|














| |
Electrical Stimulation In
Incontinence
Adobe Reader Version
(2000) Pelvic floor electrical
stimulation in the treatment of adult urinary incontinence. Tecnologica. MAP.
Suppl 15-17.
Abelli L., Ferri G.L., Astolfi
M., Conte B., Geppetti P., Parlani M., Dahl D., Polak J.M., and Maggi C.A.
(1991) Acrylamide-induced visceral neuropathy: evidence for the involvement of
capsaicin-sensitive nerves of the rat urinary bladder. Neuroscience 41, 311-321.
Abstract: The mechanisms underlying the severe urinary retention induced by
acrylamide intoxication were studied in detail in the rat. Subcutaneous
treatment with acrylamide monomer (50 mg/kg daily for 10 days) almost completely
impaired the micturition reflex, resulting in urinary retention. In fact, the
ability to eliminate an oral water load was virtually abolished, while bladder
filling with saline (transvesical cystometrogram) failed to activate reflex
micturition. Instead, a picture of overflow incontinence resulted in
urethane-anaesthetized rats, which was not reversed by intravenous
administration of 4- aminopyridine. The nerve-mediated contractile response to
field stimulation (0.1-20 Hz, 0.5 ms, 60 V) of the isolated bladder was
unaffected, thus suggesting the integrity of bladder efferent innervation, and
no evidence was found from in vitro experiments that the myogenic contractility
of the bladder was depressed by acrylamide treatment. Conversely, the sensory
nerve-mediated response to capsaicin was abolished and sensory nerve fibres of
the bladder were selectively depleted of their content of substan
Aitchison M., Fisher B.M.,
Carter K., McKee R., MacCuish A.C., and Finlay I.G. (1991) Impaired anal
sensation and early diabetic faecal incontinence. Diabet. Med. 8, 960-963.
Abstract: Faecal incontinence develops in up to 20% of diabetic patients. To try
to determine the relative contributions of sensory and motor neuropathy in this
troublesome complication, anorectal function was examined in 10 male diabetic
patients with early faecal incontinence (mucus leakage or faecal staining
without the need to wear a pad), 10 asymptomatic male diabetic patients, and 10
normal control subjects. Motor function was tested using anal manometry to
determine the resting and maximum squeeze pressure, and the functional anal
canal length. No significant differences were found between the groups. Sensory
function was tested by measuring the mucosal sensitivity to electrical
stimulation, and the response to inflation of a balloon in the rectum. In the
mid-anal canal position the symptomatic patients had a significantly higher
sensory threshold at 6.6 +/- 2.8 mA compared with 3.0 +/- 1.2 mA in the normal
control subjects (p less than 0.002), and in the high anal zone symptomatic
patients had a significantly elevated sensory threshold at 9.1 +/- 2.0 mA
compared with 4.6 +/- 1.6 mA in asymptomatic patients and 3.6 +/- 1.3 mA in the
normal control subjects (both p less than 0.001). There were no significant
differences in the first sensation of fullness, maximum tolerated volume or
percentage fall from resting pressure between the groups on inflation of the
balloon. Elevation of the sensory threshold in the upper anal canal is an early
abnormality in the development of diabetic faecal incontinence
Alexander S. and Rowan D.
(1966) Closure of the urinary sphincter mechanism in anaesthetized dogs by means
of electrical stimulation of the perineal muscles. Br. J. Surg. 53, 1053-1056.
Alexander S. (1976) A critical
look at incontinence radio-implants. Urol. Int. 31, 129-133.
Abstract: Indwelling electrical stimulation of the pelvic floor by a radio-
implant benefits some cases of problem or recurrent urinary incontinence. It is
not possible to predict success or failure with a given patient. The only
worthwhile criterion for selection is the presence of contraction of pelvic
floor musculature in response to voluntary effort or trial electrical
stimulation. The results are not simply explained by postulating electrically
induced closure of the urethra. There may be conscious enhancement of the
urinary sphincter mechanism. Re-education of voluntary sphincter muscles by
electrophysiotherapy may occur. Reflex inhibition of the detrusor may occur. The
surgery involved in inserting an implant restores continence in some patients
Andersson K.E., Andersson P.O.,
Fovaeus M., Hedlund H., Malmgren A., and Sjogren C. (1988) Effects of pinacidil
on bladder muscle. Drugs 36 Suppl 7, 41-49.
Abstract: Infravesical outflow obstruction and bladder hypertrophy are often
associated with bladder hyperactivity causing frequency, urge and urinary
incontinence. This hyperactivity may be due to a supersensitivity to
depolarising stimuli. Drugs that inhibit smooth muscle activity by opening K+
channels, resulting in hyperpolarisation, would therefore seem to be an
attractive therapeutic principle. Pinacidil is an effective vasodilator
classified as a K+ channel opener. The drug has been shown to effectively
depress spontaneous contractile activity, the contractions induced by low (less
than 40 mmol/L) concentrations of K+, carbachol and by electrical stimulation of
nerves in isolated normal human bladder tissue and also in normal and
hypertrophied rat bladder. The effect was more pronounced in hypertrophied
detrusor. Pinacidil in concentrations inhibiting muscle activity also increased
the efflux of 86Rb in bladder tissue. In vivo pinacidil suppressed spontaneous
contractile activity in rats with infravesical bladder obstruction and detrusor
hypertrophy. The findings make K+ channel openers an interesting, potentially
useful therapeutic principle in hyperactivity associated with bladder
hypertrophy
Appell R.A. (1998) Electrical
stimulation for the treatment of urinary incontinence. Urology 51, 24-26.
Abstract: OBJECTIVES: To describe the rationale for the use of electrical
stimulation (ES) for the treatment of urinary incontinence, and to summarize the
results of clinical studies assessing these techniques. METHODS: The effect of
ES on the lower urinary tract (LUT) is explained, and the literature on clinical
application of this technique is reviewed. RESULTS: The use of ES is aimed at
altering LUT function by stimulation of the sacral autonomic or somatic nerves.
Two types of ES have been used: chronic stimulation and acute maximal functional
electrostimulation. The frequency used depends on the clinical diagnosis. In
patients with stress incontinence, uncontrolled studies suggest that high
frequency and high amperage are required to obtain a 50% success rate, although
success does not necessarily equate with cure. The only placebo-controlled trial
in this population found that 62% of patients experienced significant
improvement on provocative pad test determinations, but only 20% were dry.
Researchers agree that low frequency and moderate amperage are required in
patients with detrusor instability. The reported effectiveness of ES in this
population has ranged widely, from 45% to 91%, but all studies agree that
approximately one-third of patients will obtain a good long-term results. A
review of multiple studies found that 20% of patients were reported as dry and
37% were significantly improved with functional ES. CONCLUSIONS: Although nearly
all studies of ES have been uncontrolled, a substantial body of "soft" data
attests to the efficacy and safety of this technique
Aristizabal Agudelo J.M.,
Salinas C.J., Fuertes M.E., Virseda C.M., Salman M.S., Bravo de Rueda A.C., and
Resel E.L. (1996) [Urodynamic results of the treatment of urinary incontinence
with peripheral electric stimulation]. Arch. Esp. Urol. 49, 836-842.
Abstract: OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the urodynamic results achieved by
electrostimulation in patients with different types of urinary incontinence.
METHODS: 37 patients (32 females and 5 males) with urinary incontinence were
treated with peripheral electrical stimulation. The urodynamic diagnosis were:
detrusor instability (24.3%), stress urinary incontinence (24.3%), mixed urinary
incontinence (48.6%), and bladder hyper-reflexia (2.7%). Rectal and vaginal
electrodes were utilized. The therapeutic frequencies were 10 Hz, 20 Hz and 50
Hz. RESULTS: Detrusor instability disappeared in the cases treated with the 10
Hz frequency (79%) and in one case treated with the 50 Hz frequency. A
significantly increased bladder capacity and decreased first micturition
sensation were observed in this patient group. All patients with stress urinary
incontinence were treated with high frequency (50 Hz), which achieved positive
results in 44%. In the group of patients with mixed urinary incontinence. 45%
remained unchanged. Treatment failed to achieve satisfactory results in the
single case of detrusor hyperreflexia in this series. CONCLUSION: Peripheral
electrical stimulation is a valid alternative in the treatment of male and
female incontinence. Satisfactory results were achieved with the 10 Hz frequency
in 89% of the patients with bladder instability and with the 50 Hz frequency in
44% of the patients with stress urinary incontinence
Baeten C.G., Konsten J.,
Heineman E., and Soeters P.B. (1994) Dynamic graciloplasty for anal atresia. J.
Pediatr. Surg. 29, 922-924.
Abstract: The aim of this study was to assess whether an electrically stimulated
graciloplasty (dynamic graciloplasty) can achieve continence in nine patients
with anal atresia (median age, 28 years; range, 18 to 40). As the first
procedure, a gracilis muscle was transposed. Six weeks later, intramuscular
electrodes were implanted and connected to a pulse generator. Eventually, the
muscle was gradually trained, by electrical stimulation, to achieve fecal
continence. Continence was obtained in five patients (55%). Manometry
demonstrated an increase in mean anal pressure, from 36 mm Hg (without
stimulation) to 52 mm Hg (with stimulation), after 8 weeks (mean increase, 16 mm
Hg, [95% confidence interval, 8, 24 mm Hg; n = 9; P < .01). Failures resulted
from a noncontracting distal part of the gracilis muscle (in three patients) and
a nondistending rectum (in one patient). We conclude that dynamic graciloplasty
can achieve continence in a substantial number of patients with thus-far
untreatable incontinence after surgical correction for anal atresia
Balcom A.H., Wiatrak M.,
Biefeld T., Rauen K., and Langenstroer P. (1997) Initial experience with home
therapeutic electrical stimulation for continence in the myelomeningocele
population. J. Urol. 158, 1272-1276.
Abstract: PURPOSE: In an attempt to enhance bladder and bowel continence 29
patients underwent long duration, low intensity transcutaneous therapeutic
electrical stimulation. This technology has previously been shown to be
effective for inducing regenerative hypertrophy of disuse atrophied skeletal
muscle, and it has been associated with improved continence in the
myelomeningocele population. Our objectives were to enhance urinary and fecal
continence, and evaluate the mechanisms by which therapeutic electrical
stimulation influences continence. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A total of 29 children
with lumbar or sacral myelomeningocele underwent therapeutic electrical
stimulation at home during sleep using a commercially available stimulator with
a safety sensing circuit and 2 sets of electrodes placed on the skin at bedtime.
Left and right side electrode placement was alternated on 6 of 7 consecutive
nights. In 9 boys and 2 girls with more than 9 months of followup initial and
subsequent cystometrography, urethral pressure profile, electromyography,
voiding cystourethrography and renal ultrasound studies were evaluated. RESULTS:
In the 11 children there was no radiographic evidence of urinary tract or
musculoskeletal deterioration during treatment. Mean actual bladder capacity
increased from 133 to 196 ml. (p < 0.05). Mean bladder capacity, as a percent of
maximum predicted bladder capacity for a normal age matched child without
myelomeningocele, also significantly increased from 59 before to 76% after 9
months of therapeutic electrical stimulation (p < 0.05). No significant change
was noted in urethral pressure profile. A subjective improvement in the
sensation of pelvic fullness was also observed. CONCLUSIONS: When administered
at home by parents while the child sleeps, therapeutic electrical stimulation is
safe for bladder and bowel continence in the myelomeningocele population. It
seems to increase significantly bladder capacity, does not appear to change
urethral pressure profile and results in a subjectively improved sensation of
pelvic fullness, enhancing urinary and fecal continence. The most beneficial
effect of therapeutic electrical stimulation seems to be on the bladder wall and
less so on the striated pelvic floor musculature with subjective enhancement of
pelvic fullness also contributing positively
Bardoel J.W., Stadelmann W.K.,
Perez-Abadia G.A., Galandiuk S., Zonnevijlle E.D., Maldonado C., Stremel R.W.,
Tobin G.R., Kon M., and Barker J.H. (2001) Dynamic rectus abdominis muscle
sphincter for stoma continence: an acute functional study in a dog model. Plast.
Reconstr. Surg. 107, 478-484.
Abstract: Fecal stomal incontinence is a problem that continues to defy surgical
treatment. Previous attempts to create continent stomas using dynamic myoplasty
have had limited success due to denervation atrophy of the muscle flap used in
the creation of the sphincter and because of muscle fatigue resulting from
continuous electrical stimulation. To address the problem of denervation
atrophy, a stomal sphincter was designed using the most caudal segment of the
rectus abdominis muscle, preserving its intercostal innervation as well as its
vascular supply. The purpose of the present study was to determine whether this
rectus abdominis muscle island flap sphincter design could maintain stomal
continence acutely. In this experiment, six dogs were used to create eight
rectus abdominis island flap stoma sphincters around a segment of distal ileum.
Initially, the intraluminal stomal pressures generated by the sphincter using
different stimulation frequencies were determined. The ability of this stomal
sphincter to generate continence at different intraluminal bowel pressures was
then assessed. In all cases, the rectus abdominis muscle sphincter generated
peak pressures well above those needed to maintain stomal continence (60 mmHg).
In addition, each sphincter was able to maintain stomal continence at all
intraluminal bowel pressures tested
Bauchet L., Segnarbieux F.,
Martinazzo G., Frerebeau P., and Ohanna F. (2001) [Neurosurgical treatment of
hyperactive bladder in spinal cord injury patients]. Neurochirurgie 47, 13-24.
Abstract: OBJECTIVES: We report long-term results of posterior sacral root
rhizotomies in combination with Finetech-Brindley anterior sacral root
stimulators implanted intradurally in 20 spinal cord injury patients. MATERIAL:
and methods: The 14 female and 6 male patients included 14 paraplegics and 6
tetraplegics. All of them initially presented hyperactive bladder, detrusor-sphincter
dyssynergia, recurrent urinary tract infection and performed (self) intermittent
catheterization. Prior to implantation, an intrathecal test using bupivacaine
was performed to confirm the compliances of the bladder. The main indication for
implantation was persistent urinary incontinence refractory to medical therapy.
RESULTS: After implantation the mean follow-up was 4,5 years. In all, 18
patients used the stimulator alone for bladder emptying and 18 patients were
completely continent. The mean bladder capacity increased from 190 ml
preoperatively to 460 ml after the operation. The mean residual urinary volume
was reduced from 90 ml to 25 ml. No changes were noted by renal isotopic
scanning in upper urinary tracts of patients. In 1 patient, a second extradural
implant was performed. DISCUSSION: This article also include an overview of a)
the different available sites where application of electrical stimulation
results in a detrusor contraction, b) the benefits and disadvantages of the
sacral posterior rhizotomy, c) selective stimulation techniques that allow
selective detrusor activation by sacral root stimulation. CONCLUSION: Sacral
anterior root stimulation combined with sacral posterior rhizotomy is a valuable
method to restore bladder functions in spinal cord injured patients suffering
from hyperactive bladder refractory to medical therapy
Beckman N.J. (1995) An overview
of urinary incontinence in adults: assessments and behavioral interventions.
Clin. Nurse Spec. 9, 241-7, 274.
Abstract: Urinary incontinence affects millions of Americans. Often the goal of
treatment is to improve the condition, prevent complications and provide
comfort. Behavioral interventions can improve the condition in 54-75% of
patients with urge and/or stress incontinence and can cure 12- 16% of patients.
Advanced practice nurses (APNs) are in a unique position of both providing
direct care to patients who experience these problems and educating other nurses
about signs, symptoms and appropriate nursing interventions for urinary
incontinence. The scope of the problem, costs of urinary incontinence and
potential cost savings with treatment are discussed in this article. Acute and
chronic urinary incontinence and the necessary assessments to be performed by
the APN are reviewed. Bladder training, habit training, prompted voiding and
pelvic muscle exercises are the behavioral interventions used with urinary
incontinence. Adjunct therapy, including biofeedback, vaginal cones and
electrical stimulation, also is discussed
Benson J.T. (2000) Sacral nerve
stimulation results may be improved by electrodiagnostic techniques. Int.
Urogynecol. J. Pelvic. Floor. Dysfunct. 11, 352-357.
Abstract: Sacral nerve electrical stimulation (sacral neuromodulation) therapy
for patients with refractory urge incontinence, frequency and urgency, and
non-obstructive retention yields an effective 75%-80% success rate. Electrodes
are surgically implanted if initial percutaneous stimulation testing has a
successful clinical response. Unfortunately, up to 50% of patients are denied
surgical implantation because of an unsuccessful response to the test
stimulation. In this descriptive study, adding electrodiagnostic monitoring to
the currently used biological monitoring techniques was associated with a
reduction in the number of tested patients denied implantation to 20%. These
findings suggest that the incorporation of electrodiagnostic techniques may
improve the clinical efficacy of sacral stimulation therapy. Randomized
prospective testing of this hypothesis is suggested
Berghmans L.C., Hendriks H.J.,
Bo K., Hay-Smith E.J., de Bie R.A., and van Waalwijk van Doorn ES (1998)
Conservative treatment of stress urinary incontinence in women: a systematic
review of randomized clinical trials. Br. J. Urol. 82, 181-191.
Abstract: OBJECTIVE: To assess the efficacy of physical therapies for first-line
use in the treatment and prevention of stress urinary incontinence (SUI) in
women, using a systematic review of randomized clinical trials (RCTs). MATERIALS
AND METHODS: A computer-aided and manual search for published RCTs investigating
treatment and prevention of SUI using physical therapies, e.g. pelvic floor
muscle (PFM) exercises, with or without other treatment modalities, were carried
out. The methodological quality of the included trials was assessed using
criteria based on generally accepted principles of interventional research.
RESULTS: Twenty-four RCTs (22 treatment and two prevention) were identified; the
methodological quality of the studies included was moderate and 11 RCTs were of
sufficient quality to be included in further analysis. Based on
levels-of-evidence criteria, there is strong evidence to suggest that PFM
exercises are effective in reducing the symptoms of SUI. There is limited
evidence for the efficacy of high- intensity vs a low-intensity regimen of PFM
exercises. Despite significant effects of biofeedback after testing as an
adjunct to PFM exercises, there is no evidence that PFM exercises with
biofeedback are more effective than PFM exercises alone. There is little
consistency (of stimulation types and parameters) in the studies of electrical
stimulation, but when the results are combined there is strong evidence to
suggest that electrostimulation is superior to sham electrostimulation, and
limited evidence that there is no difference between electrostimulation and
other physical therapies. In the prevention of SUI the efficacy of PFM
exercises, with or without other adjuncts, is uncertain
Berghmans L.C., Hendriks H.J.,
de Bie R.A., van Waalwijk van Doorn ES, Bo K., and van Kerrebroeck P.E. (2000)
Conservative treatment of urge urinary incontinence in women: a systematic
review of randomized clinical trials. BJU. Int. 85, 254-263.
Abstract: OBJECTIVE: To assess the efficacy of physical therapies for first-line
use in the treatment of urge urinary incontinence (UUI) in women, using a
systematic review of randomized clinical trials (RCTs). MATERIALS AND METHODS: A
computer-aided and manual search was carried out for RCTs published between 1980
and 1999 investigating the treatment of UUI defined by the keywords 'physical
therapies', e.g. bladder (re)training (including 'behavioural' treatment),
pelvic floor muscle (PFM) exercises, with or without biofeedback and/or
electrical stimulation. The methodological quality of the included trials was
assessed using methodological criteria, based on generally accepted principles
of interventional research. RESULTS: Fifteen RCTs were identified; the
methodological quality of the studies was moderate, with a median (range) score
of 6 (3-8.5) (maximum possible 10). Eight RCTs were considered of sufficient
quality, i.e. an internal validity score of >/= 5.5 points on a scale of 0-10,
and were included in a further analysis. Based on levels-of-evidence criteria,
there is weak evidence to suggest that bladder (re)training is more effective
than no treatment (controls), and that bladder (re)training is better than drug
therapy. Stimulation types and parameters in the studies of electrical
stimulation were heterogeneous. There is insufficient evidence that electrical
stimulation is more effective than sham electrical simulation. To date there are
too few studies to evaluate effects of PFM exercise with or without biofeedback,
and of toilet training for women with UUI. CONCLUSION: Although almost all
studies included reported positive results in favour of physical therapies for
the treatment of UUI, more research of high methodological quality is required
to evaluate the effects of each method in the range of physical therapies
Bielefeldt K., Enck P., and
Erckenbrecht J.F. (1990) Sensory and motor function in the maintenance of anal
continence. Dis. Colon Rectum 33, 674-678.
Abstract: Anorectal function was prospectively evaluated in 43 consecutive
patients with fecal incontinence and in 19 healthy volunteers using manometry
and electrical stimulation of the anoderm. Both anorectal motor and sensory
function was impaired in incontinent patients as compared with healthy controls.
Further statistical analysis identified four subgroups of patients showing
different pathomechanisms of fecal incontinence: severe combined anorectal motor
and sensory dysfunction, isolated anal sphincter dysfunction, isolated anorectal
sensory dysfunction, and combined dysfunction of the internal anal sphincter and
impaired anorectal sensitivity. These data support the hypothesis that sensory
function of both the rectum and the anal canal is an important and independent
factor in the preservation of continence
Bladou F., Houvenaeghel G.,
Delpero J.R., Monges G., Serment G., and Guerinel G. (1996) Construction of a
urinary sphincter by means of an electrically stimulated striated muscle:
experimental procedure and urodynamic results on canine model. Int. Surg. 81,
94-98.
Abstract: A canine model of urinary neosphincter using electrically stimulated
autologous striated muscle is described. The superior belly of canine sartorius
was activated by a pacemaker with an intermittent low frequency stimulation
(0.5-1 pulse per sec) during 7 weeks. Then, the muscle graft was passed around
the urethra and sutured back on to itself to form a neosphincter. The surgical
procedure was easy to perform and with no complication. Urethral pressure
profile was performed initially (T0), and when the muscle was in peri-urethral
position, before (T1) and during electrical stimulation (T2). The continence
parameter readings (maximal urethral closure pressure MUP, functional length FL,
continence zone CZ, and continence area CA) increased from T0 to T1, and from T1
to T2. We noted: 1) 28%, 38%, 52%, and 86% increases for the MUP, FL, CZ, and CA
respectively from T0 to T1, 2) 10%, 41%, 30%, and 43% increases for MUP, FL, CZ,
and CA respectively from T1 to T2. Chronic low frequency stimulation could
transform a skeletal fast-twitch type 2 muscle into a slow-twitch
fatigue-resistant type 1 muscle. In this study, morphological changes of the
stimulated muscle were noted, whereas phenotype was unchanged. This dynamic
autologous neosphincter may be a new alternative to the artificial urinary
sphincter prosthesis with fewer complications. Further studies are ongoing to
evaluate the efficacy of such a neosphincter as continent system for bladder
substitution after pelvic exenteration for pelvic cancers
Bo K. and Maanum M. (1996) Does
vaginal electrical stimulation cause pelvic floor muscle contraction? A pilot
study. Scand. J. Urol. Nephrol. Suppl 179, 39-45.
Abstract: The purpose of the present study was to evaluate whether vaginal
electrical stimulation using Conmax and Medicon MS-105 causes pelvic floor
muscle contraction. In addition, pain and discomfort described by the
participants were registered. Nine women, mean age 37.7 years (range 24-54)
participated in the study; five healthy physio-therapists and four patients with
diagnosed genuine stress incontinence. All the participants used Conmax and
Medicon MS-105 with 10, 20 and 50 Hz in random order. The women increased the
current step by step to tolerance level. Two physiotherapists were observing the
perineum and notified whether a correct contraction was occurring. The
participants reported whether there was a correct contraction of the pelvic
floor and described pain and discomfort, classified according to McGill Pain
Questionnaire. The results demonstrated that a correct contraction was reported
and observed in only one of nine women. Electrical stimulation with all
frequencies caused pain and discomfort in all women
Bo K. and Talseth T. (1997)
Change in urethral pressure during voluntary pelvic floor muscle contraction and
vaginal electrical stimulation. Int. Urogynecol. J. Pelvic. Floor. Dysfunct. 8,
3-6.
Abstract: The purpose of the study was to compare the effect of voluntary pelvic
floor muscle (FFM) contraction and vaginal electrical stimulation on urethral
pressure. Twelve women with genuine stress incontinence, mean age 49.4 years
(range 33-66) participated in the study. The urethral and bladder pressures were
recorded simultaneously through a double- lumen 8 Ch catheter. The patients
first performed three voluntary PFM contractions. Then two electrical
stimulators, Conmax and Medicon MS 105, 50 Hz, were used in random order. A
visual analog scale was used to measure pain and discomfort. Pain was reported
to mean 6.8, SEM 0.64 (range 0.7-9.9) and mean 6.1, SEM 0.81 (range 0-9.1) with
Conmax and Medicon MS 105, respectively. The mean paired difference in favor of
voluntary contraction with Conmax was -8.0, SD 6.7, P = 0.0067, and with Medicon
MS 105 it was -12.2, SD 5.9, P = 0.0022. The results demonstrated that voluntary
PFM contraction increased urethral pressure significantly more than did vaginal
electrical stimulation
Bo K. (1998) Effect of
electrical stimulation on stress and urge urinary incontinence. Clinical outcome
and practical recommendations based on randomized controlled trials. Acta Obstet.
Gynecol. Scand. Suppl 168, 3-11.
Abstract: BACKGROUND: The aim of the present study was to review the literature
on randomized controlled trials of electrical stimulation to treat urge and
stress urinary incontinence. METHODS: Studies were compiled from Medline from
1980 till 1996 and manual searches of relevant journals. Randomized controlled
studies full length published in English, German and Scandinavian languages were
included. RESULTS: Nine studies evaluating the effect of electrical stimulation
on stress urinary incontinence and one study evaluating the effect of urge
incontinence were found. Only three studies had a sufficient sample size to
enable conclusion on stress urinary incontinence. Two demonstrated negative, and
one positive effect (20%) cure and 46% improved measured by pad test). The study
on urge incontinence demonstrated that there was no difference in effect after
electrical stimulation or anticholinergic drugs. CONCLUSION: The results of
randomized controlled trials evaluating the effect of electrical stimulation to
treat stress and urge urinary incontinence are conflicting. There is a need for
more randomized controlled trials with sufficient sample sizes, use of
sensitive, reproducible and valid outcome measures, and optimal stimulation
parameters. Based on the present knowledge pelvic floor muscle exercise should
be the first choice of treatment for stress urinary incontinence
Bo K., Talseth T., and Holme I.
(1999) Single blind, randomised controlled trial of pelvic floor exercises,
electrical stimulation, vaginal cones, and no treatment in management of genuine
stress incontinence in women. BMJ 318, 487-493.
Abstract: OBJECTIVE: To compare the effect of pelvic floor exercises, electrical
stimulation, vaginal cones, and no treatment for genuine stress incontinence.
DESIGN: Stratified, single blind, randomised controlled trial. SETTING:
Multicentre. PARTICIPANTS: 107 women with clinically and urodynamically proved
genuine stress incontinence. Mean (range) age was 49.5 (24-70) years, and mean
(range) duration of symptoms 10.8 (1- 45) years. INTERVENTIONS: Pelvic floor
exercise (n=25) comprised 8-12 contractions 3 times a day and exercise in groups
with skilled physical therapists once a week. The electrical stimulation group
(n=25) used vaginal intermittent stimulation with the MS 106 Twin at 50 Hz 30
minutes a day. The vaginal cones group (n=27) used cones for 20 minutes a day.
The untreated control group (n=30) was offered the use of a continence guard.
Muscle strength was measured by vaginal squeeze pressure once a month. MAIN
OUTCOME MEASURES: Pad test with standardised bladder volume, and self report of
severity. RESULTS: Improvement in muscle strength was significantly greater
(P=0.03) after pelvic floor exercises (11.0 cm H2O (95% confidence interval 7.7
to 14.3) before v 19.2 cm H2O (15.3 to 23.1) after) than either electrical
stimulation (14.8 cm H2O (10. 9 to 18.7) v 18.6 cm H2O (13.3 to 23.9)) or
vaginal cones (11.8 cm H2O (8.5 to 15.1) v 15.4 cm H2O (11.1 to 19.7)).
Reduction in leakage on pad test was greater in the exercise group (-30.2 g;
-43. 3 to 16.9) than in the electrical stimulation group (-7.4 g; -20.9 to 6.1)
and the vaginal cones group (-14.7 g; - 27.6 to -1.8). On completion of the
trial one participant in the control group, 14 in the pelvic floor exercise
group, three in the electrical stimulation group, and two in the vaginal cones
group no longer considered themselves as having a problem. Conclusion: Training
of the pelvic floor muscles is superior to electrical stimulation and vaginal
cones in the treatment of genuine stress incontinence
Bo K. (2000) [Pelvic floor
muscle exercise and urinary incontinence--train yourself continent!]. Tidsskr.
Nor Laegeforen. 120, 3583-3589.
Abstract: BACKGROUND: Urinary incontinence is a major female health problem with
prevalence rates varying between 8% and 52%. Urinary incontinence can be treated
with surgery, medication, and several forms of pelvic floor muscle training. The
aim of this review article is to evaluate the evidence from randomized
controlled trials of pelvic floor muscle training in the treatment of urinary
incontinence. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Computerised search in Medline and Sport and
manual search in former published systematic reviews were undertaken. Only
published articles of randomized controlled trials were included. RESULTS:
Several randomized controlled trials have demonstrated that pelvic floor muscle
training is more effective than no treatment and electrical stimulation in the
treatment of stress incontinence. Adding biofeedback to the training has so far
showed no additional effect. There is a lack of published studies on the effect
of pelvic floor muscle training in urge incontinence and in men. INTERPRETATION:
Female stress urinary incontinence can be effectively treated by pelvic floor
muscle exercise; this is suggested as the first choice of treatment. There is a
need for randomized controlled trials to evaluate the effect of pelvic floor
muscle exercise in prevention of urinary incontinence
Bo K. and Berghmans L.C. (2000)
Nonpharmacologic treatments for overactive bladder-pelvic floor exercises.
Urology 55, 7-11.
Abstract: The theory behind the use of physical therapies (electrical
stimulation or pelvic floor muscle [PFM] training with or without biofeedback)
for overactive bladder is to (1) inhibit detrusor muscle contraction by
voluntary contraction of the PFMs at the same time as the urge to void; and (2)
prevent sudden falls in urethral pressure by a change in PFM morphology,
position, and neuromuscular function. Few trials have evaluated the effect of
PFM training on symptoms of overactive bladder. Most studies are flawed because
they include several diagnoses and treatment modalities in the same
intervention. Because of the lack of evidence, no firm conclusion can be drawn
on the effect of PFM exercise on overactive bladder. There are some initially
promising results, but there is still a need for high-quality, randomized
controlled trials on the effect of PFM training on the inhibition of detrusor
contraction in human beings. The efficacy of PFM training in combination with
other treatments, such as pharmacotherapy, also requires investigation
Boccon-Gibod L. (1980) [Urinary
incontinence following prostatectomy: hopes and disappointments. 42 cases
(author's transl)]. Nouv. Presse Med. 9, 2339-2342.
Abstract: Between 0,5 and 1% of prostatectomies are complicated by urinary
incontinence due to the destruction of both proximal and distal urethral
sphincters. Any incontinence persisting more than 12 months after surgery should
be considered as permanent. Among all treatments proposed (medical treatment,
electrical stimulation of the perineum, various plastic operations and
prostheses with varied and numerous materials), only inflatable prostheses seem
to give "better than nothing results. The best treatment of post-operative
incontinence, however, is preventive: extreme care should be exercised during
the enucleation or trans-urethral resection of the adenoma
Bock J.U. and Jongen J. (1996)
[Diagnostic and therapeutic procedures in fecal incontinence in general practice
of the surgically educated proctologist]. Zentralbl. Chir 121, 659-664.
Abstract: Age related, about 10% of the general population suffer from faecal
incontinence. In a surgical, proctological office diagnosis is possible with
carefully taken history, physical examination, digital examination of the
anorectum, rigid rectosigmoidoscopy, and anoscopy. Together with special
examinations (endoanal ultrasound, electromyography, pudendal nerve terminal
motor latency [PNTML], anorectal manometry, defaecography, transit time of the
colon) the plan for medical and surgical treatment can be made. The basic
medical conservative therapy consists of regulating the form of stool (high
fibre diet and/or loperamid), training of the sphincter and pelvic muscles
electrical stimulation or biofeedback training. Outpatient surgery is possible
for small prolapsing tumors of the lower rectum or anal canal, hemorrhoids grade
2 or segmental anal prolapse. Inpatient surgery is needed for any form of
reconstruction of the sphincter or the sensitive area of the anal canal,
Borrelli M., Alves P.R., Gama
A.H., and Goes G.M. (1977) Urinary incontinence: two cases of electronic
stimulation after failing the Leadbetter technique. Urol. Int. 32, 260-264.
