan L.E., Ditunno J.F., Jr., Osterholm J.L., Cotler J.M., and Staas W.E., Jr. (1990) Spinal cord injury: a ten-year report. Pa Med. 93, 36-39.
Abstract: In the past 10 years, the RSCICDV has had a unique opportunity to serve and expand the bounds of knowledge regarding this most devastating injury. The RSCICDV has collaborated with other model SCI systems in research regarding the incidence of respiratory complications, the value of removing bullet fragments lodged within the spinal canal, the survival/cause of death following spinal cord injury, the cost of spinal cord injury care, and the recovery of motor strength after quadriplegia. Key on-site research efforts have focused on preventing deep vein thrombosis and in documenting the course of motor recovery after spinal cord injury. The identification of electrical stimulation plus low dose heparin as a prophylaxis has been a major breakthrough in the prevention of deep vein thrombosis. The documentation of motor recovery after injury has led to the designation of Thomas Jefferson University as a federally-funded National Rehabilitation Research and Training Center in Neural Recovery and Functional Enhancement (1988- 1993). It cannot be stressed enough, however, that the accomplishments of the Regional Spinal Cord Injury Center of Delaware Valley would have been quite impossible without the cooperation and support of the many physicians who have referred their patients to this regional center program. Continuing and expanding this cooperative effort should result in even greater achievements for persons with spinal cord injury in the years to come

Burridge J., Taylor P., Hagan S., and Swain I. (1997) Experience of clinical use of the Odstock dropped foot stimulator. Artif. Organs 21, 254-260.
Abstract: The Odstock dropped foot stimulator (ODFS) is a simple functional electrical stimulation (FES) device for the correction of dropped foot. Improved reliability, fine control of stimulation parameters, and careful application and follow-up have let to 86% compliance. Data on 56 patients (50 patients with hemiplegia, 5 patients with multiple sclerosis, and 1 patient with spinal cord injury) who have used the system for between 6 and 18 months are presented and show a statistically significant increase in walking speed with the stimulator at 3 months of 14% (p < 0.001); decreased effort of walking, measured as physiological cost index (PCI), of 37% (p < 0.001); and statistically significant improvement in functional mobility tests and questionnaires. No statistically significant carryover was seen although 3 patients had sufficient improvement in active ankle control and gait parameters to no longer need the stimulator. Six patients who used the stimulator all day every day had a problem with skin irritation, which we have not yet been able to solve. Two patients discontinued use after experiencing increased spasticity in the calf

Campbell J.M., Gerber N., Mathe C. (1988) Innervation status of muscles paralyzed by SCI. Phys Ther 68, 864.

Campbell J.M., Meadows P.M., Waters R.L. (1991) Spasticity in SCI: day to day variability in response to joint movement and electrical stimulation. Proc 14 Annual RESNA Conf , Kansas City, MO, pp 274-276.

Campbell J.M., Meadows P.M., Wederich C., Waters R.L. (1992) FNS Knee Extension in paraplegia: factors associated with gains in muscle performance. Proc 15 Annual RESNA Conf, Toronto, Canada, pp 225-227.

Campbell J.M., Meadows P.M. (1992) Therapeutic FES: From Rehabilitation to Neural Prosthetics. Assistive Technology 4, 4-18.

Campbell J.M., Meadows P.M., Monlux J., Waters R.L., Wederich C. (1994) FES in SCI: Comprehensive Management of Muscle Performance in Complete and Incomplete Paralysis. Basic and Applied Myology 4, 187-194.

Campos R.J., Dimitrijevic M.M., Faganel J., and Sharkey P.C. (1981) Clinical evaluation of the effect of spinal cord stimulation on motor performance in patients with upper motor neuron lesions. Appl. Neurophysiol. 44, 141-151.
Abstract: The effect of chronic electrical stimulation of the spinal cord was evaluated in a group of 24 patients with multiple sclerosis, spinal cord injury, and degenerative disorders of the central nervous system. The systems for stimulation had been implanted from 12 to 30 months prior to completion of evaluation. At the time of completion of evaluation, 23 of the 24 patients still had implanted systems, although 6 of them had not used spinal cord stimulation because of no noticeable effect. In 3 patients stimulation had been disconnected because of technical failure of the system. In 1 patient the system had been removed 8 weeks after implantation because of inflammation in the under- skin receiver pocket. The effects on motor performance of the remaining 14 patients who had continuously active systems were improved bladder control, diminished spasticity, improved movement coordination, and increased endurance

