|













| |
Electrical Stimulation In
Incontinence
Adobe Reader Version
(2000) Pelvic floor electrical
stimulation in the treatment of adult urinary incontinence. Tecnologica. MAP.
Suppl 15-17.
Abelli L., Ferri G.L., Astolfi
M., Conte B., Geppetti P., Parlani M., Dahl D., Polak J.M., and Maggi C.A.
(1991) Acrylamide-induced visceral neuropathy: evidence for the involvement of
capsaicin-sensitive nerves of the rat urinary bladder. Neuroscience 41, 311-321.
Abstract: The mechanisms underlying the severe urinary retention induced by
acrylamide intoxication were studied in detail in the rat. Subcutaneous
treatment with acrylamide monomer (50 mg/kg daily for 10 days) almost completely
impaired the micturition reflex, resulting in urinary retention. In fact, the
ability to eliminate an oral water load was virtually abolished, while bladder
filling with saline (transvesical cystometrogram) failed to activate reflex
micturition. Instead, a picture of overflow incontinence resulted in
urethane-anaesthetized rats, which was not reversed by intravenous
administration of 4- aminopyridine. The nerve-mediated contractile response to
field stimulation (0.1-20 Hz, 0.5 ms, 60 V) of the isolated bladder was
unaffected, thus suggesting the integrity of bladder efferent innervation, and
no evidence was found from in vitro experiments that the myogenic contractility
of the bladder was depressed by acrylamide treatment. Conversely, the sensory
nerve-mediated response to capsaicin was abolished and sensory nerve fibres of
the bladder were selectively depleted of their content of substan
Aitchison M., Fisher B.M.,
Carter K., McKee R., MacCuish A.C., and Finlay I.G. (1991) Impaired anal
sensation and early diabetic faecal incontinence. Diabet. Med. 8, 960-963.
Abstract: Faecal incontinence develops in up to 20% of diabetic patients. To try
to determine the relative contributions of sensory and motor neuropathy in this
troublesome complication, anorectal function was examined in 10 male diabetic
patients with early faecal incontinence (mucus leakage or faecal staining
without the need to wear a pad), 10 asymptomatic male diabetic patients, and 10
normal control subjects. Motor function was tested using anal manometry to
determine the resting and maximum squeeze pressure, and the functional anal
canal length. No significant differences were found between the groups. Sensory
function was tested by measuring the mucosal sensitivity to electrical
stimulation, and the response to inflation of a balloon in the rectum. In the
mid-anal canal position the symptomatic patients had a significantly higher
sensory threshold at 6.6 +/- 2.8 mA compared with 3.0 +/- 1.2 mA in the normal
control subjects (p less than 0.002), and in the high anal zone symptomatic
patients had a significantly elevated sensory threshold at 9.1 +/- 2.0 mA
compared with 4.6 +/- 1.6 mA in asymptomatic patients and 3.6 +/- 1.3 mA in the
normal control subjects (both p less than 0.001). There were no significant
differences in the first sensation of fullness, maximum tolerated volume or
percentage fall from resting pressure between the groups on inflation of the
balloon. Elevation of the sensory threshold in the upper anal canal is an early
abnormality in the development of diabetic faecal incontinence
Alexander S. and Rowan D.
(1966) Closure of the urinary sphincter mechanism in anaesthetized dogs by means
of electrical stimulation of the perineal muscles. Br. J. Surg. 53, 1053-1056.
Alexander S. (1976) A critical
look at incontinence radio-implants. Urol. Int. 31, 129-133.
Abstract: Indwelling electrical stimulation of the pelvic floor by a radio-
implant benefits some cases of problem or recurrent urinary incontinence. It is
not possible to predict success or failure with a given patient. The only
worthwhile criterion for selection is the presence of contraction of pelvic
floor musculature in response to voluntary effort or trial electrical
stimulation. The results are not simply explained by postulating electrically
induced closure of the urethra. There may be conscious enhancement of the
urinary sphincter mechanism. Re-education of voluntary sphincter muscles by
electrophysiotherapy may occur. Reflex inhibition of the detrusor may occur. The
surgery involved in inserting an implant restores continence in some patients
Andersson K.E., Andersson P.O.,
Fovaeus M., Hedlund H., Malmgren A., and Sjogren C. (1988) Effects of pinacidil
on bladder muscle. Drugs 36 Suppl 7, 41-49.
Abstract: Infravesical outflow obstruction and bladder hypertrophy are often
associated with bladder hyperactivity causing frequency, urge and urinary
incontinence. This hyperactivity may be due to a supersensitivity to
depolarising stimuli. Drugs that inhibit smooth muscle activity by opening K+
channels, resulting in hyperpolarisation, would therefore seem to be an
attractive therapeutic principle. Pinacidil is an effective vasodilator
classified as a K+ channel opener. The drug has been shown to effectively
depress spontaneous contractile activity, the contractions induced by low (less
than 40 mmol/L) concentrations of K+, carbachol and by electrical stimulation of
nerves in isolated normal human bladder tissue and also in normal and
hypertrophied rat bladder. The effect was more pronounced in hypertrophied
detrusor. Pinacidil in concentrations inhibiting muscle activity also increased
the efflux of 86Rb in bladder tissue. In vivo pinacidil suppressed spontaneous
contractile activity in rats with infravesical bladder obstruction and detrusor
hypertrophy. The findings make K+ channel openers an interesting, potentially
useful therapeutic principle in hyperactivity associated with bladder
hypertrophy
Appell R.A. (1998) Electrical
stimulation for the treatment of urinary incontinence. Urology 51, 24-26.
Abstract: OBJECTIVES: To describe the rationale for the use of electrical
stimulation (ES) for the treatment of urinary incontinence, and to summarize the
results of clinical studies assessing these techniques. METHODS: The effect of
ES on the lower urinary tract (LUT) is explained, and the literature on clinical
application of this technique is reviewed. RESULTS: The use of ES is aimed at
altering LUT function by stimulation of the sacral autonomic or somatic nerves.
Two types of ES have been used: chronic stimulation and acute maximal functional
electrostimulation. The frequency used depends on the clinical diagnosis. In
patients with stress incontinence, uncontrolled studies suggest that high
frequency and high amperage are required to obtain a 50% success rate, although
success does not necessarily equate with cure. The only placebo-controlled trial
in this population found that 62% of patients experienced significant
improvement on provocative pad test determinations, but only 20% were dry.
Researchers agree that low frequency and moderate amperage are required in
patients with detrusor instability. The reported effectiveness of ES in this
population has ranged widely, from 45% to 91%, but all studies agree that
approximately one-third of patients will obtain a good long-term results. A
review of multiple studies found that 20% of patients were reported as dry and
37% were significantly improved with functional ES. CONCLUSIONS: Although nearly
all studies of ES have been uncontrolled, a substantial body of "soft" data
attests to the efficacy and safety of this technique
Aristizabal Agudelo J.M.,
Salinas C.J., Fuertes M.E., Virseda C.M., Salman M.S., Bravo de Rueda A.C., and
Resel E.L. (1996) [Urodynamic results of the treatment of urinary incontinence
with peripheral electric stimulation]. Arch. Esp. Urol. 49, 836-842.
Abstract: OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the urodynamic results achieved by
electrostimulation in patients with different types of urinary incontinence.
METHODS: 37 patients (32 females and 5 males) with urinary incontinence were
treated with peripheral electrical stimulation. The urodynamic diagnosis were:
detrusor instability (24.3%), stress urinary incontinence (24.3%), mixed urinary
incontinence (48.6%), and bladder hyper-reflexia (2.7%). Rectal and vaginal
electrodes were utilized. The therapeutic frequencies were 10 Hz, 20 Hz and 50
Hz. RESULTS: Detrusor instability disappeared in the cases treated with the 10
Hz frequency (79%) and in one case treated with the 50 Hz frequency. A
significantly increased bladder capacity and decreased first micturition
sensation were observed in this patient group. All patients with stress urinary
incontinence were treated with high frequency (50 Hz), which achieved positive
results in 44%. In the group of patients with mixed urinary incontinence. 45%
remained unchanged. Treatment failed to achieve satisfactory results in the
single case of detrusor hyperreflexia in this series. CONCLUSION: Peripheral
electrical stimulation is a valid alternative in the treatment of male and
female incontinence. Satisfactory results were achieved with the 10 Hz frequency
in 89% of the patients with bladder instability and with the 50 Hz frequency in
44% of the patients with stress urinary incontinence
Baeten C.G., Konsten J.,
Heineman E., and Soeters P.B. (1994) Dynamic graciloplasty for anal atresia. J.
Pediatr. Surg. 29, 922-924.
Abstract: The aim of this study was to assess whether an electrically stimulated
graciloplasty (dynamic graciloplasty) can achieve continence in nine patients
with anal atresia (median age, 28 years; range, 18 to 40). As the first
procedure, a gracilis muscle was transposed. Six weeks later, intramuscular
electrodes were implanted and connected to a pulse generator. Eventually, the
muscle was gradually trained, by electrical stimulation, to achieve fecal
continence. Continence was obtained in five patients (55%). Manometry
demonstrated an increase in mean anal pressure, from 36 mm Hg (without
stimulation) to 52 mm Hg (with stimulation), after 8 weeks (mean increase, 16 mm
Hg, [95% confidence interval, 8, 24 mm Hg; n = 9; P < .01). Failures resulted
from a noncontracting distal part of the gracilis muscle (in three patients) and
a nondistending rectum (in one patient). We conclude that dynamic graciloplasty
can achieve continence in a substantial number of patients with thus-far
untreatable incontinence after surgical correction for anal atresia
Balcom A.H., Wiatrak M.,
Biefeld T., Rauen K., and Langenstroer P. (1997) Initial experience with home
therapeutic electrical stimulation for continence in the myelomeningocele
population. J. Urol. 158, 1272-1276.
Abstract: PURPOSE: In an attempt to enhance bladder and bowel continence 29
patients underwent long duration, low intensity transcutaneous therapeutic
electrical stimulation. This technology has previously been shown to be
effective for inducing regenerative hypertrophy of disuse atrophied skeletal
muscle, and it has been associated with improved continence in the
myelomeningocele population. Our objectives were to enhance urinary and fecal
continence, and evaluate the mechanisms by which therapeutic electrical
stimulation influences continence. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A total of 29 children
with lumbar or sacral myelomeningocele underwent therapeutic electrical
stimulation at home during sleep using a commercially available stimulator with
a safety sensing circuit and 2 sets of electrodes placed on the skin at bedtime.