Abstract: Two cases of urinary incontinence treated by electrical stimulation
after failing the Leadbetter technique are presented. Both were first seen
bearing imperforated anus. They suffered several operations for correcting this
pathology and further attempting to relieve complete urinary incontinence. After
a trial with intrarectal stimulation one of them received an implant. The other
continued to use the anal plug. In both cases the result has been satisfactory.
Cine radiological documentation of the sphincteric action of the stimulated
muscles was performed
Bosch J.L. and Groen J. (1995)
Sacral (S3) segmental nerve stimulation as a treatment for urge incontinence in
patients with detrusor instability: results of chronic electrical stimulation
using an implantable neural prosthesis. J. Urol. 154, 504-507.
Abstract: PURPOSE: We studied the effects of sacral (S3) nerve stimulation in
patients with urge incontinence due to detrusor instability. MATERIALS AND
METHODS: A permanent S3 foramen electrode was implanted in 18 patients (average
age 46 years) who had shown a good response during temporary stimulation via a
percutaneously placed wire electrode. Average followup was 29 months. RESULTS:
The average voiding frequency and pad use per 24 hours decreased significantly.
Improvement in several urodynamic parameters was noted. The correlation between
symptomatic and urodynamic improvement was incomplete. CONCLUSIONS:
Neuromodulation appears to be a valuable treatment option in these patients
Bosch J.L. and Groen J. (2000)
Sacral nerve neuromodulation in the treatment of patients with refractory motor
urge incontinence: long-term results of a prospective longitudinal study. J.
Urol. 163, 1219-1222.
Abstract: PURPOSE: Conservative treatment rarely results in a durable cure of
patients with urge incontinence and bladder overactivity. Instrumental and
surgical procedures often have significant side effects and less than optimal
results. We developed a technique of sacral nerve neuromodulation using chronic
unilateral electrical stimulation of the S3 sacral nerve to inhibit the
micturition reflex to provide effective nondestructive alternative therapy for
patients whose condition is refractory to conservative treatment. MATERIALS AND
METHODS: Of 85 patients 45 who responded to a test with a temporary electrode
underwent implantation of a permanent S3 sacral nerve electrode coupled to a
pulse generator. Treatment results were evaluated by urodynamic studies and
voiding/incontinence diaries documenting pad use, incontinence episodes, voiding
frequency and voided volume. Partial success and cure were defined as 50% to 90%
and more than 90% improvement, respectively, in pad use and/or incontinence
episodes. RESULTS: Of 45 patients 18 (40%) were cured at an average followup of
47.1 months and 9 (20%) achieved partial success. Median number of pads used and
median number of incontinence episodes daily had decreased from 5.4 to 1.2 (p =
0.0001) and 7.1 to 1.3 (p = 0.0001), respectively, 6 months after implantation.
Subsequently these results remained almost constant for 5 years. Bladder
overactivity disappeared in 19 of the 44 patients (43%). The repeat intervention
rate was 37.7% and there was no permanent injury or nerve damage. CONCLUSIONS:
Sacral nerve neuromodulation is safe, effective and durable in patients with
urge incontinence refractory to conservative treatment
Bouamrirene D., Micallef J.P.,
Rouanet P., and Bacou F. (2000) Electrical stimulation-induced changes in
double-wrapped muscles for dynamic graciloplasty. Arch. Surg. 135, 1161-1167.
Abstract: HYPOTHESIS: Treatment of fecal incontinence has been greatly improved
by electrical stimulation of gracilis muscle transposed around the anal canal.
Various configurations of the muscle have been used: single alpha, gamma,
epsilon muscle loops, split sling, or double wrap. We report herein experimental
data on muscle transformation and damage induced by the latter surgical
approach. DESIGN, INTERVENTIONS, AND MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: This study was
conducted on 4 groups of New Zealand white rabbits. Group 1 had unstimulated
transposed gracilis muscles. Group 2 had left transposed gracilis muscles
stimulated only. Group 3 had both right and left transposed gracilis muscles
stimulated. Group 4 were the controls (not operated on). Muscle properties were
studied by electrophysiological,immunohistochemical,and biochemical techniques.
RESULTS: Transformation from fast-contractile glycolytic muscle fibers into
fast-intermediate to slow-contractile oxidative muscle fiber types induced a
fatigue resistance of the transposed muscle that has undergone long-term
stimulation and muscle alterations characterized by fiber atrophy and fibrosis.
CONCLUSIONS: Whatever technique of dynamic graciloplasty is used, muscle
degeneration associated with mobilization might result primarily from the
surgical dissection, whereby collateral blood supply to the gracilis is
interrupted and exacerbated by long-term stimulation
Bourcier A.P. and Juras J.C.
(1995) Nonsurgical therapy for stress incontinence. Urol. Clin. North Am. 22,
613-627.
Abstract: This article discusses the therapies that have been developed for the
treatment of stress incontinence due to female pelvic-floor dysfunction. A
combination of pelvic muscle exercises, biofeedback, behavioral modification,
and electrical stimulation are all treatment options that do not involve
surgery. When physiotherapy proves successful, and surgery is avoided, it is
necessary for the patient to be put on a maintenance program to avoid relapse.
The authors also discuss the link between urinary stress incontinence and women
involved in sports
Bratt H., Salvesen K.A.,
Eriksen B.C., and Kulseng-Hanssen S. (1998) Long-term effects ten years after
maximal electrostimulation of the pelvic floor in women with unstable detrusor
and urge incontinence. Acta Obstet. Gynecol. Scand. Suppl 168, 22-24.
Abstract: OBJECTIVE: The purpose was to study any long-term therapeutic effects
of maximal electrical stimulation in female urge incontinence. METHODS: A postal
questionnaire containing six questions about urinary incontinence was
distributed to 30 women who had been treated with maximal stimulation because of
unstable detrusor and urge incontinence 9-13 years earlier. The response rate
was 90% (27 women). The mean age at follow-up was 62 years. RESULTS: Twenty-one
(78%) women reported symptoms of urge incontinence. Among them, 13 had this
problem daily, whereas eight only had problems weekly or even more seldom.
Nineteen (70%) women reported symptoms of stress incontinence. Twenty-one women
would have recommended maximal stimulation to a friend today. CONCLUSION: After
approximately ten years most of the women had symptoms of urge incontinence.
This was, however, a minor problem among a third of them. A majority of the
women were satisfied with maximal stimulation as a treatment modality. The
treatment had not prevented a later occurrence of stress incontinence
Brehmer M. and Nilsson B.Y.
(2000) Elevation of sensory thresholds in the prostatic urethra after microwave
thermotherapy. BJU. Int. 86, 427-431.
Abstract: OBJECTIVES: To determine whether transurethral microwave thermotherapy
(TUMT) affects the sensory threshold in the posterior urethra and whether such
an effect influences urinary storage symptoms. PATIENTS AND METHODS: The sensory
threshold was measured before and at 3 and 12 weeks after TUMT in 13 men with
minor obstructive symptoms caused by benign prostatic hyperplasia. Sensations
were evoked by electrical stimulation at different frequencies, using a bipolar
ring-electrode mounted on a urethral catheter. Changes in sensory thresholds
were evaluated in the patients both as a group and individually. The patients
were interviewed about their symptoms at each measurement. RESULTS: After TUMT,
12 patients were satisfied and reported decreased irritative symptoms, primarily
less frequent nocturnal micturition; two patients were cured of urgency
incontinence. In 11 of the satisfied patients, and the unsuccessful patient,
decreased urge accompanied increased sensory thresholds. Thresholds elevated by
>/= 30% were correlated with decreased irritative symptoms. CONCLUSIONS: TUMT
decreases sensitivity in the posterior urethra, which may alleviate storage
symptoms
Brown C. (1998) Pelvic floor
rehabilitation: conservative treatment for incontinence. Ostomy. Wound. Manage.
44, 72-76.
Abstract: Pelvic floor rehabilitation is used to treat stress urinary
incontinence, urge, and fecal incontinence as well as other pelvic floor
musculature disorders. When treating patients, it is important to thoroughly
assess the pelvic floor. In addition to evaluating the urinary system, sexual
and bowel functions must also be considered. Treatment plans should be devised
on an individual basis according to the evaluation findings. Rehabilitation
goals should be established. The patient must understand the function of her
urinary system and the role she must play in its control. Muscle retraining is
achieved through a personalized exercise program. This program may be augmented
by manual techniques, biofeedback or electrical stimulation. While the Agency
for Health Care Policy and Research (AHCPR) does endorse the use of behavioral
modalities in treating urinary incontinence, the use of bladder retraining and
pelvic floor rehabilitation is not always recommended when indicated, nor
accessible for all patients who require it. More research is needed, in addition
to ongoing public and professional education on behavioral interventions in
order to underline the advantages of this form of treatment for incontinence
Brubaker L., Benson J.T., Bent
A., Clark A., and Shott S. (1997) Transvaginal electrical stimulation for female
urinary incontinence. Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol. 177, 536-540.
Abstract: OBJECTIVE: Our purpose was to determine the objective and subjective
efficacy of transvaginal electrical stimulation for treatment of common forms of
urinary incontinence in women. STUDY DESIGN: A prospective, double-blind,
randomized clinical trial included 121 women with either urinary incontinence
caused by detrusor instability or genuine stress incontinence, or both (mixed
incontinence). Participants used the assigned device for 8 weeks. Identical
preintervention and postintervention assessment included multichannel urodynamic
testing, quality-of-life scale, and urinary diaries. RESULTS: A total of 121
women completed this study at four North American urogynecology centers.
Detrusor instability was cured (stable on provocative cystometry) in 49% of
women with detrusor instability who used an active electrical device (p =
0.0004, McNemar's test), whereas there was no statistically significant change
in the percentage with detrusor instability in the sham device group. There was
no statistically significant difference between the preintervention and
postintervention rates of genuine stress incontinence for either the active
device group or the sham device group. CONCLUSION: This form of transvaginal
electrical stimulation may be effective for treatment of detrusor overactivity,
with or without genuine stress incontinence
Brubaker L. (2000) Electrical
stimulation in overactive bladder. Urology 55, 17-23.
Abstract: Electrical stimulation is an effective and well-tolerated treatment
for overactive bladder. Initial work in animals indicated the potential of this
treatment, and early clinical experience in Europe further supported its likely
efficacy. Although the mechanism of action of electrical stimulation remains
unproven in humans, it is believed to be a neuromodulating therapy which affects
the neural signaling that controls continence. There is also strong evidence
that electrical stimulation affects striated muscle. The therapy can cause
hypertrophy of skeletal muscle fibers, possibly by the recruitment of faster-
conducting motor units, which would not normally be recruited during voluntary
efforts. In addition, electrical stimulation can alter the expression of myosin
isoforms, favoring a conversion to type I muscle. Despite our incomplete
understanding of the mechanism of action of electrical stimulation, clinical
devices have been developed quickly. Case series have been reported throughout
Europe. These were followed by controlled clinical trials in the United States.
There is good evidence that the use of vaginal electrical stimulators can reduce
the occurrence of symptoms of overactive bladder in about half of the patients
treated. Multiple uses of nonimplanted stimulation, including thigh stimulation,
anal stimulation, and direct pelvic muscle stimulation, have been reported. In
these trials, it is common for objective findings to be poorly correlated with
subjective reports of improvements or cure. Patients frequently report that the
urge-to-leak time improves, but this is difficult to measure objectively. The
use of nonimplanted devices is effective and well tolerated, and should precede
the use of implanted devices. A direct comparison with other effective methods
of treatment for overactive bladder is warranted
Caldwell K.P. (1968) The use of
electrical stimulation in urinary retention and incontinence. Proc. R. Soc. Med.
61, 703.
Caldwell K.P., Cook P.J., Flack
F.C., and James E.D. (1968) Urethral pressure recordings in male incontinents
under electrical stimulation. Invest Urol. 5, 572-579.
Caldwell K.P. (1974)
Proceedings: Electrical stimulation. Urol. Int. 29, 225.
Caputo R.M., Benson J.T., and
McClellan E. (1993) Intravaginal maximal electrical stimulation in the treatment
of urinary incontinence. J. Reprod. Med. 38, 667-671.
Abstract: Urinary incontinence imposes a large economic burden, estimated at $10
billion per year. As the cost of health care continues to rise, conservative
therapeutic measures are becoming more attractive. Anecdotal reports suggest
that electrical stimulation may be up to 87% effective in the treatment of
urinary incontinence. Investigators use different stimulation devices and
protocols and make a comparison of results difficult. The true efficacy of
electrical stimulation for the treatment of urinary incontinence is unknown
since there have been no controlled clinical trials. Within our referral-based
urogynecology practice, we employ intermittent, intravaginal maximal electrical
stimulation in conjunction with bladder drills and pelvic floor exercises. Over
a one-year period we treated 76 women with urinary incontinence: 19 with stress
incontinence (SUI), 30 with detrusor instability (DI) and 27 with mixed
incontinence (MI). After six weeks, our overall objective improvement rate was
76%; 89% of patients with SUI, 73% with DI and 70% with MI met the criteria for
improvement. Long- term follow-up averaged 6 months, with a range of 2-12. Of
patients who showed an initial objective improvement, 87% maintained that
improvement. Intravaginal electrical stimulation may be effective therapy for
urinary incontinence. Controlled clinical trials are needed to determine its
efficacy and standardize stimulation protocols before its widespread use
Chancellor M.B., Hong R.D.,
Rivas D.A., Watanabe T., Crewalk J.A., and Bourgeois I. (1997) Gracilis
urethromyoplasty--an autologous urinary sphincter for neurologically impaired
patients with stress incontinence. Spinal Cord. 35, 546-549.
Abstract: PURPOSE: To investigate the effect of a neurovascularly intact
gracilis muscle urethral wrap, to be used to restore urinary continence as a
transposed urinary sphincter graft, in patients with neurogenic lower urinary
tract dysfunction. METHODS: Five neurologically impaired men with a denervated
and damaged urinary sphincter mechanisms were treated. The etiology of
sphincteric insufficiency included sphincter denervation in three patients,
external sphincterotomy in one, and urethral trauma due to a chronic indwelling
catheter in one. All patients underwent gracilis urethromyoplasty sphincter
reconstruction. Two patients also underwent concomitant ileocystoplasty and one
patient ileocystostomy because of poor bladder compliance and a bladder capacity
of < 200 ml. RESULTS: The gracilis urethromyoplasty functioned as a new
autologous sphincter with follow-ups ranging from 6-35 months. The surgery was
successful in four patients. Three of the four patients were managed with
intermittent catheterization, and one managed by ileocystostomy. The fifth
patient continued to require an indwelling urethral catheter. CONCLUSION:
Gracilis urethromyoplasty achieves compression of the urethra using a
neurovascularly intact muscle graft. The functional urethral closure, obtained
from the gracilis muscle wrap, assures dryness, and permits intermittent
self-catheterization. It also avoids the risks of infection, erosion, or
malfunction associated with the artificial urinary sphincter. The potential
exists for electrical stimulation of this muscle graft to allow volitional
control of the neo-sphincter mechanism, and voluntary voiding
Chancellor M.B., Heesakkers
J.P., and Janknegt R.A. (1997) Gracilis muscle transposition with electrical
stimulation for sphincteric incontinence: a new approach. World J. Urol. 15,
320-328.
Abstract: Neurovascularly intact gracilis-muscle transposition to the proximal
urethra is an exciting new technique for sphincteric incontinence. The
functional urethral closure of gracilis myoplasty assures dryness, permits
intermittent self-catheterization when necessary, and avoids the risks of
erosion associated with the artificial urinary sphincter. Electrical stimulation
of the transposed muscle (dynamic urethral myoplasty) using intramuscular
electrodes and a subcutaneously placed pulse generator can alter the molecular
physiology of the gracilis muscle from that of predominantly fast-twitch to that
of slow-twitch fibers that are fatigue-resistant and more suitable for long-term
sphincter function
Collins C.D., Brown B.H., and
Duthie H.L. (1968) A basis for electrical stimulation for anal continence.
Scand. J. Gastroenterol. 3, 395-400.
Collins C.D., Brown B.H., and
Duthie H.L. (1969) An assessment of intraluminal electrical stimulation for anal
incontinence. Br. J. Surg. 56, 542-546.
Collins C.D. (1972) Urethral
incontinence in women. Observations on the effect of electrical stimulation.
Proc. R. Soc. Med. 65, 832-833.
Collins C.D. (1974)
Proceedings: Intermittent electrical stimulation. Urol. Int. 29, 221.
Creasey G.H., Kilgore K.L.,
Brown-Triolo D.L., Dahlberg J.E., Peckham P.H., and Keith M.W. (2000) Reduction
of costs of disability using neuroprostheses. Assist. Technol. 12, 67-75.
Abstract: The lifetime costs associated with spinal cord injury are substantial.
Assistive technology that reduces complications, increases independence, or
decreases the need for attendant services can provide economic as well as
medical or functional benefit. This study describes two approaches for
estimating the economic consequences of implanted neuroprostheses utilizing
functional electrical stimulation. Life care plan analysis was used to estimate
the costs of bladder and bowel care with and without a device restoring bladder
and bowel function and to compare these with the costs of implementing the
device. For a neuroprosthesis restoring hand grasp, the costs of implementation
were compared to the potential savings in attendant care costs that could be
achieved by the use of the device. The results indicate that the costs of
implementing the bladder and bowel system would be recovered in 5 years,
primarily from reduced costs of supplies, medications, and procedures. The costs
of the hand grasp neuroprosthesis would be recovered over the lifetime of the
user if attendant time was reduced only 2 hours per day and in a shorter time if
attendant care was further reduced. Neither analysis includes valuation of the
quality of life, which is further enhanced by the neuroprostheses through
restoration of greater independence and dignity. Our results demonstrate that
implantable neuroprosthetic systems provide good health care value in addition
to improved independence for the disabled individual
Dahms S.E. and Tanagho E.A.
(1998) The impact of sacral root anatomy on selective electrical stimulation for
bladder evacuation. World J. Urol. 16, 322-328.
Abstract: Although different structures have been studied with
electrostimulation to elicit bladder evacuation, only the sacral root remains
feasible for clinical application at present. However, the resultant concomitant
contractions of the bladder and sphincteric muscles have been the principal
problem over the last few decades. Attempts to identify fibers within the sacral
ventral root that innervate the detrusor predominantly have been made by
microsurgery alone or in combination with advanced electrical blocking
techniques. This article evaluates our past and present efforts to achieve
voiding in light of the mixed nature of sacral root anatomy
Davila G.W. (1994) Urinary
incontinence in women. How to help patients regain bladder control. Postgrad.
Med. 96, 103-110.
Abstract: Urinary incontinence can have devastating effects on a woman's social
life and physical activities. Simple diagnostic tools, including the Q- tip test
and cystometry, can help identify the cause. Many causes are reversible, and an
appropriate treatment regimen can bring improvement in or completely restore
bladder control. Management options that may help patients avoid surgical
intervention include bladder drills, pelvic floor muscle exercises, and
functional electrical stimulation. Additional nonsurgical approaches are
currently under investigation and should result in more options for treating
urinary incontinence in women
Deen K.I., Premaratna R.,
Fonseka M.M., and De Silva H.J. (1998) The recto-anal inhibitory reflex:
abnormal response in diabetics suggests an intrinsic neuroenteropathy. J.
Gastroenterol. Hepatol. 13, 1107-1110.
Abstract: As electrical stimulation of the rectum has been shown to result in
reflex internal sphincter inhibition mediated by intrinsic nerves, we aimed to
evaluate the integrity of these nerves in the rectum of diabetic patients. Anal
canal pressure, recto-anal inhibitory reflex (RAIR) and continence were
evaluated in 30 diabetic patients (male:female 13:17, median age 57 years, range
37-70) and these data were compared with similar data obtained from 22 age- and
sex-matched healthy controls (male:female 9:13, median age 51 years, range 19-65
years). Median duration of diabetes was 8 years (range 3-30). Twelve (40%) of
the 30 diabetics had impaired continence for gas (n = 12) and liquid faeces (n =
3). None of the controls had incontinence. Median maximum resting anal canal
pressure (MRP) was: patients 30 mmHg (range 20-75 mmHg) versus controls 40 mmHg
(range 20-105 mmHg, P = 0.61). Median maximum squeeze pressure (MSP) was 65 mmHg
(range 30-150 mmHg) in patients versus 84mmHg (range 35-230 mm Hg) in controls
(P = 0.59). Median threshold rectal mucosal electrosensation (RMES-T) was 27mA
(5- 40 mA) in patients versus 13 mA (5-28 mA) in controls (P = 0.03). Maximum
tolerable rectal mucosal electrosensation was 40 mA (20-60) in patients versus
20 mA (10-30), in controls (P = 0.042, all comparisons using the Wilcoxon rank
test). Recto-anal inhibitory reflex was present in eight, abnormal in five (one
incontinent) and absent in 17 (11 incontinent) diabetics, while it was present
in 18 and abnormal in four controls (test of proportion, P = 0.031). Blood
glucose in diabetics on the day of the procedure was 98 mg/dL (70-165 mg/dL).
Rectal mucosal electrosensitivity and RAIR were impaired in significantly more
patients with diabetes than controls, implying impairment of intrinsic neuronal
function. The recto-anal inhibitory reflex was either impaired or absent in all
diabetic patients with incontinence
Dijkema H.E., Weil E.H., Mijs
P.T., and Janknegt R.A. (1993) Neuromodulation of sacral nerves for incontinence
and voiding dysfunctions. Clinical results and complications. Eur. Urol. 24,
72-76.
Abstract: Neuromodulation of sacral nerves is a new form of treatment for
patients with refractory voiding dysfunctions such as incontinence, retention
and chronic pelvic pain. Electrical stimulation of S3 activates the pelvic floor
and modulates innervation of the bladder, sphincter and pelvic floor, restoring
the balance and coordination in sacral reflexes. 19 of 23 patients with an
implanted neuroprosthesis for neuromodulation have a more than 50% improvement
in their main symptoms after a median follow-up of 12 months. In
urge-incontinent patients the number of leakings decreased from 7.4 to 1.5/day,
and the functional capacity increased from 135 to 227 ml
Donnelly V.S., O'Herlihy C.,
Campbell D.M., and O'Connell P.R. (1998) Postpartum fecal incontinence is more
common in women with irritable bowel syndrome. Dis. Colon Rectum 41, 586-589.
Abstract: PURPOSE: Anal sphincter damage can occur during vaginal delivery and
may lead to impairment of fecal continence. The aim of this study was to
determine the influence of irritable bowel syndrome on symptoms of fecal
incontinence following first vaginal delivery. METHODS: A prospective,
observational study was performed before delivery, six weeks, and six months
following delivery in primiparous women. A bowel function questionnaire was
completed, and anal vector manometry, mucosal electrosensitivity, pudendal nerve
terminal motor latency, and anal endosonography were performed. A total of 208
women were assessed before and after delivery, and 104 primigravid women were
studied after delivery only. A total of 34 of 312 (11 percent) had an existing
diagnosis of irritable bowel syndrome. RESULTS: The prevalence of abnormal
manometry or endosonography was similar in women with and without irritable
bowel syndrome. However, six weeks after delivery, women with irritable bowel
syndrome had a higher incidence of defecatory urgency (64 percent) and loss of
control of flatus (35 percent) compared with those without (urgency, 10 percent,
P < 0.001; flatus, 13 percent, P = 0.007). The incidence of frank fecal
incontinence was similar in the two groups. Women with IBS had increased mucosal
sensitivity to electrical stimulation of the upper anal canal both before and
after delivery. CONCLUSION: Women with IBS are more likely to experience
subjective alteration of fecal continence postpartum compared with the healthy
primigravid population, but they are not at increased risk of anal sphincter
injury
Dorey G. (2000) Male patients
with lower urinary tract symptoms. 2: Treatment. Br. J. Nurs. 9, 553-558.
Abstract: The first part of this article (Dorey, 2000) described the subjective
and objective assessment of men with lower urinary tract symptoms (LUTS). This
article will examine treatment protocols for stress incontinence, urge
incontinence, post-prostatectomy incontinence, post- micturition dribble,
overflow incontinence, reflex incontinence and functional incontinence. Pelvic
floor muscle exercises, biofeedback, electrical stimulation, urge suppression
techniques, and fluid intake are discussed. It is concluded that men with LUTS
can benefit from conservative treatment
Dudognon P., Salle J.Y., Munoz
M., Guinvarc'h S., Bouru M., and Labrousse C. (1995) [Rehabilitation of female
urinary incontinence]. Rev. Prat. 45, 322-327.
Abstract: Perineal rehabilitation is an appropriate alternative to surgery in
the treatment of urinary female incontinence. The most important factors
influencing the success of this technique is the ability of the patient to
identify correctly the muscles of the pelvic floor, to strengthen this muscles
using exercises, electrical stimulation and biofeedback, to contract voluntarily
the pelvic floor musculature during stress or sensation of voiding for having a
preventive effect on loss of urine, and also to change, if necessary, the
micturitional and drinking customs. Some conditions are required to complete a
good result: strong motivation of the woman, ability of the physiotherapist or
the midwife, quality of care and follow-up of the physician who must clearly
know the place of this conservative treatment in selected patients, particularly
in moderate stress incontinence, without important prolapse, urge incontinence,
pregnancy and post-partum, two conditions in which this technique must have a
preventive and curative efficiency
Dumoulin C., Seaborne D.E.,
Quirion-DeGirardi C., and Sullivan S.J. (1995) Pelvic-floor rehabilitation, Part
1: Comparison of two surface electrode placements during stimulation of the
pelvic-floor musculature in women who are continent using bipolar interferential
currents. Phys. Ther. 75, 1067-1074.
Abstract: BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Electrical stimulation of the pelvic floor is
used as an adjunct in the conservative treatment of urinary incontinence. No
consensus exists, however, regarding electrode placements for optimal
stimulation of the pelvic-floor musculature. The purpose of this study was to
compare two different bipolar electrode placements, one suggested by Laycock and
Green (L2) the other by Dumoulin (D2), during electrical stimulation with
interferential currents of the pelvic-floor musculature in continent women,
using a two-group crossover design. SUBJECTS: Ten continent female volunteers,
ranging in age from 20 to 39 years (mean = 27.3, SD = 5.6), were randomly
assigned to one of two study groups. METHODS: Each study group received
neuromuscular electrical stimulation (NMES) of the pelvic- floor musculature
using both electrode placements, the order of application being reversed for
each group. Force of contraction was measured as pressure (in centimeters of
water [cm H2O]) exerted on a vaginal pressure probe attached to a manometer.
Data were analyzed using a two-way, mixed-model analysis of variance. RESULTS:
No difference in pressure was observed between the two electrode placements.
Differences in current amplitude were observed, with the D2 electrode placement
requiring less current amplitude to produce a maximum recorded pressure on the
manometer. Subjective assessment by the subjects revealed a preference for the
D2 electrode placement (7 of 10 subjects). CONCLUSION AND DISCUSSION: The lower
current amplitudes required with the D2 placement to obtain recordings
comparable to those obtained with the L2 technique suggest a more comfortable
stimulation of the pelvic-floor muscles. The lower current amplitudes required
also suggest that greater increases in pressure might be obtained with the D2
placement by increasing the current amplitude while remaining within the comfort
threshold. These results will help to define treatment guidelines for a planned
clinical study investigating the effects of NMES and exercise in the treatment
of urinary stress incontinence in women postpartum. [Dumoulin C, Seaborne DE,
Quirion-DeGirardi C, Sullivan SJ. Pelvic-floor rehabilitation, part 1:
comparison of two surface electrode placements during stimulation of the
pelvic-floor musculature in women who are continent using bipolar interferential
currents
Duthie H.L. (1968) The use of
intermittent electrical stimulation in anal incontinence. Proc. R. Soc. Med. 61,
706-707.
Eckstein H.B. (1975) Treatment
of incontinence by electrical stimulation. Nurs. Times 71, 1423-1424.
Egon G., Barat M., Colombel P.,
Visentin C., Isambert J.L., and Guerin J. (1998) Implantation of anterior sacral
root stimulators combined with posterior sacral rhizotomy in spinal injury
patients. World J. Urol. 16, 342-349.
Abstract: Brindley-Finetech sacral anterior root stimulators combined with
posterior sacral rhizotomy were implanted in 68 males and 28 females with spinal
cord lesions. In 9 patients the electrodes were implanted extradurally in the
sacrum, and in 90 patients they were implanted intradurally (3 patients had a
second extradural implant after a first intradural implant). Three patients died
from causes unrelated to the implant. Of the 93 surviving patients, 83 used
their implants for micturition and 82 were fully continent. The mean bladder
capacity increased from 206 ml preoperatively to 564 ml after the operation.
Three patients had a preoperative vesicorenal reflux that disappeared after
surgery. In all, 51 patients used the stimulator for defecation. Erection was
possible with electrical stimulation in 46 males and was used for coitus by 17
couples. Secondary deafferentation at the level of the conus was performed four
times. Three patients who had a cerebrospinal fluid leak were operated on again.
Two implants had to be removed because of infection. Sacral anterior root
stimulation combined with sacral deafferentation is a welcome addition to the
treatment of neurogenic bladder in spinal cord injury patients
Erlandson B.E., Fall M.,
Carlsson C.A., and Linder L.E. (1977) Mechanisms for closure of the human
urethra during intravaginal electrical stimulation. Scand. J. Urol. Nephrol.
Suppl 49-54.
Abstract: The effect of intravaginal electrical stimulation (IVS) on the
urethral pressure profile (UPP) before and during succinylcholine blockade or
spinal anaesthesia was studied in patients with stress incontinence and in
patients with clinically normal urethral function. During succinylcholine
blockade, the UPP was lowered to 74% and during spinal anaesthesia to 39% of the
original maximal UPP. IVS could not influence the UPP during succinylcholine
blockade, while the UPP could be restored during spinal anaesthesia when the
stimulation strength was increased 3 to 4 times. The following conclusions were
arrived at: 1) The urethral effect of IVS is due to activation of somatic nerves
and not to activation of nerves supplying smooth muscles or direct activation of
striated and smooth muscles. 2) The more pronounced depression of the UPP during
spinal anaesthesia compared to succinylcholine blockade should be caused by the
loss of nervous activity of the smooth muscles. 3) The fact that the UPP could
be restored during spinal anaesthesia indicates that activation of somatic
efferents can compensate for the loss of striated and smooth muscle activity.
Therefore, IVS can control incontinence in partial lower motor neuron lesions,
provided a sufficient number of efferent neurons are preserved
Erlandson B.E., Fall M., and
Carlsson C.A. (1977) The effect of intravaginal electrical stimulation on the
feline urethra and urinary bladder. Electrical parameters. Scand. J. Urol.
Nephrol. Suppl 5-18.
Abstract: Intravaginal electrical stimulation (IVS) in cats caused urethral
closure and bladder inhibition. The aim was to ascertain the electrical
parameters most appropriate for these effects. Minimum voltage was used as main
criterion to select an effective, non-destructive stimulation when the shape,
frequency and duration of the pulses were systematically varied. Urethral
closure was achieved at minimum voltage (3 V) with alternating pulses at a
frequency of 50 Hz and a pulse duration of 1.5 ms. Corresponding optimal
parameters for bladder inhibition were: alternating pulses, 10 Hz and 1.5 ms.
Minimum voltage was 1 V. Moreover, the positions of the electrodes were of
significance for the responses. The clinical implications of these findings are
that: 1)more differentiated treatment of incontinence could be achieved by
adapting the stimulation parameters to the cause of incontinence, and 2)
specific electrode positions would probably give optimal responses
Erlandson B.E., Fall M., and
Sundin T. (1977) Intravaginal electrical stimulation. Clinical experiments of
urethral closure. Scand. J. Urol. Nephrol. Suppl 31-39.
Abstract: The effect on the urethra of intravaginal electrical stimulation (IVS)
was registered by means of urethral pressure profiles (UPP). With the object of
finding the most appropriate electrical parameters and optimal electrode
positions within the vagina, 24 patients with stress incontinence, 22 with
urgency and 4 continent women were studied. Electrical stimulation was given via
an obturator with seven electrodes, which could be connected in different
combinations of pairs. In all the women, stimulation with the electrodes in
specific positions effected a more marked rise in the UPPs than with the
electrodes in other positions. A change in position of more than 5 to 10 mm
caused a decrease in the response. It was determined that a frequency of between
20 to 50 Hz with a pulse duration of 1 to 5 ms was most effective for urethral
closure
Esa A., Kiwamoto H., Sugiyama
T., Park Y.C., Kaneko S., and Kurita T. (1991) Functional electrical stimulation
in the management of incontinence: studies of urodynamics. Int. Urol. Nephrol.