Castro M.J., Apple D.F., Jr., Staron R.S., Campos G.E., and Dudley G.A. (1999) Influence of complete spinal cord injury on skeletal muscle within 6 mo of injury. J. Appl. Physiol 86, 350-358.
Abstract: This study examined the influence of spinal cord injury (SCI) on affected skeletal muscle. The right vastus lateralis muscle was biopsied in 12 patients as soon as they were clinically stable (average 6 wk after SCI), and 11 and 24 wk after injury. Samples were also taken from nine able-bodied controls at two time points 18 wk apart. Surface electrical stimulation (ES) was applied to the left quadriceps femoris muscle to assess fatigue at these same time intervals. Biopsies were analyzed for fiber type percent and cross-sectional area (CSA), fiber type-specific succinic dehydrogenase (SDH) and alpha-glycerophosphate dehydrogenase (GPDH) activities, and myosin heavy chain percent. Controls showed no change in any variable over time. Patients showed 27- 56% atrophy (P = 0.000) of type I, IIa, and IIax+IIx fibers from 6 to 24 wk after injury, resulting in fiber CSA approximately one-third that of controls. Their fiber type specific SDH and GPDH activities increased (P </= 0.001) from 32 to 90% over the 18 wk, thereby approaching or surpassing control values. The relative CSA of type I fibers and percentage of myosin heavy chain type I did not change. There was apparent conversion among type II fiber subtypes; type IIa decreased and type IIax+IIx increased (P </= 0.012). Force loss during ES did not change over time for either group but was greater (P = 0.000) for SCI patients than for controls overall (27 vs. 9%). The results indicate that vastus lateralis muscle shows marked fiber atrophy, no change in the proportion of type I fibers, and a relative independence of metabolic enzyme levels from activation during the first 24 wk after clinically complete SCI. Over this time, quadriceps femoris muscle showed moderately greater force loss during ES in patients than in controls. It is suggested that the predominant response of mixed human skeletal muscle within 6 mo of SCI is loss of contractile protein. Therapeutic interventions could take advantage of this to increase muscle mass

Chaplin E.R. (1996) Functional Neuromuscular Stimulation for Mobility in People with Spinal Cord Injuries - The Parastep System. J Spinal Cord Med 19, 100-105.

Chen D., Jaeger R.J. (1977) Functional Electrical Stimulation: Technical Advances and Clinical Applications. Phys Med & Rehabil: State of the Art Reviews 11, 39-53.

Closson J.B., Toerge J.E., Ragnarsson K.T., Parsons K.C., and Lammertse D.P. (1991) Rehabilitation in spinal cord disorders. 3. Comprehensive management of spinal cord injury. Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil. 72, S298-S308.
Abstract: This self-directed learning module highlights advances in the management of the person with a spinal cord deficit. Traumatic spinal cord injury is being used as the model, but the principles apply to all patients with spinal cord deficits. This article is part of the chapter on rehabilitation of spinal cord disorders for the Self-Directed Medical Knowledge Program Study Guide for practitioners and trainees in physical medicine and rehabilitation. Specifically, this section contains information regarding prehospital care, acute assessment and management, primary rehabilitation by systems, sexuality and psychosocial issues, management of pain and spasticity, functional goals, the role of functional electrical stimulation, and long-term follow-up

Crago P.E., Memberg W.D., Usey M.K., Keith M.W., Kirsch R.F., Chapman G.J., Katorgi M.A., and Perreault E.J. (1998) An elbow extension neuroprosthesis for individuals with tetraplegia. IEEE Trans. Rehabil. Eng 6, 1-6.
Abstract: Functional electrical stimulation (FES) of the triceps to restore control of elbow extension was integrated into a portable hand grasp neuroprosthesis for use by people with cervical level spinal cord injury. An accelerometer mounted on the upper arm activated triceps stimulation when the arm was raised above a predetermined threshold angle. Elbow posture was controlled by the subjects voluntarily flexing to counteract the stimulated elbow extension. The elbow moments created by the stimulated triceps were at least 4 N.m, which was sufficient to extend the arm against gravity. Electrical stimulation of the triceps increased the range of locations and orientations in the workspace over which subjects could grasp and move objects. In addition, object acquisition speed was increased. Thus elbow extension enhances a person's ability to grasp and manipulate objects in an unstructured environment

Crameri R.M., Weston A.R., Rutkowski S., Middleton J.W., Davis G.M., and Sutton J.R. (2000) Effects of electrical stimulation leg training during the acute phase of spinal cord injury: a pilot study. Eur. J. Appl. Physiol 83, 409-415.
Abstract: Four individuals with a spinal cord injury underwent 16 weeks of isometric electrical stimulation training to both legs for 60 min, five times per week during the first 5 months after injury, while two SCI individuals remained untrained. A baseline biopsy sample of the vastus lateralis muscle was obtained within 1 month of injury, and another biopsy sample was taken after a further 16 weeks. The untrained, paralyzed skeletal muscle displayed a reduction in (1) type I fibers (from 50% to 9%), (2) myosin heavy chain (MHC) I (from 27% to 6%), and (3) fiber cross-sectional area of type I, type IIA and type IIX fibers (-62%, -68%, and -55%, respectively) when compared to the baseline sample of muscle taken within 1 month of injury. In contrast, the trained group showed smaller alterations in type I fibers (from 49% to 40%) and MHC I composition (from 39% to 25%), while fiber cross- sectional area was similar to baseline levels for type I, type IIA and type IIX fibers (-3%, -8%, and -4%, respectively). In conclusion, electrical stimulation training can largely prevent the adverse effects of a spinal cord injury upon paralyzed human skeletal muscle if applied soon after the injury