Left and right side electrode placement was alternated on 6 of 7 consecutive
nights. In 9 boys and 2 girls with more than 9 months of followup initial and
subsequent cystometrography, urethral pressure profile, electromyography,
voiding cystourethrography and renal ultrasound studies were evaluated. RESULTS:
In the 11 children there was no radiographic evidence of urinary tract or
musculoskeletal deterioration during treatment. Mean actual bladder capacity
increased from 133 to 196 ml. (p < 0.05). Mean bladder capacity, as a percent of
maximum predicted bladder capacity for a normal age matched child without
myelomeningocele, also significantly increased from 59 before to 76% after 9
months of therapeutic electrical stimulation (p < 0.05). No significant change
was noted in urethral pressure profile. A subjective improvement in the
sensation of pelvic fullness was also observed. CONCLUSIONS: When administered
at home by parents while the child sleeps, therapeutic electrical stimulation is
safe for bladder and bowel continence in the myelomeningocele population. It
seems to increase significantly bladder capacity, does not appear to change
urethral pressure profile and results in a subjectively improved sensation of
pelvic fullness, enhancing urinary and fecal continence. The most beneficial
effect of therapeutic electrical stimulation seems to be on the bladder wall and
less so on the striated pelvic floor musculature with subjective enhancement of
pelvic fullness also contributing positively
Bardoel J.W., Stadelmann W.K.,
Perez-Abadia G.A., Galandiuk S., Zonnevijlle E.D., Maldonado C., Stremel R.W.,
Tobin G.R., Kon M., and Barker J.H. (2001) Dynamic rectus abdominis muscle
sphincter for stoma continence: an acute functional study in a dog model. Plast.
Reconstr. Surg. 107, 478-484.
Abstract: Fecal stomal incontinence is a problem that continues to defy surgical
treatment. Previous attempts to create continent stomas using dynamic myoplasty
have had limited success due to denervation atrophy of the muscle flap used in
the creation of the sphincter and because of muscle fatigue resulting from
continuous electrical stimulation. To address the problem of denervation
atrophy, a stomal sphincter was designed using the most caudal segment of the
rectus abdominis muscle, preserving its intercostal innervation as well as its
vascular supply. The purpose of the present study was to determine whether this
rectus abdominis muscle island flap sphincter design could maintain stomal
continence acutely. In this experiment, six dogs were used to create eight
rectus abdominis island flap stoma sphincters around a segment of distal ileum.
Initially, the intraluminal stomal pressures generated by the sphincter using
different stimulation frequencies were determined. The ability of this stomal
sphincter to generate continence at different intraluminal bowel pressures was
then assessed. In all cases, the rectus abdominis muscle sphincter generated
peak pressures well above those needed to maintain stomal continence (60 mmHg).
In addition, each sphincter was able to maintain stomal continence at all
intraluminal bowel pressures tested
Bauchet L., Segnarbieux F.,
Martinazzo G., Frerebeau P., and Ohanna F. (2001) [Neurosurgical treatment of
hyperactive bladder in spinal cord injury patients]. Neurochirurgie 47, 13-24.
Abstract: OBJECTIVES: We report long-term results of posterior sacral root
rhizotomies in combination with Finetech-Brindley anterior sacral root
stimulators implanted intradurally in 20 spinal cord injury patients. MATERIAL:
and methods: The 14 female and 6 male patients included 14 paraplegics and 6
tetraplegics. All of them initially presented hyperactive bladder, detrusor-sphincter
dyssynergia, recurrent urinary tract infection and performed (self) intermittent
catheterization. Prior to implantation, an intrathecal test using bupivacaine
was performed to confirm the compliances of the bladder. The main indication for
implantation was persistent urinary incontinence refractory to medical therapy.
RESULTS: After implantation the mean follow-up was 4,5 years. In all, 18
patients used the stimulator alone for bladder emptying and 18 patients were
completely continent. The mean bladder capacity increased from 190 ml
preoperatively to 460 ml after the operation. The mean residual urinary volume
was reduced from 90 ml to 25 ml. No changes were noted by renal isotopic
scanning in upper urinary tracts of patients. In 1 patient, a second extradural
implant was performed. DISCUSSION: This article also include an overview of a)
the different available sites where application of electrical stimulation
results in a detrusor contraction, b) the benefits and disadvantages of the
sacral posterior rhizotomy, c) selective stimulation techniques that allow
selective detrusor activation by sacral root stimulation. CONCLUSION: Sacral
anterior root stimulation combined with sacral posterior rhizotomy is a valuable
method to restore bladder functions in spinal cord injured patients suffering
from hyperactive bladder refractory to medical therapy
Beckman N.J. (1995) An overview
of urinary incontinence in adults: assessments and behavioral interventions.
Clin. Nurse Spec. 9, 241-7, 274.
Abstract: Urinary incontinence affects millions of Americans. Often the goal of
treatment is to improve the condition, prevent complications and provide
comfort. Behavioral interventions can improve the condition in 54-75% of
patients with urge and/or stress incontinence and can cure 12- 16% of patients.
Advanced practice nurses (APNs) are in a unique position of both providing
direct care to patients who experience these problems and educating other nurses
about signs, symptoms and appropriate nursing interventions for urinary
incontinence. The scope of the problem, costs of urinary incontinence and
potential cost savings with treatment are discussed in this article. Acute and
chronic urinary incontinence and the necessary assessments to be performed by
the APN are reviewed. Bladder training, habit training, prompted voiding and
pelvic muscle exercises are the behavioral interventions used with urinary
incontinence. Adjunct therapy, including biofeedback, vaginal cones and
electrical stimulation, also is discussed
Benson J.T. (2000) Sacral nerve
stimulation results may be improved by electrodiagnostic techniques. Int.
Urogynecol. J. Pelvic. Floor. Dysfunct. 11, 352-357.
Abstract: Sacral nerve electrical stimulation (sacral neuromodulation) therapy
for patients with refractory urge incontinence, frequency and urgency, and
non-obstructive retention yields an effective 75%-80% success rate. Electrodes
are surgically implanted if initial percutaneous stimulation testing has a
successful clinical response. Unfortunately, up to 50% of patients are denied
surgical implantation because of an unsuccessful response to the test
stimulation. In this descriptive study, adding electrodiagnostic monitoring to
the currently used biological monitoring techniques was associated with a
reduction in the number of tested patients denied implantation to 20%. These
findings suggest that the incorporation of electrodiagnostic techniques may
improve the clinical efficacy of sacral stimulation therapy. Randomized
prospective testing of this hypothesis is suggested
Berghmans L.C., Hendriks H.J.,
Bo K., Hay-Smith E.J., de Bie R.A., and van Waalwijk van Doorn ES (1998)
Conservative treatment of stress urinary incontinence in women: a systematic
review of randomized clinical trials. Br. J. Urol. 82, 181-191.
Abstract: OBJECTIVE: To assess the efficacy of physical therapies for first-line
use in the treatment and prevention of stress urinary incontinence (SUI) in
women, using a systematic review of randomized clinical trials (RCTs). MATERIALS
AND METHODS: A computer-aided and manual search for published RCTs investigating
treatment and prevention of SUI using physical therapies, e.g. pelvic floor
muscle (PFM) exercises, with or without other treatment modalities, were carried
out. The methodological quality of the included trials was assessed using
criteria based on generally accepted principles of interventional research.
RESULTS: Twenty-four RCTs (22 treatment and two prevention) were identified; the
methodological quality of the studies included was moderate and 11 RCTs were of
sufficient quality to be included in further analysis. Based on
levels-of-evidence criteria, there is strong evidence to suggest that PFM
exercises are effective in reducing the symptoms of SUI. There is limited
evidence for the efficacy of high- intensity vs a low-intensity regimen of PFM
exercises. Despite significant effects of biofeedback after testing as an
adjunct to PFM exercises, there is no evidence that PFM exercises with
biofeedback are more effective than PFM exercises alone. There is little
consistency (of stimulation types and parameters) in the studies of electrical
stimulation, but when the results are combined there is strong evidence to
suggest that electrostimulation is superior to sham electrostimulation, and
limited evidence that there is no difference between electrostimulation and
other physical therapies. In the prevention of SUI the efficacy of PFM
exercises, with or without other adjuncts, is uncertain
Berghmans L.C., Hendriks H.J.,
de Bie R.A., van Waalwijk van Doorn ES, Bo K., and van Kerrebroeck P.E. (2000)
Conservative treatment of urge urinary incontinence in women: a systematic
review of randomized clinical trials. BJU. Int. 85, 254-263.
Abstract: OBJECTIVE: To assess the efficacy of physical therapies for first-line
use in the treatment of urge urinary incontinence (UUI) in women, using a
systematic review of randomized clinical trials (RCTs). MATERIALS AND METHODS: A
computer-aided and manual search was carried out for RCTs published between 1980
and 1999 investigating the treatment of UUI defined by the keywords 'physical
therapies', e.g. bladder (re)training (including 'behavioural' treatment),
pelvic floor muscle (PFM) exercises, with or without biofeedback and/or
electrical stimulation. The methodological quality of the included trials was
assessed using methodological criteria, based on generally accepted principles
of interventional research. RESULTS: Fifteen RCTs were identified; the
methodological quality of the studies was moderate, with a median (range) score
of 6 (3-8.5) (maximum possible 10). Eight RCTs were considered of sufficient
quality, i.e. an internal validity score of >/= 5.5 points on a scale of 0-10,
and were included in a further analysis. Based on levels-of-evidence criteria,
there is weak evidence to suggest that bladder (re)training is more effective
than no treatment (controls), and that bladder (re)training is better than drug
therapy. Stimulation types and parameters in the studies of electrical
stimulation were heterogeneous. There is insufficient evidence that electrical
stimulation is more effective than sham electrical simulation. To date there are
too few studies to evaluate effects of PFM exercise with or without biofeedback,
and of toilet training for women with UUI. CONCLUSION: Although almost all
studies included reported positive results in favour of physical therapies for
the treatment of UUI, more research of high methodological quality is required
to evaluate the effects of each method in the range of physical therapies
Bielefeldt K., Enck P., and
Erckenbrecht J.F. (1990) Sensory and motor function in the maintenance of anal
continence. Dis. Colon Rectum 33, 674-678.
Abstract: Anorectal function was prospectively evaluated in 43 consecutive
patients with fecal incontinence and in 19 healthy volunteers using manometry
and electrical stimulation of the anoderm. Both anorectal motor and sensory
function was impaired in incontinent patients as compared with healthy controls.
Further statistical analysis identified four subgroups of patients showing
different pathomechanisms of fecal incontinence: severe combined anorectal motor
and sensory dysfunction, isolated anal sphincter dysfunction, isolated anorectal
sensory dysfunction, and combined dysfunction of the internal anal sphincter and
impaired anorectal sensitivity. These data support the hypothesis that sensory
function of both the rectum and the anal canal is an important and independent
factor in the preservation of continence
Bladou F., Houvenaeghel G.,
Delpero J.R., Monges G., Serment G., and Guerinel G. (1996) Construction of a
urinary sphincter by means of an electrically stimulated striated muscle:
experimental procedure and urodynamic results on canine model. Int. Surg. 81,
94-98.