23, 135-141.
Abstract: Intermittent functional electrical stimulation (FES) was employed for
the control of incontinence. One FES session lasted for 30 minutes. It was
repeated at intervals of 3 days to 1 week via an anal plug electrode. The
success rate was 64% in 41 patients with pollakiuria, urgency and/or urge
incontinence, and 43% in 7 patients with stress incontinence. Detrusor activity
measured by cystometry did not correlate significantly with the effect on
subjective symptoms and the urethral pressure did not increase. The remarkable
clinical effect was observed in patients with overactive detrusor function. It
seems that FES indirectly inhibits detrusor contraction by suppressing the
intrasacral pathway for detrusor activity
Fall M., Erlandson B.E., Sundin
T., and Waagstein F. (1977) Intravaginal electrical stimulation. Clinical
experiments on bladder inhibition. Scand. J. Urol. Nephrol. Suppl 41-47.
Abstract: The effect of intravaginal electrical stimulation (IVS) on the bladder
in 17 patients with motor detrusor instability was explored. Isotonic volume
registrations and cystometries were used for evaluation of volume increase and
inhibition of abortive detrusor contractions. With either one or the other
method, bladder inhibition was found in all patients, but with both methods only
in 6. During isotonic volume registration, the volume increase showed
considerable variations ranging between 4 to 465%, and during cystometry between
11 to 3500%. Bladder inhibition proved to be most effective when using a
frequency of 10 Hz
Fall M., Erlandson B.E., Nilson
A.E., and Sundin T. (1977) Long-term intravaginal electrical stimulation in urge
and stress incontinence. Scand. J. Urol. Nephrol. Suppl 55-63.
Abstract: Using a new device for intravaginal electrical stimulation (IVS), 24
women with pure stress incontinence, mixed urge and stress incontinence or urge
incontinence due to detrusor instability, were treated. To minimize mechanical
discomfort, the electrode carrier was made of flexible material and inflatable.
Furthermore, this design facilitated fixed, constant positioning of the
electrodes at individually tested sites to produce maximum response at voltage
well tolerated by the patient. The stimulation frequency was adjusted to suit
the cause of incontinence: 20 to 50 Hz in stress incontinence, 10 Hz detrusor
instability. The electrode carrier was well accepted. Seven of the 9 patients
with pure stress incontinence became continent during IVS. Three of them have so
far remained continent for 2 to 8 months without IVS. The 15 patients with
detrusor instability or mixed incontinence were all free from symptoms after IVS
for more than 3 months. Two of them have remained cured for more than 3 months
after they had stopped IVS
Fall M., Erlandson B.E.,
Carlsson C.A., and Sundin T. (1978) Effects of electrical intravaginal
stimulation on bladder volume: an experimental and clinical study. Urol. Int.
33, 440-442.
Abstract: Clinical observations have indicated that not only stress incontinence
due to defective urethral closure but also urge incontinence due to bladder
hyperactivity can be successfully treated by electrical stimulation of the
pelvic floor. Clinical investigations revealed that intravaginal electrical
stimulation caused bladder inhibition registered as a volume increase. This
inhibition was most marked at a low stimulation frequency (10 Hz). Animal
experiments indicated that the bladder inhibition was achieved by autonomic
spinal reflex mechanisms activated by stimulation of pudendal afferents
Fall M. (1984) Does
electrostimulation cure urinary incontinence? J. Urol. 131, 664-667.
Abstract: A followup study is presented of a prospective series of women treated
with an inflatable intravaginal electrode carrier and an external pulse
generator. The devices were individually adjustable with respect to electrode
positioning and stimulation parameters. The study included 40 women with
detrusor instability and/or genuine stress incontinence. The primary results for
urge symptoms were favorable. Of the patients 73 per cent were primarily free of
symptoms during treatment and 45 per cent remained free of symptoms after
withdrawal of treatment, including two-thirds in whom re-education persisted
during the followup of 6 years. Of the patients with genuine stress incontinence
40 per cent exhibited persistent re-education. There were considerable
discrepancies between symptomatic cure or improvement, and the urodynamic
findings at followup. Intravaginal electrical stimulation may be regarded as the
treatment of choice for urge incontinence due to detrusor instability, and in
mixed stress and urge incontinence. The method also is an alternative to an
operation in some women with genuine stress incontinence
Fall M., Ahlstrom K., Carlsson
C.A., Ek A., Erlandson B.E., Frankenberg S., and Mattiasson A. (1986) Contelle:
pelvic floor stimulator for female stress-urge incontinence. A multicenter
study. Urology 27, 282-287.
Abstract: The clinical efficacy of a new device for treatment of female
incontinence was studied in a multicenter trial. The device consists of an
inflatable electrode carrier and an external stimulator unit. Forty women were
treated: 10 had primary or recurrent genuine stress incontinence, 15 had urge
incontinence due to idiopathic detrusor instability, not responding to drug
treatment, and 15 had stress incontinence combined with detrusor instability.
Twenty-five patients were improved by the treatment. Another 8 reported an
excellent result of treatment and remained free of symptoms for more than six
months after withdrawal of the treatment. The results were more favorable in
patients with bladder hyperactivity than in genuine stress incontinence. The
patients' general ratings of treatment efficacy correlated well with their
recordings of urinary frequency and consumption of incontinence pads. The
functional bladder capacity increased in improved patients, but normalization of
urodynamic parameters was no prerequisite for clinical improvement. We found
intravaginal electrical stimulation to be a valuable alternative to medical and
surgical intervention in patients with detrusor instability
Fall M. and Lindstrom S. (1991)
Electrical stimulation. A physiologic approach to the treatment of urinary
incontinence. Urol. Clin. North Am. 18, 393-407.
Abstract: Appropriate management of patients with urinary incontinence requires
access to a variety of methods. Electrical stimulation, although so far
proportionally small in the armamentarium of methods, is founded on physiologic
principles and has the advantage of being curative without significant side
effects
Fall M. (1998) Advantages and
pitfalls of functional electrical stimulation. Acta Obstet. Gynecol. Scand.
Suppl 168, 16-21.
Abstract: Functional electrical stimulation has many theoretical advantages. In
clinical practice, very favorable results have been repeatedly presented. The
experience now encompasses thirty years and a very large number of incontinent
patients. Although the methods are widely used, they are differently
appreciated. Problems include the fact that functional electrical stimulation
does not belong to the therapeutic traditions in urology and gynecology, there
is a need of personal training for successful treatment and there is a lack of
systematic studies on different clinical applications. Significant advantages
are a rational physiological basis, applicability in a variety of lower urinary
tract dysfunctions, few side effects and a potential curative effect
Flack F.C. (1968) The use of
electrical stimulation in urinary retention and incontinence. Proc. R. Soc. Med.
61, 704.
Flannery J.F., Ellis F.G., and
Lale P.G. (1969) Electrical stimulation of the striated urinary sphincter
mechanism. Br. J. Surg. 56, 632.
Formal C.S., Cawley M.F., and
Stiens S.A. (1997) Spinal cord injury rehabilitation. 3. Functional outcomes.
Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil. 78, S59-S64.
Abstract: This self-directed learning module highlights new advances in this
topic area. It is part of the chapter on spinal cord injury rehabilitation in
the Self-Directed Physiatric Education Program for practitioners and trainees in
physical medicine and rehabilitation. This article contains information about
mobility, ambulation, upper extremity function, bowel management, and technology
to enhance function in the community. New advances covered in this section
include functional electrical stimulation for enhancing mobility and upper
extremity function
Fossberg E., Sorensen S., Ruutu
M., Bakke A., Stien R., Henriksson L., and Kinn A.C. (1990) Maximal electrical
stimulation in the treatment of unstable detrusor and urge incontinence. Eur.
Urol. 18, 120-123.
Abstract: Ninety-one patients with unstable detrusor and urge incontinence were
treated with maximal electrical stimulation. There were 17 dropouts. From the
remaining 74 patients 51 were subjectively cured or significantly improved, this
effect lasted for more than 6 weeks in 40. Objectively a significant decrease in
frequency was found, also a significant increase in bladder volume. No effect on
detrusor pressure at bladder contraction was noted
Geirsson G. and Fall M. (1997)
Maximal functional electrical stimulation in routine practice. Neurourol. Urodyn.
16, 559-565.
Abstract: Maximal functional electrical stimulation is now an established
treatment for urgency and urge incontinence. Many studies have been presented
with good and consistent results. In a number of prospective studies we have
previously recorded very favourable effects in stress incontinence and urge
incontinence. In the present study, we have compared our previous experience
with a retrospective analysis of a series of maximal functional electrical
stimulation given according to a simple routine protocol and including 84
patients. The overall subjective improvement rate was 54% but the cure rate was
only 5%, which is far below our experience in previous studies, as well as in
others. The subjective outcome was in agreement with changes in mictrurition
variables as recorded in voiding diaries. The discrepancy probably depends on a
number of factors. It is suggested that the most crucial ones are patient
selection, the intensity of stimulation, and the number of sessions given. It is
important to realize the limitations and pitfalls of the technique when it is
applied in routine practice
George B.D., Williams N.S.,
Patel J., Swash M., and Watkins E.S. (1993) Physiological and histochemical
adaptation of the electrically stimulated gracilis muscle to neoanal sphincter
function. Br. J. Surg. 80, 1342-1346.
Abstract: The physiological and histochemical characteristics of the gracilis
muscle were studied in 19 patients undergoing electrically stimulated gracilis
neosphincter construction. Indications for surgery were faecal incontinence (n =
11) and reconstruction following sphincter excision or congenital absence (n =
8). Transposition of the gracilis muscle around the anal canal followed by
chronic low-frequency electrical stimulation was associated with a shift in the
frequency-response curve and a prolongation of the time-course of individual
muscle twitches suggestive of transformation to a slow-twitch fatigue-resistant
type. Temporary cessation of electrical stimulation resulted in a reversal of
the frequency-response changes. Muscle biopsies taken before and a median of 80
(range 49-137) days after transposition and low-frequency electrical stimulation
indicated a significant increase in the proportion of type 1 fibres and a
significant decrease in their diameter. These results show that the human
gracilis muscle is capable of physiological and histochemical adaptation to
long-term neosphincter function
Gladh G., Mattsson S., and
Lindstrom S. (2001) Anogenital electrical stimulation as treatment of urge
incontinence in children. BJU. Int. 87, 366-371.
Abstract: OBJECTIVES: To evaluate retrospectively the result of anogenital
afferent stimulation (AGAS) in neurological healthy children with
therapy-resistant urge incontinence. PATIENTS AND METHODS: The study included 48
children (24 girls and 24 boys, 5-14 years old) with a diagnosis of bladder
instability verified by cystometry in all. Anogenital afferent stimulations were
applied using a battery-powered dual constant-current stimulator. The children
were stimulated continuously at 10 Hz for 20 min once or twice daily and if
required the children and/or the parents continued to apply the treatment at
home. For home stimulation a single (anal) channel stimulator was used. The
patients were instructed to stimulate for 20 min at maximum intensity two to
three times a week until the effects were optimal. The outcome was evaluated
retrospectively by comparing voiding/incontinence diaries obtained before and at
the follow-up 6-12 months after the end of treatment. RESULTS: AGAS was applied
at the clinic for a median (range) of 9 (4-20) times. Thirty-one children
continued with home stimulation for another 25 (5-96) sessions. At the
follow-up, 18 children were cured and another seven improved, with a leakage
score of less than half that before treatment. The treatment was well tolerated
by most children. CONCLUSIONS: Anogenital afferent stimulation is an effective,
potentially curative treatment in children with severe urge incontinence. Home
stimulation is a well accepted adjuvant to treatment at the clinic and improves
the outcome
Godec C., Cass A.S., and Ayala
G.F. (1975) Bladder inhibition with functional electrical stimulation. Urology
6, 663-666.
Abstract: Spastic or hyperreflex bladder dysfunction can cause frequency,
urgency, and incontinence. Detrusor activity was inhibited by FES (functional
electrical stimulation) applied to the anal sphincter causing decreased bladder
spasticity and increased bladder capacity. FES is indicated for incontinence not
only because of weakness of the pelvic floor but also because of hyperreflex
bladder
Godec C. and Kralj B. (1976)
Selection of patients with urinary incontinence for application of functional
electrical stimulation. Urol. Int. 31, 124-128.
Abstract: Contradictory data from the literature along with our own experience
using functional electrical stimulation (FES) have facilitated the determination
of objective criteria for the application of FES in correcting urinary
incontinence. Simultaneous urodynamic, neurophysiological, and radiological
examinations employed during our studies enabled us to determine changes in
these parameters due to FEX. Among a large number of patients with urinary
incontinence (for example: paraplegics, patients with spina bifida, stress
incontinence following prostate operations, or resistant enuresis) we have
determined that FES is appropriate if applied to properly selected patients. FES
is indicated on the basis of the following criteria: the degree of morphological
lesion of the urinary tract, the peripheral denervation of the muscles of the
pelvic floor, the condition of the spinal center for miction, and, above all the
quality of response to FES. FES not only activates the closing muscles of the
bladder, but also inhibits the reflex contractions of the detrusor. Here, it
should be noted that FES is indicated for cases of reflex incontinence. During
FES of the pelvic floor muscles intravesical pressure normally diminishes and
the reflex contractions of the detrusor subside. Sometimes, however, the reflex
of miction occurs. In such a case, two reflex mechanisms are engaged. Their
equilibrium, i.e. controlled miction, can be achieved with an afferent in flow
which inhibits the reflex of miction. The use of FES for the correction of
urinary incontinence can be a very good method if the FES parameters are
individually chosen and patients properly selected
Godec C., Cass A.S., and Ayala
G.F. (1976) Electrical stimulation for incontinence. Technique, selection, and
results. Urology 7, 388-397.
Abstract: Incontinence due to hyperreflexic bladder and/or pelvic floor weakness
can be corrected by chronic functional electrical stimulation (FES). Cystometry,
electromyography of pelvic floor muscles, and anal sphincter pressure
measurements with and without electrical stimulation determines if chronic FES
will be successful. Post-acute stimulation improvement occurred in patients with
incontinence due to hyperreflexic bladder and/or pelvic floor weakness. A
success rate of 92 per cent was achieved with chronic FES in incontinent
patients with this method of selection
Godec C., Ayala G., and Cass A.
(1977) Electrical stimulation of the rectal ampulla causing reflex voiding. J.
Urol. 117, 770-772.
Abstract: Electrical stimulation of the rectal ampulla resulted in a desire to
void and defecate in 11 patients with an intact nervous system. There was a
contraction of the detrusor and the rectal ampulla with relaxation of the anal
sphincter. Electrical stimulation of the rectal ampulla and anal sphincter has
clinical applications in patients with incontinence of, or inability to empty,
the lower urinary tract or fecal system
Godec C. and Cass A. (1978)
Acute electrical stimulation for urinary incontinence. Urology 12, 340-341.
Abstract: Acute or maximal electric stimulation of the pelvic floor muscles has
been used in incontinent patients who are suitable candidates for electrical
stimulation, but unwilling or unable to use the anal plug electrodes. Seventeen
of 20 patients had relief or improvement of their incontinence. However 5 of
these 17 patients had a relapse of symptoms on follow-up, requiring a repeat
treatment with acute or maximal electrical stimulation
Godec C. and Cass A.S. (1978)
Electrical stimulation in the management of incontinence in children. Minn. Med.
61, 157-160.
Godec C. and Cass A.S. (1979)
Electrical stimulation for voiding dysfunction after spinal cord injury. J. Urol.
121, 73-75.
Abstract: Incontinence and frequency of voiding were present after spinal cord
injuries in 18 patients. A hyperreflexic bladder and/or pelvic floor weakness
was found in these patients. Functional electrical stimulation resulted in
relief or improvement of symptoms in 9 of the 11 patients in whom this procedure
was used. An increase in anal sphincter pressure with functional electrical
stimulation was a more reliable criterion than an increase in maximum urethral
pressure in the selection of patients for the procedure
Godec C.J. and Cass A.S. (1978)
Electrical stimulation for incontinence in myelomeningocele. J. Urol. 120,
729-731.
Abstract: Urinary incontinence is the most obvious urinary tract complication in
children with myelomeningocele. Incontinence is owing to a hyperreflexic
(spastic) bladder and/or pelvic floor weakness, which responds to functional
electrical stimulation. Of 33 incontinent children the criteria for functional
electrical stimulation were absent in 21 because of denervation of the pelvic
floor muscles. Of 6 children who used functional electrical stimulation 5 had a
successful result. However, incontinence recurred in 3 of the 5 patients between
6 and 18 months after functional electrical stimulation treatment was completed
and they are awaiting repeat treatment
Godec C.J., Fravel R., and Cass
A.S. (1981) Optimal parameters of electrical stimulation in the treatment of
urinary incontinence. Invest Urol. 18, 239-241.
Abstract: We evaluated five types of electrical stimulation (continuous,
intermittent pseudorandomized, randomized (stochastic), and intermittent
randomized) for their effects on muscle contraction and muscle fatigue in 12
patients with urinary incontinence. Continuous stimulation, used in the
available commercial stimulators, was not optimal. Randomized (stochastic)
stimulation seems to be optimal although this conclusion was not statistically
confirmed
Gonzalez-Chamorro F., Verdu T.F.,
and Hernandez F.C. (1997) [Current status of neurostimulation and
neuromodulation for vesicourethral dysfunction]. Arch. Esp. Urol. 50, 687-694.
Abstract: OBJECTIVE: To describe the current indications, techniques and results
of sacral root stimulation in patients with spinal cord lesions as a treatment
for patients with high pressure bladders and/or urinary incontinence despite
conservative management, as well as sacral root neuromodulation with permanent
stimulators for complex bladder dysfunction: vesical instability, sensory
urgency, chronic pelvic pain and chronic voiding dysfunction. METHODS/RESULTS:
The literature is reviewed, both techniques are described and the results of the
most significant series are discussed, with special reference to the first
groups that utilized these techniques. CONCLUSIONS: There is ample experience in
the application of sacral root electrical stimulation. The reported results are
comparable with those achieved by other treatments, such as augmentation
cystoplasty. Neurostimulation and neuromodulation techniques are simple, the
complications are minimal and they do not prelude the use of other therapies
Gonzalez-Chamorro F., Esteban
F.M., Tamayo Ruiz J.C., Angulo C.J., and Sanchez-Chapado M. (1998) [Electric
stimulation of sacral roots for the treatment of urinary incontinence due to
detrusor instability: application of a technique and results in a clinical
case]. Arch. Esp. Urol. 51, 278-283.
Abstract: OBJECTIVE: To describe a case treated with a new technique in our
therapeutic algorithm for non-neurogenic vesicourethral dysfunction.
METHODS/RESULTS: A 47-year-old female underwent retropubic urethropexy for
stress urinary incontinence. She remained incontinent due to detrusor
instability to a degree that was socially unacceptable. After conservative
treatment had failed, a percutaneous electrode was applied to the sacral nerve
root and she received electrical stimulation of 4-6 milliamperes, 15 Hz and 200
microseconds duration for 7 days. Incontinence remitted for as long as 3 months
after the electrode had been removed. CONCLUSION: The results achieved with
sacral nerve electrical stimulation reported in the literature and our results
support the use of this technique in urological clinical practice
Grandjean P., Acker M., Madoff
R., Williams N.S., Woloszko J., and Kantor C. (1996) Dynamic myoplasty: surgical
transfer and stimulation of skeletal muscle for functional substitution or
enhancement. J. Rehabil. Res. Dev. 33, 133-144.
Abstract: Dynamic myoplasty combines muscle transfer with electrical stimulation
to provide contractile function that augments or replaces impaired organ
function. Dynamic cardiomyoplasty was the first clinical application in which a
skeletal muscle, latissimus dorsi, was transferred and stimulated to provide
cardiac assistance, a function different from its original one. The problem of
early muscle fatigue that was encountered in the initial implementation of the
method was solved by training the muscle with electrical stimulation and thus
changing its fiber composition. With intramuscular electrodes, the conditioned
latissimus dorsi is stimulated in synchrony with the heart muscle. Safeguards
are built into the two-channel implanted stimulator to avoid excessively high
pulse rates. Clinicians report that 80% of patients with moderate to severe
heart failure prior to operation showed a clinical improvement of 1.6 New York
Heart Association classes. Alternative methods of providing cardiac assistance
that are also being investigated include wrapping the muscle around the aorta,
creating a skeletal muscle ventricle, and using the muscle to power an
implantable pump. These latter techniques are still under preclinical
investigation. Compared with heart transplant, cardiomyoplasty has the great
advantage of not being subject to tissue rejection. The second principal
application of dynamic myoplasty is treatment of fecal incontinence through
creation of an electrically stimulated skeletal muscle neosphincter (ESMNS). The
gracilis muscle of the leg is mobilized, wrapped around the anal canal, and
conditioned with electrical stimulation to become more fatigue resistant. To
achieve continence, the muscle is continuously stimulated except when the
patient wishes to defecate. Overall success rates in achieving continence are
60-65%. Both cardiomyoplasty and the ESMNS technique, and their associated
devices, are being refined through ongoing clinical trials
Halverstadt D.B. (1971)
Electrical stimulation of the human bladder: 3 years later. J. Urol. 106,
673-677.
Hay-Smith E.J., Bo K.,
Berghmans L.C., Hendriks H.J., de Bie R.A., and van W. (2001) Pelvic floor
muscle training for urinary incontinence in women (Cochrane Review). Cochrane.
Database. Syst. Rev. 1, CD001407.
Abstract: BACKGROUND: Pelvic floor muscle training is the most commonly
recommended physical therapy treatment for women with stress leakage of urine.
It is also used in the treatment of women with mixed incontinence, and less
commonly for urge incontinence. Adjuncts, such as biofeedback or electrical
stimulation, are also commonly used with pelvic floor muscle training. The
content of pelvic floor muscle training programmes is highly variable.
OBJECTIVES: To determine the effects of pelvic floor muscle training for women
with symptoms or urodynamic diagnoses of stress, urge and mixed incontinence, in
comparison to no treatment or other treatment options. SEARCH STRATEGY: Search
strategy: We searched the Cochrane Incontinence Group trials register (May
2000), Medline (1980 to 1998), Embase (1980 to 1998), the database of the Dutch
National Institute of Allied Health Professions (to 1998), the database of the
Cochrane Rehabilitation and Related Therapies Field (to 1998), Physiotherapy
Index (to 1998) and the reference lists of relevant articles. We handsearched
the proceedings of the International Continence Society (1980 to 2000). We
contacted investigators in the field to locate studies. Date of the most recent
searches: May 2000. SELECTION CRITERIA: Randomised trials in women with symptoms
or urodynamic diagnoses of stress, urge or mixed incontinence that included
pelvic floor muscle training in at least one arm of the trial. DATA COLLECTION
AND ANALYSIS: Two reviewers assessed all trials for inclusion/exclusion and
methodological quality. Data were extracted by the lead reviewer onto a standard
form and cross checked by another. Disagreements were resolved by discussion.
Data were processed as described in the Cochrane Handbook. Sensitivity analysis
on the basis of diagnosis was planned and undertaken where appropriate. MAIN
RESULTS: Forty-three trials met the inclusion criteria. The primary or only
reference for 15 of these was a conference abstract. The pelvic floor muscle
training programs, and comparison interventions, varied markedly. Outcome
measures differed between trials, and methods of data reporting varied, making
the data difficult to combine. Many of the trials were small. Allocation
concealment was adequate in five trials, and nine trials used assessors masked
to group allocation. Thirteen trials reported that there were no losses to
follow up, seven trials had dropout rates of less than 10%, but in the remaining
trials the proportion of dropouts ranged from 12% to 41%. Pelvic floor muscle
training was better than no treatment or placebo treatments for women with
stress or mixed incontinence. 'Intensive' appeared to be better than 'standard'
pelvic floor muscle training. PFMT may be more effective than some types of
electrical stimulation but there were problems in combining the data from these
trials. There is insufficient evidence to determine if pelvic floor muscle
training is better or worse than other treatments. The effect of adding pelvic
floor muscle training to other treatments (e.g. electrical stimulation,
behavioural training) is not clear due to the limited amount of evidence
available. Evidence of the effect of adding other adjunctive treatments to PFMT
(e.g. vaginal cones, intravaginal resistance) is equally limited. The
effectiveness of biofeedback assisted PFMT is not clear, but on the basis of the
evidence available there did not appear to be any benefit over PFMT alone at
post treatment assessment. Long-term outcomes of pelvic floor muscle training
are unclear. Side effects of pelvic floor muscle training were uncommon and
reversible. A number of the formal comparisons should be viewed with caution due
to statistical heterogeneity, lack of statistical independence, and the
possibility of spurious confidence intervals in some instances. REVIEWER'S
CONCLUSIONS: Pelvic floor muscle training appeared to be an effective treatment
for adult women with stress or mixed incontinence. Pelvic floor muscle training
was better than no treatment or placebo treatments. The limitations of the
evidence available mean that is difficult to judge if pelvic floor muscle
training was better or worse than other treatments. Most trials to date have
studied the effect of treatment in younger, premenopausal women. The role of
pelvic floor muscle training for women with urge incontinence alone remains
unclear. Many of the trials were small with poor reporting of allocation
concealment and masking of outcome assessors. In addition there was a lack of
consistency in the choice and reporting of outcome measures that made data
difficult to combine. Methodological problems limit the confidence that can be
placed in the findings of the review. Further, large, high quality trials are
necessary
Henry M.M. (1994) The role of
pudendal nerve innervation in female pelvic floor function. Curr. Opin. Obstet.
Gynecol. 6, 324-325.
Abstract: The assessment of motor conduction along the pudendal nerve is an
accurate objective measure of pudendal nerve function. Measurement of its
latency (that is the time interval between electrical stimulation of the nerve
and induced contraction of the external anal sphincter) has been demonstrated to
be abnormally long following vaginal delivery, particularly if the delivery was
associated with a heavy fetus or a prolonged second stage of labor. The
significance of pudendal neuropathy and its relationship to abnormal degrees of
descent of the pelvic floor have also been examined in this review
Herold A., Bruch H.P., Hocht
B., and Muller G. (1989) [Biofeedback training and functional electrostimulation
for improving incontinence in children with anal atresia]. Langenbecks Arch.
Chir Suppl II Verh. Dtsch. Ges. Chir 991-995.
Abstract: Eleven children with anal incontinence following a pull-through
operation for anorectal agenesis (4 low, 7 high anomalies) were treated with a
conservative continence training program (optic/acoustic biofeedback,
transcutaneous electrical stimulation, physical therapy, contraction exercises
and sensibility training). All patients with one exception showed subjective and
objective improvement of continence. Sphincter contraction increased by 80% in
high and by 40% in low anomalies. For a short time electrostimulation provided
an improvement of up to 20% in sphincter pressure. One additional success was
improved coordination. Beside surgical therapy and other methods continence
training is always indicated
Hofbauer J., Preisinger F., and
Nurnberger N. (1990) [The value of physical therapy in genuine female stress
incontinence]. Z. Urol. Nephrol. 83, 249-254.
Abstract: In a prospective randomized study the efficiacy of physical therapy in
female stress incontinence could be verified. The greatest success rate was
achieved by medical gymnastics, whereas the perineal electrical stimulation
should be used as supporting measure like a biofeedback mechanism because of its
low effective intensity. Despite of the good therapeutic success (51.5%) with
lasting effects no objective criteria to the use of physical therapy in female
stress incontinence were found
Hosker G., Norton C., and
Brazzelli M. (2000) Electrical stimulation for faecal incontinence in adults.
Cochrane. Database. Syst. Rev. CD001310.
Abstract: BACKGROUND: Faecal incontinence is a particularly embarrassing and
distressing condition with significant medical, social and economic
implications. Electrical stimulation has been used with apparent success in the
treatment of faecal incontinence. However, standards of treatment are still
lacking and the magnitude of alleged benefits has yet to be established.
OBJECTIVES: To determine the effects of electrical stimulation for the treatment
of faecal incontinence in adults. SEARCH STRATEGY: We searched the Cochrane
Incontinence Group trials register, the Cochrane Controlled Trials Register,
Medline, Embase and reference lists of potentially eligible articles up to
November 1999. Date of the most recent searches: November 1999. SELECTION
CRITERIA: All randomised or quasi-randomised trials evaluating electrical
stimulation in adults with faecal incontinence. DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS:
Three reviewers assessed the methodological quality of potentially eligible
trials and two reviewers independently extracted data from the included trial. A
wide range of outcome measures were considered. MAIN RESULTS: Only one eligible
trial with 40 participants was identified. It was a randomised trial, but it
suffered from methodological drawbacks and did not follow up patients beyond the
end of the trial period. Findings from this trial suggest that electrical
stimulation with anal biofeedback and exercises provides more short-term
benefits than vaginal biofeedback and exercises for women with obstetric-related
faecal incontinence. No further conclusions could be drawn from the data
available. REVIEWER'S CONCLUSIONS: At present, there are insufficient data to
allow reliable conclusions to be drawn on the effects of electrical stimulation
in the management of faecal incontinence. There is a suggestion that electrical
stimulation may have a therapeutic effect, but this is not certain. Larger, more
generalisable trials are needed
Hughes S.F., Scott S.M., Pilot
M.A., and Williams N.S. (1995) Electrically stimulated colonic reservoir for
total anorectal reconstruction. Br. J. Surg. 82, 1321-1326.
Abstract: Total anorectal reconstruction after abdominoperineal excision of the
rectum has failed to achieve perfect continence. Electrically stimulated
reservoir evacuation in combination with an electrically stimulated gracilis
neoanal sphincter might improve results. A J pouch was constructed in an
isolated colonic loop of seven dogs. Bipolar square wave pulses were delivered
via two intramural stainless steel electrode pairs at 10 Hz. Stimulation
parameters were varied to achieve adequate contraction. Serosal strain gauges
recorded spontaneous and stimulated pouch motility. Evacuation was quantified by
a volume displacement technique and observed fluoroscopically. Recordings were
performed for a median of 3 (range 1-11) months. At 10 Hz and 0.5 ms pulse
width, stimulation was required for 2 min and at voltages of 15 V (n = 4), 18 V
(n = 1) and 20 V (n = 2) to obtain a contraction of amplitude comparable to that
of a spontaneous contraction. Suprathreshold stimulation invariably resulted in
colonic pouch contraction. The mean(95 per cent confidence interval (c.i.))
stimulus- response latency was 25.5(1.9) s. The mean(95 per cent c.i.)
intraluminal pressure generated during stimulation was 114.1(17.0) cmH2O and
64.6(12.0) cmH2O during spontaneous activity (P < 0.001). In conclusion,
electrical stimulation via intramural electrodes produced contraction generating
sufficient intraluminal pressure to effect evacuation of a canine colonic pouch.
This has potential for incorporation with an electrically stimulated neoanal
sphincter in total anorectal reconstruction to improve evacuation and continence
Hugonnet C.L., Danuser H.,
Springer J.P., and Studer U.E. (2001) Urethral sensitivity and the impact on
urinary continence in patients with an ileal bladder substitute after cystectomy.
J. Urol. 165, 1502-1505.
Abstract: PURPOSE: After cystectomy and ileal bladder substitution, sensitivity
in the membranous urethra correlates with postoperative urinary continence. We
determine whether sensitivity is decreased only in the most proximal part of the
urethra or also more distally in the bulbar urethra, which would give some
indication as to which nerves may be injured during radical cystoprostatectomy.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: The sensory threshold for electrical stimulation was
measured with double ring electrodes in the membranous urethra, and 2.5 cm.
distally to it in 41 men after cystectomy and ileal bladder substitution, and in
a control group of 29 men. RESULTS: The mean sensory threshold plus or minus
standard deviation of the membranous urethra was 9 +/- 2 mA. in the control
group compared to 26 +/- 11 mA. in the postoperative group (p <0.001). Mean
sensory threshold 2.5 cm. distal to the membranous urethra was 8 +/- 3 versus 9
+/- 3 mA. in the control and postoperative groups, respectively (not
significant). Patients with daytime continence had a mean threshold of 22 +/- 8
mA. in the membranous urethra compared to 38 +/- 11 mA. in those who were
incontinent (p <0.004) and a threshold of 8 +/- 3 mA. 2.5 cm. distal to the
membranous urethra compared to 8 +/- 2 mA. in those who were incontinent (not
significant). CONCLUSIONS: After cystectomy and ileal bladder substitution,
urethral sensitivity 2.5 cm. distal to the membranous urethra is unaffected by
surgery and does not correlate with postoperative continence. In contrast, a
decreased sensitivity in the membranous urethra correlates with an increased
risk of postoperative incontinence. Preservation of sensitivity in the
membranous urethra seems to be an important factor for achieving continence
after cystectomy and ileal bladder substitution, and does not seem to be
dependent on the extrapelvic portion of the pudendal nerve
Ince L.P., Brucker B.S., and
Alba A. (1978) Conditioned responding of the neurogenic bladder. Psychosom. Med.