Creasey G.H. (1993) Electrical stimulation of sacral roots for micturition after spinal cord injury. Urol. Clin. North Am. 20, 505-515.
Abstract: In patients with suprasacral spinal cord injury, electrical stimulation of the sacral anterior nerve roots can produce micturition with low residual volumes of urine and reduced urinary tract infection. Voiding pressures can be maintained at acceptable levels by selective peripheral neurotomy and myotomy or, more commonly, by an intermittent pattern of stimulation. Occasionally, external sphincterotomy is required. The procedure is usually combined with division of the sacral posterior roots, which increases bladder capacity and continence; this also increases bladder compliance, which may be protective for the upper urinary tracts. A reduction in constipation usually is observed, and some patients are able to defecate with the aid of electrical stimulation. Penile erection is produced in a substantial proportion of male patients. The procedure has now been applied in about 700 patients with spinal cord injury, some of whom have been followed for nearly 15 years. The nerves do not appear to be damaged by long-term stimulation, and technical faults with the equipment are now uncommon

Creasey G.H. (1994) Managing bladder, bowel and sexual function after spinal cord injury. In: Rushton D.N. [Ed]: Neuro-urology. New York, Marcel Dekker, pp 233-251.

Creasey G.H., Elefteriades J., DeMarco A., Talonen P., Bijak M., Girsch W., Kantor C. (1996) Electrical stimulation to restore respiration. J Rehab Res & Dev 33, 123-132.

Creasey G.H. (2000) Lecture 6: restoration of male sexual function following spinal cord injury. Int. J. Impot. Res. 12 Suppl 3, S54-S55.

Creasey G.H., Kilgore K.L., Brown-Triolo D.L., Dahlberg J.E., Peckham P.H., and Keith M.W. (2000) Reduction of costs of disability using neuroprostheses. Assist. Technol. 12, 67-75.
Abstract: The lifetime costs associated with spinal cord injury are substantial. Assistive technology that reduces complications, increases independence, or decreases the need for attendant services can provide economic as well as medical or functional benefit. This study describes two approaches for estimating the economic consequences of implanted neuroprostheses utilizing functional electrical stimulation. Life care plan analysis was used to estimate the costs of bladder and bowel care with and without a device restoring bladder and bowel function and to compare these with the costs of implementing the device. For a neuroprosthesis restoring hand grasp, the costs of implementation were compared to the potential savings in attendant care costs that could be achieved by the use of the device. The results indicate that the costs of implementing the bladder and bowel system would be recovered in 5 years, primarily from reduced costs of supplies, medications, and procedures. The costs of the hand grasp neuroprosthesis would be recovered over the lifetime of the user if attendant time was reduced only 2 hours per day and in a shorter time if attendant care was further reduced. Neither analysis includes valuation of the quality of life, which is further enhanced by the neuroprostheses through restoration of greater independence and dignity. Our results demonstrate that implantable neuroprosthetic systems provide good health care value in addition to improved independence for the disabled individual

Dai R., Stein R.B., Andrews B.J., James K.B., and Wieler M. (1996) Application of tilt sensors in functional electrical stimulation. IEEE Trans. Rehabil. Eng 4, 63-72.
Abstract: Tilt sensors, or inclinometers have been investigated for the control of Functional Electrical Stimulation (FES) to improve the gait of persons who had a stroke or incomplete spinal cord injury (SCI). Different types of tilt sensors were studied for their characteristics and their performance in measuring the angular displacement of leg segments during gait. Signal patterns of the lower leg with inertial tilt sensors were identified with control subjects and subjects with footdrop who are being stimulated during level walking. To minimize acceleration responses when the foot swings or hits the ground, we use low-pass filtering (1.5-2 Hz). A finite state approach allows the sensor fixed on the shank to effectively detect the step intention in a population of stroke and incomplete SCI subjects and to control the FES. When the lower leg tilts backward, the common peroneal nerve is stimulated to bring the foot up and forward. We have designed a miniature footdrop stimulator with a magnetoresistive tilt sensor built in, so no external sensor cables are required. The thresholds to turn the stimulator on and off can be adjusted, as well as the maximum period of stimulation and the minimum interval between periods of stimulation. This device features several important advantages over traditional AFO's or stimulators controlled by foot switches. Initial trials with stroke and SCI subjects have demonstrated substantial gait improvement for some subjects, while most liked the good cosmesis and ease of using the device with a tilt sensor

Daly J.J., Marsolais E.B., Mendell L.M., Rymer W.Z., Stefanovska A., Wolpaw J.R., and Kantor C. (1996) Therapeutic neural effects of electrical stimulation. IEEE Trans. Rehabil. Eng 4, 218-230.
Abstract: The use of a functional neuromuscular stimulation (FNS) device can have therapeutic effects that persist when the device is not in use. Clinicians have reported changes in both voluntary and electrically assisted neuromuscular function and improvements in the condition of soft tissue. Motor recovery has been observed in people with incomplete spinal cord injury, stroke, or traumatic brain injury after the use of motor prostheses. Improvement in voluntary dorsiflexion and overall gait pattern has been reported both in the short term (several hours) and permanently. Electrical stimulation of skin over flexor muscles in the upper limb produced substantial reductions for up to 1 h in the severity of spasticity in brain-injured subjects, as measured by the change in torque generation during ramp-and-hold muscle stretch. There was typically an aggravation of the severity of spasticity when surface stimulation reached intensities sufficient to also excite muscle. Animals were trained to alter the size of the H-reflex to obtain a reward. The plasticity that underlies this operantly conditioned H- reflex change includes changes in the spinal cord itself. Comparable changes appear to occur with acquisition of certain motor skills. Current studies are exploring such changes in humans and animals with spinal cord injuries with the goal of using conditioning methods to assess function after injury and to promote and guide recovery of function. A better understanding of the mechanisms of neural plasticity, achieved through human and animal studies, may help us to design and implement FNS systems that have the potential to produce beneficial changes in the subject's central nervous systems

Dewald J.P.A., Given J.D., Rymer W.Z. (1996) Long-Lasting Reductions of Spasticity Induced by Skin Electrical Stimulation. IEEE Trans Rehab Eng 4, 231-242.