Abstract: A canine model of urinary neosphincter using electrically stimulated
autologous striated muscle is described. The superior belly of canine sartorius
was activated by a pacemaker with an intermittent low frequency stimulation
(0.5-1 pulse per sec) during 7 weeks. Then, the muscle graft was passed around
the urethra and sutured back on to itself to form a neosphincter. The surgical
procedure was easy to perform and with no complication. Urethral pressure
profile was performed initially (T0), and when the muscle was in peri-urethral
position, before (T1) and during electrical stimulation (T2). The continence
parameter readings (maximal urethral closure pressure MUP, functional length FL,
continence zone CZ, and continence area CA) increased from T0 to T1, and from T1
to T2. We noted: 1) 28%, 38%, 52%, and 86% increases for the MUP, FL, CZ, and CA
respectively from T0 to T1, 2) 10%, 41%, 30%, and 43% increases for MUP, FL, CZ,
and CA respectively from T1 to T2. Chronic low frequency stimulation could
transform a skeletal fast-twitch type 2 muscle into a slow-twitch
fatigue-resistant type 1 muscle. In this study, morphological changes of the
stimulated muscle were noted, whereas phenotype was unchanged. This dynamic
autologous neosphincter may be a new alternative to the artificial urinary
sphincter prosthesis with fewer complications. Further studies are ongoing to
evaluate the efficacy of such a neosphincter as continent system for bladder
substitution after pelvic exenteration for pelvic cancers
Bo K. and Maanum M. (1996) Does
vaginal electrical stimulation cause pelvic floor muscle contraction? A pilot
study. Scand. J. Urol. Nephrol. Suppl 179, 39-45.
Abstract: The purpose of the present study was to evaluate whether vaginal
electrical stimulation using Conmax and Medicon MS-105 causes pelvic floor
muscle contraction. In addition, pain and discomfort described by the
participants were registered. Nine women, mean age 37.7 years (range 24-54)
participated in the study; five healthy physio-therapists and four patients with
diagnosed genuine stress incontinence. All the participants used Conmax and
Medicon MS-105 with 10, 20 and 50 Hz in random order. The women increased the
current step by step to tolerance level. Two physiotherapists were observing the
perineum and notified whether a correct contraction was occurring. The
participants reported whether there was a correct contraction of the pelvic
floor and described pain and discomfort, classified according to McGill Pain
Questionnaire. The results demonstrated that a correct contraction was reported
and observed in only one of nine women. Electrical stimulation with all
frequencies caused pain and discomfort in all women
Bo K. and Talseth T. (1997)
Change in urethral pressure during voluntary pelvic floor muscle contraction and
vaginal electrical stimulation. Int. Urogynecol. J. Pelvic. Floor. Dysfunct. 8,
3-6.
Abstract: The purpose of the study was to compare the effect of voluntary pelvic
floor muscle (FFM) contraction and vaginal electrical stimulation on urethral
pressure. Twelve women with genuine stress incontinence, mean age 49.4 years
(range 33-66) participated in the study. The urethral and bladder pressures were
recorded simultaneously through a double- lumen 8 Ch catheter. The patients
first performed three voluntary PFM contractions. Then two electrical
stimulators, Conmax and Medicon MS 105, 50 Hz, were used in random order. A
visual analog scale was used to measure pain and discomfort. Pain was reported
to mean 6.8, SEM 0.64 (range 0.7-9.9) and mean 6.1, SEM 0.81 (range 0-9.1) with
Conmax and Medicon MS 105, respectively. The mean paired difference in favor of
voluntary contraction with Conmax was -8.0, SD 6.7, P = 0.0067, and with Medicon
MS 105 it was -12.2, SD 5.9, P = 0.0022. The results demonstrated that voluntary
PFM contraction increased urethral pressure significantly more than did vaginal
electrical stimulation
Bo K. (1998) Effect of
electrical stimulation on stress and urge urinary incontinence. Clinical outcome
and practical recommendations based on randomized controlled trials. Acta Obstet.
Gynecol. Scand. Suppl 168, 3-11.
Abstract: BACKGROUND: The aim of the present study was to review the literature
on randomized controlled trials of electrical stimulation to treat urge and
stress urinary incontinence. METHODS: Studies were compiled from Medline from
1980 till 1996 and manual searches of relevant journals. Randomized controlled
studies full length published in English, German and Scandinavian languages were
included. RESULTS: Nine studies evaluating the effect of electrical stimulation
on stress urinary incontinence and one study evaluating the effect of urge
incontinence were found. Only three studies had a sufficient sample size to
enable conclusion on stress urinary incontinence. Two demonstrated negative, and
one positive effect (20%) cure and 46% improved measured by pad test). The study
on urge incontinence demonstrated that there was no difference in effect after
electrical stimulation or anticholinergic drugs. CONCLUSION: The results of
randomized controlled trials evaluating the effect of electrical stimulation to
treat stress and urge urinary incontinence are conflicting. There is a need for
more randomized controlled trials with sufficient sample sizes, use of
sensitive, reproducible and valid outcome measures, and optimal stimulation
parameters. Based on the present knowledge pelvic floor muscle exercise should
be the first choice of treatment for stress urinary incontinence
Bo K., Talseth T., and Holme I.
(1999) Single blind, randomised controlled trial of pelvic floor exercises,
electrical stimulation, vaginal cones, and no treatment in management of genuine
stress incontinence in women. BMJ 318, 487-493.
Abstract: OBJECTIVE: To compare the effect of pelvic floor exercises, electrical
stimulation, vaginal cones, and no treatment for genuine stress incontinence.
DESIGN: Stratified, single blind, randomised controlled trial. SETTING:
Multicentre. PARTICIPANTS: 107 women with clinically and urodynamically proved
genuine stress incontinence. Mean (range) age was 49.5 (24-70) years, and mean
(range) duration of symptoms 10.8 (1- 45) years. INTERVENTIONS: Pelvic floor
exercise (n=25) comprised 8-12 contractions 3 times a day and exercise in groups
with skilled physical therapists once a week. The electrical stimulation group
(n=25) used vaginal intermittent stimulation with the MS 106 Twin at 50 Hz 30
minutes a day. The vaginal cones group (n=27) used cones for 20 minutes a day.
The untreated control group (n=30) was offered the use of a continence guard.
Muscle strength was measured by vaginal squeeze pressure once a month. MAIN
OUTCOME MEASURES: Pad test with standardised bladder volume, and self report of
severity. RESULTS: Improvement in muscle strength was significantly greater
(P=0.03) after pelvic floor exercises (11.0 cm H2O (95% confidence interval 7.7
to 14.3) before v 19.2 cm H2O (15.3 to 23.1) after) than either electrical
stimulation (14.8 cm H2O (10. 9 to 18.7) v 18.6 cm H2O (13.3 to 23.9)) or
vaginal cones (11.8 cm H2O (8.5 to 15.1) v 15.4 cm H2O (11.1 to 19.7)).
Reduction in leakage on pad test was greater in the exercise group (-30.2 g;
-43. 3 to 16.9) than in the electrical stimulation group (-7.4 g; -20.9 to 6.1)
and the vaginal cones group (-14.7 g; - 27.6 to -1.8). On completion of the
trial one participant in the control group, 14 in the pelvic floor exercise
group, three in the electrical stimulation group, and two in the vaginal cones
group no longer considered themselves as having a problem. Conclusion: Training
of the pelvic floor muscles is superior to electrical stimulation and vaginal
cones in the treatment of genuine stress incontinence
Bo K. (2000) [Pelvic floor
muscle exercise and urinary incontinence--train yourself continent!]. Tidsskr.
Nor Laegeforen. 120, 3583-3589.
Abstract: BACKGROUND: Urinary incontinence is a major female health problem with
prevalence rates varying between 8% and 52%. Urinary incontinence can be treated
with surgery, medication, and several forms of pelvic floor muscle training. The
aim of this review article is to evaluate the evidence from randomized
controlled trials of pelvic floor muscle training in the treatment of urinary
incontinence. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Computerised search in Medline and Sport and
manual search in former published systematic reviews were undertaken. Only
published articles of randomized controlled trials were included. RESULTS:
Several randomized controlled trials have demonstrated that pelvic floor muscle
training is more effective than no treatment and electrical stimulation in the
treatment of stress incontinence. Adding biofeedback to the training has so far
showed no additional effect. There is a lack of published studies on the effect
of pelvic floor muscle training in urge incontinence and in men. INTERPRETATION:
Female stress urinary incontinence can be effectively treated by pelvic floor
muscle exercise; this is suggested as the first choice of treatment. There is a
need for randomized controlled trials to evaluate the effect of pelvic floor
muscle exercise in prevention of urinary incontinence
Bo K. and Berghmans L.C. (2000)
Nonpharmacologic treatments for overactive bladder-pelvic floor exercises.
Urology 55, 7-11.
Abstract: The theory behind the use of physical therapies (electrical
stimulation or pelvic floor muscle [PFM] training with or without biofeedback)
for overactive bladder is to (1) inhibit detrusor muscle contraction by
voluntary contraction of the PFMs at the same time as the urge to void; and (2)
prevent sudden falls in urethral pressure by a change in PFM morphology,
position, and neuromuscular function. Few trials have evaluated the effect of
PFM training on symptoms of overactive bladder. Most studies are flawed because
they include several diagnoses and treatment modalities in the same
intervention. Because of the lack of evidence, no firm conclusion can be drawn
on the effect of PFM exercise on overactive bladder. There are some initially
promising results, but there is still a need for high-quality, randomized
controlled trials on the effect of PFM training on the inhibition of detrusor
contraction in human beings. The efficacy of PFM training in combination with
other treatments, such as pharmacotherapy, also requires investigation
Boccon-Gibod L. (1980) [Urinary
incontinence following prostatectomy: hopes and disappointments. 42 cases
(author's transl)]. Nouv. Presse Med. 9, 2339-2342.
Abstract: Between 0,5 and 1% of prostatectomies are complicated by urinary
incontinence due to the destruction of both proximal and distal urethral
sphincters. Any incontinence persisting more than 12 months after surgery should
be considered as permanent. Among all treatments proposed (medical treatment,
electrical stimulation of the perineum, various plastic operations and
prostheses with varied and numerous materials), only inflatable prostheses seem
to give "better than nothing results. The best treatment of post-operative
incontinence, however, is preventive: extreme care should be exercised during
the enucleation or trans-urethral resection of the adenoma
Bock J.U. and Jongen J. (1996)
[Diagnostic and therapeutic procedures in fecal incontinence in general practice
of the surgically educated proctologist]. Zentralbl. Chir 121, 659-664.
Abstract: Age related, about 10% of the general population suffer from faecal
incontinence. In a surgical, proctological office diagnosis is possible with
carefully taken history, physical examination, digital examination of the
anorectum, rigid rectosigmoidoscopy, and anoscopy. Together with special
examinations (endoanal ultrasound, electromyography, pudendal nerve terminal
motor latency [PNTML], anorectal manometry, defaecography, transit time of the
colon) the plan for medical and surgical treatment can be made. The basic
medical conservative therapy consists of regulating the form of stool (high
fibre diet and/or loperamid), training of the sphincter and pelvic muscles
electrical stimulation or biofeedback training. Outpatient surgery is possible
for small prolapsing tumors of the lower rectum or anal canal, hemorrhoids grade
2 or segmental anal prolapse. Inpatient surgery is needed for any form of
reconstruction of the sphincter or the sensitive area of the anal canal,
Borrelli M., Alves P.R., Gama
A.H., and Goes G.M. (1977) Urinary incontinence: two cases of electronic
stimulation after failing the Leadbetter technique. Urol. Int. 32, 260-264.