40, 14-24.
Abstract: Classical conditioning techniques were employed to condition
responding of the spastic neurogenic bladder in a man with quadriparesis and
urinary incontinence secondary to spinal cord injury at the cervical level. A
neutral stimulus of mild electrical stimulation to the thigh was paired
temporally with an unconditioned stimulus (UCS) of stronger electrical
stimulation of the lower abdomen, and then was presented alone as a conditioned
stimulus (CS) to elicit the conditioned response (CR) of voiding. The previously
neutral CS reliably elicited large amounts of urine and left little residual
urine in the subject's bladder. Following the experimental sessions, the subject
self-applied the CS on a predetermined schedule during his daily routine outside
of the laboratory. The CS initially was successful, but after several days the
CR exhibited extinction. Additional CS-UCS pairing sessions did not reinstate
the responses satisfactorily. Aspects of the experimental procedure and the
results are discussed as well as the feasibility of conditioning the human
spinal cord in the absence of an intact central nervous system
Indrekvam S., Fosse O.A., and
Hunskaar S. (2001) A Norwegian national cohort of 3198 women treated with
home-managed electrical stimulation for urinary incontinence--demography and
medical history. Scand. J. Urol. Nephrol. 35, 26-31.
Abstract: OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to describe the demography,
medical history and clinical characteristics of women treated with home- managed
electrical stimulation in Norway. MATERIAL AND METHODS: This prospective cohort
study investigated all 3198 women treated with home- managed electrical
stimulation in Norway from 1992 to 1994. Data were collected from both patients
and physicians by questionnaires before and after treatment. RESULTS: Mean age
was 53 years. According to the physicians, 43, 15, 37 and 5% of the patients had
stress, urge, mixed incontinence and other diagnoses, respectively. Fifty-five
per cent of the women had had symptoms for 5 years or more, 62% had urinary loss
every day/night, and 59% of the patients were classified as having severe or
very severe incontinence according to a validated severity index. Fifty-two per
cent of the women used a long-term stimulator and 48% a maximal stimulator. Of
645 physicians who requested stimulators, 65% worked in general practice; 70% of
the stimulators were requested by physicians working in hospital or specialists
in private practice. Gynaecologists requested 53% of the stimulators.
CONCLUSIONS: The Norwegian reimbursement system can be said to be a numeric
success. Electrical stimulation is a treatment option for everyday use in
Norway. This complete national cohort of 3198 women treated with home- managed
electrical stimulation for urinary incontinence was biased towards younger
patients and more severe incontinence
Indrekvam S., Sandvik H., and
Hunskaar S. (2001) A Norwegian national cohort of 3198 women treated with
home-managed electrical stimulation for urinary incontinence--effectiveness and
treatment results. Scand. J. Urol. Nephrol. 35, 32-39.
Abstract: OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to analyse the effectiveness of
home-managed electrical stimulation. MATERIAL AND METHODS: A prospective cohort
study was conducted on all 3198 women treated with home-managed electrical
stimulation in Norway during 1992-1994. Data were collected from both patients
and physicians by questionnaires before and after treatment. RESULTS: 29% of the
women were cured or much improved according to their own assessment; altogether
61% were improved. According to the physicians' assessment, 33% were cured or
much improved; a total of 55% was improved. Thirty-seven per cent of compliers
and 12% of non-compliers regarded themselves as cured or much improved. The
number of incontinence episodes, amount of leakage and use of pads decreased
significantly; and 44% had less severe incontinence than before treatment
according to a validated severity index. CONCLUSIONS: Women treated with
electrical stimulation for urinary incontinence experienced a significant
reduction in incontinence problems, both subjectively and semi-objectively. The
treatment results seem to be strongly dependent on good acceptance of the
treatment
Ishigooka M., Ishii N.,
Hashimoto T., Suzuki Y., Adachi M., Nakada T., Saito C., Ichie M., and Handa Y.
(1992) Electrical stimulation of pelvic floor musculature by percutaneous
implantable electrodes: a case report. Int. Urol. Nephrol. 24, 277-282.
Abstract: A forty-year-old man with reflex urinary incontinence due to spinal
cord injury was treated with electrical stimulation of the pelvic floor
musculature. In this case we employed percutaneous implantable electrodes and an
external pulse regulator. After 4 weeks of stimulation incontinence was improved
and urodynamically maximum cystometric capacity increased from 220 ml to 350 ml.
Our method is easy and not invasive. This technique can be an alternative for
the electrical stimulation for urinary incontinence
Ishigooka M., Hashimoto T.,
Izumiya K., Katoh T., Yaguchi H., Nakada T., Handa Y., and Hoshimiya N. (1993)
Electrical pelvic floor stimulation in the management of urinary incontinence
due to neuropathic overactive bladder. Front Med. Biol. Eng 5, 1-10.
Abstract: Electrical pelvic floor stimulation employing a portable functional
electrical stimulation system with percutaneously indwelling electrodes was
carried out to improve detrusor urinary incontinence. Cyclic stimulation using
negative going pulse trains of 20 Hz was applied 3 to 6 times daily to the
bilateral pudendal nerves distributing to the pelvic floor muscles for the
purpose of strengthening these muscles, including the urethral sphincter, and
simultaneously, suppressing detrusor overactivity and increasing cystometric
capacity. Electrical training for 4-8 weeks resulted in an improvement of
urinary incontinence in five of six patients. In two of six cases incontinence
had subjectively disappeared. Urodynamic investigations demonstrated an increase
in detrusor reflex threshold and less tendency for abortive detrusor
contraction. No apparent complications were encountered during these periods.
This procedure appears to be efficient for the management of patients with
detrusor incontinence who respond poorly to conservative therapies
Ishigooka M., Hashimoto T.,
Sasagawa I., Nakada T., and Handa Y. (1993) Technique of percutaneous electrode
implantation for electrical pelvic floor stimulation. Eur. Urol. 23, 413-416.
Abstract: A modified technique of electrical pelvic floor stimulation is
described in detail. Six patients suffering from detrusor urinary incontinence
underwent percutaneous electrode implantation for electrical pelvic floor
stimulation. By this procedure adequate muscle contraction was obtained with a
significant rise in urethral closure pressure. Detrusor reflex thresholds were
increased in 5 of 6 patients at the initial stimulation. Percutaneous
implantation appears to be an easy and noninvasive technique. This method
provides stable and adequate effects on the pelvic floor structure and may be
used in chronic electrical stimulation
Ishigooka M., Hashimoto T.,
Sasagawa I., Nakada T., and Handa Y. (1994) Electrical pelvic floor stimulation
by percutaneous implantable electrode. Br. J. Urol. 74, 191-194.
Abstract: OBJECTIVE: To describe a clinical experience of chronic pelvic floor
stimulation using a percutaneous implantable electrode for the treatment of
urinary incontinence. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Pelvic floor stimulation using a
percutaneous procedure was performed in 10 patients who were suffering from
urinary incontinence due to overactive detrusor function. After implantation of
the electrode chronic stimulation was instituted with a portable external
electrical stimulator. RESULTS: Four to 16 weeks of maximal electrical
stimulation improved urinary incontinence in eight of 10 patients. In two of
these eight patients incontinence disappeared as measured subjectively.
Urodynamic investigations demonstrated a significantly increased volume at the
first unstable contraction (P < 0.01) in all patients. One of 30 electrodes
migrated during the follow-up period. CONCLUSION: Inhibition of detrusor
overactivity was obtained using this procedure. Response appeared to be constant
during chronic stimulation. This procedure appears to provide stable and
reliable stimulation for chronic treatment of urinary incontinence and may be an
alternative to electrical pelvic floor stimulation
Ishigooka M., Hashimoto T.,
Hayami S., Suzuki Y., Nakada T., and Handa Y. (1996) Electrical pelvic floor
stimulation: a possible alternative treatment for reflex urinary incontinence in
patients with spinal cord injury. Spinal Cord. 34, 411-415.
Abstract: The present study demonstrates the clinical experience of pelvic floor
stimulation using percutaneous implantable electrodes and implantable electrical
stimulator for the treatment of reflex urinary incontinence in patients with
spinal cord injury. Pelvic floor stimulation was carried out on six paraplegic
patients who had urinary incontinence from an overactive bladder. After the
percutaneous implantation of a pair of electrodes, chronic stimulation was
carried out by employing an implanted receiver or an external pulse regulator.
Within 4 to 16 weeks of electrical stimulation urinary incontinence was improved
in four of the six patients. In two of these six patients, incontinence was
completely abolished subjectively. Urodynamic investigations demonstrated an
increased volume at the first unstable contraction (P < 0.01) in all of the
patients. Inhibition of detrusor overactivity was obtained from this procedure.
The stimulation effect appeared to be constant during chronic stimulation. This
new procedure probably provides a stable and reliable stimulation effect for
long term treatment, and may be an alternative treatment for previous external
electrical pelvic floor stimulation
Ishii T., Takamura C., Esa A.,
Park Y.C., Mitsubayashi S., Kaneko S., and Kurita T. (1989) [A study of urinary
incontinence after prostatectomy]. Nippon Hinyokika Gakkai Zasshi 80, 1474-1480.
Abstract: With respect to prostatectomies carried out in clinic since the
opening of the Kinki University Hospital in 1975, incontinence after
prostatectomy was investigated with 470 patients as subjects for whom a
follow-up study after the operation was possible. Also, the usefulness of the
urodynamic tests for diagnosing underlying diseases was investigated. 1) Overall
incidence of incontinence after transurethral resection of the prostate (TUR-P),
retropubic prostatectomy (RPP) and cryoprostatectomy was 5.7 percent. 2) The
incidence of incontinence was 7.1 percent of the patients with TUR-P and 3.5
percent of patients with RPP. The incidence of incontinence after
cryoprostatectomy was none. 3) There was no clear differences among the
incidence of incontinence after prostatectomy and the weight of resected
tissues. 4) There was no clear differences among various types of incontinence
after each procedures of prostatectomies. 5) The incontinence was satisfactorily
treated and disappeared in 18 patients within one year after the operation. In
patients who failed to get continence within a year, the incontinence was likely
to persist furthermore. 6) The cure rate was low in patients with abnormal
findings in a cystometrogram performed prior to the operation. Associated
diseases which could cause disorders in nervous system were frequently
encountered in such patients. 7) Drugs and functional electrical stimulation (FES)
were introduced for the treatment of incontinence after prostatectomy. FES was
effective in 36.4 percent in which drug therapy was not effective. Since
multiple drug regimen was administered in most of the patients, it was difficult
to make a precise evaluation of judgement for effect of each of drugs
Jabs C.F. and Stanton S.L.
(2001) Urge incontinence and detrusor instability. Int. Urogynecol. J. Pelvic.
Floor. Dysfunct. 12, 58-68.
Abstract: Detrusor instability is a syndrome of urinary frequency, urgency and
urge incontinence which can be demonstrated using urodynamic studies to document
uninhibited bladder contractions. Idiopathic cases account for 90% and 10% are
related to neurologic disorders. Several different treatment modalities are
available, including bladder training/drill, electrical stimulation, medical and
surgical therapies
James E.D. (1968) Equipment and
methods involved in the treatment of urinary incontinence by electrical
stimulation. Med. Biol. Eng 6, 595-602.
Janez J., Plevnik S., and Suhel
P. (1979) Urethral and bladder responses to anal electrical stimulation. J. Urol.
122, 192-194.
Abstract: Urethral and bladder responses to anal electrical stimulation were
evaluated by cystometry and urethral pressure profile measurements in 55
patients with different urethral-bladder dysfunctions. In 50 per cent of the
patients examined the electrical stimulation caused normal reciprocal response,
that is bladder inhibition with urethral contraction. In other patients the
electrical stimulation caused almost all other possible bladder and urethral
responses
Janez J., Plevnik S., and
Vrtacnik P. (1981) Maximal electrical stimulation for female urinary
incontinence. Prog. Clin. Biol. Res. 78, 369-372.
Janknegt R.A., Baeten C.G.,
Weil E.H., and Spaans F. (1992) Electrically stimulated gracilis sphincter for
treatment of bladder sphincter incontinence. Lancet 340, 1129-1130.
Abstract: Correction of total urinary incontinence due to sphincter damage is
done with an artificial sphincter prosthesis or urinary diversion. In this pilot
study we used graciloplasty around the bladder neck followed by electrical
stimulation of this muscle with an implanted stimulator, which could be switched
off and on by a magnet. Stimulus variables could be changed externally. With the
stimulator on, urethral pressures of about 50 cm H2O were obtained. Of three
patients who underwent the procedure, two became continent and one improved but
remained incontinent. Dynamic graciloplasty can restore urinary incontinence
Janknegt R.A., Weil E.H., and
Eerdmans P.H. (1997) Improving neuromodulation technique for refractory voiding
dysfunctions: two-stage implant. Urology 49, 358-362.
Abstract: OBJECTIVES: Neuromodulation is a new technique that uses electrical
stimulation of the sacral nerves for patients with refractory urinary
urge/frequency or urge-incontinence, and some forms of urinary retention. The
limiting factor for receiving an implant is often a failure of the percutaneous
nerve evaluation (PNE) test. Present publications mention only about a 50%
success score for PNE of all patients, although the micturition diaries and
urodynamic parameters are similar. We wanted to investigate whether PNE results
improved by using a permanent electrode as a PNE test. This would show that
improvement of the PNE technique is feasible. METHODS: In 10 patients where the
original PNE had failed to improve the micturition diary parameters more than
50%, a permanent electrode was implanted by operation. It was connected to an
external stimulator. In those cases where the patients improved according to
their micturition diary by more than 50% during a period of 4 days, the external
stimulator was replaced by a permanent subcutaneous neurostimulator. RESULTS:
Eight of the 10 patients had a good to very good result (60% to 90% improvement)
during the testing period and received their implant 5 to 14 days after the
first stage. CONCLUSIONS: The good results of the two-stage implant technique we
used indicate that the development of better PNE electrodes may lead to an
improvement of the testing technique and better selection between nonresponders
and technical failures
Jeyaseelan S.M., Haslam E.J.,
Winstanley J., Roe B.H., and Oldham J.A. (2000) An evaluation of a new pattern
of electrical stimulation as a treatment for urinary stress incontinence: a
randomized, double-blind, controlled trial. Clin. Rehabil. 14, 631-640.
Abstract: OBJECTIVE: To evaluate a new pattern of electrical of electrical
stimulation as a treatment for stress incontinence. DESIGN: A randomized,
double-blind, controlled trial. SETTING: The study took place on three clinical
sites. SUBJECTS: Patients (n = 27) with urodynamically proven stress
incontinence recruited via consultant referral. INTERVENTIONS: Patients were
randomly allocated to one of two groups: the new pattern of stimulation or sham
stimulation. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Patients were assessed pre, mid and post
treatment using: perineometry, digital assessment and pad testing. The following
were only used pre and post treatment: seven-day frequency/volume chart, SF-36,
the Incontinence Impact Questionnaire and the Urogenital Distress Inventory.
RESULTS: No significant between-group differences were highlighted except when
quality of life was assessed with the Urogenital Distress Inventory (p = 0.01).
A significant reduction in scores was observed in the stimulation group (p =
0.03) However, improvements were seen in both the strength and endurance
characteristics of the pelvic floor musculature, although these changes were not
translated into a reduction in symptoms. CONCLUSION: Although promising, the
improvement in pelvic floor function did not result in a reduction in symptoms
in all patients. Further research is required to investigate the effects of the
new stimulation in combination with pelvic floor exercises and to compare the
new stimulation pattern with existing forms of electrical stimulation
Jeyaseelan S.M. and Oldham J.A.
(2000) Electrical stimulation as a treatment for stress incontinence. Br. J.
Nurs. 9, 1001-1007.
Abstract: Much research has been conducted into the use of electrical
stimulation to restore function in weak/atrophied muscle and it is used widely
in the field of muscle rehabilitation. As stress incontinence is a condition
which is the result of pelvic floor muscle weakness, it is thought that the
symptoms of this condition may be alleviated once the strength and endurance
characteristics of this muscle group have been improved. Many studies have been
conducted to evaluate the efficacy of various types of electrical stimulation,
although definitive conclusions have yet to be drawn. Current forms of
electrical stimulation for stress incontinence involve the use of uniform
frequencies. In animal studies this type of stimulation has been shown to have
drawbacks that are unacceptable when trying to rehabilitate muscle.
Consequently, there is a need to develop more physiological patterns of
stimulation that will enhance both strength and endurance characteristics
without causing premature fatigue
Jiang C.H. and Lindstrom S.
(1998) Prolonged increase in micturition threshold volume by anogenital afferent
stimulation in the rat. Br. J. Urol. 82, 398-403.
Abstract: OBJECTIVE: To investigate whether anogenital afferent stimulation
induces a prolonged increase in the micturition threshold volume of
anaesthetized rats. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Thirteen female rats, anaesthetized
by alpha-chloralose and paralysed by pancuronium bromide were used for the
experiments. The micturition threshold volume was determined by repeated
cystometry. In two experiments, afferent activity was recorded from the exposed
pudendal nerve; vaginal and anal afferents were stimulated electrically by ring
electrodes. In one experiment, the dorsal clitoris nerves were exposed
bilaterally and mounted for electrical stimulation. The afferents were
stimulated continuously for 5 min at 10 Hz, using unipolar cathodic pulses of
0.5 ms duration with an amplitude of 10 mA (or 0.8 mA for the dorsal clitoral
nerves). RESULTS: Anogenital stimulation for 5 min induced a significant and
prolonged increase in the micturition threshold volume (from a median value of
0.35 mL before to 0.45 mL after stimulation; P < 0.01). The increase in
threshold volume was maintained for about 40 min after the end of stimulation.
There was no obvious difference in effect between the stimulation sites nor with
direct dorsal clitoral nerve stimulation. Neither the micturition threshold
pressure nor the maximal contraction pressure were altered by stimulation. No
tonic afferent after-discharge could be detected in the pudendal nerve
recordings. CONCLUSIONS: Artificial electrical stimulation of anogenital
afferents induced a prolonged increase in the micturition threshold volume of
anaesthetized rats. The change presumably involved the modulation of the
synaptic transmission in the central micturition reflex pathway. It is proposed
that the observed change represents the first step in the curative
're-education' process induced in patients with urge incontinence by electrical
stimulation of anovaginal afferents
Jonasson A., Larsson B.,
Pschera H., and Nylund L. (1990) Short-term maximal electrical stimulation--a
conservative treatment of urinary incontinence. Gynecol. Obstet. Invest 30,
120-123.
Abstract: Seventeen women with stress and 20 with motor-urge urinary
incontinence were treated ambulatorily with short-term maximal electrical
stimulation. The duration of the treatment was 20 min daily for 12 weeks.
According to the patients' subjective evaluation, two thirds were improved. A
markedly diminished leakage of urine (greater than 50% by use of pad test) was
found in 6 out of 17 women with stress, and in 13 out of 20 women with
motor-urge urinary incontinence. There were no significant differences observed
in urodynamic parameters between the registrations performed before and after
the present electrical stimulation therapy
Kaiho Y., Namima T., Uchi K.,
Nakagawa H., Aizawa M., and Orikasa S. (1999) [Electromyographic study of the
striated urethral sphincter by using the bulbocavernosus reflex: study of the
normal voluntary voiding and the involuntary sphincter relaxation]. Nippon
Hinyokika Gakkai Zasshi 90, 893-900.
Abstract: PURPOSE: The aim of this study was to investigate the sacral reflex
activity at the striated urethral sphincter relaxation by evoking the potential
of the bulbocavernosus reflex (BCR). METHODS: 17 normal male subjects were
investigated. BCR was elicited by electrical stimulation of dorsal nerve of the
penis, and the evoked potential of the BCR (BCR- EP) was recorded by a
concentric needle electrode at the periurethral striated muscle. In normal
subjects BCR was performed at rest and during voluntary voiding. In 8 of the
normal subjects electrical stimulation was increased gradually during voluntary
voiding, and changes of BCR-EP were studied. 3 male patients with neurogenic
bladder suffering from urinary incontinence caused by involuntary sphincter
relaxation (IVSR) were also investigated. In these patients with neurogenic
bladder, BCR was performed at rest and during voluntary voiding as well as
during involuntary voiding. RESULTS: In the normal subjects stable BCR-EP was
elicited at rest and disappeared during voluntary voiding. But a gradually
increased larger stimulation clearly demonstrated BCR-EP during voluntary
voiding. In 3 patients with neurogenic bladder, stable ECR-EP was elicited at
rest. During involuntary voiding caused by IVSR obvious BCR-EP was also
elicited, but its amplitude was slightly less than the amplitude of BCR-EP at
rest. During voluntary voiding in 2 of the 3 patients BCR-EP was recognized but
the amplitude was much less, and in the third patient BCR-EP could not be
recognized. CONCLUSION: BCR-EP was suppressed during voluntary voiding in normal
subjects, but insufficiently suppressed in the patients with neurogenic bladder.
In these patients BCR-EP during voluntary voiding was suppressed more distinctly
than BCR- EP during involuntary voiding due to IVSR. In urodynamic study, the
detrusor contraction and the sphincter relaxation were common phenomenon in both
voluntary voiding and involuntary voiding, but the difference in the degree of
the BCR suppression depended on whether micturition was voluntary or
involuntary. It was suggested that the measurement of BCR-EP could distinguish
involuntary voiding caused by pathological urethral sphincter relaxation from
voluntary voiding
Kamm M.A. (1998) Diagnostic,
pharmacological, surgical and behavioural developments in benign anorectal
disease. Eur. J. Surg. Suppl 119-123.
Abstract: The investigation of benign anorectal disease has been transformed by
new techniques of imaging such as anal endosonography and magnetic resonance
imaging. This has led to more specific surgical treatments when structural
damage is identified. It has also led to the identification of newly recognised
pathologies, such as primary internal sphincter degeneration which causes
passive faecal incontinence. A variety of new treatment modalities is also
emerging. Pharmacological therapies are assuming great importance in relation to
anal disease, with topical glyceryl trinitrate now the first treatment of choice
for chronic anal fissure. For patients with intractable constipation behavioural
techniques to modify pelvic floor and intestinal function are now the mainstay
of therapy. New approaches to the surgical therapy of incontinence include the
use of an artificial bowel sphincter, and the electrical stimulation of sacral
nerves to modify pelvic floor function
Keating J.C., Jr., Schulte
E.A., and Miller E. (1988) Conservative care of urinary incontinence in the
elderly. J. Manipulative Physiol Ther. 11, 300-308.
Abstract: Urinary incontinence is a common, costly and demoralizing problem
among the elderly. Remedial efforts are often not attempted owing to the
misconception that incontinence is an inevitable and irreversible characteristic
of aging. In fact, a variety of relatively conservative methods of reducing
geriatric incontinence are available. This paper reviews the categories of
incontinence, outlines assessment strategies and critiques the literature on
biofeedback, exercise, behavior therapy and electrical stimulation as treatments
for geriatric incontinence, and briefly considers a role for the chiropractic
physician
Kennedy M.L., Nguyen H.,
Lubowski D.Z., and King D.W. (1996) Stimulated gracilis neosphincter: a new
procedure for anal incontinence. Aust. N. Z. J. Surg. 66, 353-357.
Abstract: BACKGROUND: The gracilis muscle has been used previously to construct
an anal neosphincter, but this was not successful since a short-lived muscle
contraction was insufficient to restore continence. Recently, a procedure was
described in which conversion to a fatigue-resistant muscle was achieved by
chronic low frequency electrical stimulation, and the resultant ability to
sustain a constant contraction was associated with improved continence. Our
initial results with this procedure, using a standardized operation and
treatment protocol in 12 consecutive patients, is reported. METHODS: Seven women
(mean age 50 years, range 22-71 years) had faecal incontinence, and five
patients (F:M, 3:2; aged 53-72 years) underwent reconstruction after
abdominoperineal excision of the rectum for cancer. A detailed questionnaire
including continence score was completed pre-operatively. Eight patients have
been assessed after ileostomy closure at a mean time of 10 months. RESULTS:
Slow-twitch muscle conversion was achieved in each case and all patients have a
functional neosphincter. Mean continence score was 6.8 (range 4-12), and seven
patients were continent. There was significant improvement in continence in the
non- cancer group (p = 0.03). Mean pre-operative resting anal pressure,
functional neosphincter pressure (NPfunc), and maximal neosphincter pressure
(NP(max)) were 36, 102 and 207 cmH2O, respectively. There was a significant
improvement in pressure comparing NPfunc (P = 0.03) and NP(max) (P = 0.03) with
pre-operative pressure. Complications included deep vein thrombosis, pulmonary
embolism, saphenous nerve injury, leg wound haematoma, and late pacemaker
infection. CONCLUSION: The stimulated gracilis neosphincter achieves
satisfactory continence in a majority of patients
Kerrigan D.D., Lucas M.G., Sun
W.M., Donnelly T.C., and Read N.W. (1989) Idiopathic constipation associated
with impaired urethrovesical and sacral reflex function. Br. J. Surg. 76,
748-751.
Abstract: Sixteen chronically constipated women (age range 20-66 years) and 29
healthy control subjects (age range 22-53 years) underwent neurophysiological
assessment of the integrity of pelvic spinal reflexes. The results were compared
with videourodynamic studies and multiport anorectal manometry combined with
external anal sphincter electromyography. The neurophysiological assessment
consisted of electrical stimulation of the dorsogenital nerve, while recording
any evoked reflex activity in the external anal and urethral sphincters with
concentric needle and surface electrodes. Of these constipated women, 75 per
cent had absence of one or more evoked sacral reflexes (compared with 20 per
cent of healthy controls, P less than 0.05). Sensory thresholds and motor unit
potentials in the external anal sphincter were similar in healthy and
constipated women. Nine (56 per cent) constipated women displayed urodynamic
abnormalities (increased bladder capacity, acontractile bladder and genuine
stress incontinence). Only 38 per cent of constipated women perceived a desire
to defaecate during rectal distension with up to 100 ml, compared with 95 per
cent of normal subjects (P less than 0.0005). Moreover, 73 per cent of
constipated women did not relax the external anal sphincter during defaecation,
compared with 12 per cent of controls (P = 0.001). Taking into account the
possible significance of our data in relation to previous findings it is
suggested that the integration of sensory information within the sacral cord may
be impaired in chronic idiopathic constipation
Kirsch S.E., Shandling B.,
Watson S.L., Gilmour R.F., and Pape K.E. (1993) Continence following electrical
stimulation and EMG biofeedback in a teenager with imperforate anus. J. Pediatr.
Surg. 28, 1408-1409.
Abstract: A teenage boy with repaired high imperforate anus relied on daily
enemas for social continence. After treatment with low intensity transcutaneous
electrical stimulation and electromyographic biofeedback home programs, he
achieved improved fecal continence requiring only one enema per month
Konsten J., Baeten C.G.,
Havenith M.G., and Soeters P.B. (1993) Morphology of dynamic graciloplasty
compared with the anal sphincter. Dis. Colon Rectum 36, 559-563.
Abstract: Dynamic graciloplasty for fecal incontinence includes gracilis muscle
transposition around the anal canal as a new sphincter and subsequent electrical
stimulation. The aim of electrical stimulation is to transform the gracilis
fast-twitch, "fatigue-prone" fibers into slow- twitch, "fatigue-resistant"
fibers to achieve a sustained tonic contraction. The latter is considered
essential for sphincter function. Therefore, the following features of
transposed gracilis muscle morphology were studied in nine patients before and
after electrical stimulation: 1) the percentage of Type I fibers, 2) the lesser
diameter of these fibers, and 3) the positive collagen staining area.
Furthermore, the external and sphincter and gracilis muscle histology was
investigated in six autopsy cases. The mean percentage of Type I, slow-twitch,
fatigue-resistant fibers in transposed gracilis muscle increased from 46 percent
before electrical stimulation to 64 percent (P < 0.01, paired Student's t-test)
after electrical stimulation. The mean lesser diameter of these fibers did not
change significantly (from 32 to 29 microns), and the mean percentage of
collagen increased from 4 percent before electrical stimulation to 7 percent (P
< 0.01) afterward. The external sphincter in cadavers demonstrated a
predominance of Type I fibers (80 percent) with a lesser diameter of 23 microns
and a high percentage (12 percent) of collagen. Gracilis muscle histology was
uniform at six different sample sites in these cadaver dissections. We conclude
that electrical stimulation induces histologic changes in transposed gracilis
muscle, allowing this muscle to function as an external anal sphincter
Konsten J., Baeten C.G.,
Havenith M.G., and Oei T.K. (1993) Evaluation of gracilis muscle transposition
for fecal incontinence with magnetic resonance imaging. Eur. J. Radiol. 16,
190-194.
Abstract: Ten consecutive patients with incapacitating fecal incontinence were
treated with 'anal dynamic graciloplasty' (transposition of the gracilis muscle
around the anal canal and implantation of intramuscular electrodes connected
with an implanted pulse generator, 6 weeks later) to achieve continence. We
measured the gracilis muscle diameter immediately after transposition and before
implantation of the stimulation device. It was found that gracilis diameter
decreased from 12 (5 days after transposition) to 8 mm, 6 weeks later (mean
decrease: 4 mm (95% confidence interval 3.6), n = 10, P ` 0.05). In addition,
morphology demonstrated a decrease of both Type I and Type II muscle fiber
diameter and an increase in endomysial collagen. Despite this decrease in muscle
(and muscle fiber) diameter, electrical stimulation of the transposed gracilis
muscle increased the pressure into the anal canal from 37 to 55 mmHg (mean
increase: 17 mmHg (95% confidence interval 6.29), P < 0.05). Fecal continence
was achieved in seven (70%) of these patients. Further analysis revealed no
correlations between reduction of the gracilis muscle diameter before
implantation of the stimulation device and clinical outcome in terms of achieved
continence and/or anal canal pressures. MRI is an excellent method to
demonstrate the shape of gracilis muscle after transposition. However, the size
of transposed gracilis muscle is not associated with the functional outcome
Konsten J., Baeten C.G., Spaans
F., Havenith M.G., and Soeters P.B. (1993) Follow-up of anal dynamic
graciloplasty for fecal continence. World J. Surg. 17, 404-408.
Abstract: The feasibility of anal dynamic graciloplasty (transposition of the
gracilis muscle and subsequent implantation of a stimulation device) to restore
continence, was assessed in a case-control study of 26 patients with severe
fecal incontinence. It was shown that anal dynamic graciloplasty is capable of
achieving the sphincter tone of healthy persons, as stimulated graciloplasty
increased anal pressure from 46 mmHg without stimulation to 65 mmHg with
stimulation (mean increase 19 mmHg; 95% confidence interval 13, 25; n = 25; p <
0.01). Time to retain a 250-ml phosphate enema increased from 52 seconds before
to 204 seconds after 8 weeks of electrical stimulation (mean increase 151
seconds; 95% confidence interval 61, 241; n = 25; p < 0.01). Complete fecal
continence was achieved in 17 patients (65%); two of these patients developed a
wound infection, but one of the two realized continence without stimulation and
the other patient became continent after reimplantation. Three other patients
improved after anal dynamic graciloplasty, but infection necessitated removal of
the stimulation device. One patient developed a fistula. Failures were
encountered in five patients. Although our long-term follow-up results suggest a
learning curve, it is concluded that electrical stimulation improves the results
of conventional graciloplasty and avoids construction of a colostomy
Konsten J., Baeten C.G.,
Havenith M.G., and Soeters P.B. (1994) Canine model for treatment of faecal
incontinence using transposed and electrically stimulated sartorius muscle. Br.
J. Surg. 81, 466-469.
Abstract: A neosphincter was successfully created around each end of a Thiry-
Vella loop in five dogs using transposed sartorius muscle to study new
treatments for faecal incontinence. One of these dynamic neosphincters in each
dog was electrically trained for 8 weeks while the other served as a control.
Muscle biopsies demonstrated an increase in type 1 fatigue-resistant fibres from
a median of 49 (range 37-54) per cent before electrical stimulation to 78 (range
53-99) per cent 8 weeks later in the stimulated sartorius neosphincters (P <
0.05), whereas the percentage of type 1 fibres in control neosphincters
increased only slightly. Retention times of saline increased from a median of 10
(range 5-50)s before to 340 (range 100-470)s after electrical stimulation (P <
0.05) but also increased in control neosphincters (to 370 (range 330-1200)s);
this may indicate that electrical stimulation immediately increases acute
retention times. It is concluded that construction of a neosphincter is
technically feasible with preservation of muscle morphology and that stimulation
induces morphological and functional changes towards the characteristics of the
external anal sphincter
Konsten J., Geerdes B., Baeten
C.G., Heineman E., Arends J.W., Pette D., and Soeters P.B. (1995) Dynamic
myoplasty in growing dogs as a feasibility study for treatment of fecal
incontinence. J. Pediatr. Surg. 30, 580-584.