DiMarco A.F., Romaniuk J.R., and Supinski G.S. (1995) Electrical activation of the expiratory muscles to restore cough. Am. J. Respir. Crit Care Med. 151, 1466-1471.
Abstract: Many patients with spinal cord injury have paralysis of their expiratory muscles and, consequently, lack an effective cough. The purpose of the present study was to evaluate the utility of lower thoracic spinal cord stimulation (SCS) to activate the expiratory muscles. Studies were performed on 15 anesthetized dogs. A quadripolar stimulating electrode (Medtronic Model 3586) was inserted epidurally and on the ventral surface of the lower thoracic spinal cord. Changes in airway pressure, airflow, and internal intercostal and abdominal muscle length were monitored to assess the effects of electrical stimulation. Spinal stimulation applied at the T9-T10 spinal level provided maximal changes in airway pressure generation in preliminary experiments. All subsequent studies were therefore performed with the electrode positioned at this level. The expiratory muscles were stimulated supramaximally over a wide range of lung volumes which were expressed as the corresponding change in airway pressure. The pressure- generating capacity of the expiratory muscles was evaluated by the change in airway pressure produced by SCS during airway occlusion. Peak expiratory airflow was also monitored following release of occlusion. At FRC, deflation (-10 cm H2O) and inflation (+ 30 cm H2O), SCS resulted in positive airway pressures of 44 cm H2O +/- 4 SE, 28 cm H2O +/- 3 SE, and 82 cm H2O +/- 7 SE. The relationship between airway pressure expiratory airflow generation and lung volume was linear (slope = 1.34 +/- 0.04) over the entire vital capacity range. Our results indicate that: (1) a major portion of the expiratory muscles can be activated reproducibly and in concert by electrical stimulation, and (2) this technique may be a clinically useful method of restoring cough in spinal cord injured patients

Donaldson N., Perkins T.A., Fitzwater R., Wood D.E., and Middleton F. (2000) FES cycling may promote recovery of leg function after incomplete spinal cord injury. Spinal Cord. 38, 680-682.
Abstract: STUDY DESIGN: Single subject pilot. OBJECTIVES: (i) To see whether strength and endurance for recreational cycling by functional electrical stimulation (FES) are possible following spinal cord injury (SCI). (ii) To develop the equipment for FES-cycling. SETTING: England. METHODS: Near-isometric or cycling exercise was performed by the incomplete SCI subject at home. RESULTS: After training for an average of 21 min per day for 16 months, the stimulated muscles increased in size and the subject was able to cycle for 12 km on the level. Surprisingly, there was a substantial increase in the measured voluntary strength of the knee extensors and the subject reports improved leg function. CONCLUSION: FES-cycling may promote recovery after incomplete spinal cord injury. If so, it offers the possibility of being a convenient method for widespread use

Dudley G.A., Castro M.J., Rogers S., and Apple D.F., Jr. (1999) A simple means of increasing muscle size after spinal cord injury: a pilot study. Eur. J. Appl. Physiol Occup. Physiol 80, 394-396.
Abstract: This study tested that hypothesis that skeletal muscle within a year of spinal cord injury (SCI) would respond to intermittent high force loading by showing an increase in size. Three males about 46 weeks post clinically complete SCI underwent surface electrical stimulation of their left or right m. quadriceps femoris 2 days per week for 8 weeks to evoke 4 sets of ten isometric or dynamic actions each session. Conditioning increased average cross-sectional area of m. quadriceps femoris, assessed by magnetic resonance imaging, by 20+/-1% (p = 0.0103). This reversed 48 weeks of atrophy such that m. quadriceps femoris 54 weeks after SCI was the same size as when the patients were first studied 6 weeks after injury. The results suggest that skeletal muscle is remarkably responsive to intermittent, high force loading after almost one year of little if any contractile activity

Egon G., Barat M., Colombel P., Visentin C., Isambert J.L., and Guerin J. (1998) Implantation of anterior sacral root stimulators combined with posterior sacral rhizotomy in spinal injury patients. World J. Urol. 16, 342-349.
Abstract: Brindley-Finetech sacral anterior root stimulators combined with posterior sacral rhizotomy were implanted in 68 males and 28 females with spinal cord lesions. In 9 patients the electrodes were implanted extradurally in the sacrum, and in 90 patients they were implanted intradurally (3 patients had a second extradural implant after a first intradural implant). Three patients died from causes unrelated to the implant. Of the 93 surviving patients, 83 used their implants for micturition and 82 were fully continent. The mean bladder capacity increased from 206 ml preoperatively to 564 ml after the operation. Three patients had a preoperative vesicorenal reflux that disappeared after surgery. In all, 51 patients used the stimulator for defecation. Erection was possible with electrical stimulation in 46 males and was used for coitus by 17 couples. Secondary deafferentation at the level of the conus was performed four times. Three patients who had a cerebrospinal fluid leak were operated on again. Two implants had to be removed because of infection. Sacral anterior root stimulation combined with sacral deafferentation is a welcome addition to the treatment of neurogenic bladder in spinal cord injury patients