Abstract: Two cases of urinary incontinence treated by electrical stimulation
after failing the Leadbetter technique are presented. Both were first seen
bearing imperforated anus. They suffered several operations for correcting this
pathology and further attempting to relieve complete urinary incontinence. After
a trial with intrarectal stimulation one of them received an implant. The other
continued to use the anal plug. In both cases the result has been satisfactory.
Cine radiological documentation of the sphincteric action of the stimulated
muscles was performed
Bosch J.L. and Groen J. (1995)
Sacral (S3) segmental nerve stimulation as a treatment for urge incontinence in
patients with detrusor instability: results of chronic electrical stimulation
using an implantable neural prosthesis. J. Urol. 154, 504-507.
Abstract: PURPOSE: We studied the effects of sacral (S3) nerve stimulation in
patients with urge incontinence due to detrusor instability. MATERIALS AND
METHODS: A permanent S3 foramen electrode was implanted in 18 patients (average
age 46 years) who had shown a good response during temporary stimulation via a
percutaneously placed wire electrode. Average followup was 29 months. RESULTS:
The average voiding frequency and pad use per 24 hours decreased significantly.
Improvement in several urodynamic parameters was noted. The correlation between
symptomatic and urodynamic improvement was incomplete. CONCLUSIONS:
Neuromodulation appears to be a valuable treatment option in these patients
Bosch J.L. and Groen J. (2000)
Sacral nerve neuromodulation in the treatment of patients with refractory motor
urge incontinence: long-term results of a prospective longitudinal study. J.
Urol. 163, 1219-1222.
Abstract: PURPOSE: Conservative treatment rarely results in a durable cure of
patients with urge incontinence and bladder overactivity. Instrumental and
surgical procedures often have significant side effects and less than optimal
results. We developed a technique of sacral nerve neuromodulation using chronic
unilateral electrical stimulation of the S3 sacral nerve to inhibit the
micturition reflex to provide effective nondestructive alternative therapy for
patients whose condition is refractory to conservative treatment. MATERIALS AND
METHODS: Of 85 patients 45 who responded to a test with a temporary electrode
underwent implantation of a permanent S3 sacral nerve electrode coupled to a
pulse generator. Treatment results were evaluated by urodynamic studies and
voiding/incontinence diaries documenting pad use, incontinence episodes, voiding
frequency and voided volume. Partial success and cure were defined as 50% to 90%
and more than 90% improvement, respectively, in pad use and/or incontinence
episodes. RESULTS: Of 45 patients 18 (40%) were cured at an average followup of
47.1 months and 9 (20%) achieved partial success. Median number of pads used and
median number of incontinence episodes daily had decreased from 5.4 to 1.2 (p =
0.0001) and 7.1 to 1.3 (p = 0.0001), respectively, 6 months after implantation.
Subsequently these results remained almost constant for 5 years. Bladder
overactivity disappeared in 19 of the 44 patients (43%). The repeat intervention
rate was 37.7% and there was no permanent injury or nerve damage. CONCLUSIONS:
Sacral nerve neuromodulation is safe, effective and durable in patients with
urge incontinence refractory to conservative treatment
Bouamrirene D., Micallef J.P.,
Rouanet P., and Bacou F. (2000) Electrical stimulation-induced changes in
double-wrapped muscles for dynamic graciloplasty. Arch. Surg. 135, 1161-1167.
Abstract: HYPOTHESIS: Treatment of fecal incontinence has been greatly improved
by electrical stimulation of gracilis muscle transposed around the anal canal.
Various configurations of the muscle have been used: single alpha, gamma,
epsilon muscle loops, split sling, or double wrap. We report herein experimental
data on muscle transformation and damage induced by the latter surgical
approach. DESIGN, INTERVENTIONS, AND MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: This study was
conducted on 4 groups of New Zealand white rabbits. Group 1 had unstimulated
transposed gracilis muscles. Group 2 had left transposed gracilis muscles
stimulated only. Group 3 had both right and left transposed gracilis muscles
stimulated. Group 4 were the controls (not operated on). Muscle properties were
studied by electrophysiological,immunohistochemical,and biochemical techniques.
RESULTS: Transformation from fast-contractile glycolytic muscle fibers into
fast-intermediate to slow-contractile oxidative muscle fiber types induced a
fatigue resistance of the transposed muscle that has undergone long-term
stimulation and muscle alterations characterized by fiber atrophy and fibrosis.
CONCLUSIONS: Whatever technique of dynamic graciloplasty is used, muscle
degeneration associated with mobilization might result primarily from the
surgical dissection, whereby collateral blood supply to the gracilis is
interrupted and exacerbated by long-term stimulation
Bourcier A.P. and Juras J.C.
(1995) Nonsurgical therapy for stress incontinence. Urol. Clin. North Am. 22,
613-627.
Abstract: This article discusses the therapies that have been developed for the
treatment of stress incontinence due to female pelvic-floor dysfunction. A
combination of pelvic muscle exercises, biofeedback, behavioral modification,
and electrical stimulation are all treatment options that do not involve
surgery. When physiotherapy proves successful, and surgery is avoided, it is
necessary for the patient to be put on a maintenance program to avoid relapse.
The authors also discuss the link between urinary stress incontinence and women
involved in sports
Bratt H., Salvesen K.A.,
Eriksen B.C., and Kulseng-Hanssen S. (1998) Long-term effects ten years after
maximal electrostimulation of the pelvic floor in women with unstable detrusor
and urge incontinence. Acta Obstet. Gynecol. Scand. Suppl 168, 22-24.
Abstract: OBJECTIVE: The purpose was to study any long-term therapeutic effects
of maximal electrical stimulation in female urge incontinence. METHODS: A postal
questionnaire containing six questions about urinary incontinence was
distributed to 30 women who had been treated with maximal stimulation because of
unstable detrusor and urge incontinence 9-13 years earlier. The response rate
was 90% (27 women). The mean age at follow-up was 62 years. RESULTS: Twenty-one
(78%) women reported symptoms of urge incontinence. Among them, 13 had this
problem daily, whereas eight only had problems weekly or even more seldom.
Nineteen (70%) women reported symptoms of stress incontinence. Twenty-one women
would have recommended maximal stimulation to a friend today. CONCLUSION: After
approximately ten years most of the women had symptoms of urge incontinence.
This was, however, a minor problem among a third of them. A majority of the
women were satisfied with maximal stimulation as a treatment modality. The
treatment had not prevented a later occurrence of stress incontinence
Brehmer M. and Nilsson B.Y.
(2000) Elevation of sensory thresholds in the prostatic urethra after microwave
thermotherapy. BJU. Int. 86, 427-431.
Abstract: OBJECTIVES: To determine whether transurethral microwave thermotherapy
(TUMT) affects the sensory threshold in the posterior urethra and whether such
an effect influences urinary storage symptoms. PATIENTS AND METHODS: The sensory
threshold was measured before and at 3 and 12 weeks after TUMT in 13 men with
minor obstructive symptoms caused by benign prostatic hyperplasia. Sensations
were evoked by electrical stimulation at different frequencies, using a bipolar
ring-electrode mounted on a urethral catheter. Changes in sensory thresholds
were evaluated in the patients both as a group and individually. The patients
were interviewed about their symptoms at each measurement. RESULTS: After TUMT,
12 patients were satisfied and reported decreased irritative symptoms, primarily
less frequent nocturnal micturition; two patients were cured of urgency
incontinence. In 11 of the satisfied patients, and the unsuccessful patient,
decreased urge accompanied increased sensory thresholds. Thresholds elevated by
>/= 30% were correlated with decreased irritative symptoms. CONCLUSIONS: TUMT
decreases sensitivity in the posterior urethra, which may alleviate storage
symptoms
Brown C. (1998) Pelvic floor
rehabilitation: conservative treatment for incontinence. Ostomy. Wound. Manage.
44, 72-76.
Abstract: Pelvic floor rehabilitation is used to treat stress urinary
incontinence, urge, and fecal incontinence as well as other pelvic floor
musculature disorders. When treating patients, it is important to thoroughly
assess the pelvic floor. In addition to evaluating the urinary system, sexual
and bowel functions must also be considered. Treatment plans should be devised
on an individual basis according to the evaluation findings. Rehabilitation
goals should be established. The patient must understand the function of her
urinary system and the role she must play in its control. Muscle retraining is
achieved through a personalized exercise program. This program may be augmented
by manual techniques, biofeedback or electrical stimulation. While the Agency
for Health Care Policy and Research (AHCPR) does endorse the use of behavioral
modalities in treating urinary incontinence, the use of bladder retraining and
pelvic floor rehabilitation is not always recommended when indicated, nor
accessible for all patients who require it. More research is needed, in addition
to ongoing public and professional education on behavioral interventions in
order to underline the advantages of this form of treatment for incontinence
Brubaker L., Benson J.T., Bent
A., Clark A., and Shott S. (1997) Transvaginal electrical stimulation for female
urinary incontinence. Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol. 177, 536-540.
Abstract: OBJECTIVE: Our purpose was to determine the objective and subjective
efficacy of transvaginal electrical stimulation for treatment of common forms of
urinary incontinence in women. STUDY DESIGN: A prospective, double-blind,
randomized clinical trial included 121 women with either urinary incontinence
caused by detrusor instability or genuine stress incontinence, or both (mixed
incontinence). Participants used the assigned device for 8 weeks. Identical
preintervention and postintervention assessment included multichannel urodynamic
testing, quality-of-life scale, and urinary diaries. RESULTS: A total of 121
women completed this study at four North American urogynecology centers.
Detrusor instability was cured (stable on provocative cystometry) in 49% of
women with detrusor instability who used an active electrical device (p =
0.0004, McNemar's test), whereas there was no statistically significant change
in the percentage with detrusor instability in the sham device group. There was
no statistically significant difference between the preintervention and
postintervention rates of genuine stress incontinence for either the active
device group or the sham device group. CONCLUSION: This form of transvaginal
electrical stimulation may be effective for treatment of detrusor overactivity,
with or without genuine stress incontinence
Brubaker L. (2000) Electrical
stimulation in overactive bladder. Urology 55, 17-23.
Abstract: Electrical stimulation is an effective and well-tolerated treatment
for overactive bladder. Initial work in animals indicated the potential of this
treatment, and early clinical experience in Europe further supported its likely
efficacy. Although the mechanism of action of electrical stimulation remains
unproven in humans, it is believed to be a neuromodulating therapy which affects
the neural signaling that controls continence. There is also strong evidence
that electrical stimulation affects striated muscle. The therapy can cause
hypertrophy of skeletal muscle fibers, possibly by the recruitment of faster-
conducting motor units, which would not normally be recruited during voluntary
efforts. In addition, electrical stimulation can alter the expression of myosin
isoforms, favoring a conversion to type I muscle. Despite our incomplete
understanding of the mechanism of action of electrical stimulation, clinical
devices have been developed quickly. Case series have been reported throughout
Europe. These were followed by controlled clinical trials in the United States.
There is good evidence that the use of vaginal electrical stimulators can reduce
the occurrence of symptoms of overactive bladder in about half of the patients
treated. Multiple uses of nonimplanted stimulation, including thigh stimulation,
anal stimulation, and direct pelvic muscle stimulation, have been reported. In
these trials, it is common for objective findings to be poorly correlated with
subjective reports of improvements or cure. Patients frequently report that the
urge-to-leak time improves, but this is difficult to measure objectively. The
use of nonimplanted devices is effective and well tolerated, and should precede
the use of implanted devices. A direct comparison with other effective methods
of treatment for overactive bladder is warranted
Caldwell K.P. (1968) The use of
electrical stimulation in urinary retention and incontinence. Proc. R. Soc. Med.