Abstract: The feasibility of skeletal muscle transposition and electrical
stimulation (dynamic myoplasty) for treatment of fecal incontinence has been
shown in adults. It might be attractive to use such a technique in pediatric
patients. Therefore, the influence of growth on skeletal muscle transposition
and stimulation was studied in five puppies. In each dog, two neosphincters were
constructed around a Thiry-Vella loop by using a dissected sartorius muscle with
the neurovascular supply intact. In each of these five puppies, one of these
muscles was electrically stimulated during a mean of 19 weeks (one puppy died
during the first postoperative week). Muscle biopsies showed an increase in the
percentage type I, fatigue-resistant muscle fibers from 61 to 94 in electrically
stimulated sartorius neosphincters, but also an increase from 57 to 67 percent
in transposed nonstimulated sartorius muscles. The diameter of these type I
fibers during growth increased 36% in eletrically stimulated sartorius
neosphincters and 55% in nonstimulated sphincters. Function of the neosphincters
was tested with the inflow of saline in the Thiry-Vella loop. It was shown that
the stimulated neosphincters were capable of inhibiting flow (which corresponded
to manometric pressure registrations), but the nonstimulated sphincters were
unable to inhibit flow. The experiments were complicated by infection and
necrosis around the implanted stimulators in four puppies (which required
reimplantation). We conclude that a dynamic myoplasty for fecal incontinence is
feasible in growing puppies but that the technique is unacceptable during rapid
growth because of the risks of infection and dislocation of the implanted device
Kontani H., Nakagawa M., and
Sakai T. (1992) Effects of adrenergic agonists on an experimental urinary
incontinence model in anesthetized rabbits. Jpn. J. Pharmacol. 58, 339-346.
Abstract: We have developed an experimental urinary incontinence model in
anesthetized female rabbits, in order to study the effects of alpha- adrenergic
receptor agonists on it in vivo. Micturition was induced artificially by
electrical stimulation of the abdomen of rabbits receiving a continuous infusion
of glucose-free. Tyrode's solution into the urinary bladder. Alpha-1 adrenergic
agonists, phenylephrine (1 mg/kg, i.v.) and the newly synthesized agent ST-1059
(1 mg/kg, i.v.) and its prodrug midodrine (10 mg/kg), which was intraduodenally
administered, elevated the bladder pressure and arrested micturition induced by
electrical stimulation. Prazosin (0.1 mg/kg, i.v.) inhibited these effects of
phenylephrine. The effect of an alpha-2 agonist, clonidine (1 mg/kg, i.v.), on
micturition induced by electrical stimulation was not clearly defined. This
study demonstrates that alpha- 1 adrenergic agonists can arrest
artificially-induced micturition via urethral contraction. This method may be
useful for evaluating the effect of a drug on urethral leakage in vivo
Kontani H. and Hayashi K.
(1997) Urinary bladder response to hypogastric nerve stimulation after bilateral
resection of the pelvic nerve or spinal cord injury in rats. Int. J. Urol. 4,
394-400.
Abstract: BACKGROUND: We examined the mechanism of urinary bladder motility
return after bladder areflexia induced by interruption of the sacral
parasympathetic outflow to the urinary bladder following damage to the sacral
cord or pelvic nerves in the rat. METHODS: The L6 and S1 nerve bundles were
resected near the vertebrae, and bilateral pelvic nerve resections (PNR)
performed. Spinal cord injury (SCI) was performed by means of a legion generator
at the T12 vertebra. Thirty days after PNR and SCI, cystometrograms were
recorded under anesthesia. RESULTS: In all rats subjected to PNR or SCI,
overflow incontinence continued, yet some rats subjected to SCI recovered within
2 weeks after the operation. Cystometrograms showed that repetitive bladder
contractions appeared in rats subjected to SCI irrespective of hypogastric nerve
(HGN) innervation, while bladder contractions did not appear in rats subjected
to PNR. Electrical stimulation of the HGN induced higher bladder pressure
elevation in rats who underwent PNR than in rats subjected to SCI. CONCLUSIONS:
These results suggest that the generation of repetitive bladder contractions
induced by bladder distention after bladder areflexia requires the presence of
intact pelvic nerves that transmit sacral cord-originating excitatory
information to the bladder. However, the HGN system and functioning pelvic nerve
ganglia are not involved in this process. Also, the connection from the
preganglionic HGN to the postganglionic parasympathetic nerves in the pelvic
plexus did not form after PNR
Kralj B. (1982) [Selection of
patients in the treatment of urinary incontinence]. Jugosl. Ginekol. Opstet. 22,
1-3.
Abstract: Criteria for the selection of female patients with urinary
incontinence for treatment are described. The following procedures are
suggested: the patient's history, gynecological examination, urological
examination, urodynamic examinations (urethral pressure profile and cystometry),
and neurophysiological examinations (especially the electromyography of pelvic
floor muscles). For the treatment with functional electrical stimulation the
role of the trial application of stimulators is emphasized. The importance of an
accurate classification of incontinence is stressed. The results of treatment
depend mainly on the appropriate selection of patients
Kralj B. (1999) Conservative
treatment of female stress urinary incontinence with functional electrical
stimulation. Eur. J. Obstet. Gynecol. Reprod. Biol. 85, 53-56.
Abstract: BACKGROUND: Treatment of stress urinary incontinence with functional
electrical stimulation (FES) is a recent and efficient method of conservative
treatment. STUDY DESIGN: Before treatment, examinations determining the type of
urinary incontinence should be made: patient history, pelvic and urologic
examination, laboratory tests of urine, multi-channel urodynamic tests. The
degree of urinary incontinence is assessed by pad tests. Only the patients with
moderate stress urinary incontinence without or with a mild utero-vaginal
prolapse, are treated by FES. The parameters of stimulation: the impulse is
rectangular and biphasic, duration of impulse is 1 ms, frequency of impulse is
20 Hz, and intensity of current 35 mA. The chronic treatment with FES should be
applied 1.5-2 h daily for 3 months. This long-term treatment requires
appropriate motivation of the patient. RESULTS: Three months after terminated
treatment 56 of the total 111 patients (50.5%) were cured, in 26 (23.4%) the
condition improved, whereas in 29 patients (26.1%) the treatment failed.
CONCLUSIONS: The efficiency of treatment depends on the patient selection,
parameters of electrical stimulation, stimulator of the pelvic floor muscles,
mode of stimulation--chronic stimulation, and on motivation of the patient
Kulseng-Hanssen S.,
Kristoffersen M., and Larsen E. (1998) Evaluation of the subjective and
objective effect of maximal electrical stimulation in patients complaining of
urge incontinence. Acta Obstet. Gynecol. Scand. Suppl 168, 12-15.
Abstract: BACKGROUND: Favorable results have been reported following Maximal
Electrical Stimulation (MES) of patients with urgency and urge incontinence.
However, patient groups have often been mixed and outcome measures poorly
defined. We therefore wanted to treat a homogeneous patient population with MES
and evaluate the effect by defined subjective and objective outcome measures.
METHODS: Eighteen female patients complaining of urge incontinence had MES
performed. Before and 3 months after MES, the patients performed a 24 hour
micturition chart and pad test. They indicated on a visual analogue scale their
subjective degree of urgency and leakage and had an ambulatory urodynamic
monitoring performed. Nine months after MES the patients were asked whether
their urge incontinence was less, equal or more troublesome than before MES.
RESULTS: After MES the patients indicated significantly less urgency and
leakage. A significant difference was not found in any of the objective outcome
measures after MES. Six out of 18 patients (33%) found their urge incontinence
less troublesome 9 months after MES, while 12 (66%) found it unchanged or more
troublesome than before. CONCLUSIONS: Significantly subjective effect was found
following MES. However, none of the objective outcome measures were
significantly improved. We were disappointed by the results and have stopped
using the method
Lamhut P., Jackson T.W., and
Wall L.L. (1992) The treatment of urinary incontinence with electrical
stimulation in nursing home patients: a pilot study. J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 40,
48-52.
Abstract: OBJECTIVES: To test the effectiveness of electrical stimulation in the
treatment of urinary incontinence in female nursing home patients. SETTING: A
community long term care facility. PARTICIPANTS: Nine unselected female nursing
home patients with urinary incontinence. All patients were moderately to
severely cognitively impaired. By bedside cystometry, six patients had
involuntary detrusor contractions while two had inconclusive results.
INTERVENTION: Participants were treated with electrical stimulation for 8 weeks
using the Microgyn II device. A current with a frequency of 20 hertz and a pulse
width of 1 millisecond was delivered repeatedly for 2 seconds on, 4 seconds off
for 15 seconds twice a week. MEASUREMENTS: The number of every-2-hour wet
episodes during a 48-hour period (Wet) was recorded by a blinded observer at
baseline and after 4 and 8 weeks of treatment. We evaluated the overall effect
of electrical stimulation by averaging the Wet at 4 and 8 weeks for each patient
and comparing it to Wet at baseline. MAIN RESULTS: The mean +/- standard
deviation of intensity of electrical stimulation was 12 +/- 5 milliamps. Mean
Wet at baseline was 11.8 +/- 4.2. For all patients mean Wet increased by 2.3 +/-
3.2, P = 0.07. Analysis of patients with documented involuntary detrusor
contractions showed a mean increase in Wet of 2.6 +/- 3.6, P = 0.16. The volume
of fluid at which an involuntary contraction occurred during cystometry showed a
mean increase of 48.3 +/- 52.6 mL, P = 0.07 after 8 weeks of treatment.
CONCLUSIONS: Electrical stimulation is well tolerated in elderly nursing home
patients. However, it was ineffective in improving urinary incontinence. In
fact, there was a tendency for the treatment to worsen the incontinence
Lanmuller H., Bijak M., Mayr
W., Rafolt D., Sauermann S., and Thoma H. (1997) Useful applications and limits
of battery powered implants in functional electrical stimulations. Artif. Organs
21, 210-212.
Abstract: Battery powered stimulation implants have been well-known for a long
time as heart pacemakers. In the last few years, fully implantable stimulators
have been used in the field of functional electrical stimulation (FES) for
applications like dynamic cardiomyoplasty and electro-stimulated graciloplasty
for fecal incontinence. The error rate of battery powered implants is
significantly smaller than that for conventional stimulator systems, and the
quality of life for the patients is increased because the need for an external
power and control unit is eliminated. The use of battery powered implants is
limited by the complexity of the stimulation control strategies and the battery
capacity. Therefore, applications like the stimulation of lower extremities for
walking, cochlea stimulation, or direct muscle stimulation cannot be supported.
The improvement of implantable batteries, microcontrollers, and ultralow power
products is ongoing. In the future, battery powered implants will also meet the
requirements of complex applications. Systems for restoration of hand and
breathing functions after spinal cord injury can be the next field of use for
battery powered implants. For these purposes, we developed a battery powered
multichannel implant with a sufficient life span for phrenic pacing. The
problems during development and the limits of this system are described in this
paper
Lazareff J.A., Mata-Acosta
A.M., Garcia-Mendez M.A., and Escanero-Salazar A. (1990) [Selective limited
posterior rhizotomy at 3 dorsal levels. A variant for the neurosurgical
treatment of spasticity]. Bol. Med. Hosp. Infant Mex. 47, 72-77.
Abstract: INTRODUCTION. Selective posterior rhizotomy (SPR) is effective for
reducing spasticity associated to infantile cerebral palsy (ICP). To avoid
excessive muscular hypotone a different surgical technique is proposed. PATIENTS
AND METHODS. Sixteen children with spasticity secondary to ICP were evaluated
before and after rhizotomy. The degree of spasticity was compared in the lower
an in the upper limbs. Dorsal roots of levels L4, L5, and S1 were analyzed and
sectioned according to the results yielded by intraoperative electrical
stimulation. RESULTS. Spasticity was reduced in all the muscular groups
analyzed. One of the patients had bladder incontinence. CONCLUSIONS. The limited
surgical procedure is sufficient for reducing spasticity
Leroi A.M., Ducrotte P.,
Bouaniche M., Touchais J.Y., Weber J., and Denis P. (1997) Assessment of the
reliability of cerebral potentials evoked by electrical stimulation of the anal
canal. Int. J. Colorectal Dis. 12, 335-339.
Abstract: The aim of this study was to assess the reliability of cortical evoked
potentials after electrical stimulation of the anal canal. Cortical evoked
potentials were recorded on 243 patients presenting with perineal pain (28
patients), impotence (55 patients), anal incontinence (52 patients), urinary
continence (30 patients), constipation (49 patients), and on 29 neurological
patients, by stimulating the external anal sphincter and penis (or clitoris).
The i
Lewey J. and Lilas L. (1999)
Electrical stimulation of the overactive bladder. Prof. Nurse 15, 211-214.
Abstract: Bladder overactivity is a significant health-care problem. Electrical
stimulation has been shown to be a safe and effective treatment option. Careful
patient selection may improve results obtained with this technique. Further
studies are required to determine optimal treatment parameters
Lightner D.J. and Itano N.M.
(1999) Treatment options for women with stress urinary incontinence. Mayo Clin.
Proc. 74, 1149-1156.
Abstract: About one-quarter million surgical procedures are performed each year
in the United States for stress urinary incontinence. After outlining the
presentation and diagnostic evaluation of stress urinary incontinence, this
review concentrates specifically on the numerous conservative management
strategies and minimally invasive surgical options for women with this common
complaint. In the evaluation of nursing home residents with incontinence, the
Minimum Data Set and Resident Assessment Protocol facilitate nonspecialist
evaluation and management. In healthy adults, the therapeutic implications of
the physical examination of the pelvic floor, assessing for the presence and
strength of the voluntary contraction of the pelvic floor muscles, are detailed
as the basis for all conservative management strategies. Reports on the
effectiveness of pelvic floor muscle reeducation and pelvic floor electrical
stimulation vary substantially, as do long-term results of surgical
interventions. Surgical management is highly effective in the appropriate
candidate. The current theory and practice of surgical treatment of stress
urinary incontinence are outlined, with certain caveats regarding the lack of
long-term follow-up for newer less invasive techniques
Lindstrom S., Fall M., Carlsson
C.A., and Erlandson B.E. (1983) The neurophysiological basis of bladder
inhibition in response to intravaginal electrical stimulation. J. Urol. 129,
405-410.
Abstract: Intravaginal electrical stimulation (IVS) induces a profound bladder
inhibition and is successful in the treatment of incontinence due to detrusor
instability. In this experimental study in cats, direct recordings of the
efferent activity in thin hypogastric and pelvic nerve filaments to the bladder
were used to analyze the neuronal mechanisms underlying this bladder inhibition.
A longlasting reflex discharge, with a latency of 35 to 50 msec., was evoked in
the hypogastric nerve by IVS. The reflex discharge was unaffected by imposed
changes in intravesical pressure or by micturition contractions, but the
response was very frequency-sensitive with an optimal transmission at about 5 Hz
of stimulation. A "spontaneous" efferent activity could be recorded in the
pelvic nerve filaments when the bladder pressure was elevated above 5 to 7 cm.
H2O. The pelvic activity occurred in 10 to 20-second bursts, each followed by an
abortive detrusor contraction. IVS of 5 to 10 Hz completely abolished this
efferent pelvic activity by central inhibition. The findings are discussed in
relation to the normal neuronal control of the bladder and to the clinical
application of IVS
Lobe T.E. (1984) Fecal
continence following an anterior-sagittal ano-enteroplasty in a patient with
cloacal exstrophy. J. Pediatr. Surg. 19, 843-845.
Abstract: A two-year-old Latin American female was referred for treatment of
what appeared to be a straightforward case of cloacal exstrophy. At operation,
incision along the superior margin of the exstrophic bladder allowed
identification of an unusual variant of exstrophy which consisted of bladder
exstrophy; erminal colon duplication, the common medial wall of which protruded
8 cm beyond the end of the bowel lumen, and which exited ventrally and
immediately caudad to the exstrophic bladder; an enteric diverticulum at the
superior rim of the bladder; and two small vaginae, existing laterally on either
side, at the junction between the bladder and the terminal bowel. The terminal
bowel was mobilized, the duplications were excised, and a tapering enteroplasty
was performed. Despite a flat-appearing bottom, a posterior muscle complex was
identified which extended anterolaterally and attached to the pubis on either
side. Following observation of an appropriate response to electrical
stimulation, the muscle complex was partially divided in the midline, from
anterior to posterior, just enough to make room for the tapered bowel. The
muscle was then reapproximated in the midline anteriorly, surrounding the bowel,
and an anoplasty was constructed. The bladder was closed, and the pubic rami
were wired together (bilateral posterior iliac osteotomies were performed at the
beginning of the operation). One and 1/2 years following this procedure, the
child has a normal "rectal" exam with a palpable sphincter. She has 3 to 4 solid
bowel movements daily without soiling, and she awaits genitourinary
reconstruction
Luber K.M. and Wolde-Tsadik G.
(1997) Efficacy of functional electrical stimulation in treating genuine stress
incontinence: a randomized clinical trial. Neurourol. Urodyn. 16, 543-551.
Abstract: Our objective was to determine the efficacy of functional electrical
stimulation as a stand-alone therapy for female stress incontinence. The study
was conducted as a prospective, double-blind, randomized controlled trial using
subjective and objective outcome criteria. Patients enrolled in this study had
stress incontinence consistent with International Continence Society criteria.
Patients with significant pelvic prolapse or detrusor instability were excluded.
Patients underwent twice-daily treatment sessions for a total of 3 months.
Results were analyzed for confounding variables between the treatment and
control groups. Statistical analysis was performed utilizing Fisher's exact test
and the paired t-test. Of the 54 patients enrolled in this study, 44 completed
the program. The dropout rate was similar for both the treatment and control
groups. There was no statistically significant difference between the treatment
and control groups with regard to age, gravity, parity, previous
antiincontinence surgery, menopausal status, or previous hysterectomy. Objective
success for the treatment group was 15% and for the control group, 12.5% (NS).
The subjective success for the treatment group was 25% and for the control
group, 29% (NS). There was no relationship demonstrated between age, parity,
previous surgery, hysterectomy, or menopausal status and the successful
treatment of genuine stress incontinence with functional electrical stimulation.
In this patient population, functional electrical stimulation was no more
effective at improving or eliminating the symptoms of genuine stress
incontinence than was the daily retention of the control probe
Lundeberg T. (1996) Electrical
stimulation techniques. Lancet 348, 1672-1673.
Madersbacher H. (1978) [The
effect of transurethral electrical stimulation on the paralyzed and incontinent
bladder: objective results (author's transl)]. Urologe A 17, 355-357.
Abstract: Using objective parameters, improvement of the detrusor function and
bladder sensitivity can be obtained in most children. A significant improvement
in incontinence appears possible in 30--40% of the patients. The method
according to Katona is the only one which creates bladder sensitivity. This
method is not a cure all but has improved our therapeutic possibilities,
especially when it is combined with pharmacotherapy, long term low dose
antibiotic therapy and sphincterotomy
Malissard M., Souquet J., and
Jullien D. (1994) Optimisation of pulse duration for intravaginal electrical
stimulation: effect of tissue excitability. Med. Biol. Eng Comput. 32, 327-330.
Mander B.J., Abercrombie J.F.,
George B.D., and Williams N.S. (1996) The electrically stimulated gracilis
neosphincter incorporated as part of total anorectal reconstruction after
abdominoperineal excision of the rectum. Ann. Surg. 224, 702-709.
Abstract: OBJECTIVE: The authors investigated the feasibility and effectiveness
of combining electrically stimulated gracilis neoanal (ESGN) sphincter and a
coloperineal anastomosis in selected patients after abdominoperineal excision of
the rectum (APER). SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA: The ESGN is effective in the
treatment of idiopathic fecal incontinence. METHODS: Between March 1989 and
September 1993, 12 patients (9 men, 3 women) with a median age of 59.25 years
(range, 45- 70) underwent the procedure. The underlying disease was
adenocarcinoma in 10, anal malignant melanoma in 1, and a sweat gland tumor in
the other. In all patients, a sphincter saving resection was contraindicated.
The procedure was performed in stages. Stage 1 involved a conventional APER with
the formation of a perineal stoma. Eleven patients underwent a vascular delay
procedure. All patients were defunctioned. In stage 2, the gracilis was
mobilized, transposed around the anal canal, and the electrodes and hardware
needed for electrical stimulation were implanted. Once muscle conversion was
complete, the defunctioning stoma was closed. RESULTS: Eight patients were
closed successfully. In seven of the eight patients, complete physiologic
measurements were taken. Median basal and maximum neosphincter pressures were 30
and 122 cm H2O, respectively, at the start of electrical stimulation and 22.5
and 76.2 cm H2O, respectively, after 1 year. Median functioning neosphincter
pressure was 36 cm H2O at 1 year. All of the patients whose stomas were closed
experienced episodes of incontinence to solid stool and wore pads for persistent
fecal soiling. They all reported difficulty in evacuation. Despite imperfect
continence, no patient wished to go back to life with a stoma. CONCLUSIONS: The
incorporation of ESGN as part of total anorectal reconstruction is technically
feasible. The majority of patients are satisfied with their function and pleased
to avoid a permanent stoma
Mander B.J. and Williams N.S.
(1996) Electrical stimulation of sacral nerves for treatment of incontinence.
Lancet 347, 63-64.
Marshall D.F. and Boston V.E.
(1997) Altered bladder and bowel function following cutaneous electrical field
stimulation in children with spina bifida--interim results of a randomized
double-blind placebo-controlled trial. Eur. J. Pediatr. Surg. 7 Suppl 1, 41-43.
Abstract: Bladder and bowel dysfunction in spina bifida are the result of
abnormal electrical input, secondary to the neurological lesion of the spinal
cord. Experimental attempts to correct this deficit with invasive electrical
stimulation have demonstrated promising effects, as has a recent preliminary
study of transcutaneous electro-stimulation in children with myelomeningocoele.
A randomized controlled trial of non- invasive electrical stimulation in
children with neuropathic bladder and bowel has been established. Interim
results of 50 patients are presented. Treatment was performed at home for one
hour daily for a mean period of 45 days. The only statistically significant
difference between the active and placebo-groups was a 32% relative decrease in
night-time urinary incontinence, favoring the placebo group. However there were
non-significant trends of preferential improvement in the active group for the
relative increases in maximum and average bladder content and episodes of
spontaneous normal defecation. It is anticipated that a continued increase in
patient numbers will overcome the large placebo effect observed and yield more
significant results
Mathers S.E., Ingram D.A., and
Swash M. (1990) Electrophysiology of motor pathways for sphincter control in
multiple sclerosis. J. Neurol. Neurosurg. Psychiatry 53, 955-960.
Abstract: The central and peripheral motor pathways serving striated sphincter
muscle function were studied using cortical and lumbar transcutaneous electrical
stimulation, pudendal nerve stimulation and sphincter electromyography in 23
patients with multiple sclerosis (MS), and sphincter disturbance, including
incontinence of urine or faeces, urinary voiding dysfunction, or constipation.
The central motor conduction time was significantly increased in the MS group
compared to controls (p less than 0.05). Damage to both the upper and lower
motor neuron pathways can contribute to sphincter disturbance in MS. The latter
may be due to coexisting pathology or to involvement of the conus medullaris by
MS
Matzel K.E., Stadelmaier U.,
and Gall F.P. (1995) [Direct electrostimulation of sacral spinal nerves within
the scope of the diagnosis of anorectal function]. Langenbecks Arch. Chir 380,
184-188.
Abstract: A technique is demonstrated to evaluate the functional relevance of
the sacral spinal nerves regarding anal sphincter function. Sacral spinal nerves
S2, S3, S4 can be reached selectively for electrical stimulation by a dorsal
approach through the sacral foramina. Electrical stimulation of S3 and S4
results in visible contraction of the different striated muscular anal sphincter
components and in an increase of anal canal closure pressure. These effects
differ among individuals. Thus, the functional relevance of each single sacral
spinal nerve on the striated muscular anal sphincter can be tested specifically
Matzel K.E., Stadelmaier U.,
Hohenfellner M., and Gall F.P. (1995) Electrical stimulation of sacral spinal
nerves for treatment of faecal incontinence. Lancet 346, 1124-1127.
Abstract: Functional deficits of the striated anal sphincteric muscles without
any apparent gross defect often result in a lack of ability to postpone
defaecation by intention or in faecal incontinence in response to increased
intra-abdominal or intra-rectal pressure. We applied electrostimulation to the
sacral spinal nerves to increase function of the striated muscles of the anal
sphincter. Of three patients followed for 6 months, two gained full continence
and one improved from gross incontinence to minor soiling. Closure pressure of
the anal canal increased in all. Preliminary data indicate that anal closure
pressure increases with the duration of stimulation. Continuous stimulation of
sacral spinal nerves can help some patients with faecal incontinence. It may be
possible to promote continence with intermittent stimulation
McGuire E.J., Zhang S.C.,
Horwinski E.R., and Lytton B. (1983) Treatment of motor and sensory detrusor
instability by electrical stimulation. J. Urol. 129, 78-79.
Abstract: A new application of electrical stimulation to inhibit detrusor
activity has been used in 15 patients with a variety of neural lesions. The
results were astonishingly good and the device was well tolerated. In patients
treated successfully for detrusor instability an absence of urgency occurred as
a by-product of electrical stimulation. Therefore, stimulation was used to treat
uncomfortable bladder urgency without detrusor instability and was successful in
the majority of patients
McIntosh L.J., Frahm J.D.,
Mallett V.T., and Richardson D.A. (1993) Pelvic floor rehabilitation in the
treatment of incontinence. J. Reprod. Med. 38, 662-666.
Abstract: This study assessed the effectiveness of a pelvic floor rehabilitation
program in a clinical practice. A retrospective convenience sample of 48 women
was evaluated pretreatment and posttreatment with follow-up interviews from six
months to three years. This group consisted of 81% with stress urinary
incontinence, 6% with unstable bladder and 10% with mixed incontinence. Fecal
incontinence was present as well in 35% of the subjects. The patients were
taught pelvic floor muscle exercises and instruction reinforced with
electromyographic biofeedback. Neuromuscular electrical stimulation was used
when clinically indicated. Two women did not continue the program beyond the
first visit and were excluded. Sixty-two percent of patients with two or more
visits demonstrated an improvement. Thirteen percent were completely dry, and
49% demonstrated a significant improvement. Patients with genuine stress urinary
incontinence, unstable bladder and mixed incontinence showed a 66%, 33% and 50%
improvement rate, respectively. Fecal incontinence was improved in 63% of women
trained in pelvic floor muscle exercises. A significant decrease (P < .001) was
found in the frequency of self-reported leakage at the six-month to three-year
follow-up. The strength and duration of a pelvic muscle contraction was
significantly greater between the first and last visit in all patients,
regardless of the subjective improvement. A pelvic floor rehabilitation program
was an effective alternative to surgical intervention in reducing the frequency
of urinary leakage. Further studies are needed to identify factors predicting
success and to determine the most cost- effective method of achieving pelvic
floor rehabilitation
Melick W.F. (1970) Electrical
stimulation in urology. J. Urol. 103, 815-821.
Merrill D.C., Conway C., and
DeWolf W. (1975) Urinary incontinence. Treatment with electrical stimulation of
the pelvic floor. Urology 5, 67-72.
Abstract: Electrical pelvic floor stimulation may be administered either
externally by the transrectal tampon or internally with the implantable pelvic
floor stimulator. This treatment modality requires intact pelvic floor
innervation and therefore is unsuccessful in patients with pelvic floor
denervation. Pelvic floor stimulation has been successful in patients with
stress and with congenital, iatrogenic, and postoperative urinary incontinence
Merrill D.C. (1979) The
treatment of detrusor incontinence by electrical stimulation. J. Urol. 122,
515-517.
Abstract: Cystometrograms were done on 20 patients before and during transrectal
stimulation to determine if electrical stimulation increased the detrusor reflex
threshold. In 4 patients the detrusor reflex threshold was increased during
stimulation and urinary continence was restored. However, each patient became
incontinent when transrectal stimulation was discontinued for 1 to 5 days. Thus,
cyclic periods of stimulation were necessary to maintain the beneficial effects
of electrical stimulation and a permanent pelvic floor stimulator was implanted
since chronic transrectal stimulation was inconvenient
Merton P.A., Hill D.K., Morton
H.B., and Marsden C.D. (1982) Scope of a technique for electrical stimulation of
human brain, spinal cord, and muscle. Lancet 2, 597-600.
Abstract: Brief high-voltage electrical shocks from a special low-output-
resistance stimulator, delivered through electrodes on the skin, can excite
human muscle directly (not by way of the nerves) and can also excite the motor
cortex, the visual cortex, and the spinal cord. Possible applications of the
technique include measurement in muscle disorders of the latency relaxation and
of the excitability and contractility of muscle without the interposition of
nerve fibres or the neuromuscular junction; measurement of conduction velocity
in the pyramidal tract; and the detection of neuropathy in the nerves to the
external sphincter ani
Miller K., Richardson D.A.,
Siegel S.W., Karram M.M., Blackwood N.B., and Sand P.K. (1998) Pelvic floor
electrical stimulation for genuine stress incontinence: who will benefit and
when? Int. Urogynecol. J. Pelvic. Floor. Dysfunct. 9, 265-270.
Abstract: This study sought to determine the characteristics of women in whom
pelvic floor electrical stimulation will reduce stress urinary incontinence. It
also evaluates how long electrical stimulation should be used before significant
improvements are seen in clinical outcomes. Subjects with genuine stress
incontinence were enrolled into a multicenter non-randomized trial. They used
electrical stimulation for 15 minutes twice daily or every other day for 20
weeks. At the end of 20 weeks, those with a 50% reduction in leakage episodes on
voiding diary ('responders') were compared with those who did not show a 50%
reduction ('non-responders'). Thirty-one subjects were enrolled and 28 completed
the study. After the treatment period, 19 subjects were defined as responders
and 9 as non-responders. There were no significant differences between the two
groups in baseline demographics (e.g. age, parity, largest birth weight etc.)
other than body mass index (greater in nonresponders). Significant subjective
and objective improvements were noted among responders by 10 and 14 weeks,
respectively. Compliance was higher in responders during weeks 12-15 of the
study (P=0.05). It was concluded that a minimum of 14 weeks of pelvic floor
stimulation was necessary before significant objective improvements were seen.
Body mass index and patient compliance may affect success
Mizunaga M., Morikawa M.,
Miyata M., Kaneko S., and Yachiku S. (1995) [A case of psychological
non-neuropathic bladder successfully diagnosed by continuous monitoring of
detrusor pressure]. Nippon Hinyokika Gakkai Zasshi 86, 337-340.
Abstract: We report a case of psychological non-neuropathic bladder difficult to
diagnose and treat. A 44-year-old woman was admitted to the Department of
Urology of the Asahikawa Medical College Hospital with complaints of difficulty
in micturition and urinary incontinence. Urodynamic studies revealed underactive
function of the detrusor and incompetent urethra. She was instructed in self
intermittent catheterization for difficulty in micturition. Drug therapy,
electrical stimulation and vesicourethral suspension were not effective to
control urinary incontinence. Since uninhibited detrusor contraction was
elicited by psychogenic stress during continuous monitoring of the detrusor
function, she was diagnosed as psychological non-neuropathic bladder closely
related to psychogenic factor. She had a careful counselling and medical
treatment designed by her psychiatrist, urinary incontinence was remitted in
about one year and a half
Montgomery E. and Shepherd A.M.
(1983) Electrical stimulation and graded pelvic exercises for genuine stress
incontinence. Physiotherapy. 69, 112.
Moore K.N. (1994) Electrical
stimulation for the treatment of urinary incontinence: do we know enough to
accept it as part of our practice? J. Adv. Nurs. 20, 1018-1022.
Abstract: While many nurses are involved in the treatment of incontinent
patients, few are well-informed on electrical stimulation. In this paper,
patient-controlled stimulation is discussed and implications for current nursing
practice considered. The paper includes a discussion of the weaknesses in
current research with electrostimulation and concludes with recommendations for
future research in the treatment of incontinence with this new modality
Moore K.N., Griffiths D., and
Hughton A. (1999) Urinary incontinence after radical prostatectomy: a randomized
controlled trial comparing pelvic muscle exercises with or without electrical
stimulation. BJU. Int. 83, 57-65.