Ferguson A.C., Keating J.F., Delargy M.A., and Andrews B.J. (1992) Reduction of seating pressure using FES in patients with spinal cord injury. A preliminary report. Paraplegia 30, 474-478.
Abstract: The aim of this study was to investigate the use of functional electrical stimulation (FES) as a means of pressure sore prevention in seated spinal cord injured (SCI) subjects. Nine SCI subjects took part in tests in which electrical stimulation was applied to the quadriceps with the lower legs restrained. Ischial pressures were measured during periods of quiet sitting and FES application. A strain gauged lever arm was used to measure the knee moment during quadriceps stimulation. The average pressure drop at the right and left buttocks was 44 mmHg and 27 mmHg respectively. In general the greatest reductions occurred in subjects with larger knee moments; however, there was no direct relationship between the pressure reduction obtained and the quadriceps strength. This form of FES may be useful as a prophylactic aid in the management of pressure sores in SCI subjects

Field-Fote E.C. (2000) Spinal cord control of movement: implications for locomotor rehabilitation following spinal cord injury. Phys. Ther. 80, 477-484.
Abstract: In recent years, our understanding of the spinal cord's role in movement control has been greatly advanced. Research suggests that body weight support (BWS) walking and functional electrical stimulation (FES), techniques that are used by physical therapists, have potential to improve walking function in individuals with spinal cord injury (SCI), perhaps long after the stage of spontaneous recovery. Walking is one of the most desired goals of people with SCI; however, we are obligated to be judicious in our claims of locomotor recovery. There are few controlled studies that compare outcomes of BWS training or FES with those of conventional interventions, and access to services using BWS training or FES may be restricted under managed care

Figoni S.F. (1990) Perspectives on cardiovascular fitness and SCI. J. Am. Paraplegia Soc. 13, 63-71.
Abstract: The purpose of these papers is to review and discuss the fundamental concepts and problems underlying cardiovascular fitness and spinal cord injury. Particular attention is paid to several modes of exercise available to individuals with spinal cord injury (SCI)--voluntary arm- crank and wheelchair ergometry, electrical stimulation leg cycle ergometry, and combined voluntary arm-cranking and electrical stimulation leg (hybrid) exercise. The effects of level of injury, active muscle mass, and sympathetic dysfunction upon acute central hemodynamic adjustments during exercise testing and chronic training adaptations are discussed for both quadriplegics and paraplegics. Several topics for future research are suggested

Formal C.S., Cawley M.F., and Stiens S.A. (1997) Spinal cord injury rehabilitation. 3. Functional outcomes. Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil. 78, S59-S64.
Abstract: This self-directed learning module highlights new advances in this topic area. It is part of the chapter on spinal cord injury rehabilitation in the Self-Directed Physiatric Education Program for practitioners and trainees in physical medicine and rehabilitation. This article contains information about mobility, ambulation, upper extremity function, bowel management, and technology to enhance function in the community. New advances covered in this section include functional electrical stimulation for enhancing mobility and upper extremity function

Franco J.C., Perell K.L., Gregor R.J., and Scremin A.M. (1999) Knee kinetics during functional electrical stimulation induced cycling in subjects with spinal cord injury: a preliminary study. J. Rehabil. Res. Dev. 36, 207-216.
Abstract: The purpose of this preliminary study was to describe pedal effectiveness parameters and knee-joint reaction forces generated by subjects with chronic spinal cord injury (SCI) during functional electrical stimulation (FES)-induced bicycling. Three male subjects (age 33-36 years old), who were post-traumatic SCI (ASIA-modified level A, level T4-C5) and enrolled in an FES rehabilitation program, signed informed consent forms and participated in this study. Kinematic data and pedal forces during bicycling were collected and effective force, knee-joint reaction forces, knee generalized muscle moments, and knee- joint power and work were calculated. There were three critical findings of this study: 1) pedaling effectiveness was severely compromised in this subject population as indicated by a lack of overall positive crank work; 2) knee-joint kinetics were similar in magnitude to data reported for unimpaired individuals pedaling at higher rates and workloads, suggesting excessive knee-joint loading for subjects with SCI; and 3) shear reaction forces and muscle moments were opposite in direction to data reported for unimpaired individuals, revealing an energetically unfavorable knee stabilizing mechanism. The critical findings of this study suggest that knee-joint kinetics may be large enough to produce a fracture in the compromised lower limbs of individuals with SCI

Freehafer A.A., Hazel C.M., Becker C.L. (1981) Lower extremity fractures in patients with spinal cord injury. Paraplegia 19, 367-372.