61, 703.
Caldwell K.P., Cook P.J., Flack
F.C., and James E.D. (1968) Urethral pressure recordings in male incontinents
under electrical stimulation. Invest Urol. 5, 572-579.
Caldwell K.P. (1974)
Proceedings: Electrical stimulation. Urol. Int. 29, 225.
Caputo R.M., Benson J.T., and
McClellan E. (1993) Intravaginal maximal electrical stimulation in the treatment
of urinary incontinence. J. Reprod. Med. 38, 667-671.
Abstract: Urinary incontinence imposes a large economic burden, estimated at $10
billion per year. As the cost of health care continues to rise, conservative
therapeutic measures are becoming more attractive. Anecdotal reports suggest
that electrical stimulation may be up to 87% effective in the treatment of
urinary incontinence. Investigators use different stimulation devices and
protocols and make a comparison of results difficult. The true efficacy of
electrical stimulation for the treatment of urinary incontinence is unknown
since there have been no controlled clinical trials. Within our referral-based
urogynecology practice, we employ intermittent, intravaginal maximal electrical
stimulation in conjunction with bladder drills and pelvic floor exercises. Over
a one-year period we treated 76 women with urinary incontinence: 19 with stress
incontinence (SUI), 30 with detrusor instability (DI) and 27 with mixed
incontinence (MI). After six weeks, our overall objective improvement rate was
76%; 89% of patients with SUI, 73% with DI and 70% with MI met the criteria for
improvement. Long- term follow-up averaged 6 months, with a range of 2-12. Of
patients who showed an initial objective improvement, 87% maintained that
improvement. Intravaginal electrical stimulation may be effective therapy for
urinary incontinence. Controlled clinical trials are needed to determine its
efficacy and standardize stimulation protocols before its widespread use
Chancellor M.B., Hong R.D.,
Rivas D.A., Watanabe T., Crewalk J.A., and Bourgeois I. (1997) Gracilis
urethromyoplasty--an autologous urinary sphincter for neurologically impaired
patients with stress incontinence. Spinal Cord. 35, 546-549.
Abstract: PURPOSE: To investigate the effect of a neurovascularly intact
gracilis muscle urethral wrap, to be used to restore urinary continence as a
transposed urinary sphincter graft, in patients with neurogenic lower urinary
tract dysfunction. METHODS: Five neurologically impaired men with a denervated
and damaged urinary sphincter mechanisms were treated. The etiology of
sphincteric insufficiency included sphincter denervation in three patients,
external sphincterotomy in one, and urethral trauma due to a chronic indwelling
catheter in one. All patients underwent gracilis urethromyoplasty sphincter
reconstruction. Two patients also underwent concomitant ileocystoplasty and one
patient ileocystostomy because of poor bladder compliance and a bladder capacity
of < 200 ml. RESULTS: The gracilis urethromyoplasty functioned as a new
autologous sphincter with follow-ups ranging from 6-35 months. The surgery was
successful in four patients. Three of the four patients were managed with
intermittent catheterization, and one managed by ileocystostomy. The fifth
patient continued to require an indwelling urethral catheter. CONCLUSION:
Gracilis urethromyoplasty achieves compression of the urethra using a
neurovascularly intact muscle graft. The functional urethral closure, obtained
from the gracilis muscle wrap, assures dryness, and permits intermittent
self-catheterization. It also avoids the risks of infection, erosion, or
malfunction associated with the artificial urinary sphincter. The potential
exists for electrical stimulation of this muscle graft to allow volitional
control of the neo-sphincter mechanism, and voluntary voiding
Chancellor M.B., Heesakkers
J.P., and Janknegt R.A. (1997) Gracilis muscle transposition with electrical
stimulation for sphincteric incontinence: a new approach. World J. Urol. 15,
320-328.
Abstract: Neurovascularly intact gracilis-muscle transposition to the proximal
urethra is an exciting new technique for sphincteric incontinence. The
functional urethral closure of gracilis myoplasty assures dryness, permits
intermittent self-catheterization when necessary, and avoids the risks of
erosion associated with the artificial urinary sphincter. Electrical stimulation
of the transposed muscle (dynamic urethral myoplasty) using intramuscular
electrodes and a subcutaneously placed pulse generator can alter the molecular
physiology of the gracilis muscle from that of predominantly fast-twitch to that
of slow-twitch fibers that are fatigue-resistant and more suitable for long-term
sphincter function
Collins C.D., Brown B.H., and
Duthie H.L. (1968) A basis for electrical stimulation for anal continence.
Scand. J. Gastroenterol. 3, 395-400.
Collins C.D., Brown B.H., and
Duthie H.L. (1969) An assessment of intraluminal electrical stimulation for anal
incontinence. Br. J. Surg. 56, 542-546.
Collins C.D. (1972) Urethral
incontinence in women. Observations on the effect of electrical stimulation.
Proc. R. Soc. Med. 65, 832-833.
Collins C.D. (1974)
Proceedings: Intermittent electrical stimulation. Urol. Int. 29, 221.
Creasey G.H., Kilgore K.L.,
Brown-Triolo D.L., Dahlberg J.E., Peckham P.H., and Keith M.W. (2000) Reduction
of costs of disability using neuroprostheses. Assist. Technol. 12, 67-75.
Abstract: The lifetime costs associated with spinal cord injury are substantial.
Assistive technology that reduces complications, increases independence, or
decreases the need for attendant services can provide economic as well as
medical or functional benefit. This study describes two approaches for
estimating the economic consequences of implanted neuroprostheses utilizing
functional electrical stimulation. Life care plan analysis was used to estimate
the costs of bladder and bowel care with and without a device restoring bladder
and bowel function and to compare these with the costs of implementing the
device. For a neuroprosthesis restoring hand grasp, the costs of implementation
were compared to the potential savings in attendant care costs that could be
achieved by the use of the device. The results indicate that the costs of
implementing the bladder and bowel system would be recovered in 5 years,
primarily from reduced costs of supplies, medications, and procedures. The costs
of the hand grasp neuroprosthesis would be recovered over the lifetime of the
user if attendant time was reduced only 2 hours per day and in a shorter time if
attendant care was further reduced. Neither analysis includes valuation of the
quality of life, which is further enhanced by the neuroprostheses through
restoration of greater independence and dignity. Our results demonstrate that
implantable neuroprosthetic systems provide good health care value in addition
to improved independence for the disabled individual
Dahms S.E. and Tanagho E.A.
(1998) The impact of sacral root anatomy on selective electrical stimulation for
bladder evacuation. World J. Urol. 16, 322-328.
Abstract: Although different structures have been studied with
electrostimulation to elicit bladder evacuation, only the sacral root remains
feasible for clinical application at present. However, the resultant concomitant
contractions of the bladder and sphincteric muscles have been the principal
problem over the last few decades. Attempts to identify fibers within the sacral
ventral root that innervate the detrusor predominantly have been made by
microsurgery alone or in combination with advanced electrical blocking
techniques. This article evaluates our past and present efforts to achieve
voiding in light of the mixed nature of sacral root anatomy
Davila G.W. (1994) Urinary
incontinence in women. How to help patients regain bladder control. Postgrad.
Med. 96, 103-110.
Abstract: Urinary incontinence can have devastating effects on a woman's social
life and physical activities. Simple diagnostic tools, including the Q- tip test
and cystometry, can help identify the cause. Many causes are reversible, and an
appropriate treatment regimen can bring improvement in or completely restore
bladder control. Management options that may help patients avoid surgical
intervention include bladder drills, pelvic floor muscle exercises, and
functional electrical stimulation. Additional nonsurgical approaches are
currently under investigation and should result in more options for treating
urinary incontinence in women
Deen K.I., Premaratna R.,
Fonseka M.M., and De Silva H.J. (1998) The recto-anal inhibitory reflex:
abnormal response in diabetics suggests an intrinsic neuroenteropathy. J.
Gastroenterol. Hepatol. 13, 1107-1110.
Abstract: As electrical stimulation of the rectum has been shown to result in
reflex internal sphincter inhibition mediated by intrinsic nerves, we aimed to
evaluate the integrity of these nerves in the rectum of diabetic patients. Anal
canal pressure, recto-anal inhibitory reflex (RAIR) and continence were
evaluated in 30 diabetic patients (male:female 13:17, median age 57 years, range
37-70) and these data were compared with similar data obtained from 22 age- and
sex-matched healthy controls (male:female 9:13, median age 51 years, range 19-65
years). Median duration of diabetes was 8 years (range 3-30). Twelve (40%) of
the 30 diabetics had impaired continence for gas (n = 12) and liquid faeces (n =
3). None of the controls had incontinence. Median maximum resting anal canal
pressure (MRP) was: patients 30 mmHg (range 20-75 mmHg) versus controls 40 mmHg
(range 20-105 mmHg, P = 0.61). Median maximum squeeze pressure (MSP) was 65 mmHg
(range 30-150 mmHg) in patients versus 84mmHg (range 35-230 mm Hg) in controls
(P = 0.59). Median threshold rectal mucosal electrosensation (RMES-T) was 27mA
(5- 40 mA) in patients versus 13 mA (5-28 mA) in controls (P = 0.03). Maximum
tolerable rectal mucosal electrosensation was 40 mA (20-60) in patients versus
20 mA (10-30), in controls (P = 0.042, all comparisons using the Wilcoxon rank
test). Recto-anal inhibitory reflex was present in eight, abnormal in five (one
incontinent) and absent in 17 (11 incontinent) diabetics, while it was present
in 18 and abnormal in four controls (test of proportion, P = 0.031). Blood
glucose in diabetics on the day of the procedure was 98 mg/dL (70-165 mg/dL).
Rectal mucosal electrosensitivity and RAIR were impaired in significantly more
patients with diabetes than controls, implying impairment of intrinsic neuronal
function. The recto-anal inhibitory reflex was either impaired or absent in all
diabetic patients with incontinence
Dijkema H.E., Weil E.H., Mijs
P.T., and Janknegt R.A. (1993) Neuromodulation of sacral nerves for incontinence
and voiding dysfunctions. Clinical results and complications. Eur. Urol. 24,
72-76.
Abstract: Neuromodulation of sacral nerves is a new form of treatment for
patients with refractory voiding dysfunctions such as incontinence, retention
and chronic pelvic pain. Electrical stimulation of S3 activates the pelvic floor
and modulates innervation of the bladder, sphincter and pelvic floor, restoring
the balance and coordination in sacral reflexes. 19 of 23 patients with an
implanted neuroprosthesis for neuromodulation have a more than 50% improvement
in their main symptoms after a median follow-up of 12 months. In
urge-incontinent patients the number of leakings decreased from 7.4 to 1.5/day,
and the functional capacity increased from 135 to 227 ml
Donnelly V.S., O'Herlihy C.,
Campbell D.M., and O'Connell P.R. (1998) Postpartum fecal incontinence is more
common in women with irritable bowel syndrome. Dis. Colon Rectum 41, 586-589.