Abstract: OBJECTIVES: To assess the effectiveness of intensive conservative
treatment on and the impact of urinary incontinence after radical retropubic
prostatectomy. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Sixty-three men with urinary incontinence
>/= 8 weeks after radical prostatectomy were randomized to one of three groups;
group 1, standard treatment (control); group 2, intensive pelvic muscle
exercises (PME); or group 3, PME plus electrical stimulation (PME+ES). Group 1
received verbal and written instructions about postoperative PME from their
urologist and from the nurses at the pre-admission clinic. Groups 2 and 3 were
treated by a physiotherapist for 30 min twice a week for 12 weeks and carried
out home exercises three times a day on the days when they were not treated.
Outcome was assessed using the 24-h pad test, two validated quality-of-life
questionnaires and a urine symptom inventory, all obtained at baseline, 12, 16
and 24 weeks after enrolment. The final pad test was carried out approximately 8
months after surgery. RESULTS: Fifty-eight patients completed the study, 21 in
group 1, 18 in group 2 and 19 in group 3; five discontinued, three with bladder
neck contractures requiring dilatation, one with rectal pain when doing the
exercises and one unable to complete therapy while on vacation. The mean
(median) time elapsed from surgery to entry into the study was 19 (8) weeks. At
12 weeks from baseline, the mean overall urine loss had decreased from 463 g to
115 g but there were no differences among groups, nor were there significant
differences in urine loss at 16 and 24 weeks (F=0. 16, P=0.69). There was a
significant impact on quality of life during the early recovery. Despite
preoperative instructions, many patients revealed little or no knowledge about
catheter care, bladder spasms, rectal pain, incontinence and erectile
dysfunction. Little of the preoperative education was retained because of the
overwhelming nature of the diagnosis. CONCLUSIONS: From the initial assessment
to the final pad-test at approximately 8 months after surgery, incontinence
improved greatly in all three groups. This rapid improvement may have masked any
treatment benefit. Further research should address incontinence in men whose
urine loss has stabilized and who underwent surgery >8 months previously.
Moreover, a telephone-based follow-up soon after discharge may alleviate many of
the concerns expressed
Moore K.N., Cody D.J., and
Glazener C.M. (2000) Conservative management of post prostatectomy incontinence.
Cochrane. Database. Syst. Rev. CD001843.
Abstract: BACKGROUND: Urinary incontinence after prostatectomy is a common
problem. Conservative management of this condition includes pelvic floor muscle
training, biofeedback, electrical stimulation using a rectal electrode,
transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation, or a combination of methods.
OBJECTIVES: To assess the effects of conservative management for urinary
incontinence after transurethral, suprapubic, radical retropubic or perineal
prostatectomy. SEARCH STRATEGY: The Cochrane Incontinence Group's trials
register, Medline, Cinahl, Embase, PsycLit and ERIC all up to January 1999, and
reference lists of relevant articles. We contacted investigators to locate
studies and we handsearched the following conference proceedings: American
Urological Association (1989-1999); Society of Urologic Nurses and Associates
(1991-1998); Wound Ostomy and Continence Nurses (1996- 1999); and International
Continence Society (1980-1998). Date of most recent searches: January 1999.
SELECTION CRITERIA: Randomised or quasi- randomised trials which evaluated
conservative management aimed at improving urinary continence after
prostatectomy. DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS: Two reviewers independently
assessed the methodological quality of studies and abstracted data from included
trials onto a standard form. MAIN RESULTS: Only five randomised trials were
identified which included 365 men, each evaluating different treatments, and all
studying men after radical prostatectomy. The trials were of moderate quality
and data were not available for many of the pre-stated outcomes. Confidence
intervals for both dichotomous and continuous data were wide; it was not
possible to reliably identify or rule out a useful effect. Men's symptoms tended
to improve over time, irrespective of management. REVIEWER'S CONCLUSIONS: The
value of the various approaches to conservative management of post prostatectomy
incontinence remains uncertain. Further well designed trials are needed
Moore K.N. (2000) Treatment of
urinary incontinence in men with electrical stimulation: is practice
evidence-based? J. Wound. Ostomy. Continence. Nurs. 27, 20-31.
Abstract: Electrical stimulation is frequently recommended for the treatment of
urinary incontinence in men. However, few randomized, controlled trials allow
practitioners to evaluate the evidence base for this practice. The purpose of
this article is to determine, based on a review of the literature, whether
adequate evidence exists to support the use of electrical stimulation as a
treatment of male urinary incontinence. Urge, stress, and overflow incontinence
are evaluated separately. This review led to 3 conclusions: (1) theoretical and
urodynamic evidence exists to support the use of electrical stimulation for urge
incontinence, (2) conflicting evidence exists in the use of electrical
stimulation for stress urinary incontinence, and (3) treatment of overflow
incontinence in men has not been evaluated in a systematic way. For both stress
urinary or overflow incontinence, practitioners should consider the existing
research before recommending electrical stimulation as a first line of
treatment. For urge incontinence, electrical stimulation may be an effective
first-line treatment strategy
Moore K.N. and Jensen L. (2000)
Testing of the Incontinence Impact Questionnaire (IIQ-7) with men after radical
prostatectomy. J. Wound. Ostomy. Continence. Nurs. 27, 304-312.
Abstract: OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study was to test the validity and
reliability of the Incontinence Impact Questionnaire (IIQ-7), a 7-item
self-report instrument designed to assess the impact of urinary incontinence
(UI), in men. SUBJECTS: Fifty-eight men with incontinence after radical
prostatectomy were the subjects of the study. METHODS: Content validity was
assessed by a panel of experts. Construct and criterion validity were examined
with 3 groups of men who had UI in a randomized controlled trial comparing
pelvic muscle exercises with pelvic muscle exercises plus electrical
stimulation. Internal consistency and stability coefficients for the IIQ-7 were
determined. RESULTS: The content validity index was 0.88. Four items were below
the designated content validity index level. A 2-factor analysis solution
(factor I-impact on daily activities; factor II-emotional impact) explained
84.94% of the variance. No significant group differences were recorded on impact
of UI (F = 0.37, P =.70), nor were any differences among subjects found over
time (F = 0.90, P =.50). A positive relationship was found between grams of
urine loss on a 24-hour pad test and IIQ-7 scores (r = 0.34, P =.003 to.51, P
=.001). When the IIQ- 7 score decreased, self-reported quality of life improved
as measured by the European Organization for the Research and Treatment of
Cancer Quality of Life Questionnaire Version 2 (r = -0.57, P =.0001 to -.49, P
=.001). A strong relationship was found between responses to the question "Does
leakage affect your life?" and the IIQ-7 scores. Internal consistency ranged
between 0.88 and 0.92. IIQ-7 scores were consistent when urine loss was
stabilized between 16 and 24 weeks after entry into the study (r = 0.89, P
=.0001). CONCLUSION: The IIQ-7 is a reliable measure of the impact of UI;
however, the scale requires additional testing regarding construct validity in
men
Moore T. and Schofield P.F.
(1967) Treatment of stress incontinence by maximum perineal electrical
stimulation. Br. Med. J. 3, 150-151.
Moul J.W. (1998) Pelvic muscle
rehabilitation in males following prostatectomy. Urol. Nurs. 18, 296-301.
Abstract: Post-prostatectomy incontinence (PPI) is a common problem in the era
of increased detection of prostate cancer and use of radical prostatectomy.
Whether temporary or permanent, mild or more severe, PPI can be effectively
treated and improved by pelvic muscle rehabilitation. It is important for
urologic nurses to understand the various pelvic muscle rehabilitation
methods--for example, Kegel exercises, biofeedback, and electrical
stimulation--to better educate and care for PPI patients and their families
Nagasaki A. and Ikeda K. (1985)
[Bowel control after surgery for Hirschsprung's disease]. Nippon Geka Gakkai
Zasshi 86, 1287-1289.
Abstract: Bowel control was studied in 66 children operated by Ikeda's Z-shaped
anastomosis for Hirschsprung's disease. At the age of 2 or 3 years, mild
constipation was recognized in 16% of the children, incontinence in 12% and
soiling in 28%. However, these disorders reduced as the patients grew up and
finally over 7 years, constipation was seen in 8% of the patients, incontinence
in 8% and soiling in 19%. According to barium enema, megarectum was seen in all
constipated children but one, though slight megarectum was sometimes seen even
in normal or incontinent children. Frequently, anal canal was wide and leakage
of barium through the anus was seen in incontinent or soiling children. Anal
canal pressure was high in constipated group, low in soiling group and the
lowest in incontinent group. The appearance rate of rhythmical wave of anal
canal and recto-anal reflex was the same among all groups. Our treatment of the
constipation and incontinence is daily bowel movement using laxative,
suppository or enema. For the incontinent patients without rectal sensation,
biofeedback method or electrical stimulation is applied
Nakamura M., Sakurai T.,
Tsujimoto Y., and Tada Y. (1983) [Transcutaneous electrical stimulation for the
control of frequency and urge incontinence]. Hinyokika Kiyo 29, 1053-1059.
Abstract: To control frequency, urgency and urge incontinence, transcutaneous
electrical stimulation was applied to the tibial nerve, the pudendal nerve or
the anal sphincter in 79 patients. All patients were refractory to any
medications for the control of frequency, nocturia, urgency and urge
incontinence from a variety of causes including disk protrusion, Parkinson's
disease and idiopathic conditions. The parameters of stimulation were 0.1 to 0.5
msec. duration for each stimulus, frequency 10 to 40 Hz, amplitude 5 to 500
voltage. Cystometrography was repeated during and after electrical stimulation
and showed increased bladder capacity, measured at first and/or at maximum
desire to void, increased compliance, decreased bladder pressure and/or
disappearance of uninhibited contractions in 79% of the patients examined. At
least one of these changes was observed in 64, 72 and 85% of the patients who
underwent stimulation of the tibial nerve, the pudendal nerve and the anal
sphincter, respectively. In some patients inhibition of bladder contraction
persisted for more than 2 or 3 days after stimulation. Electromyographic
activity of the pelvic floor muscles increased in all of the patients during the
stimulation of the pudendal nerve or the anal sphincter, but did not increase
and rather decreased during stimulation of the tibial nerve. Urethral pressure
measured during electrical stimulation, did not change in many cases. Clinical
success was also obtained in 19 of 22 patients who underwent two electrical
stimulation program; one was continuous daily use of a portable stimulator, and
the other was periodic anal stimulation once or twice a week.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED
AT 250 WORDS)
Nakamura M. and Sakurai T.
(1984) Bladder inhibition by penile electrical stimulation. Br. J. Urol. 56,
413-415.
Abstract: Transcutaneous electrical stimulation was applied to the penis in 22
patients complaining of frequency, urgency and/or urge incontinence. Detrusor
activity was suppressed with this stimulation, causing decreased bladder
spasticity and/or increased cystometric capacity in 10 of 22 patients. Clinical
success was noted in four patients with a portable stimulator
Nakamura M., Sakurai T.,
Tsujimoto Y., and Tada Y. (1986) Bladder inhibition by electrical stimulation of
the perianal skin. Urol. Int. 41, 62-63.
Abstract: Transcutaneous electrical stimulation was applied to the perianal skin
of 25 patients with frequency, urgency or incontinence. Repeated cystometrogram
during this stimulation disclosed suppression of detrusor activity, inhibition
of detrusor instability in 4 of 8 patients and increase of maximum cystometric
capacity in 5 of 25 patients. Electromyographic activity of the anal sphincter
muscle increased in all the 25 patients. Poststimulation improvement was
observed clinically in 9 of 12 patients
Nakamura M., Sakurai T., Sugao
H., and Sonoda T. (1987) Maximum electrical stimulation for urge incontinence.
Urol. Int. 42, 285-287.
Abstract: Urge incontinence was controlled in 13 (62%) of 21 patients by maximum
electrical stimulation which was applied to the anus or the perianal skin. The
first session of maximum electrical stimulation was able to determine if this
treatment would be successful. This method of patient selection for further
stimulation was simple and reliable and achieved clinical success in all of 13
selected patients
Niriella D.A. and Deen K.I.
(2000) Neosphincters in the management of faecal incontinence. Br. J. Surg. 87,
1617-1628.
Abstract: BACKGROUND: Surgical treatment of end-stage faecal incontinence has
its origin in the early 1950s. Interest has been revived as a result of
technical advances achieved in the recent past. The purpose of this article is
to review the principles that underlie the use of skeletal muscle transposition
around the anal canal and of electrical stimulation in the treatment of
incontinence, and to explore new methods of treatment of this condition.
METHODS: A literature search was performed using Pubmed and Medline, employing
keywords related to treatment of faecal incontinence by neosphincter
reconstruction. Basic science and clinical aspects of neosphincter
reconstruction were gathered from relevant texts, original articles and recently
published abstracts. RESULTS: The electrically stimulated gracilis neoanal
sphincter seems to be the popular choice of biological neosphincter. It is more
likely to produce higher resting anal canal pressures than the unstimulated
neosphincter, and hence improved continence. However, electrostimulator failure
may result in explantation in a proportion of patients. Impairment of evacuation
is a functional setback in approximately one-third of patients with the gracilis
neosphincter. Overall, improvement of continence may be expected in up to 90 per
cent of patients according to some reports. By contrast, experience with the
artificial neosphincter, which is less expensive, has been limited to a few
tertiary centres across the world. Reported continence of stool is 100 per cent,
and that of gas and stool 50 per cent, following implantation of the artificial
sphincter. Both of the above operations have been associated with
implant-related infection and impaired evacuation. CONCLUSION: Neoanal sphincter
operations are technically demanding, require a considerable learning experience
and should be confined to specialist colorectal centres. Patients are likely to
benefit from a plan that incorporates preoperative counselling and a selective
approach
Norlen L. and Sundin T. (1982)
Influence of the adrenergic nervous system on the lower urinary tract and its
clinical implications. Int. Rehabil. Med. 4, 37-43.
Abstract: The morphology of the adrenergic nervous systems as well as
adrenoceptor functions of the human lower urinary tract are outlined and
compared to some animal studies. Special emphasis is given to the altered
adrenergic innervation and adrenoceptor function after parasympathetic
decentralization. Pharmacological treatment affecting adrenoceptors is described
in different disturbances of lower urinary tract function and some evidence for
adrenergic mechanisms working in intravaginal electrical stimulation is
presented. The importance of the sympathetic nervous system for the normal
function of the human lower urinary tract is still unclear. Nevertheless,
clinical data obtained by treatment with agents influencing this system indicate
that the contractory alpha-adrenoceptors of the human urethra can be stimulated
or blocked pharmacologically producing significant changes in intraurethral
pressure. On the other hand, the relaxatory effect on the human detrusor
obtained by stimulation of the beta-adrenoceptors seems to be negligible
Norton C., Hosker G., and
Brazzelli M. (2000) Biofeedback and/or sphincter exercises for the treatment of
faecal incontinence in adults. Cochrane. Database. Syst. Rev. CD002111.
Abstract: BACKGROUND: Faecal incontinence is a particularly embarrassing and
distressing condition with significant medical, social and economic
implications. Sphincter exercises and biofeedback therapy have been used to
treat the symptoms of people with faecal incontinence. However, standards of
treatment are still lacking and the magnitude of alleged benefits has yet to be
established. OBJECTIVES: To determine the effects of biofeedback and/or anal
sphincter exercises/pelvic floor muscle training for the treatment of faecal
incontinence in adults. SEARCH STRATEGY: We searched the Cochrane Incontinence
Group trials register, the Cochrane Controlled Trials Register, Medline, Embase
and all reference lists of relevant articles up to November 1999. Date of the
most recent searches: November 1999. SELECTION CRITERIA: All randomised or
quasi-randomised trials evaluating biofeedback and/or anal sphincter exercises
in adults with faecal incontinence. DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS: Three
reviewers assessed the methodological quality of eligible trials and two
reviewers independently extracted data from included trials. A wide range of
outcome measures were considered. MAIN RESULTS: Only five eligible studies were
identified with a total of 109 participants. In the majority of trials
methodological quality was poor or uncertain. All trials were small and employed
a limited range of outcome measures. Follow-up information was not consistently
reported amongst trials. Only two trials provided data in a form suitable for
statistical analyses. There are suggestions that rectal volume discrimination
training improves continence more than sham training and that anal biofeedback
combined with exercises and electrical stimulation provides more short-term
benefits than vaginal biofeedback and exercises for women with obstetric-related
faecal incontinence. Further conclusions are not warranted from the available
data. REVIEWER'S CONCLUSIONS: The limited number of identified trials together
with their methodological weaknesses do not allow a reliable assessment of the
possible role of sphincter exercises and biofeedback therapy in the management
of people with faecal incontinence. There is a suggestions that some elements of
biofeedback therapy and sphincter exercises may have a therapeutic effect, but
this is not certain. Larger well-designed trials are needed to enable safe
conclusions
Nygaard I.E. and Kreder K.J.
(1996) Spine update. Urological management in patients with spinal cord
injuries. Spine 21, 128-132.
Abstract: In the past, urologic complications contributed greatly to spinal cord
injury mortality. With improved evaluation and treatment, this is no longer the
case. Treatment should be guided by urodynamic data gathered after the
resolution of spinal shock symptoms. Goals of treatment are to facilitate
voiding, reduce incontinence, and prevent renal damage. Indwelling catheters are
almost never indicated for long-term treatment of the neurogenic bladder.
Commonly used treatments include intermittent catheterization, condom catheter
drainage with sphincter ablation, and pharmaceutical manipulation. Electrical
stimulation of sacral nerve roots shows promise for future therapy
Nygaard I.E. (1996)
Nonoperative management of urinary incontinence. Curr. Opin. Obstet. Gynecol. 8,
347-350.
Abstract: Recent public health policies emphasize managing urinary incontinence
nonoperatively, rather than proceeding directly to surgery. Advantages of this
approach include decreased cost and risk. Additionally, incontinence treatment
becomes accessible to many more women, by expanding care to nonspecialists. This
article reviews data published in the past 18-24 months pertaining to
conservative management of incontinence. Specific modalities reviewed include
pelvic floor muscle exercises, electrical stimulation, medication, vaginal
devices, and bladder training
O'Donnell P.D. (1998) Special
considerations in elderly individuals with urinary incontinence. Urology 51,
20-23.
Abstract: OBJECTIVES: To describe special considerations related to the
etiology, evaluation, and treatment of urinary incontinence (UI) in the elderly.
METHODS: The characteristics of UI in older patients are contrasted with those
in younger patients. Recommended evaluations for elderly individuals are
reviewed, and treatment issues are addressed. RESULTS: The etiology of UI is
more complex in older than in younger patients, and a different clinical
approach is required. Bladder overactivity is a common underlying component of
UI in the elderly patient regardless of the complexity of the etiology. The most
common voiding symptom in elderly patients is urgency with urge UI. The
evaluation of the older patient with UI should include a symptom assessment,
physical examination, review of the medical history (particularly with regard to
previous surgeries), and assessments of social environment and functional status
(which can have an impact on the type of treatment selected and the success of
therapy). Urodynamic evaluations are particularly important because of the
complexity of UI in this population. Treatment options include pharmacologic
therapies, behavioral interventions, electrical stimulation, and combination
therapies. The combination of surgical and nonsurgical therapies may be
particularly important in the future. CONCLUSIONS: Control of bladder
overactivity is the most significant long-term challenge in the management of UI
in the elderly. Successful treatment can produce a marked improvement in the
quality of life for these individuals
Ohlsson B., Lindstrom S.,
Erlandson B.E., and Fall M. (1986) Effects of some different pulse parameters on
bladder inhibition and urethral closure during intravaginal electrical
stimulation: an experimental study in the cat. Med. Biol. Eng Comput. 24, 27-33.
Ohlsson B.L. and Erlandson B.E.
(1988) Miniaturised device for long-term intravaginal electrical stimulation for
the treatment of urinary incontinence. Med. Biol. Eng Comput. 26, 509-515.
Ohlsson B.L. (1988) Effects of
some different pulse parameters on the perception of intravaginal and intra-anal
electrical stimulation. Med. Biol. Eng Comput. 26, 503-508.
Ojemann J.G., Park T.S.,
Komanetsky R., Day R.A., and Kaufman B.A. (1997) Lack of specificity in
electrophysiological identification of lower sacral roots during selective
dorsal rhizotomy. J. Neurosurg. 86, 28-33.
Abstract: The authors investigated the efficacy of anal sphincter
electromyography (EMG) in identifying the lower sacral roots during selective
dorsal rhizotomy. In nine children undergoing selective dorsal rhizotomy for
cerebral palsy (CP) spasticity, direct electrical stimulation of the L1-S5
dorsal and ventral roots was performed while monitoring EMG responses from the
anal sphincter and lower-extremity muscles. Anal sphincter activation was seen
with stimulation of lumbosacral roots at many levels. Stimulation of dorsal and
ventral roots gave anal sphincter EMG responses in 100% of the dorsal and
ventral roots from L-4 and caudally. Only at the L-1 level did a minority of
nerve roots have anal sphincter response to stimulation. Patterns of extremity
muscle and sphincter activation specific to the S3-5 roots, namely anal
sphincter activation without activation of other muscle groups, were found in
only five (22%) of 23 roots stimulated. The pattern of stimulation responses in
the majority of S3- 5 roots indicated that the pathophysiology of
lower-extremity spasticity in CP may involve the anal sphincter and does not
spare the lower sacral roots. Thus, this study indicates that
electrophysiological mapping alone, without anatomical identification, cannot be
used to identify the lower sacral roots during selective dorsal rhizotomy for CP
spasticity, and it proposes a model for investigation of associated bowel and
bladder symptoms
Okada N., Igawa Y., Ogawa A.,
and Nishizawa O. (1998) Transcutaneous electrical stimulation of thigh muscles
in the treatment of detrusor overactivity. Br. J. Urol. 81, 560-564.
Abstract: OBJECTIVE: To investigate the clinical effects on detrusor
overactivity of a new method of transcutaneous reciprocal electrical stimulation
of the thigh muscles. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Nineteen patients with detrusor
overactivity, comprising 14 with detrusor hyperreflexia (DH) and five with
idiopathic detrusor instability (IDI), were studied. Electrical stimulation was
applied alternately to the quadriceps and hamstring muscles of one or both legs
through surface electrodes for 20 min. The treatment was given once a day for 14
days and then the patients were evaluated urodynamically. RESULTS: All 19
patients tolerated the therapy well and none reported any adverse effects. The
mean maximum cystometric capacity increased significantly (P < 0.05) after
treatment. In 11 of the 19 patients, the maximum cystometric capacity was
increased by > 50% of the pretreatment value; this occurred in eight of 14 of
those with DH and in three of five of those with IDI. In six of the 11 who
responded in this way, there was a clinical improvement in their urinary
incontinence and frequency for several weeks to 3 months after the period of
therapy. A second 14-day treatment was also effective in all four patients who
underwent a repeat trial. CONCLUSION: This method of transcutaneous electrical
stimulation can inhibit DH as well as IDI with no adverse effects. The
suppressive effect on detrusor overactivity may persist for several months and
repeat trials appear to be effective. Thus, we believe that this new stimulation
technique should be tried as an alternative to other types of electrical
stimulation and augmentation cystoplasty
Okada N., Igawa Y., and
Nishizawa O. (1999) Functional electrical stimulation for detrusor instability.
Int. Urogynecol. J. Pelvic. Floor. Dysfunct. 10, 329-335.
Abstract: The clinical efficacy of functional electrical stimulation (FES) for
female detrusor instability (DI) is reviewed. Various types of FES methods
(including anogenital long-term stimulation, short-term maximal stimulation,
implantable stimulation and transcutaneous stimulation) have been reported. The
therapeutic effects of these approaches were similar: the percentage of patients
improved has been reported to be in the range 50%-90%. FES for female DI is a
non-destructive procedure with a curative effect and very few side effects. This
curative effect (re-education) is a major benefit of FES
Petersen T. (1987) Management
of urinary incontinence in children with myelomeningocele. Acta Neurol. Scand.
75, 52-55.
Abstract: Several forms of treatment of lower urinary tract functional disorders
have been attempted in children with myelomeningocele (MMC). Intravesical
electrical stimulation was attempted in 10 patients. Urinary control was
achieved in one and in the remaining 9 either the bladder was resistant to
stimulation or the children discontinued the treatment due to loss of interest.
A combined anticholinergic and calcium blocking agent, terodiline, was tested in
8: symptoms improved in 4, but bladder compliance was unchanged. Clean
intermittent catheterization, either alone or in combination with medication,
seems to be the most beneficial treatment
Plevnik S. (1976) Model of the
proximal urethra: measurement of the urethral stress profile. Urol. Int. 31,
23-32.
Abstract: Research on the activity of the urinary tract has led to the creation
of a theoretical mechanical model where elastic forces, affecting rigid segments
represent the living tissue of the urethral walls whereby it is assumed that the
tissue acts as an elastic material. Such a model provides a clearer picture of
changes in the physical parameters of the elastic walls of the urethra and
facilitates better analysis of measurement errors. Artefacts make it
exceptionally difficult to accurately measure the urethral pressure profile. The
known methods have a measurement error of at least 30%. We have been trying to
eliminate the basic error caused by the size of the measuring sensor. The
methods involves measuring the urethral pressure profile in one patients using
several sensors of varying diameters. The problem was defined mathematically. By
extrapolation of measuring points, the value of elastic force under normal
conditions can be obtained. Preliminary results of pressure profile measurements
in our patients are much more accurate than those of other currently known
measuring techniques. It is too early, however, to predict the extent of
increased objectivity in the results of the new method for measuring urethral
pressure profile, with and without functional electrical stimulation. The
parameters of stimuli produced by our electrical stimulators will be based upon
these findings
Plevnik S., Suhel P., Rakovec
S., and Kralj B. (1977) Effects of functional electrical stimulation on the
urethral closing muscles. Med. Biol. Eng Comput. 15, 155-167.
Plevnik S. and Janez J. (1979)
Maximal electrical stimulation for urinary incontinence: report of 98 cases.
Urology 14, 638-645.
Abstract: Ninety-eight patients with urinary incontinence have been treated with
maximal electrical stimulation (MES) The MES method used is a modification of
previously used similar methods of maximal stimulation with respect to reduced
intensity of stimulation and reduced number of electrodes. Thus, discomfort to
the patient during treatment is considerably lessened. Anal or vaginal MES
produced temporary or sustained improvement or relief of incontinence in 47 of
98 patients
Plevnik S. (1983) Bladder
stretch during increase in abdominal pressure. Clin. Phys. Physiol Meas. 4,
315-320.
Abstract: The circumference of single bladder projections (CBP) was estimated
from oblique and lateral cystographs obtained in the supine and erect positions
during both rest and straining, with and without electric stimulation of the
pelvic floor. The results obtained indicate an increase of CBP and a flattening
of the bladder during an increase of abdominal pressure, and a decrease of CBP
during electrical stimulation. Increase of CBP means an increase in the
stretching of the bladder wall, which may produce an increase in the forces in
the bladder wall and hence act to open the bladder neck. The decrease of the CBP
during electrical stimulation of the pelvic floor indicates that the pelvic
floor support reduces flattening of the bladder and hence limits the development
of the bladder wall stretch
Primus G. (1992) Maximal
electrical stimulation in neurogenic detrusor hyperactivity: experiences in
multiple sclerosis. Eur. J. Med. 1, 80-82.
Abstract: OBJECTIVES: We report our experiences with maximal tolerable
electrical stimulation in neurogenic bladder dysfunction due to multiple
sclerosis. METHODS: 27 female patients were treated with an intravaginal
electrode carrier and an external pulse generator. The devices were individually
adjustable with respect to electrode positioning and stimulation parameters. The
frequency was 20 Hz. The threshold for sensation of the electrical stimulus was
determined by slowly increasing the current and care was taken to stimulate with
maximal tolerable stimuli. Urodynamic evaluation was done before and after
cessation of treatment. RESULTS: During stimulation, 85% of the patients were
free of symptoms. Three months after cessation of treatment only 18% remained
free of symptoms, but the symptoms were not as pronounced as before treatment.
CONCLUSION: Electrical stimulation using intravaginal electrodes represents a
practical technical choice to treat motor urge incontinence in multiple
sclerosis patients, although chronic stimulation is needed to retain improvement
Primus G. and Kramer G. (1996)
Maximal external electrical stimulation for treatment of neurogenic or
non-neurogenic urgency and/or urge incontinence. Neurourol. Urodyn. 15, 187-194.
Abstract: Maximal electrical stimulation by intravaginal or intra-anal
electrodes was used for treatment of 75 patients with complaints of urgency
and/or urge incontinence. The patient group consisted of 51 women and 24 men. A
neurogenic background was present in 30 of the women who had a diagnosis of
multiple sclerosis, in the other 45 patients the pathology was idiopathic in
nature. After 3 weeks of maximal electrical stimulation treatment, composed of
15 sessions of 20 minutes duration, 59% of the patients had urodynamic and
subjective improvement and an additional 40% only subjective improvement. One
patient found no benefit after this treatment. The effect lasted for at least 2
years in 64% of the idiopathic group. In the multiple sclerosis group relapse
occurred within about 2 months. Re-treatment of the failures was successful
again immediately; the multiple sclerosis patients do need daily home
stimulation treatments
Radil T. (1989) Evolutionary
aspects of genito-urinal reflexes. Med. Hypotheses 30, 31-33.
Abstract: The favourable effect of vaginal electrical stimulation in patients
with urinary incontinence may be caused by activation of ancient reflex
mechanisms assuring mutually exclusive function of the female genital and
urinary system linked to anatomica structures which were partially common during
phylogenesis. Reciprocal inhibition of genital and urinary reflexes and of the
corresponding behavior, assuring safe transport of the sperm to the egg, would
represent an advantage greatly supported by selective pressure
Rakovec S. (1975) Reflex
electrical stimulation for urinary incontinence. Eur. Urol. 1, 24-25.
Abstract: Experiments with several patients suffering from stress incontinence
have shown that indirect stimulation of the levator ani with a vaginal
stimulator and especially of the anal sphincter with an anal stimulator affects
the urethral sphincter in the same way as direct stimulation. These findings are
significant since they enable us to avoid the use of implantable stimulators by
substituting external ones. External stimulation is worth trying in all cases of
stress incontinence, where other conservative measures have failed. In our cases
the results have been very satisfactory
Rakovec S. (1976) Reflex
electrical stimulation for urinary incontinence. Urol. Int. 31, 111-123.
Abstract: Our previous observations have shown that the electrical stimulation
of muscles is prevalently reflex. One of the advantages of reflex stimulation is
that it activates not only a limited number of motor units, but rather a number
of muscles connected by the same reflex from a single stimulation site.
Consequently, it is not necessary to place electrodes into the muscle to be
activated. They can be put elsewhere provided that the same effect is obtained
and that it is more convenient for the patient. Such an opportunity arises when
treating urinary incontinence which involves not only the urethral sphincter but
also the group of synergistic muscles of the pelvic floor. Our experiments with
several patients suffering stress incontinence have shown that indirect
stimulation of the levator ani with a vaginal stimulator and especially of the
anal sphincter with an anal stimulator affects the urethral sphincter in the
same way as direct stimulation. These findings are significant since they enable
us to use external instead of implantable stimulators. External stimulation is
worth trying in all cases of stress incontinence where conservative measures
have failed. In our cases, the results have been very satisfactory
Rakovec S., Plevnik S., and
Kralj B. (1977) The mechanisms of the action of electrical stimulation of
muscles. Urol. Int. 32, 232-237.
Abstract: The mechanisms of the action of electrical stimulation of muscles are
discussed. We believe that the principal cause for the good results obtained in
cases of stress incontinence with electrical stimulation must be due to the
formation of a better reflex in contraction of the muscles of the pelvic floor.
This, however, envolves changes at the level of the spinal cord. By the help of
stimulation the patient learns to use the urethral sphincter and secondary
forces of retention in a better and a more proper way. The good results obtained
in the treatment of some cases of nocturnal enuresis by anal plugs require yet
another explanation. It can be considered that in nocturnal enuresis the
unconscious inhibition of the reflex mechanism for emptying the bladder is not
developed enough. From the experience we know that vigorous voluntary activation
of the muscles of the pelvic floor inhibits the contraction of the detrusor
muscle. In this way it is possible to depress the urging sensation to urinate.
In the paper we have tried to demonstrate this mechanism objectively. On the
basis of our findings we believe that the good results in treating nocturnal
enuresis may be due to this mechanism of stimulation
Ratani R.S., Yazaki E., Scott
M., Pilot M.A., and Williams N.S. (1997) Electrically stimulated smooth muscle
neosphincter. Br. J. Surg. 84, 1286-1289.