Frost F., Hartwig D., Jaeger R., Leffler E., and Wu Y. (1993) Electrical stimulation of the sacral dermatomes in spinal cord injury: effect on rectal manometry and bowel emptying. Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil. 74, 696-701.
Abstract: The impairment in defecation function that comes as a result of spinal cord injury may have a significant negative impact upon quality of life. Electrical stimulation (ES) of the somatic nervous system has been used to elicit autonomic reflexes in animals, before and after spinal cord transection. To determine whether ES might be used to promote bowel emptying, seven persons with recent spinal cord injury (SCI) and seven control subjects were studied. Electrical stimulation of the second sacral dermatome was applied during rectal manometry in both groups, and ES was added to the bowel programs of SCI patients. A significant rise in the number of rectal pressure spikes was noted in both groups after application of ES (p < .002, f = 6.34). There was no significant differences between the SCI and control groups when measuring the amplitude of spike waves in the colon. No significant change was noted in the time required for SCI patients to initiate a bowel movement, or in the time required to complete bowel emptying. Electrical stimulation of the sacral dermatomes can result in a change in the bowel activity of the recto-sigmoid colon. To date, no clinical effect on bowel emptying has been demonstrated

Gallien P., Brissot R., Eyssette M., Tell L., Barat M., Wiart L., and Petit H. (1995) Restoration of gait by functional electrical stimulation for spinal cord injured patients. Paraplegia 33, 660-664.
Abstract: In this clinical study, we report the results of functional electrical stimulation for the ambulation of paraplegic patients without long leg braces (LLB), according to the Parastep approach. Of 13 SCI patients with complete neurological lesions included in this trial, 12 progressed to independent ambulation with the aid of the Parastep. The average walking distance was 76 m, with a maximum of 350 m, and the mean speed 0.2 m s-1. Compared to the situation with long leg braces, which in fact are given up by most paraplegic patients, long term home use seems to be much more important. Tolerance of this method is satisfactory. The psychological benefits of the device are remarkable. From this experience, it is concluded that this method is valuable for the restoration of standing and walking in the long term management of spinal cord injury patients

Garland D.E. (1988) Clinical observations on fractures and heterotopic ossification in the spinal cord and traumatic brain injured populations. Clin Orthop 86-101.

Garland D.E., Stewart C.A., Adkins R.H., Hu S.S., Rosen C., Liotta F.J. and Weinstein D.A. (1992) Osteoporosis after spinal cord injury. J Orthop Res 10, 371-378.

Garland D.E., Adkins R.H., Matsuno N.N., and Stewart C.A. (1999) The effect of pulsed electromagnetic fields on osteoporosis at the knee in individuals with spinal cord injury. J. Spinal Cord. Med. 22, 239-245.
Abstract: The purpose of this study was to determine the effects of pulsed electromagnetic fields on osteoporotic bone at the knee in individuals with chronic spinal injury. The study consisted of 6 males with complete spinal cord injury at a minimum of 2 years duration. Bone mineral density (BMD) was obtained at both knees at initiation, 3 months, 6 months, and 12 months using dual energy X-ray absorptiometry. In each case, 1 knee was stimulated using The Bone Growth Stimulator Model 3005 from American Medical Electronics, Incorporated and the opposite knee served as the control. Stimulation ceased at 6 months. At 3 months BMD increased in the stimulated knees 5.1% and declined in the control knees 6.6% (p < .05 and p < .02, respectively). By 6 months the BMD returned to near baseline values and at 12 months both knees had lost bone at a similar rate to 2.4% below baseline for the stimulated knee and 3.6% below baseline for the control. There were larger effects closer to the site of stimulation. While the stimulation appeared useful in retarding osteoporosis, the unexpected exaggerated decline in the control knees and reversal at 6 months suggests underlying mechanisms are more complex than originally anticipated. The authors believe a local as well as a systemic response was created

Garland D. and Wharton G. (1994) Spinal cord injury care: funding for the future. Orthopedics 17, 675-678.

Rubayi S., Ambe M.K.,  Garland D.E., and Capen D. (1992) Heterotopic ossification as a complication of the staged total thigh muscles flap in spinal cord injury patients. Ann. Plast. Surg. 29, 41-46.
Abstract: Between 1980 and 1990, 24 total thigh flap procedures were performed at Rancho Los Amigos Medical Center (Downey, CA) by the Pressure Ulcer Management Service. An unexpected occurrence was identified, that is, the rapid development of heterotopic ossification (HO) occurring in the exposed muscle flap between the first and second stages. There were 15 two-stage total thigh flap procedures on 14 patients performed between 1980 and 1990. Of these 15 flap procedures, 11 in 10 patients were found to have HO evident at the second-stage debridement/closure. In comparing our findings with those in other studies (earliest evidence of HO at 19 days), the initial presentation of HO in affected tissues might be even earlier than previously detected. The risks and technical difficulties due to development of HO associated with the two-stage total thigh flap procedure point toward future modifications in preoperative planning that may prove beneficial. Therefore, if the two- stage total thigh flap procedure is necessary, the interval between initial debridement/disarticulation (stage 1) and definitive flap closure (stage 2) should be kept to an absolute minimum. Additionally, HO medicinal prophylaxis (that is, indomethacin or diphosphonates) or radiation after the first stage of the total thigh flap procedure should be considered. Our final conclusion is that the total thigh flap procedure should be done as a one-stage procedure if possible