Abstract: PURPOSE: Anal sphincter damage can occur during vaginal delivery and
may lead to impairment of fecal continence. The aim of this study was to
determine the influence of irritable bowel syndrome on symptoms of fecal
incontinence following first vaginal delivery. METHODS: A prospective,
observational study was performed before delivery, six weeks, and six months
following delivery in primiparous women. A bowel function questionnaire was
completed, and anal vector manometry, mucosal electrosensitivity, pudendal nerve
terminal motor latency, and anal endosonography were performed. A total of 208
women were assessed before and after delivery, and 104 primigravid women were
studied after delivery only. A total of 34 of 312 (11 percent) had an existing
diagnosis of irritable bowel syndrome. RESULTS: The prevalence of abnormal
manometry or endosonography was similar in women with and without irritable
bowel syndrome. However, six weeks after delivery, women with irritable bowel
syndrome had a higher incidence of defecatory urgency (64 percent) and loss of
control of flatus (35 percent) compared with those without (urgency, 10 percent,
P < 0.001; flatus, 13 percent, P = 0.007). The incidence of frank fecal
incontinence was similar in the two groups. Women with IBS had increased mucosal
sensitivity to electrical stimulation of the upper anal canal both before and
after delivery. CONCLUSION: Women with IBS are more likely to experience
subjective alteration of fecal continence postpartum compared with the healthy
primigravid population, but they are not at increased risk of anal sphincter
injury
Dorey G. (2000) Male patients
with lower urinary tract symptoms. 2: Treatment. Br. J. Nurs. 9, 553-558.
Abstract: The first part of this article (Dorey, 2000) described the subjective
and objective assessment of men with lower urinary tract symptoms (LUTS). This
article will examine treatment protocols for stress incontinence, urge
incontinence, post-prostatectomy incontinence, post- micturition dribble,
overflow incontinence, reflex incontinence and functional incontinence. Pelvic
floor muscle exercises, biofeedback, electrical stimulation, urge suppression
techniques, and fluid intake are discussed. It is concluded that men with LUTS
can benefit from conservative treatment
Dudognon P., Salle J.Y., Munoz
M., Guinvarc'h S., Bouru M., and Labrousse C. (1995) [Rehabilitation of female
urinary incontinence]. Rev. Prat. 45, 322-327.
Abstract: Perineal rehabilitation is an appropriate alternative to surgery in
the treatment of urinary female incontinence. The most important factors
influencing the success of this technique is the ability of the patient to
identify correctly the muscles of the pelvic floor, to strengthen this muscles
using exercises, electrical stimulation and biofeedback, to contract voluntarily
the pelvic floor musculature during stress or sensation of voiding for having a
preventive effect on loss of urine, and also to change, if necessary, the
micturitional and drinking customs. Some conditions are required to complete a
good result: strong motivation of the woman, ability of the physiotherapist or
the midwife, quality of care and follow-up of the physician who must clearly
know the place of this conservative treatment in selected patients, particularly
in moderate stress incontinence, without important prolapse, urge incontinence,
pregnancy and post-partum, two conditions in which this technique must have a
preventive and curative efficiency
Dumoulin C., Seaborne D.E.,
Quirion-DeGirardi C., and Sullivan S.J. (1995) Pelvic-floor rehabilitation, Part
1: Comparison of two surface electrode placements during stimulation of the
pelvic-floor musculature in women who are continent using bipolar interferential
currents. Phys. Ther. 75, 1067-1074.
Abstract: BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Electrical stimulation of the pelvic floor is
used as an adjunct in the conservative treatment of urinary incontinence. No
consensus exists, however, regarding electrode placements for optimal
stimulation of the pelvic-floor musculature. The purpose of this study was to
compare two different bipolar electrode placements, one suggested by Laycock and
Green (L2) the other by Dumoulin (D2), during electrical stimulation with
interferential currents of the pelvic-floor musculature in continent women,
using a two-group crossover design. SUBJECTS: Ten continent female volunteers,
ranging in age from 20 to 39 years (mean = 27.3, SD = 5.6), were randomly
assigned to one of two study groups. METHODS: Each study group received
neuromuscular electrical stimulation (NMES) of the pelvic- floor musculature
using both electrode placements, the order of application being reversed for
each group. Force of contraction was measured as pressure (in centimeters of
water [cm H2O]) exerted on a vaginal pressure probe attached to a manometer.
Data were analyzed using a two-way, mixed-model analysis of variance. RESULTS:
No difference in pressure was observed between the two electrode placements.
Differences in current amplitude were observed, with the D2 electrode placement
requiring less current amplitude to produce a maximum recorded pressure on the
manometer. Subjective assessment by the subjects revealed a preference for the
D2 electrode placement (7 of 10 subjects). CONCLUSION AND DISCUSSION: The lower
current amplitudes required with the D2 placement to obtain recordings
comparable to those obtained with the L2 technique suggest a more comfortable
stimulation of the pelvic-floor muscles. The lower current amplitudes required
also suggest that greater increases in pressure might be obtained with the D2
placement by increasing the current amplitude while remaining within the comfort
threshold. These results will help to define treatment guidelines for a planned
clinical study investigating the effects of NMES and exercise in the treatment
of urinary stress incontinence in women postpartum. [Dumoulin C, Seaborne DE,
Quirion-DeGirardi C, Sullivan SJ. Pelvic-floor rehabilitation, part 1:
comparison of two surface electrode placements during stimulation of the
pelvic-floor musculature in women who are continent using bipolar interferential
currents
Duthie H.L. (1968) The use of
intermittent electrical stimulation in anal incontinence. Proc. R. Soc. Med. 61,
706-707.
Eckstein H.B. (1975) Treatment
of incontinence by electrical stimulation. Nurs. Times 71, 1423-1424.
Egon G., Barat M., Colombel P.,
Visentin C., Isambert J.L., and Guerin J. (1998) Implantation of anterior sacral
root stimulators combined with posterior sacral rhizotomy in spinal injury
patients. World J. Urol. 16, 342-349.
Abstract: Brindley-Finetech sacral anterior root stimulators combined with
posterior sacral rhizotomy were implanted in 68 males and 28 females with spinal
cord lesions. In 9 patients the electrodes were implanted extradurally in the
sacrum, and in 90 patients they were implanted intradurally (3 patients had a
second extradural implant after a first intradural implant). Three patients died
from causes unrelated to the implant. Of the 93 surviving patients, 83 used
their implants for micturition and 82 were fully continent. The mean bladder
capacity increased from 206 ml preoperatively to 564 ml after the operation.
Three patients had a preoperative vesicorenal reflux that disappeared after
surgery. In all, 51 patients used the stimulator for defecation. Erection was
possible with electrical stimulation in 46 males and was used for coitus by 17
couples. Secondary deafferentation at the level of the conus was performed four
times. Three patients who had a cerebrospinal fluid leak were operated on again.
Two implants had to be removed because of infection. Sacral anterior root
stimulation combined with sacral deafferentation is a welcome addition to the
treatment of neurogenic bladder in spinal cord injury patients
Erlandson B.E., Fall M.,
Carlsson C.A., and Linder L.E. (1977) Mechanisms for closure of the human
urethra during intravaginal electrical stimulation. Scand. J. Urol. Nephrol.
Suppl 49-54.
Abstract: The effect of intravaginal electrical stimulation (IVS) on the
urethral pressure profile (UPP) before and during succinylcholine blockade or
spinal anaesthesia was studied in patients with stress incontinence and in
patients with clinically normal urethral function. During succinylcholine
blockade, the UPP was lowered to 74% and during spinal anaesthesia to 39% of the
original maximal UPP. IVS could not influence the UPP during succinylcholine
blockade, while the UPP could be restored during spinal anaesthesia when the
stimulation strength was increased 3 to 4 times. The following conclusions were
arrived at: 1) The urethral effect of IVS is due to activation of somatic nerves
and not to activation of nerves supplying smooth muscles or direct activation of
striated and smooth muscles. 2) The more pronounced depression of the UPP during
spinal anaesthesia compared to succinylcholine blockade should be caused by the
loss of nervous activity of the smooth muscles. 3) The fact that the UPP could
be restored during spinal anaesthesia indicates that activation of somatic
efferents can compensate for the loss of striated and smooth muscle activity.
Therefore, IVS can control incontinence in partial lower motor neuron lesions,
provided a sufficient number of efferent neurons are preserved
Erlandson B.E., Fall M., and
Carlsson C.A. (1977) The effect of intravaginal electrical stimulation on the
feline urethra and urinary bladder. Electrical parameters. Scand. J. Urol.
Nephrol. Suppl 5-18.
Abstract: Intravaginal electrical stimulation (IVS) in cats caused urethral
closure and bladder inhibition. The aim was to ascertain the electrical
parameters most appropriate for these effects. Minimum voltage was used as main
criterion to select an effective, non-destructive stimulation when the shape,
frequency and duration of the pulses were systematically varied. Urethral
closure was achieved at minimum voltage (3 V) with alternating pulses at a
frequency of 50 Hz and a pulse duration of 1.5 ms. Corresponding optimal
parameters for bladder inhibition were: alternating pulses, 10 Hz and 1.5 ms.
Minimum voltage was 1 V. Moreover, the positions of the electrodes were of
significance for the responses. The clinical implications of these findings are
that: 1)more differentiated treatment of incontinence could be achieved by
adapting the stimulation parameters to the cause of incontinence, and 2)
specific electrode positions would probably give optimal responses
Erlandson B.E., Fall M., and
Sundin T. (1977) Intravaginal electrical stimulation. Clinical experiments of
urethral closure. Scand. J. Urol. Nephrol. Suppl 31-39.
Abstract: The effect on the urethra of intravaginal electrical stimulation (IVS)
was registered by means of urethral pressure profiles (UPP). With the object of
finding the most appropriate electrical parameters and optimal electrode
positions within the vagina, 24 patients with stress incontinence, 22 with
urgency and 4 continent women were studied. Electrical stimulation was given via
an obturator with seven electrodes, which could be connected in different
combinations of pairs. In all the women, stimulation with the electrodes in
specific positions effected a more marked rise in the UPPs than with the
electrodes in other positions. A change in position of more than 5 to 10 mm
caused a decrease in the response. It was determined that a frequency of between
20 to 50 Hz with a pulse duration of 1 to 5 ms was most effective for urethral
closure
Esa A., Kiwamoto H., Sugiyama
T., Park Y.C., Kaneko S., and Kurita T. (1991) Functional electrical stimulation
in the management of incontinence: studies of urodynamics. Int. Urol. Nephrol.
23, 135-141.
Abstract: Intermittent functional electrical stimulation (FES) was employed for
the control of incontinence. One FES session lasted for 30 minutes. It was
repeated at intervals of 3 days to 1 week via an anal plug electrode. The
success rate was 64% in 41 patients with pollakiuria, urgency and/or urge
incontinence, and 43% in 7 patients with stress incontinence. Detrusor activity
measured by cystometry did not correlate significantly with the effect on
subjective symptoms and the urethral pressure did not increase. The remarkable
clinical effect was observed in patients with overactive detrusor function. It
seems that FES indirectly inhibits detrusor contraction by suppressing the
intrasacral pathway for detrusor activity
Fall M., Erlandson B.E., Sundin
T., and Waagstein F. (1977) Intravaginal electrical stimulation. Clinical
experiments on bladder inhibition. Scand. J. Urol. Nephrol. Suppl 41-47.