Abstract: BACKGROUND: Most patients undergoing total anorectal reconstruction
suffer some degree of incontinence despite the incorporation of an electrically
stimulated gracilis neosphincter. As smooth muscle has the ability to maintain
prolonged contraction without fatigue, the aim of this study was to assess the
feasibility of developing an electrically stimulated smooth muscle neosphincter.
METHODS: Electrical stimulation of the rabbit colon was performed via intramural
wire electrodes using a constant voltage DC stimulator. Contractile activity was
recorded by serosal strain gauges and an intraluminal pressure probe. RESULTS:
Basal colonic pressure was 4-13 (median 11) cmH2O. Peak pressures generated by
stimulated contractions (10 V, 1 ms, 10 Hz) ranged from 14 to 37 (median 26, n =
36) cmH2O and were significantly higher than those with spontaneous contractions
(P = 0.005). During continuous stimulation contractions lasted for 45-96 (median
74) s. Intermittent stimulation using trains of electrical pulses of 1-2-min
duration at 1- 2-min intervals produced repeated contractions. Alternative
contractions were produced when intermittent electrical stimulation was
performed at two sites alternately with two pairs of electrodes more than 2.5 cm
apart, producing a sustained high-pressure zone. CONCLUSION: An electrically
stimulated smooth muscle neosphincter is feasible. It has potential applications
in the management of faecal incontinence
Read D.J., James E.D., and
Shaldon C. (1985) The effect of spinal cord stimulation on idiopathic detrusor
instability and incontinence: a case report. J. Neurol. Neurosurg. Psychiatry
48, 832-834.
Abstract: A patient with long-standing symptoms of detrusor instability has been
treated by electrical stimulation of the spinal cord. Stimulation abolished all
symptoms and unequivocally inhibited episodes of instability
Reswick J.B. and Simoes N.
(1975) Application of engineering principles in management of spinal cord
injured patients. Clin. Orthop. 124-129.
Abstract: Engineering services currently being used for spine stabilization,
respiratory assist, and pressure sore prevention are discussed as well as
devices under development for bowel and bladder control, reduction of
contractural deformities and spasticity, and electrical stimulation of paralyzed
muscles. Concepts and devices for improved function are divided into categories
of: orthotic devices; environmental control systems; mobility systems;
page-turning devices. A wide range of engineering devices are available but
strict attention must be given to medical rationale for their use
Riabinskii V.S., Stepanov V.N.,
and Shadmanov A.K. (1990) [The combined treatment of urinary incontinence after
adenomectomy]. Urol. Nefrol. (Mosk) 23-28.
Abstract: Treatment was applied in 55 patients with enuresis after removal of
adenoma of the prostate. Nonoperative treatment of 46 patients included
therapeutic exercises, drug therapy (anti-inflammatory agents and tonics), and
physical methods: transurethral direct electrical stimulation of the vesical
sphincters (25 patients), transperineal ultrasonic stimulation (21 patients).
After nonoperative treatment enuresis was completely cured in 31 patients.
Fifteen patients with poor results were subjected to a second course of
treatment: a satisfactory result was produced in another 6 patients, an
improvement was recorded in 9 patients. Operative treatment was carried out in 9
patients: 4 of them by A. Puigvert's method (satisfactory result in 1,
improvement in 1, poor result in 1, acute ischuria in 1) and 5 by a modified
Puigvert's operation the techniques of which consisted in forming 2 rectangular
grafts from the tunica albuginea of the cavernous bodies of the penis, suturing
the medial grafts to one another above the urethra on the midline, and suturing
to their bases the lateral grafts (satisfactory results in 4, improvement in 1).
Thus, complex treatment of 55 patients for enuresis consequent upon removal of
adenoma of the prostate caused a satisfactory result in 42 (76.4%), an
improvement in 11 (20%), and a poor result in 2 (3.6%) patients
Richardson D.A., Miller K.L.,
Siegel S.W., Karram M.M., Blackwood N.B., and Staskin D.R. (1996) Pelvic floor
electrical stimulation: a comparison of daily and every- other-day therapy for
genuine stress incontinence. Urology 48, 110-118.
Abstract: OBJECTIVES. To compare the effectiveness of daily and every-other-day
electrical stimulation in treating genuine stress incontinence. METHODS.
Subjects with genuine stress incontinence were enrolled in a multicenter,
prospective, nonrandomized study and underwent daily or every-other-day pelvic
floor stimulation treatments for 15 minutes twice a day. Outcome measures
assessed were (1) leakage episodes and pad count; (2) leakage amount, and (3)
subject subjective assessment and quality of life. Thirteen subjects treated
daily and 15 treated every other day completed the 20-week protocol. One-year
follow-up data were available for 21 subjects. RESULTS. No significant
differences in primary outcome variables were found between the groups. Subjects
treated every other day had significant decreases in total leakage episodes (P =
0.04), pad count (P = 0.04), total voids (P = 0.02), and visual analog scale
scores, with stress incontinence cured or improved by 50% in 73% (n = 11).
Subjects treated every day had significant decreases in urge episodes (P =
0.03), pad count (P = 0.05), and visual analog scale scores, with 62% (n = 8)
cured or improved by 50%. Compliance was higher for subjects treated every other
day (P = 0.05). Satisfaction with therapy was 75% (n = 10) for daily treatment
and 77% (n = 12) for every-other-day treatment. At 1 year, 70% (n = 7) of
subjects who continued device use maintained their cure or improvement status.
CONCLUSIONS. Both daily and every-other-day therapy with pelvic floor electrical
stimulation are effective in treating genuine stress incontinence. Subjects who
continue device use maintain a higher curve or improvement rate
Riedy L.W., Chintam R., and
Walter J.S. (2000) Use of a neuromuscular stimulator to increase anal sphincter
pressure. Spinal Cord. 38, 724-727.
Abstract: OBJECTIVES: The objective of this study was to determine if short
periods of electrical stimulation with perianal electrodes could increase anal
pressures. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Anorectal responses to electrical stimulation
were evaluated in five healthy SCI patients. Anorectal pressures were recorded
with a small pressure-recording balloon before, during, and immediately
following stimulation. A battery-powered stimulator with self-adhering surface
electrodes, two inches in diameter was used. Stimulating parameters consisted of
300 micros pulse duration, 35 Hz stimulating frequency. A current response study
was conducted by using short periods of electrical stimulating with currents
from 0-100 mA until a maximal pressure was recorded. Each current setting was
conducted for 13.2+/-9.7 s before increasing to the next higher current, and
fatigue was reduced by including a 5-minute rest between stimulations. RESULTS:
Four of the five subjects had strong anal contractions with perianal
stimulation. Increases in pressure ranged from 38 to 125 cm H2O based on maximal
responses at currents ranges of 60 to 100 ma. Even during the short periods of
stimulation used here, fatigue was apparent. There was an average drop of 11% in
anal pressure over the 13 s of stimulation. Rectal pressures were unchanged with
perianal stimulation. CONCLUSIONS: Perianal stimulation with surface electrodes
is an approach that might be considered in the future for management of fecal
incontinence in individuals with spinal cord injury. Further studies are needed
to assess the feasibility of using chronic perianal surface electrical
stimulation to sustain anal sphincter contractions
Rijkhoff N.J., Wijkstra H., van
Kerrebroeck P.E., and Debruyne F.M. (1997) Urinary bladder control by electrical
stimulation: review of electrical stimulation techniques in spinal cord injury.
Neurourol. Urodyn. 16, 39-53.
Abstract: Evacuation of urine in paraplegics without the need for catheters
would be possible when voiding could be induced by eliciting a bladder
contraction. A challenging option to obtain detrusor contraction is electrical
stimulation of the detrusor muscle or its motor nerves. This article reviews the
4 possible stimulation sites where stimulation would result in a detrusor
contraction: the bladder wall, the pelvic nerves, the sacral roots, and the
spinal cord. With respect to electrode application, sacral root stimulation is
most attractive. However, in general, sacral root stimulation results in
simultaneous activation of both the detrusor muscle and the urethral sphincter,
leading to little or no voiding. Several methods are available to overcome the
stimulation-induced detrusor-sphincter dyssynergia and allow urine evacuation.
These methods, including poststimulus voiding, fatiguing of the sphincter,
blocking pudendal nerve transmission, and selective stimulation techniques that
allow selective detrusor activation by sacral root stimulation, are reviewed in
this paper
Rijkhoff N.J., Hendrikx L.B.,
van Kerrebroeck P.E., Debruyne F.M., and Wijkstra H. (1997) Selective detrusor
activation by electrical stimulation of the human sacral nerve roots. Artif.
Organs 21, 223-226.
Abstract: The purpose of this study was to investigate the feasibility of
selective detrusor activation without activation of the urethral sphincter by
sacral root stimulation in patients. The sacral roots were stimulated using a
tripolar electrode. An anodal block was used to prevent the urethral sphincter
from contraction. Using square current pulses (700 microseconds, 6-7 mA), no
increase in intraurethral pressure was measured, while a normal increase in
intravesical pressure occurred. The minimum pulse duration to obtain a complete
block was 550 microseconds. The study shows that anodal blocking of action
potentials is possible in humans and can result in selective detrusor activation
when used in sacral root stimulation
Rogers J. (1992) Testing for
and the role of anal and rectal sensation. Baillieres Clin. Gastroenterol. 6,
179-191.
Abstract: The rectum is insensitive to stimuli capable of causing pain and other
sensations when applied to a somatic cutaneous surface. It is, however,
sensitive to distension by an experimental balloon introduced through the anus,
though it is not known whether it is the stretching or reflex contraction of the
gut wall, or the distortion of the mesentery and adjacent structures which
induces the sensation. No specific sensory receptors are seen on careful
histological examination of the rectum in humans. However, myelinated and
non-myelinated nerve fibres are seen adjacent to the rectal mucosa, but no
intraepithelial fibres arise from these. The sensation of rectal distension
travels with the parasympathetic system to S2, S3 and S4. The two main methods
for quantifying rectal sensation are rectal balloon distension and mucosal
electrosensitivity. The balloon is progressively distended until particular
sensations are perceived by the patient. The volumes at which these sensations
are perceived are recorded. Three sensory thresholds are usually defined:
constant sensation of fullness, urge to defecate, and maximum tolerated volume.
The modalities of anal sensation can be precisely defined. Touch, pain and
temperature sensation exist in normal subjects. There is profuse innervation of
the anal canal with a variety of specialized sensory nerve endings: Meissner's
corpuscles which record touch sensation, Krause end-bulbs which respond to
thermal stimuli, Golgi-Mazzoni bodies and pacinian corpuscles which respond to
changes in tension and pressure, and genital corpuscles which respond to
friction. In addition, there are large diameter free nerve endings within the
epithelium. The nerve pathway for anal canal sensation is via the inferior
haemorrhoidal branches of the pudendal nerve to the sacral roots of S2, S3 and
S4. Anal sensation may be quantitatively measured in response to electrical
stimulation. The technique involves the use of a specialized constant current
generator and bipolar electrode probe inserted in the anal canal. The equipment
is generally available and the technique has been shown to be an accurate and
repeatable quantitative test of anal sensation
Rouanet P., Senesse P.,
Bouamrirene D., Toureille E., Veyrac M., Astre C., and Bacou F. (1999) Anal
sphincter reconstruction by dynamic graciloplasty after abdominoperineal
resection for cancer. Dis. Colon Rectum 42, 451-456.
Abstract: PURPOSE: Chronic low-frequency electrical stimulation can safely
transform fatiguing muscle into fatigue-resistant muscle. This fundamental
discovery was used to reconstruct the anal sphincter. Dynamic graciloplasty was
found to be effective in the treatment of fecal incontinence. Our study was
undertaken to investigate the oncologic, functional, and quality of life results
of dynamic graciloplasty anal reconstruction after an abdominoperineal resection
for carcinoma. METHODS: Between April 1993 and April 1996, nine patients (4
males) with a median age of 51.2 (range, 29-69) years underwent an
abdominoperineal resection for carcinoma (4 had a rectal adenocarcinoma and 5
had an epidermoidal anal tumor) and an anal sphincter reconstruction with
electrically stimulated graciloplasty. Oncologic and functional results were
evaluated after a mean follow-up of 32 (range, 14-50) months. A quality of life
questionnaire was filled out by seven patients. RESULTS: Sphincter
reconstruction required the same hospitalization period as abdominoperineal
resection. Two patients died from evolutive disease. Three patients were
operated on twice, one for immediate colonic necrosis, two for colonic
perforation after enema. One of them refused the graciloplasty and had an
abdominoperineal resection. Six patients were dysfunctioned. The mean resting
pressure was 24 +/- 10 mmHg, and the mean pressure during stimulation was 95 +/-
25 mmHg. Five patients were continent for solids and liquid; four wore less than
three pads per day, and one wore more than three. Four patients used enemas
twice a week; one patient had spontaneous evacuation. The quality of life
questionnaire showed that the mean scores for social interaction, symptoms, and
psychological and physical states were 2.1, 2.2, 2.4, and 2.7, respectively. The
mean value was 1.5. CONCLUSIONS: Total anorectal reconstruction with dynamic
graciloplasty is an oncologically safe procedure. Functional results improve
with time, but careful patient selection guarantees a successful functional
outcome. Technical progress is necessary to improve the quality of life
Rudy D.C. and Woodside J.R.
(1991) The incontinent myelodysplastic patient. Urol. Clin. North Am. 18,
295-308.
Abstract: Urinary incontinence is a socially devastating aspect of the lives of
many myelodysplastic children. Incontinence results from abnormal bladder
storage function, urethral sphincteric incompetence, or both. Unfortunately, the
vesicourethral dysfunction in an individual patient cannot be discerned from the
level of the vertebral defect or the coexisting neurologic deficits. Therefore,
thorough urodynamic assessment is required to identify altered physiology
precisely and to guide rational treatment. Our therapeutic armamentarium
includes external devices, intermittent self-catheterization, pharmacologic
therapy, prosthetics, electrical stimulation, biofeedback, and innovative
surgical procedures. Comprehensive evaluation, thoughtful tailoring of therapy
to the individual patient, and a commitment by the urologist to indefinite
follow-up will enable most patients to attain social continence while preserving
renal function
Rullier E., Zerbib F., Laurent
C., Caudry M., and Saric J. (2000) Morbidity and functional outcome after double
dynamic graciloplasty for anorectal reconstruction. Br. J. Surg. 87, 909-913.
Abstract: BACKGROUND: After abdominoperineal resection (APR), anorectal
reconstruction with dynamic graciloplasty has been proposed to avoid abdominal
colostomy and improve quality of life. Graciloplasties involving one or two
gracilis muscles with various configurations have been described. The aim of
this study was to evaluate morbidity and functional results in a homogeneous
series of patients undergoing double dynamic graciloplasty following APR for
rectal cancer. PATIENTS AND METHODS:: From May 1995 to May 1998, 15 patients
(ten men and five women; mean age 54 (range 39-77) years) underwent anorectal
reconstruction with double dynamic graciloplasty after APR for low rectal
carcinoma. All patients had preoperative radiotherapy (45 Gy), 11 with
concomitant chemotherapy, eight had intraoperative radiotherapy (15 Gy) and ten
received adjuvant chemotherapy for 6 months. The surgical procedure was
performed in three stages: APR with coloperineal anastomosis and double
graciloplasty (double muscle wrap); implantation of the stimulator 2 months
later; and ileostomy closure after a training period. RESULTS: There was no
operative death. At a mean of 28 (range 3-48) months of follow-up, there was no
local recurrence; two patients had lung metastases. Early and late morbidity
occurred in 11 patients, mainly related to the neosphincter (12 of 16
complications). The main complication was stenosis of the neosphincter (n = 6),
which developed with electrical stimulation. Of 12 patients available for
functional outcome, seven were continent, two were incontinent and three had an
abdominal colostomy (two for incontinence, one for sepsis). Compared with
patients without stenosis, patients with neosphincter stenosis required major
reoperations (four versus zero) and had a poor outcome (two of six versus five
of six with a good result). CONCLUSION: The double dynamic graciloplasty is
associated with a high risk of neosphincter stenosis, which may entail
morbidity, reintervention and poor functional results. The stenosis is a
heterogeneous feature of the neosphincter induced by asymmetrical traction of
both gracilis muscles. It is suggested that single dynamic graciloplasty should
be used for anorectal reconstruction after APR. Presented to the 101st congress
of the Association Francaise de Chirurgie in Paris, France, October 1999, and to
the European Council of Coloproctology in Munich, Germany, October-November 1999
Ruud Bosch J.L. and Groen J.
(1996) Treatment of refractory urge urinary incontinence with sacral spinal
nerve stimulation in multiple sclerosis patients. Lancet 348, 717-719.
Abstract: BACKGROUND: Urge urinary incontinence in multiple sclerosis patients
is usually due to detrusor hyperreflexia. Patients who do not respond to
conservative measures such as anticholinergics, with or without clean
intermittent catheterisation, are difficult to manage. METHODS: We applied
electrical stimulation to the S3 sacral spinal nerves with the aim of activating
afferent somatic nerve fibres. Stimulation of these fibres can inhibit the
micturition reflex. An S3 electrode coupled to a subcutaneously placed pulse
generator was implanted in four women who had shown a good response during
temporary stimulation via a percutaneously placed wire electrode. All patients
were followed for at least 2 years. FINDINGS: The number of leakage episodes
decreased from a mean of 4 to 0.3 per 24 h. Two patients were completely dry.
The hyperreflexia disappeared in one, improved in two, and got worse in one
patient. The urodynamic result in the last patient may be explained by clinical
progression of the multiple sclerosis. INTERPRETATION: Chronic stimulation of
the S3 sacral spinal nerve by an implantable neuroprosthesis is a promising
treatment option for selected multiple sclerosis patients with refractory urge
incontinence
Salinas C.J., Varela E., Prieto
C.L., Virseda R.M., Salomon S., Guerrero A., and Pablo R.L. (1991) [Results of
perineal electric stimulation in stress urinary incontinence]. Arch. Esp. Urol.
44, 437-440.
Abstract: The results achieved with perineal electrical stimulation in 25
patients with stress urinary incontinence of different etiology are presented
herein. Overall, positive results were achieved in 52% and 28% were
nonresponders. The results were positive in 66% with post- prostatectomy urinary
incontinence. Before recurring to other more complicated therapeutic procedures,
this treatment modality could be an alternative in the treatment of stress
urinary incontinence
Salinas J., Tiraboschi R.,
Varela E., Vega A., Salomon S., Uson A., and Rodriguez L. (1990) [Treatment of
bladder instability using intravaginal electric stimulation (intrarectal)].
Arch. Esp. Urol. 43, 523-526.
Abstract: Fourteen patients (13 females, 1 male) with urinary incontinence from
bladder instability were treated with intravaginal (intrarectal) electrical
stimulation. Good results were achieved in 57.1% of the cases. The foregoing
finding shows that intravaginal (intrarectal) electrical stimulation may
constitute a therapeutic option in urinary incontinence from bladder instability
Sand P.K., Richardson D.A.,
Staskin D.R., Swift S.E., Appell R.A., Whitmore K.E., and Ostergard D.R. (1995)
Pelvic floor electrical stimulation in the treatment of genuine stress
incontinence: a multicenter, placebo-controlled trial. Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol.
173, 72-79.
Abstract: OBJECTIVE: Our purpose was to determine the efficacy of transvaginal
electrical stimulation in treating genuine stress incontinence. STUDY DESIGN:
This was a multicenter, prospective, randomized, double-blind,
placebo-controlled 15-week trial comparing the use of an active pelvic floor
stimulator with a sham device. Thirty-five women used an active unit and 17
control subjects used sham devices. Weekly and daily voiding diaries were
recorded throughout the trial. Urodynamic testing, including pad test and
subtracted cystometry, was done before and at the end of device use. Pelvic
muscle strength was measured at baseline and at the end of the trial. Patients
scored their symptoms on visual analog scales and completed quality-of-life
questionnaires before and after therapy. RESULTS: Significant improvements from
baseline were found in patients using active devices but not in controls.
Comparisons of changes from baseline between active-device and control patients
showed that active-device patients had significantly greater improvement in
weekly (p = 0.009) and daily (p = 0.04) leakage episodes, pad testing (p =
0.005), and vaginal muscle strength (p = 0.02) when compared with control
subjects. Significantly greater improvement was also found for both visual
analog scores of urinary incontinence (p = 0.007) and stress incontinence (p =
0.02), as well as for subjective reporting of frequency of urine loss (p =
0.002), and urine loss with sneezing, coughing, or laughing (p = 0.02), when
compared with controls. Pad testing showed that stress incontinence was improved
by at least 50% in 62% of patients using an active device compared with only 19%
of patients using sham devices (p = 0.01). Voiding diaries showed at least 50%
improvement in 48% of active-device patients compared with 13% of women using
the sham device (p = 0.02). No irreversible adverse effects were noted in either
group. CONCLUSIONS: Transvaginal pelvic floor electrical stimulation was found
to be a safe and effective therapy for genuine stress incontinence
Sander P., Bjarnesen J.,
Mouritsen L., and Fuglsang-Frederiksen A. (1999) Anal incontinence after
obstetric t. Int. Urogynecol. J. Pelvic. Floor. Dysfunct. 10, 177-181.
Abstract: The study was a 1-year follow-up of 48 women with obstetric third-
/fourth-degree perineal laceration. After primary surgical repair the
symptomatic patients were treated with pelvic floor exercises with or without
transanal electrical stimulation. Various methods for assessing anal sphincter
function were also evaluated. One month postpartum 10 women (21%) complained of
anal incontinence, 8 for flatus only; 1 patient was reoperated on. After 1 year
none complained of fecal incontinence, and 3 (7%) complained of flatus
incontinence. We found relatively few women with anal incontinence after t
Schiotz H.A. and Vormdal J.
(1990) [Electrostimulation of the pelvic floor. A simple method of treating
urinary incontinence]. Tidsskr. Nor Laegeforen. 110, 1372-1374.
Abstract: Urinary incontinence is a very common condition affecting several
hundred thousand Norwegian women. Traditional methods of treatment have often
given unsatisfactory results, and many patients either do not seek help or are
considered unsuitable for treatment. Electrical stimulation of the pelvic floor
is a fairly new method of treating urinary incontinence. It is safe, simple,
inexpensive and well tolerated. It cures or improves more than 50% of patients.
More widespread use should save considerable amounts of money for the health
services, and should improve the quality of life for many patients. It is
recommended that electrostimulation therapy be made easily available in primary
health care
Seim A., Hermstad R., and
Hunskaar S. (1998) Female urinary incontinence: long-term follow-up after
treatment in general practice. Br. J. Gen. Pract. 48, 1731-1734.
Abstract: BACKGROUND: Several reports have been published showing that women
with urinary incontinence (UI) can be taken care of and treated satisfactorily
in general practice. AIM: To find out whether the treatment of women with UI in
general practice is effective also in the long term. METHOD: One hundred and
five women with UI who consulted their general practitioner (GP) were examined
and treated according to a treatment protocol. Treatment options were pelvic
floor exercises, electrical stimulation, oestrogen supplements, bladder
training, and protective pads. Three to six years after inclusion, all women
received a postal questionnaire to evaluate the long-term effectiveness of
treatment. Women who had been referred to a specialist were excluded. RESULTS:
Eighty out of 82 eligible patients answered the questionnaire after a mean
follow-up period of 56 months. Twenty-seven per cent were continent, 26% much
better, 23% a little better, 21% unchanged, and 3% were worse compared with
before the treatment. The median score on a 100 mm visual analogue scale was 16
compared with 31 before treatment, and the percentage of women that were 'much'
or 'a great deal' bothered by UI was reduced from 35% to 12%. The percentage of
women with severe UI was reduced from 59% to 30%, and the number of women using
pads was reduced from 62% to 39%. CONCLUSION: This study confirms that
management of female UI in general practice is effective also in the long term
Shanahan D.A., George B.,
Williams N.S., Sinnatamby C.S., and Riches D.J. (1993) The long head of the
biceps femoris: anatomic basis for its possible use in the construction of an
electrically stimulated neoanal sphincter. Plast. Reconstr. Surg. 92, 55-58.
Abstract: Electrical stimulation of the nerve to the gracilis muscle following
its transposition around the anal canal creates an artificial sphincter capable
of actively opposing intrarectal pressure. Not all patients have an available or
suitable gracilis. This paper describes the anatomic basis for the use of the
long head of the biceps femoris as a potential electrically stimulated neoanal
sphincter. The muscle was found to have an adequate length and a suitable arc of
rotation for transposition around the anal canal. In 75 percent of thighs
studied the neurovascular anatomy of the long head of the biceps femoris was
compatible with its utilization in this manner as an alternative to the gracilis
Siegel S.W., Richardson D.A.,
Miller K.L., Karram M.M., Blackwood N.B., Sand P.K., Staskin D.R., and Tuttle
J.P. (1997) Pelvic floor electrical stimulation for the treatment of urge and
mixed urinary incontinence in women. Urology 50, 934-940.
Abstract: OBJECTIVES: To determine the efficacy of daily or every-other-day
electrical stimulation in treating detrusor instability (urge) or urge plus
genuine stress (mixed) urinary incontinence in women. METHODS: A multicenter,
prospective, nonrandomized study enrolled subjects with urge and mixed urinary
incontinence assigned to daily or every-other- day treatments (15 minutes twice
daily) using pelvic floor stimulation. Outcome measures assessed were (1)
leakage episodes, nocturnal episodes, voiding frequency, total voids, and pad
count, and (2) patient subjective assessment and quality of life. RESULTS:
Seventy-two subjects were enrolled. Sixty-eight subjects completed the 20-week
protocol: 33 treated daily and 35 treated every other day. The entire study
group (n = 68) experienced a significant decrease in total leaks (P < 0.001),
nocturnal episodes (P = 0.001), pad count (P = 0.002), and total voids (P =
0.003) and on visual analog scales. Sixty-nine percent (n = 46) of subjects with
urge or mixed incontinence were cured or improved by at least 50%, with 28% (n =
19) being cured. There were no significant differences between daily and
every-other-day users. Nonresponse was correlated with number of previous
therapies (P < 0.001) and number of vaginal deliveries (P = 0.007). Overall,
subjects were 93% compliant with device use, and 72% (n = 47) were satisfied
with the therapy. CONCLUSIONS: Twenty weeks of pelvic floor electrical
stimulation therapy is effective in treating urge and mixed urinary
incontinence, regardless of daily or every-other-day treatments
Smith J.J., III (1996)
Intravaginal stimulation randomized trial. J. Urol. 155, 127-130.
Abstract: PURPOSE: The effectiveness of intravaginal electrical stimulation was
compared to standard therapy in the treatment of genuine stress urinary
incontinence and detrusor instability. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A total of 57
women with urinary incontinence was evaluated with video urodynamics and voiding
diaries before and after treatment. Of the women 18 with stress urinary
incontinence were randomized to electrical stimulation or Kegel exercise and 38
with detrusor instability were randomized to anticholinergic therapy or
electrical stimulation. RESULTS: Of patients using electrical stimulation in the
stress urinary incontinence group 66% improved and 72% of the patients with
detrusor instability treated with electrical stimulation improved. These rates
were not statistically significant when compared to traditional therapy.
CONCLUSIONS: Electrical stimulation is safe and at least as effective as
properly performed Kegel and anticholinergic therapy in the treatment of stress
urinary incontinence and detrusor instability
Speakman C.T., Kamm M.A., and
Swash M. (1993) Rectal sensory evoked potentials: an assessment of their
clinical value. Int. J. Colorectal Dis. 8, 23-28.
Abstract: To assess abnormalities of sensory conduction in anorectal disease we
have evaluated peripheral sensory perception and somatosensory evoked potentials
produced by rectal stimulation in control subjects and patients with either
constipation or idiopathic faecal incontinence. Evoked potentials were also
recorded after posterior tibial and dorsal genital nerve stimulation. Rectal
sensation was also assessed using electrical stimulation. Reproducible evoked
potential recordings after anorectal stimulation were possible in only a
minority of subjects and when recorded showed intersubject and intrasubject
variation. In the constipated group there was a significant difference in rectal
electrical sensation (P < 0.05) from controls. We conclude that peripheral
sensory testing demonstrates an abnormality in severe constipation. However,
cerebral evoked potentials cannot be reliably recorded after rectal stimulation,
and when recorded the latencies are of too broad a range to discriminate between
health and disease. This probably relates to the difference between somatic and
visceral pathways
Speakman C.T. and Kamm M.A.
(1993) Abnormal visceral autonomic innervation in neurogenic faecal
incontinence. Gut 34, 215-221.
Abstract: Changes of denervation in the anal sphincter striated and smooth
muscle in patients with neurogenic faecal incontinence are well established.
This study aimed to determine if there is also a more proximal visceral
autonomic abnormality. Thirty women with purely neurogenic faecal incontinence
(prolonged pudendal nerve latencies and an intact sphincter ring) and 12
patients with neuropathic changes together with an anatomical disruption were
studied. Two control groups consisted of 18 healthy volunteer women and 17 women
with normal innervation but an anatomically disrupted sphincter. Rectal
sensation was assessed using balloon distension and electrical mucosal
stimulation, and anal sensation by electrical stimulation. Rectal compliance was
studied to determine whether sensory changes were primary or caused by altered
rectal wall viscoelastic properties. Anal canal pressure changes in response to
both rectal distension and rectal electrical stimulation were measured to assess
the intrinsic innervation of the internal anal sphincter. Patients with
neurogenic incontinence alone had impaired rectal sensation to distension (53.1
v 31.5 ml, p < 0.05, neurogenic v controls) and to electrical stimulation (24.4
v 14.8 mA, p < 0.005). Patients with neurogenic incontinence and sphincter
disruption also showed impaired sensation compared with healthy controls (55.8
ml v 31.5 ml, p < 0.05 and 22.9 mA v 14.8 mA, p < 0.05). Patients with only a
disrupted sphincter had normal visceral sensation to both types of testing. Both
rectal compliance and the response of the internal anal sphincter to rectal
distension and electrical stimulation were normal in all patient
groups.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
Stein M., Discippio W., Davia
M., and Taub H. (1995) Biofeedback for the treatment of stress and urge
incontinence. J. Urol. 153, 641-643.
Abstract: Biofeedback and pelvic floor electrical stimulation are new modalities
that have been advocated for the treatment of urinary incontinence. To evaluate
the long-term effectiveness of biofeedback and identify factors predictive of a
positive outcome, we prospectively studied 28 patients with stress and urge
incontinence. All patients were evaluated with a complete history, physical
examination, urinalysis and culture. Of 28 patients 21 were also studied with
video urodynamics. Biofeedback was performed with the InCare PRS 8900* machine
with each patient undergoing at least 6 office sessions. Quantifiable symptoms,
such as frequency, nocturia and urgency, were evaluated before and periodically
after treatment. Patients also graded the overall treatment response on a scale
of 0 to 3. Biofeedback successfully treated 5 of 14 patients (36%) with stress
incontinence and 9 of 21 (43%) with urgency incontinence. Treatment response was
durable throughout followup in all responding patients. Additionally, there was
a statistically significant decrease in daytime frequency and nocturia following
biofeedback (p = 0.038 and p = 0.044, respectively). No pretreatment factors
predictive of a positive outcome could be identified. Improvement in perineal
muscle tone with time approached statistical significance. We conclude that
biofeedback is a moderately effective treatment for stress and urge
incontinence, and should be offered to patients as a treatment option. Few
patients, however, choose biofeedback as a primary mode of therapy and, due to
the availability of other highly successful treatments for stress urinary
incontinence, it is unlikely to become a popular treatment option
Stuchfield B. (1997) The
electrically stimulated neoanal sphincter and colonic conduit. Br. J. Nurs. 6,
219-224.
Abstract: Faecal incontinence affects about 2.2% of the population. Non-surgical
interventions include dietary manipulation or the use of enemas and drug
regimens. Surgical procedures such as anterior sphincter repair may improve
function for the majority of patients, but for some a permanent stoma may be the
only therapeutic option. A technique pioneered at the Royal London Hospital uses
gracilis muscle augmentation combined with electrical stimulation to improve
sphincter control. However, some patients experience residual evacuatory
problems. Antegrade irrigation may be incorporated into the procedure, but both
techniques can be used independently to promote continence. Although these
procedures are still in a developmental stage, they are an option for a select
group of patients who would otherwise be managed with a permanent stoma
Suhel P. (1976) Adjustable
nonimplantable electrical stimulators for correction of urinary incontinence.
Urol. Int. 31, 115-123.
Abstract: Investigations of functional electrical stimulation (FES) of the
closing muscles in the lower urinary tract using nonimplantable electrical
stimulators have reached the final stage. The optimal stimuli parameters were
chosen on the basis of neurophysiological studies of the urinary tract and
urodynamic measurements of mechanical response to electrical stimulation.