Garland D.E., Stewart C.A., Adkins R.H., Hu S.S., Rosen C., Liotta F.J., and Weinstein D.A. (1992) Osteoporosis after spinal cord injury. J. Orthop. Res. 10, 371-378.
Abstract: Dual-photon absorptiometry characterized bone loss in males aged less than 40 years after complete traumatic paraplegic and quadriplegic spinal cord injury. Total bone mass of various regions and bone mineral density (BMD) of the knee were measured in 55 subjects. Three different populations were partitioned into four groups: 10 controls (healthy, age matched); 25 acutely injured (114 days after injury), with 12 reexamined 16 months after injury; and 20 chronic (greater than 5 years after injury). Significant differences (p less than 0.0001) in bone mass mineral between groups at the arms, pelvis, legs, distal femur, and proximal tibia were found, with no differences for the head or trunk. Post hoc analyses indicated no differences between the acutely injured at 16 months and the chronically injured. Paraplegic and quadriplegic subjects were significantly different only at the arms and trunk, but were highly similar at the pelvis and below. In the acutely injured, a slight but statistically insignificant rebound was noted above the pelvis. Regression techniques demonstrated early, rapid, linear (p less than 0.0001) decline of bone below the pelvis. Bone mineral loss occurs throughout the entire skeleton, except the skull. Most bone loss occurs rapidly and below the pelvis. Homeostasis is reached by 16 months at two thirds of original bone mass, near fracture threshold

Garland D.E. (1991) A clinical perspective on common forms of acquired heterotopic ossification. Clin. Orthop. 13-29.
Abstract: The clinical courses of heterotopic ossification (HO) as a consequence of trauma and central nervous system insults have many similarities as well as dissimilarities. Detection is commonly noted at two months. The incidence of clinically significant HO is 10%-20%. Approximately 10% of the HO is massive and causes severe restriction in joint motion or ankylosis. The most common sign and symptom are decreased range of motion and pain. The locations are the proximal limbs and joints. Sites of HO about a joint may vary according to the etiology of the HO. Roentgenographic evolution of HO occurs during a six-month period in the majority of patients. Treatment modalities include diphosphonates, indomethacin, radiation, range of motion exercises, and surgical excision. Surgical timing differs according to etiology: traumatic HO may be resected at six months; spinal cord injury HO is excised at one year; and traumatic brain injury HO is removed at 1.5 years. A small number of patients have progression of HO with medicinal treatment and recurrence after resection. The patients seem recalcitrant to present treatment methods regardless of the HO etiology

Garland D.E., Shimoyama S.T., Lugo C., Barras D., and Gilgoff I. (1989) Spinal cord insults and heterotopic ossification in the pediatric population. Clin. Orthop. 303-310.
Abstract: Fifteen of 152 pediatric patients with spinal cord insults (10%) developed heterotopic ossification (HO) at 19 locations. The average age of the patient was eight and one-half years. The spinal cord levels were 13 thoracic and two cervical. The average time to detection of the HO from spinal insult was six and one-half years. The hip was involved in 15 of 19 HO lesions. Decreased range of motion of the affected extremity was the most common sign of occurrence. Alkaline phosphatase was elevated in five of eight patients at the time of detection. Three patients had some resorption of the HO, and one had nearly complete resorption. Five patients (3.3%) with HO had no other etiologic agent other than the neurologic insult, and their average age at time of injury was 13 and one-half years. The hip was involved in six of seven instances. The average time to diagnose this HO was 14 months after injury. Ten patients had late concurrent etiologic factors such as surgery, decubitus ulcers, late neurogenic hip dislocation, and late acute local trauma influencing HO formation. Pediatric patients who developed HO appeared to have a lower incidence, delayed onset, and fewer associated signs and symptoms compared with their adult counterparts with spinal cord injury. Patterns of ossification about the hip differ from adults. The HO lesion has the potential to resorb. HO may be initiated years after the spinal injury by an incidental insult