Abstract: The effect of intravaginal electrical stimulation (IVS) on the bladder
in 17 patients with motor detrusor instability was explored. Isotonic volume
registrations and cystometries were used for evaluation of volume increase and
inhibition of abortive detrusor contractions. With either one or the other
method, bladder inhibition was found in all patients, but with both methods only
in 6. During isotonic volume registration, the volume increase showed
considerable variations ranging between 4 to 465%, and during cystometry between
11 to 3500%. Bladder inhibition proved to be most effective when using a
frequency of 10 Hz
Fall M., Erlandson B.E., Nilson
A.E., and Sundin T. (1977) Long-term intravaginal electrical stimulation in urge
and stress incontinence. Scand. J. Urol. Nephrol. Suppl 55-63.
Abstract: Using a new device for intravaginal electrical stimulation (IVS), 24
women with pure stress incontinence, mixed urge and stress incontinence or urge
incontinence due to detrusor instability, were treated. To minimize mechanical
discomfort, the electrode carrier was made of flexible material and inflatable.
Furthermore, this design facilitated fixed, constant positioning of the
electrodes at individually tested sites to produce maximum response at voltage
well tolerated by the patient. The stimulation frequency was adjusted to suit
the cause of incontinence: 20 to 50 Hz in stress incontinence, 10 Hz detrusor
instability. The electrode carrier was well accepted. Seven of the 9 patients
with pure stress incontinence became continent during IVS. Three of them have so
far remained continent for 2 to 8 months without IVS. The 15 patients with
detrusor instability or mixed incontinence were all free from symptoms after IVS
for more than 3 months. Two of them have remained cured for more than 3 months
after they had stopped IVS
Fall M., Erlandson B.E.,
Carlsson C.A., and Sundin T. (1978) Effects of electrical intravaginal
stimulation on bladder volume: an experimental and clinical study. Urol. Int.
33, 440-442.
Abstract: Clinical observations have indicated that not only stress incontinence
due to defective urethral closure but also urge incontinence due to bladder
hyperactivity can be successfully treated by electrical stimulation of the
pelvic floor. Clinical investigations revealed that intravaginal electrical
stimulation caused bladder inhibition registered as a volume increase. This
inhibition was most marked at a low stimulation frequency (10 Hz). Animal
experiments indicated that the bladder inhibition was achieved by autonomic
spinal reflex mechanisms activated by stimulation of pudendal afferents
Fall M. (1984) Does
electrostimulation cure urinary incontinence? J. Urol. 131, 664-667.
Abstract: A followup study is presented of a prospective series of women treated
with an inflatable intravaginal electrode carrier and an external pulse
generator. The devices were individually adjustable with respect to electrode
positioning and stimulation parameters. The study included 40 women with
detrusor instability and/or genuine stress incontinence. The primary results for
urge symptoms were favorable. Of the patients 73 per cent were primarily free of
symptoms during treatment and 45 per cent remained free of symptoms after
withdrawal of treatment, including two-thirds in whom re-education persisted
during the followup of 6 years. Of the patients with genuine stress incontinence
40 per cent exhibited persistent re-education. There were considerable
discrepancies between symptomatic cure or improvement, and the urodynamic
findings at followup. Intravaginal electrical stimulation may be regarded as the
treatment of choice for urge incontinence due to detrusor instability, and in
mixed stress and urge incontinence. The method also is an alternative to an
operation in some women with genuine stress incontinence
Fall M., Ahlstrom K., Carlsson
C.A., Ek A., Erlandson B.E., Frankenberg S., and Mattiasson A. (1986) Contelle:
pelvic floor stimulator for female stress-urge incontinence. A multicenter
study. Urology 27, 282-287.
Abstract: The clinical efficacy of a new device for treatment of female
incontinence was studied in a multicenter trial. The device consists of an
inflatable electrode carrier and an external stimulator unit. Forty women were
treated: 10 had primary or recurrent genuine stress incontinence, 15 had urge
incontinence due to idiopathic detrusor instability, not responding to drug
treatment, and 15 had stress incontinence combined with detrusor instability.
Twenty-five patients were improved by the treatment. Another 8 reported an
excellent result of treatment and remained free of symptoms for more than six
months after withdrawal of the treatment. The results were more favorable in
patients with bladder hyperactivity than in genuine stress incontinence. The
patients' general ratings of treatment efficacy correlated well with their
recordings of urinary frequency and consumption of incontinence pads. The
functional bladder capacity increased in improved patients, but normalization of
urodynamic parameters was no prerequisite for clinical improvement. We found
intravaginal electrical stimulation to be a valuable alternative to medical and
surgical intervention in patients with detrusor instability
Fall M. and Lindstrom S. (1991)
Electrical stimulation. A physiologic approach to the treatment of urinary
incontinence. Urol. Clin. North Am. 18, 393-407.
Abstract: Appropriate management of patients with urinary incontinence requires
access to a variety of methods. Electrical stimulation, although so far
proportionally small in the armamentarium of methods, is founded on physiologic
principles and has the advantage of being curative without significant side
effects
Fall M. (1998) Advantages and
pitfalls of functional electrical stimulation. Acta Obstet. Gynecol. Scand.
Suppl 168, 16-21.
Abstract: Functional electrical stimulation has many theoretical advantages. In
clinical practice, very favorable results have been repeatedly presented. The
experience now encompasses thirty years and a very large number of incontinent
patients. Although the methods are widely used, they are differently
appreciated. Problems include the fact that functional electrical stimulation
does not belong to the therapeutic traditions in urology and gynecology, there
is a need of personal training for successful treatment and there is a lack of
systematic studies on different clinical applications. Significant advantages
are a rational physiological basis, applicability in a variety of lower urinary
tract dysfunctions, few side effects and a potential curative effect
Flack F.C. (1968) The use of
electrical stimulation in urinary retention and incontinence. Proc. R. Soc. Med.
61, 704.
Flannery J.F., Ellis F.G., and
Lale P.G. (1969) Electrical stimulation of the striated urinary sphincter
mechanism. Br. J. Surg. 56, 632.
Formal C.S., Cawley M.F., and
Stiens S.A. (1997) Spinal cord injury rehabilitation. 3. Functional outcomes.
Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil. 78, S59-S64.
Abstract: This self-directed learning module highlights new advances in this
topic area. It is part of the chapter on spinal cord injury rehabilitation in
the Self-Directed Physiatric Education Program for practitioners and trainees in
physical medicine and rehabilitation. This article contains information about
mobility, ambulation, upper extremity function, bowel management, and technology
to enhance function in the community. New advances covered in this section
include functional electrical stimulation for enhancing mobility and upper
extremity function
Fossberg E., Sorensen S., Ruutu
M., Bakke A., Stien R., Henriksson L., and Kinn A.C. (1990) Maximal electrical
stimulation in the treatment of unstable detrusor and urge incontinence. Eur.
Urol. 18, 120-123.
Abstract: Ninety-one patients with unstable detrusor and urge incontinence were
treated with maximal electrical stimulation. There were 17 dropouts. From the
remaining 74 patients 51 were subjectively cured or significantly improved, this
effect lasted for more than 6 weeks in 40. Objectively a significant decrease in
frequency was found, also a significant increase in bladder volume. No effect on
detrusor pressure at bladder contraction was noted
Geirsson G. and Fall M. (1997)
Maximal functional electrical stimulation in routine practice. Neurourol. Urodyn.
16, 559-565.
Abstract: Maximal functional electrical stimulation is now an established
treatment for urgency and urge incontinence. Many studies have been presented
with good and consistent results. In a number of prospective studies we have
previously recorded very favourable effects in stress incontinence and urge
incontinence. In the present study, we have compared our previous experience
with a retrospective analysis of a series of maximal functional electrical
stimulation given according to a simple routine protocol and including 84
patients. The overall subjective improvement rate was 54% but the cure rate was
only 5%, which is far below our experience in previous studies, as well as in
others. The subjective outcome was in agreement with changes in mictrurition
variables as recorded in voiding diaries. The discrepancy probably depends on a
number of factors. It is suggested that the most crucial ones are patient
selection, the intensity of stimulation, and the number of sessions given. It is
important to realize the limitations and pitfalls of the technique when it is
applied in routine practice
George B.D., Williams N.S.,
Patel J., Swash M., and Watkins E.S. (1993) Physiological and histochemical
adaptation of the electrically stimulated gracilis muscle to neoanal sphincter
function. Br. J. Surg. 80, 1342-1346.
Abstract: The physiological and histochemical characteristics of the gracilis
muscle were studied in 19 patients undergoing electrically stimulated gracilis
neosphincter construction. Indications for surgery were faecal incontinence (n =
11) and reconstruction following sphincter excision or congenital absence (n =
8). Transposition of the gracilis muscle around the anal canal followed by
chronic low-frequency electrical stimulation was associated with a shift in the
frequency-response curve and a prolongation of the time-course of individual
muscle twitches suggestive of transformation to a slow-twitch fatigue-resistant
type. Temporary cessation of electrical stimulation resulted in a reversal of
the frequency-response changes. Muscle biopsies taken before and a median of 80
(range 49-137) days after transposition and low-frequency electrical stimulation
indicated a significant increase in the proportion of type 1 fibres and a
significant decrease in their diameter. These results show that the human
gracilis muscle is capable of physiological and histochemical adaptation to
long-term neosphincter function
Gladh G., Mattsson S., and
Lindstrom S. (2001) Anogenital electrical stimulation as treatment of urge
incontinence in children. BJU. Int. 87, 366-371.
Abstract: OBJECTIVES: To evaluate retrospectively the result of anogenital
afferent stimulation (AGAS) in neurological healthy children with
therapy-resistant urge incontinence. PATIENTS AND METHODS: The study included 48
children (24 girls and 24 boys, 5-14 years old) with a diagnosis of bladder
instability verified by cystometry in all. Anogenital afferent stimulations were
applied using a battery-powered dual constant-current stimulator. The children
were stimulated continuously at 10 Hz for 20 min once or twice daily and if
required the children and/or the parents continued to apply the treatment at
home. For home stimulation a single (anal) channel stimulator was used. The
patients were instructed to stimulate for 20 min at maximum intensity two to
three times a week until the effects were optimal. The outcome was evaluated
retrospectively by comparing voiding/incontinence diaries obtained before and at
the follow-up 6-12 months after the end of treatment. RESULTS: AGAS was applied
at the clinic for a median (range) of 9 (4-20) times. Thirty-one children
continued with home stimulation for another 25 (5-96) sessions. At the
follow-up, 18 children were cured and another seven improved, with a leakage
score of less than half that before treatment. The treatment was well tolerated
by most children. CONCLUSIONS: Anogenital afferent stimulation is an effective,
potentially curative treatment in children with severe urge incontinence. Home
stimulation is a well accepted adjuvant to treatment at the clinic and improves
the outcome
Godec C., Cass A.S., and Ayala
G.F. (1975) Bladder inhibition with functional electrical stimulation. Urology
6, 663-666.