Garland D.E. and Orwin J.F. (1989) Resection of heterotopic ossification in patients with spinal cord injuries. Clin. Orthop. 169-176.
Abstract: Nineteen spinal cord injury (SCI) patients were treated with resection of heterotopic ossification (HO) in 24 hips. The average follow-up period after surgery was 6.1 years. The mean time to surgery after injury was 50.6 months. The indication for surgery in all patients was improvement in hip motion to allow sitting. The average preoperative motion in flexion and extension was 11.5 degrees. The average intraoperative motion was 82.7 degrees. The average postoperative motion at the follow-up evaluation was 35.2 degrees. Fourteen of 19 patients (74%) had sufficient motion at the follow-up evaluation for sitting. Unlimited sitting tolerance was achieved in seven patients (37%), and seven patients (37%) had improved sitting posture with some time limitations. The average arc of motion in those patients able to sit at the follow-up evaluation was 41.5 degrees. Normal bone scans, alkaline phosphatase levels, and the mature roentgenographic appearance of HO were unreliable predictors of recurrence. The preoperative range of motion was the best predictor of improved postoperative range of motion since patients with retained motion did better than those with severe ankylosis. All six hips with severe recurrence had 0 degree of preoperative motion. The average degree of preoperative motion for all remaining hips was 15.3 degrees. The best predictor of recurrence was the roentgenographic grade of HO. Nineteen of 22 hips (86%) with a mild to severe recurrence had large amounts of bone preoperatively (Grades 3- 5). Complications excluding recurrence occurred in 19 of 24 hips (79%) and included superficial wound infections in nine of 24 hips (38%) and deep persistent infections (osteomyelitis) in eight of 24 hips (33%).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Garland D.E., Jones R.C., and Kunkle R.W. (1988) Upper extremity fractures in the acute spinal cord injured patient. Clin. Orthop. 110-115.
Abstract: Fifty-three long bone upper extremity fractures in 46 patients with recent spinal cord injuries were reviewed with reference to the outcome of operative versus nonoperative treatment. Twenty-four fractures had surgery and 29 fractures were treated nonoperatively. Criteria used in assessing outcome included range of motion, time to union, total rehabilitation time, and orthopedic and medical complications. Humeral fractures had similar outcomes with either operative or nonoperative treatment. Radial nerve injury occurring with humeral fractures prolonged the rehabilitation time. All three combined radial and ulnar fracture treated surgically developed synostosis whereas two of the three nonoperatively treated fractures had other orthopedic complications. Nondisplaced radial fractures responded appropriately to closed treatment. Displaced radial fractures treated nonoperatively had a high incidence of malunion. All ulnar fractures were treated operatively, and all achieved acceptable range of motion and fracture healing at the time of discharge. Medical complications such as deep venous thromboses and decubitus ulcers occurred more frequently in the nonoperatively treated group (28%) than in the operatively treated group (4%). Standard guidelines for upper extremity fracture care apply to the patient with a spinal cord injury. However, operative stabilization may be associated with a decreased risk of medical complications in these patients

Garland D.E. (1988) Clinical observations on fractures and heterotopic ossification in the spinal cord and traumatic brain injured populations. Clin. Orthop. 86-101.
Abstract: Fracture care and osteogeneic response deviate significantly from normal in patients with traumatic brain injury (TBI) or spinal cord injury (SCI). In TBI open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) are recommended whenever possible to improve mobilization in the face of spasticity and the formation of heterotopic ossification (HO). In the patient with SCI, immobility and paralysis negatively alter healing. A fracture above the level of SCI, although not altered in healing, when treated by ORIF will facilitate transfer training and self care. Lower extremity fractures in SCI have a high incidence malunion, delayed union, or nonunion and are best treated by internal fixation. HO occurs in 11% of TBI patients, with the hip, shoulder, and elbow being common sites. Trauma dramatically increases the incidence of HO. In SCI, the incidence of HO is 20%, with most occurring in the hip region. A genetic predisposition to form HO is suspected but not proven

Garland D.E., Saucedo T., and Reiser T.V. (1986) The management of tibial fractures in acute spinal cord injury patients. Clin. Orthop. 237-240.
Abstract: Of 34 tibia fractures in 28 acute spinal cord injuries, 13 patients had complete and 15 had incomplete neurologic lesions. Tibia fractures were divided into three groups: Group I, nonoperative treatment; Group II, early open reduction and internal fixation; and Group III, Type III open injuries. Group I included 17 fractures, of which nine (53%) had delayed union, malunion, or nonunion. The average time to union was 6.5 months. Seven patients had pressure sores and pulmonary emboli. Eleven fractures were noted in Group II. One delayed union (9%), one superficial wound infection that healed uneventfully, and one deep vein thrombosis were noted. The average time to union was 12 weeks. All six Group III tibias had delayed and nonunions, regardless of treatment. Nonoperative fractures healed at a prolonged rate, while open reduction and internal fixation enhanced the rate and time to union. Fractures treated with early open reduction and internal fixation, excluding Group III patients, had the least orthopedic and medical complications. Open reduction and internal fixation is a justifiable alternative to nonoperative treatment in the uncomplicated tibia fracture regardless of neurologic lesion for improved medical and fracture care

Garland D.E., Alday B., and Venos K.G. (1984) Heterotopic ossification and HLA antigens. Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil. 65, 531-532.
Abstract: Thirty patients with neurogenic (nontraumatic) heterotopic ossification following spinal cord injury in 20 and head injury in 10, were comprehensively screened for HLA antigens. The frequencies of 68 HLA-A, -B and -C antigens were examined. The HLA-A2 locus was present in 18 patients (60%) as compared to the phenotypically adjusted normal of 48.4% and was not statistically significant at the 0.05 level. No statistically significant increased frequency of the HLS-B18 or HLA-B27 antigens was detected. A positive correlation does not exist between the HLA antigen system and patient susceptibility to heterotopic ossification following head injury or spinal cord injury

Garland D.E., Alday B., Venos K.G., and Vogt J.C. (1983) Diphosphonate treatment for heterotopic ossification in spinal cord injury patients. Clin. Orthop. 197-200.
Abstract: Nine patients who had spinal cord injury and were receiving diphosphonate therapy for established neurogenic heterotopic ossification in 14 hips were followed up for an average of 14 months. Diphosphonate therapy at a dosage of 10 mg/kg/day when prescribed an average of 26 days after diagnosis did not prevent radiographically evident progression of heterotopic ossification. The interval of one to 30 days between clinical diagnosis and institution of diphosphonate treatment did not a