Abstract: Spastic or hyperreflex bladder dysfunction can cause frequency,
urgency, and incontinence. Detrusor activity was inhibited by FES (functional
electrical stimulation) applied to the anal sphincter causing decreased bladder
spasticity and increased bladder capacity. FES is indicated for incontinence not
only because of weakness of the pelvic floor but also because of hyperreflex
bladder
Godec C. and Kralj B. (1976)
Selection of patients with urinary incontinence for application of functional
electrical stimulation. Urol. Int. 31, 124-128.
Abstract: Contradictory data from the literature along with our own experience
using functional electrical stimulation (FES) have facilitated the determination
of objective criteria for the application of FES in correcting urinary
incontinence. Simultaneous urodynamic, neurophysiological, and radiological
examinations employed during our studies enabled us to determine changes in
these parameters due to FEX. Among a large number of patients with urinary
incontinence (for example: paraplegics, patients with spina bifida, stress
incontinence following prostate operations, or resistant enuresis) we have
determined that FES is appropriate if applied to properly selected patients. FES
is indicated on the basis of the following criteria: the degree of morphological
lesion of the urinary tract, the peripheral denervation of the muscles of the
pelvic floor, the condition of the spinal center for miction, and, above all the
quality of response to FES. FES not only activates the closing muscles of the
bladder, but also inhibits the reflex contractions of the detrusor. Here, it
should be noted that FES is indicated for cases of reflex incontinence. During
FES of the pelvic floor muscles intravesical pressure normally diminishes and
the reflex contractions of the detrusor subside. Sometimes, however, the reflex
of miction occurs. In such a case, two reflex mechanisms are engaged. Their
equilibrium, i.e. controlled miction, can be achieved with an afferent in flow
which inhibits the reflex of miction. The use of FES for the correction of
urinary incontinence can be a very good method if the FES parameters are
individually chosen and patients properly selected
Godec C., Cass A.S., and Ayala
G.F. (1976) Electrical stimulation for incontinence. Technique, selection, and
results. Urology 7, 388-397.
Abstract: Incontinence due to hyperreflexic bladder and/or pelvic floor weakness
can be corrected by chronic functional electrical stimulation (FES). Cystometry,
electromyography of pelvic floor muscles, and anal sphincter pressure
measurements with and without electrical stimulation determines if chronic FES
will be successful. Post-acute stimulation improvement occurred in patients with
incontinence due to hyperreflexic bladder and/or pelvic floor weakness. A
success rate of 92 per cent was achieved with chronic FES in incontinent
patients with this method of selection
Godec C., Ayala G., and Cass A.
(1977) Electrical stimulation of the rectal ampulla causing reflex voiding. J.
Urol. 117, 770-772.
Abstract: Electrical stimulation of the rectal ampulla resulted in a desire to
void and defecate in 11 patients with an intact nervous system. There was a
contraction of the detrusor and the rectal ampulla with relaxation of the anal
sphincter. Electrical stimulation of the rectal ampulla and anal sphincter has
clinical applications in patients with incontinence of, or inability to empty,
the lower urinary tract or fecal system
Godec C. and Cass A. (1978)
Acute electrical stimulation for urinary incontinence. Urology 12, 340-341.
Abstract: Acute or maximal electric stimulation of the pelvic floor muscles has
been used in incontinent patients who are suitable candidates for electrical
stimulation, but unwilling or unable to use the anal plug electrodes. Seventeen
of 20 patients had relief or improvement of their incontinence. However 5 of
these 17 patients had a relapse of symptoms on follow-up, requiring a repeat
treatment with acute or maximal electrical stimulation
Godec C. and Cass A.S. (1978)
Electrical stimulation in the management of incontinence in children. Minn. Med.
61, 157-160.
Godec C. and Cass A.S. (1979)
Electrical stimulation for voiding dysfunction after spinal cord injury. J. Urol.
121, 73-75.
Abstract: Incontinence and frequency of voiding were present after spinal cord
injuries in 18 patients. A hyperreflexic bladder and/or pelvic floor weakness
was found in these patients. Functional electrical stimulation resulted in
relief or improvement of symptoms in 9 of the 11 patients in whom this procedure
was used. An increase in anal sphincter pressure with functional electrical
stimulation was a more reliable criterion than an increase in maximum urethral
pressure in the selection of patients for the procedure
Godec C.J. and Cass A.S. (1978)
Electrical stimulation for incontinence in myelomeningocele. J. Urol. 120,
729-731.
Abstract: Urinary incontinence is the most obvious urinary tract complication in
children with myelomeningocele. Incontinence is owing to a hyperreflexic
(spastic) bladder and/or pelvic floor weakness, which responds to functional
electrical stimulation. Of 33 incontinent children the criteria for functional
electrical stimulation were absent in 21 because of denervation of the pelvic
floor muscles. Of 6 children who used functional electrical stimulation 5 had a
successful result. However, incontinence recurred in 3 of the 5 patients between
6 and 18 months after functional electrical stimulation treatment was completed
and they are awaiting repeat treatment
Godec C.J., Fravel R., and Cass
A.S. (1981) Optimal parameters of electrical stimulation in the treatment of
urinary incontinence. Invest Urol. 18, 239-241.
Abstract: We evaluated five types of electrical stimulation (continuous,
intermittent pseudorandomized, randomized (stochastic), and intermittent
randomized) for their effects on muscle contraction and muscle fatigue in 12
patients with urinary incontinence. Continuous stimulation, used in the
available commercial stimulators, was not optimal. Randomized (stochastic)
stimulation seems to be optimal although this conclusion was not statistically
confirmed
Gonzalez-Chamorro F., Verdu T.F.,
and Hernandez F.C. (1997) [Current status of neurostimulation and
neuromodulation for vesicourethral dysfunction]. Arch. Esp. Urol. 50, 687-694.
Abstract: OBJECTIVE: To describe the current indications, techniques and results
of sacral root stimulation in patients with spinal cord lesions as a treatment
for patients with high pressure bladders and/or urinary incontinence despite
conservative management, as well as sacral root neuromodulation with permanent
stimulators for complex bladder dysfunction: vesical instability, sensory
urgency, chronic pelvic pain and chronic voiding dysfunction. METHODS/RESULTS:
The literature is reviewed, both techniques are described and the results of the
most significant series are discussed, with special reference to the first
groups that utilized these techniques. CONCLUSIONS: There is ample experience in
the application of sacral root electrical stimulation. The reported results are
comparable with those achieved by other treatments, such as augmentation
cystoplasty. Neurostimulation and neuromodulation techniques are simple, the
complications are minimal and they do not prelude the use of other therapies
Gonzalez-Chamorro F., Esteban
F.M., Tamayo Ruiz J.C., Angulo C.J., and Sanchez-Chapado M. (1998) [Electric
stimulation of sacral roots for the treatment of urinary incontinence due to
detrusor instability: application of a technique and results in a clinical
case]. Arch. Esp. Urol. 51, 278-283.
Abstract: OBJECTIVE: To describe a case treated with a new technique in our
therapeutic algorithm for non-neurogenic vesicourethral dysfunction.
METHODS/RESULTS: A 47-year-old female underwent retropubic urethropexy for
stress urinary incontinence. She remained incontinent due to detrusor
instability to a degree that was socially unacceptable. After conservative
treatment had failed, a percutaneous electrode was applied to the sacral nerve
root and she received electrical stimulation of 4-6 milliamperes, 15 Hz and 200
microseconds duration for 7 days. Incontinence remitted for as long as 3 months
after the electrode had been removed. CONCLUSION: The results achieved with
sacral nerve electrical stimulation reported in the literature and our results
support the use of this technique in urological clinical practice
Grandjean P., Acker M., Madoff
R., Williams N.S., Woloszko J., and Kantor C. (1996) Dynamic myoplasty: surgical
transfer and stimulation of skeletal muscle for functional substitution or
enhancement. J. Rehabil. Res. Dev. 33, 133-144.
Abstract: Dynamic myoplasty combines muscle transfer with electrical stimulation
to provide contractile function that augments or replaces impaired organ
function. Dynamic cardiomyoplasty was the first clinical application in which a
skeletal muscle, latissimus dorsi, was transferred and stimulated to provide
cardiac assistance, a function different from its original one. The problem of
early muscle fatigue that was encountered in the initial implementation of the
method was solved by training the muscle with electrical stimulation and thus
changing its fiber composition. With intramuscular electrodes, the conditioned
latissimus dorsi is stimulated in synchrony with the heart muscle. Safeguards
are built into the two-channel implanted stimulator to avoid excessively high
pulse rates. Clinicians report that 80% of patients with moderate to severe
heart failure prior to operation showed a clinical improvement of 1.6 New York
Heart Association classes. Alternative methods of providing cardiac assistance
that are also being investigated include wrapping the muscle around the aorta,
creating a skeletal muscle ventricle, and using the muscle to power an
implantable pump. These latter techniques are still under preclinical
investigation. Compared with heart transplant, cardiomyoplasty has the great
advantage of not being subject to tissue rejection. The second principal
application of dynamic myoplasty is treatment of fecal incontinence through
creation of an electrically stimulated skeletal muscle neosphincter (ESMNS). The
gracilis muscle of the leg is mobilized, wrapped around the anal canal, and
conditioned with electrical stimulation to become more fatigue resistant. To
achieve continence, the muscle is continuously stimulated except when the
patient wishes to defecate. Overall success rates in achieving continence are
60-65%. Both cardiomyoplasty and the ESMNS technique, and their associated
devices, are being refined through ongoing clinical trials
Halverstadt D.B. (1971)
Electrical stimulation of the human bladder: 3 years later. J. Urol. 106,
673-677.
Hay-Smith E.J., Bo K.,
Berghmans L.C., Hendriks H.J., de Bie R.A., and van W. (2001) Pelvic floor
muscle training for urinary incontinence in women (Cochrane Review). Cochrane.
Database. Syst. Rev. 1, CD001407.
Abstract: BACKGROUND: Pelvic floor muscle training is the most commonly
recommended physical therapy treatment for women with stress leakage of urine.
It is also used in the treatment of women with mixed incontinence, and less
commonly for urge incontinence. Adjuncts, such as biofeedback or electrical
stimulation, are also commonly used with pelvic floor muscle training. The
content of pelvic floor muscle training programmes is highly variable.
OBJECTIVES: To determine the effects of pelvic floor muscle training for women
with symptoms or urodynamic diagnoses of stress, urge and mixed incontinence, in
comparison to no treatment or other treatment options. SEARCH STRATEGY: Search
strategy: We searched the Cochrane Incontinence Group trials register (May
2000), Medline (1980 to 1998), Embase (1980 to 1998), the database of the Dutch
National Institute of Allied Health Professions (to 1998), the database of the
Cochrane Rehabilitation and Related Therapies Field (to 1998), Physiotherapy
Index (to 1998) and the reference lists of relevant articles. We handsearched
the proceedings of the International Continence Society (1980 to 2000). We
contacted investigators in the field to locate studies. Date of the most recent
searches: May 2000. SELECTION CRITERIA: Randomised trials in women with symptoms
or urodynami |