According to these findings, two electronic systems for FES have been developed.
An adjustable system for stimulation of the urethral closing mechanism using
vaginal or anal plugs. The external unit of the stimulator contains a generator
producing square-wave pulses. The vaginal and anal plugs are from Vitalograph
Ltd, and Cardiac Recorders Ltd., commercial tipes redesigned to suit our needs.
Frequency and duration of the pulses can be individually adjusted for each
patient. An automatic integrated adjustable system for stimulation of the
urethral closing mechanism built into a vaginal plug. This stimulator is based
on completely new design principles. It has the form of a cylinder with
hemispherical ends. Both the electronic unit and battery supply are located
within. The system is completely automatic and is started by placing the
stimulator in the vagina. Both systems mentioned were constructed for curing
stress incontinence, post-operative incontinence, enuresis and in some cases for
use in incontinent paraplegics. Clinical evaluation has given satisfactory
results for both types of stimulators in the above-mentioned patients. They are
simple to use and instructions can be given in an urologist's prescription.
Permanent or intermittent application is possible
Suhel P., Kralj B., and Plevnik
S. (1978) Advances in nonimplantable electrical stimualtors for correction of
urinary incontinence. TIT. J. Life Sci. 8, 11-16.
Abstract: The nonimplantable electrical stimulators are widely used as
rehabilitation aids for correction of urinary incontinence. The advances in the
field of the design of nonimplantable electrical stimulators such as automatic
vaginal electrical stimulator VAGICON-X and anal pressure controlled electrical
stimulator are described. The evaluation of VAGICON-X in patients suffering from
stress and urge incontinence as well as preliminary results of acute application
of anal pressure electrical stimulation in patients with stress incontinence as
presented
Sung M.S., Choi Y.H., Back
S.H., Hong J.Y., and Yoon H. (2000) The effect of pelvic floor muscle exercises
on genuine stress incontinence among Korean women--focusing on its effects on
the quality of life. Yonsei Med. J. 41, 237-251.
Abstract: This study's purpose was to compare the treatment efficacy and the
effects on the patients' quality of life of the pelvic floor muscle (PFM)
exercise and the functional electrical stimulation (FES)- biofeedback method.
Ninety female incontinence patients were randomly selected and evenly divided
into three groups: control, intensive PFM exercise, and FES-biofeedback groups.
They were treated for 6 weeks. The subjective changes in the severity of
incontinence and discomfort in daily and social life were measured using a
translated version of Jackson's Bristol female urinary symptom questionnaire.
Objective changes of pelvic muscle contraction force were measured by
perineometer. Pre and post-treatment maximal pelvic floor muscle contractile
pressure (PMC pressure) among the three groups showed statistically significant
differences (p < 0.001). Especially the FES- biofeedback group showed
significantly increased maximal PMC pressure compared with other groups (p <
0.001). From the questionnaire, pre and post-treatment changes in the severity
of urinary incontinence and discomfort due to incontinence showed significant
differences among the three groups (p < 0.001). The level of discomfort in daily
life, social activity, physical activity, personal relations and discomfort due
to urinary symptoms had largely changed and the FES-biofeedback group, in
particular, showed a significant decrease after treatment. In conclusion, when
PFM exercise and FES-biofeedback were compared in terms of their effects on the
patients' quality of life, FES- biofeedback proved to be more effective than
verbal explanation or simple PFM exercise
Sung M.S., Hong J.Y., Choi
Y.H., Baik S.H., and Yoon H. (2000) FES-biofeedback versus intensive pelvic
floor muscle exercise for the prevention and treatment of genuine stress
incontinence. J. Korean Med. Sci. 15, 303-308.
Abstract: We undertook this work to compare the treatment efficacies and the
changes of quality of life after pelvic floor muscle (PFM) exercise and the
functional electrical stimulation (FES)-biofeedback treatment, both of which are
being widely used as conservative treatment methods for female urinary
incontinence. We randomly selected 60 female incontinence patients who visited
our department and divided them evenly into two groups. They were treated for a
period of 6 weeks. The subjective changes in the severity of incontinence and
discomfort in daily and social life were measured using a translated version of
the questionnaire by Jackson. Objective changes of pelvic muscle contraction
force were measured using a perineometer. Pre- and post- treatment maximal
pelvic floor muscle contractile (PMC) pressure and changes in the severity of
urinary incontinence and discomfort of the two groups showed statistically
significant differences (p<0.001). In particular the FES-biofeedback group
showed significantly increased maximal PMC pressure and a decreased severity of
urinary incontinence and discomfort compared to the intensive PFM exercise group
(p<0.001). In conclusion, FES-biofeedback proved more effective than simple PFM
exercise
Susset J., Galea G., Manbeck
K., and Susset A. (1995) A predictive score index for the outcome of associated
biofeedback and vaginal electrical stimulation in the treatment of female
incontinence. J. Urol. 153, 1461-1466.
Abstract: A group of 64 women with stress incontinence alone (20), urgency
incontinence (7) and mixed incontinence (37) were treated during 12 sessions,
each 20 minutes long, during 6 weeks with combined alternating biofeedback and
intravaginal electrical stimulation. Of the patients 21 had a complete recovery,
20 recovered sufficiently to avoid other forms of treatment and 23 failed to
respond to the treatment. Thus, the overall success rate for this treatment was
64%. Various physiological parameters were collected from each patient before
the start of the treatment sessions. Patient age, estrogen status, detrusor
hyperreflexia, intravaginal pressure, percent transmission of the abdominal
pressure to the urethra, degree of intrinsic sphincter deficiency and compliance
with therapy were significant factors affecting the success of treatment. A
statistical analysis was performed on these measurements to generate a score
index model capable of predicting the outcome of a treatment consisting of
associated biofeedback and electrical stimulation. We present a reliable method
for distinguishing between patients who will and will not respond to this form
of treatment. The most significant variables predictive of a good reduction
outcome are patient age, presence of estrogen, absence of detrusor instability
and intrinsic sphincter deficiency, low urethral hypermobility and, most of all,
compliance with treatment
Takiuchi H., Sakurai T.,
Tsujimoto Y., Sugao H., and Nakamura M. (1987) [A case of solitary pelvic kidney
with vesicoureteral reflux and neurogenic bladder dysfunction]. Hinyokika Kiyo
33, 75-78.
Abstract: A case of solitary pelvic kidney with neurogenic bladder dysfunction
with vesicoureteral reflux is presented. The patient was a 15-year-old boy with
sacral vertebral dysplasia and hare-lip, and he has been complaining of
recurrent fever episodes and urinary incontinence since 11 years old. Renal
anomaly was confirmed by DIP, CT and angiography, and grade IV vesicoureteral
reflux was demonstrated by voiding cystourethrography. On cystometrography, low
compliance bladder which had a 70 ml capacity on first desire to void and 90 ml
capacity on maximum desire to void was observed. Electromyography of anal
sphincter performed with uroflowmetry revealed no relaxation of external
sphincter during voiding. To preserve renal function, antireflux surgery was
performed by Cohen's method, and a successful result, that is cessation of
reflux and no ureteral obstruction, was achieved. After operation, periodic
transcutaneous electrical stimulation were applied to the pudendal nerve, as a
result bladder capacity increased to 150 ml and dysuria with incontinence
improved
Tanagho E.A., Schmidt R.A., and
Orvis B.R. (1989) Neural stimulation for control of voiding dysfunction: a
preliminary report in 22 patients with serious neuropathic voiding disorders. J.
Urol. 142, 340-345.
Abstract: Our experience with electrode implantation has demonstrated that the
most successful combination to achieve continence and promote bladder evacuation
is implantation on the ventral component of S3 or S4 and extensive dorsal
rhizotomy with selective peripheral neurotomy. Of 22 patients with serious
neuropathic voiding disorders treated during the last 6 years results were
available for evaluation in 19 (2 were lost to followup and 1 was withdrawn from
the protocol because of an infection at the receiver site). In 8 patients (42
per cent) complete success was achieved. These patients have regained reservoir
function, are completely dry and void with electrical stimulation. The voiding
is synchronous, with low voiding pressure and low residual urine volumes. Ten
patients qualify as having partial success. They have regained reservoir
function and are dry. One patient voids partially with stimulation, 5 depend on
intermittent self-catheterization, 1 regained reservoir function and received an
artificial sphincter, and 3 are catheter-dependent (these 3 all had been
incontinent preoperatively despite continuous catheter drainage). The remaining
patient entered the program long after a cerebrovascular accident and treatment
has failed owing to poor selection. The stimulation parameters, once stabilized,
did not need to be increased, and neither the surgical manipulation of the
sacral roots nor the electrode implantation resulted in further neural loss in
any patient
Tanagho E.A. (1990) Electrical
stimulation. J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 38, 352-355.
Tjelum K.B., Lose G., Abel I.,
and Pedersen L.M. (1994) [Electrostimulation of the pelvic floor muscles in
urinary incontinence]. Ugeskr. Laeger 156, 2214-2216.
Abstract: External electrical stimulation is a simple, noninvasive and
inexpensive treatment modality, which is useful in the treatment of st
Trontelj J.V., Janko M., Godec
C., Rakovec S., and Trontelj M. (1974) Proceedings: Electrical stimulation for
urinary incontinence: a neurophysiological study. Urol. Int. 29, 213-220.
Trsinar B. and Kraij B. (1996)
Maximal electrical stimulation in children with unstable bladder and nocturnal
enuresis and/or daytime incontinence: a controlled study. Neurourol. Urodyn. 15,
133-142.
Abstract: The aim of this study was to investigate clinical and urodynamic
effects of anal MES in children with unstable bladder and micturition problems
(nocturnal enuresis and/or daytime incontinence). Seventy- three girls, aged 5
to 17 years, mean age 9.7 years, with cystometrically proved idiopathic detrusor
instability and nocturnal enuresis and/or daytime incontinence, were treated by
maximal electrical stimulation (MES) for 1 to 2 months. Twenty-one girls, aged 6
to 14 years, mean age 9.3 years, with unstable bladder and micturition problems
used only the anal plug without a battery for 1 month and served as the control
group. Four and a half months (1-36 months) after the end of treatment, 75% of
the stimulated patients were cured or improved by 50% or more. In the control
group, 86% of the girls remained unchanged (P < 0.01). One month after the
completion of anal MES the average number of monthly nocturnal enuretic episodes
fell from 14 to 6.5 (P < 0.001) and the number of daytime incontinence episodes
diminished from 3 to 0 (P < 0.001). On an average of 14.5 months after the end
of anal MES, enuresis recurred in 20% of cases. Post-MES cystometry showed
intensified first desire to void (P _ 0.05), as well as an increase in maximum
cystometric capacity (P < 0.0001), bladder compliance (P < 0.0001), and volume
of the first detrusor contraction (P < 0.01). A statistically significant
decline in the number of uninhibited contractions was also noticed (P < 0.001).
In the control group, the anal plug did not produce any significant
cystometrical changes. Anal MES can be recommended as an effective method for
treating nocturnal enuresis and/or daytime incontinence and unstable bladder in
children
Vahtera T., Haaranen M.,
Viramo-Koskela A.L., and Ruutiainen J. (1997) Pelvic floor rehabilitation is
effective in patients with multiple sclerosis. Clin. Rehabil. 11, 211-219.
Abstract: OBJECTIVE: To determine the effect of pelvic floor muscle exercises
combined with electrical stimulation of pelvic floor on lower urinary tract
dysfunction in multiple sclerosis (MS) patients with near normal (# 100 ml)
postvoid residual volumes. DESIGN: Open, controlled, randomized study in two
parallel groups. SETTING: Rehabilitation centre for MS patients. SUBJECTS: Fifty
women and 30 men with definite MS and current symptoms of lower urinary tract
dysfunction. OUTCOME: The muscle activity of the pelvic floor muscles was tested
using surface EMG. Subjective urinary symptoms were assessed using a
questionnaire. INTERVENTIONS: Pelvic floor muscles were stimulated using
electrical stimulation at six sessions. During and after the final session the
patients were taught to exercise their pelvic floor muscles and advised to
continue these exercises regularly for at least six months. The control group
was not treated. RESULTS: The maximal contraction power and endurance of the
pelvic floor muscles increased after six sessions of electrical stimulation with
interferential currents. Symptoms of urinary urgency, frequency and incontinence
were significantly less frequent in the treated group than in the untreated
subjects. Male patients appeared to respond better to the treatment than female
patients. Compliance with the pelvic floor exercises was over 60% at the end of
a follow-up for six months. Most drop-outs were due to the disappearance of
urinary tract symptoms or to severe relapses in MS. CONCLUSIONS: The present
study indicates that pelvic floor muscle exercises combined with electrical
stimulation of the pelvic floor constitute an effective treatment for lower
urinary tract dysfunction at least in male patients with MS
van Kerrebroeck P.E. (1998) The
role of electrical stimulation in voiding dysfunction. Eur. Urol. 34 Suppl 1,
27-30.
Abstract: Different forms of dysfunction of the lower urinary tract can be
treated with electrical stimulation. Currently, two operative treatment
modalities are available. In patients with spinal cord injury the combination of
posterior sacral root rhizotomies with implantation of electrodes on the
anterior roots produces excellent results in terms of restoration of continence
and bladder evacuation. In patients with chronic problems of urge incontinence,
urgency/frequency and voiding dysfunction, neuromodulation of a sacral nerve
with an implantable system can reduce the symptomatology significantly. Both
these treatments are a valuable addition to the modern neuro-urological practice
Varma J.S. (1992) Autonomic
influences on colorectal motility and pelvic surgery. World J. Surg. 16,
811-819.
Abstract: The nervous control of the motility of the human distal bowel was
investigated by two physiological studies of electrical stimulation of sacral
parasympathetic outflow in patients with high spinal injuries and in patients
with intractable constipation following pelvic surgery. Identical and
reproducible motility responses of the left colon, rectum, and anal sphincters
were obtained by sequential electrical stimulation of anterior sacral roots S2,
S3, and S4 in patients with spinal injury. S2 stimulation provoked isolated
low-pressure colorectal contractions. S3 stimulation initiated
frequency-dependent high- pressure colorectal motor activity which appeared
peristaltic and was enhanced with repetitive stimuli. S4 stimulation increased
colonic and rectal tone. Quantitative responses were maximal at the splenic
flexure and rectum. Pelvic floor activity was stimulated in increasing magnitude
from S2 to S4. These results of distal bowel motility were achieved by an
implanted Brindley stimulator. A newer generation of externally active
stimulators are envisaged for the control of lower bowel in fecal incontinence.
Women with intractable constipation following hysterectomy had significantly
increased rectal volume and compliance together with deficits of rectal sensory
function. Following stimulation with Prostigmine (neostigmine) a colorectal
motility gradient was paradoxically reversed in the patients following
hysterectomy, thus constituting a functional obstruction. Denervation
supersensitivity was demonstrable in 2 patients tested with carbachol
provocation. These findings suggest dysfunction in the autonomic innervation of
the hindgut in some patients following hysterectomy
Vereecken R.L., De Meirsman J.,
Puers B., and Van Mulders J. (1982) Electrophysiological exploration of the
sacral conus. J. Neurol. 227, 135-144.
Abstract: Evoked urethral and anal responses are produced by electrical
stimulation of penis, bladder neck and anus. Latency and duration of the
responses after bladder neck and anal stimulation are greatly dependent on
stimulus parameters, suggesting a polysynaptic reflex; penile stimulation
probably involves an oligosynaptic pathway. In pathological conditions the
responses are delayed and their duration reduced
Visco A.G. and Figuers C.
(1998) Nonsurgical management of pelvic floor dysfunction. Obstet. Gynecol.
Clin. North Am. 25, 849-65, vii.
Abstract: In the 50 years since pelvic muscle exercises were introduced for the
nonsurgical management of pelvic floor dysfunction related to parturition, a
variety of approaches have been introduced and the scope of indications has
grown. This article describes the evaluation of patients with pelvic floor
complaints, discusses additional techniques for performing pelvic muscle
exercises including biofeedback and electrical stimulation, details a
comprehensive educational program, and examines the literature on the use of
pelvic muscle exercises for the treatment of stress and urge urinary
incontinence
Vodusek D.B. and Zidar J.
(1987) Pudendal nerve involvement in patients with hereditary motor and sensory
neuropathy. Acta Neurol. Scand. 76, 457-460.
Abstract: Pudendal nerve involvement was demonstrated by electromyography of
perineal muscles and by recordings of their direct and reflex responses on
perineal electrical stimulation in 10 patients with hereditary motor and sensory
neuropathy. Patients reported no defecation disturbances and the 6 men had good
erections. Urinary stress incontinence was seen in those 2 (of 4) female
patients who had delivered
Walker J.M. (1998) Curricular
content on urinary incontinence in entry-level physical therapy programmes in
three countries. Physiother. Res. Int. 3, 123-134.
Abstract: BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Urinary incontinence (UI) is a significant
psychological, social and healthcare problem across the lifespan. Although there
is evidence of physical therapy (PT) efficacy, no literature was located
pertaining to UI in PT curricula. The aim was to compare curricular content on
UI (of non-neuropathic origin) in PT programmes in Canada, the UK and the USA.
The study subjects were PT educators in entry-level programmes. METHODS: All
Canadian PT programmes (13) were surveyed. Stratification was used to make
random samples of PT programmes: 50% of UK (13/26) and 50% of USA (69/136). A
questionnaire was used to obtain information on: degree level, programme length,
specific courses, time allotted, UI topics, teaching method(s), the professional
teaching patients with UI and reasons for non-inclusion in the study. One
follow-up letter was sent. Results are presented as frequencies and percentages.
RESULTS: Overall, the response rate was 62.8%; country response rates were:
Canada 92.3%; UK 76.9% and USA 53.6%. UI was taught in 80% of Canadian, 90% of
UK (which gave the most time to teaching on UI: 70% > 60 minutes) and 78.4% of
USA PT programmes. Kegel exercises were taught in all three countries (> 81.1%)
and electrical stimulation in > 65%. Theory only was the primary method of
teaching in all countries (> 64.9%). Physical therapists were reported to have a
major role in treating patients with UI (Canada > 75%; UK 100%; USA 70.3%).
CONCLUSIONS: With Kegel exercises and electrical stimulation taught in
two-thirds of all programmes physical therapy graduates may have some knowledge
of UI management. However, for the UK and USA programmes data are from only
38.5% and 27% respectively. As the common method of teaching on UI was by theory
only, graduating physical therapists may lack the clinical skills to apply
assessment and treatment techniques
Wall L.L. (1993) Medical
management of pelvic relaxation. Curr. Opin. Obstet. Gynecol. 5, 440-445.
Abstract: Although most gynecologists consider surgery to be the treatment of
choice for pelvic relaxation, there are many non-surgical forms of therapy for
this problem and conditions which it may produce, such as urinary incontinence.
This review highlights the importance of properly diagnosing co-existent factors
which may complicate a patient's condition, and reviews therapies which may
relieve her discomfort without surgery. These options include manipulation of
concurrent medical factors, estrogen therapy, pelvic muscle rehabilitation
through exercise and electrical stimulation, prompted voiding regimens, and the
use of supportive pessaries
Walters M.D., Realini J.P., and
Dougherty M. (1992) Nonsurgical treatment of urinary incontinence. Curr. Opin.
Obstet. Gynecol. 4, 554-558.
Abstract: Genuine stress urinary incontinence can be treated by surgical or
nonsurgical methods. Conservative treatments include pelvic muscle exercises,
hormonal and nonhormonal pharmacologic therapy, and functional electrical
stimulation with vaginal or anal electrodes. All of these methods improve or
cure stress incontinence in a significant proportion of selected women, with
less cost and morbidity. Patients with genuine stress incontinence generally
should have a trial of conservative therapy before corrective surgery is
offered. Behavioral and pharmacologic methods, alone and in combination, are
used for women with detrusor instability. Behavioral regimens, including bladder
retraining and biofeedback, are particularly effective for urge and stress
incontinence, but are dependent on compliance and motivation of both patient and
caregiver. Drug therapy is effective, but with potential morbidity. As with
genuine stress incontinence, surgical methods should only be employed for
patients with detrusor instability who do not respond to nonsurgical treatment
Weinberger M.W., Goodman B.M.,
and Carnes M. (1999) Long-term efficacy of nonsurgical urinary incontinence
treatment in elderly women. J. Gerontol. A Biol. Sci. Med. Sci. 54, M117-M121.
Abstract: BACKGROUND: Although urinary incontinence affects up to 35% of
community-dwelling elderly women, the long-term efficacy of conservative
treatment in this population is unknown. METHODS: Between April 1991 and January
1994, 81 community-dwelling women over age 60 underwent nonsurgical incontinence
treatment that included pelvic muscle exercises, bladder retraining, estrogen
replacement, biofeedback, functional electrical stimulation, and pharmacologic
therapy. Information about intercurrent medical problems, urogynecologic
diagnoses, treatment recommendations, and provider- documented outcome were
collected from medical records. We mailed structured questionnaires evaluating
persistent incontinence, treatment efficacy, interval therapy, and quality of
life to women who had last attended clinic at least one year previously.
RESULTS: Fifty-three of 81 (65%) women, mean age (+/- SD) 76 +/- 8 years,
returned the questionnaire. The mean follow-up interval was 21 +/- 8 months. At
follow-up, 43% of women reported incontinence was not a problem or mild, 33%
reported moderate incontinence, and 21% reported severe incontinence. When
patients compared their initial with current incontinence severity, improvement
was significant (p < .01). Genuine stress incontinence was diagnosed in 18
women, detrusor overactivity in 14, and mixed incontinence in 13. Improvement
did not vary consistently by incontinence diagnosis. Older patients had more
severe incontinence at presentation (r = .94, p = .02) and reported less
improvement (r = .97, p < .01) than younger ones. However, the overall
likelihood of improvement was greatest among patients with the most severe
incontinence at presentation (r = .534, p < .001). Subjects considered pelvic
muscle exercises, delayed voiding, and caffeine restriction most effective in
reducing incontinence severity. CONCLUSIONS: Elderly women derive long-term
clinical benefit from nonsurgical incontinence therapy. Younger patients and
those with more severe incontinence are most likely to respond to treatment
Weiss B.D. (1991)
Nonpharmacologic treatment of urinary incontinence. Am. Fam. Physician 44,
579-586.
Abstract: Standard therapy for urinary incontinence often includes
pharmaceutical agents that carry a risk of side effects or interactions with
other drugs. As an alternative, several nonpharmacologic management approaches
are available. Scheduled voiding regimens are effective for patients who have
uninhibited detrusor contractions, even when cognitive impairment is present. In
motivated patients, pelvic muscle exercise is effective for stress incontinence.
These methods are safe and inexpensive, and studies indicate that they can be as
effective as or more effective than pharmaceutical agents. Other
nonpharmacologic approaches to management include biofeedback techniques and
electrical stimulation therapy
Wexner S.D., Gonzalez-Padron
A., Teoh T.A., and Moon H.K. (1996) The stimulated gracilis neosphincter for
fecal incontinence: a new use for an old concept. Plast. Reconstr. Surg. 98,
693-699.
Abstract: The stimulated gracilis neosphincter is a viable procedure in selected
patients with fecal incontinence. The aim of this paper is to review the
technique of this staged operative procedure and review the problems and
complications. Stage 1 consists of the vascular "delay" of the gracilis muscle
and the creation of a temporary stoma. Stage 2 consists of transposition of the
muscle around the anus with implantation of the stimulator. Low-frequency
electrical stimulation is applied to the muscle for 12 weeks, after which stage
3 (stoma closure) is undertaken. From March of 1993 to March of 1995, 14
patients (9 females and 5 males) with a mean age of 44 years (range 20 to 67
years) underwent the procedure. Two patients died within 1 year of the operation
from unrelated causes. Two patients developed anal stenosis and required
permanent stomas. Other complications noted during ascent of the learning curve
included seroma, excoriation of the skin above the stimulator, transposition of
the stimulator, premature battery discharge, wound infection, rupture of the
gracilis tendon, fatigue during programming sessions, and electrode displacement
or fibrosis from the nerve. However, 8 of the 10 eligible patients had stoma
reversal; the manometric results showed an average mean squeeze pressure that
increased from 43 mmHg prior to surgery to 151 mmHg after the operation (p <
0.01). Based on an objective functional questionnaire, 60 percent of the
patients who could be evaluated reported improvement in continence, social
interactions, and the quality of their life. In conclusion, despite a steep
learning curve, the stimulated gracilis operation is a viable operation for
selected patients with severe incontinence
Wexner S.D., Gonzalez-Padron
A., Rius J., Teoh T.A., Cheong D.M., Nogueras J.J., Billotti V.L., Weiss E.G.,
and Moon H.K. (1996) Stimulated gracilis neosphincter operation. Initial
experience, pitfalls, and complications. Dis. Colon Rectum 39, 957-964.
Abstract: PURPOSE: The stimulated gracilis neosphincter is accepted as a viable
option in select patients with fecal incontinence. The aim of this study was to
review the initial problems and complications. METHODS: A prospective analysis
of all patients who underwent this procedure was undertaken. Stage I consisted
of the distal vascular delay of the muscle and creation of a temporary stoma.
Stage II was the transposition of the muscle and implantation of the stimulator
and electrodes. Low frequency electrical stimulation was applied to the muscle
for 12 weeks, after which Stage III (stoma closure) was undertaken. RESULTS:
From March 1993 to December 1995, 17 patients (9 females and 8 males) with a
mean age of 42.2 (range, 19-72) years underwent the procedure. One patient died
from pancreatitis and another from small-bowel adenocarcinoma, three and six
months after the procedure, respectively. Two patients (one with Crohn's
disease) required permanent stomas. One additional patient required a permanent
stoma because of lead fibrosis. Other complications noted during ascent of the
learning curve included seroma of the thigh incision, excoriation of the skin
above the stimulator, fecal impaction, anal fissure, parastomal hernia, rotation
of the stimulator, premature battery discharge, fracture of the lead, perineal
skin irritation, perineal sepsis, rupture of the tendon, tendon erosion, muscle
fatigue during programming sessions, and electrode displacement from the nerve
or fibrosis around the nerve. However, ultimately after rectification of these
problems, 13 of the 15 eligible patients had stoma reversal. Manometric results
showed an average basal pressure of 43 mmHg and an average maximum squeeze
pressure that increased from 36 mmHg before surgery to 145 mmHg by stimulation
(P < 0.01). Based on objective functional questionnaires, 9 of 15 (60 percent)
evaluable patients reported improvement in continence, social interactions, and
quality of life. Three of these nine patients require daily use of enemas.
CONCLUSION: Although the stimulated gracilis operation is a feasible procedure
for selected patients with severe incontinence, the learning curve is steep.
Although the ultimate outcome in a selected group of patients can be very
gratifying, major technical modifications are required before use beyond a
research protocol setting. Furthermore, patients must have the psychological
strength, emotional commitment, and financial resources that may be necessary
for multiple revisional surgeries or ultimate device failure
Williams N.S., Patel J., George
B.D., Hallan R.I., and Watkins E.S. (1991) Development of an electrically
stimulated neoanal sphincter. Lancet 338, 1166-1169.
Abstract: In early surgical attempts to create a neoanal sphincter for patients
who are faecally incontinent, skeletal muscle (usually the gracilis) has been
transposed around the anal canal. Despite modifications, such as intermittent
electrical stimulation, this procedure is likely to fail because the fast-twitch
gracilis muscle is incapable of prolonged contraction without fatigue. Long-term
electrical stimulation to convert such a muscle to a slow-twitch,
fatigue-resistant muscle, though practicable, has yielded inconsistent results.
We describe further modifications of this technique. A neoanal sphincter was
constructed with an electrically stimulated transposed gracilis muscle in 20
incontinent patients with a deficient anal sphincter, and as part of a
reconstruction in 12 patients in whom the anorectum had been excised or was
congenitally absent. A totally implanted stimulator was used to convert the
muscle from a fast-twitch to a slow-twitch muscle. Other modifications included
vascular delay 4-6 weeks before transposition of the muscle, stimulation of the
main nerve to the gracilis rather than its peripheral branches, and intermittent
higher frequency stimulation. 2-4 of these modifications gave significantly
fewer failures than did 0-1. With the new technique, continence has been
restored in patients whose only other treatment option was a permanent stoma
Wise B. and Cardozo L. (1991)
Urge incontinence and stress incontinence. Curr. Opin. Obstet. Gynecol. 3,
520-527.
Abstract: Urinary incontinence remains a common problem that adversely affects
the quality of life of millions of women. In detrusor instability, treatment
measures often lack efficacy or are accompanied by unacceptable side effects. In
this review, standard treatments are discussed, together with recent
pharmacologic advances and the introduction of newer techniques including
maximal electrical stimulation. The nonsurgical treatment options currently
available for genuine stress incontinence are considered in the light of recent
advances
Wright A.L., Williams N.S.,
Gibson J.S., Neal D.E., and Morrison J.F. (1985) Electrically evoked activity in
the human external anal sphincter. Br. J. Surg. 72, 38-41.
Abstract: Following electrical stimulation of perianal skin, short latency
evoked electromyographic (EMG) responses from the external and sphincter have
been interpreted as the electrophysiological correlate of the anal reflex.
Delayed responses in patients with idiopathic faecal incontinence have been
interpreted as evidence for denervation of the external anal sphincter.
Electrically evoked responses were studied in normal subjects, either before and
during spinal anaesthesia (n = 8), or before and during competitive
neuromuscular blockade (n = 4), instituted for operative purposes. Short latency
responses persisted unchanged in either latency or duration during spinal
anaesthesia whereas long latency responses were completely abolished. Both short
and long latency responses were abolished during competitive neuromuscular
blockade. Short latency responses are not spinal reflex in nature, but due to
stimulus activation of alpha-motoneuronal terminal branches. Delayed responses
in incontinent patients cannot be interpreted as evidence for pudendal
neuropathy. Long latency (i.e. greater than 40 ms) responses demand a functional
sacral spinal cord and represent the true anal reflex. Their wide range of
latency in normal subjects suggests this measurement will be of little use in
confirming the presence or absence of pudendal neuropathy, and that other
measures of neuropathy may be more appropriate
Wyman J.F. (1993) Managing
urinary incontinence with bladder training: a case study. J. ET Nurs. 20,
121-126.
Abstract: Bladder training is a simple, safe, and effective treatment in the
management of mild to moderate forms of urinary incontinence in outpatient
populations. It can be used as a first-line treatment or in combination with
such other interventions as pelvic muscle exercises, bladder pressure
biofeedback, electrical stimulation, and drug therapy. This article describes
the implementation of a 6-week bladder training program for a female patient
with both stress and urge incontinence
Yamanishi T., Yasuda K.,
Sakakibara R., Hattori T., Ito H., and Murakami S. (1997) Pelvic floor
electrical stimulation in the treatment of stress incontinence: an
investigational study and a placebo controlled double- blind trial. J. Urol.
158, 2127-2131.
Abstract: PURPOSE: We designed an investigational study and a placebo
controlled, double-blind study to evaluate the usefulness of electrical pelvic
stimulation in stress incontinence. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We studied 44
patients with stress incontinence (six men and 38 women, age 63 +/- 13),
including 9 patients in the investigational study and 35 in the double-blind
study. We used 50 Hz. square waves of 1 ms. pulse duration for stimulation. A
vaginal electrode was used in women and an anal electrode in men. Urethral
pressure profile before, during and after 15- minute stimulation was measured in
the investigational study. In the double-blind trial an active device and a
dummy device were used, and efficacy was judged from patient impressions,
records in frequency/volume chart, results of 1-hour pad test and urodynamic
parameters after 4-week treatment. RESULTS: In the investigational study maximum
urethral closure pressure (mean plus or minus standard deviation) before, during
and after stimulation was 44.4 +/- 17.5, 64.5 +/- 28.8 and 46.8 +/- 25.6 cm.
water, respectively. This parameter significantly increased (p = 0.0275) during
stimulation. In the double- blind trial patient impressions were good in 60% of
the active device group and 8% of the dummy device group (p = 0.0051). For the
pad test significant improvement was noted in the active device group (p =
0.0100). Cure rate was 45% in the active device group and 7.7% in the dummy
device group. There were significantly more cured or improved patients for
frequency of leakage (p = 0.0196) and pad test (p = 0.0100). CONCLUSIONS:
Electrical stimulation is effective for the treatment of stress incontinence
Yamanishi T. and Yasuda K.
(1998) Electrical stimulation for stress incontinence. Int. Urogynecol. J.
Pelvic. Floor. Dysfunct. 9, 281-290.
Abstract: Electrical stimulation has been reported to be effective for stress
incontinence, cure and improvement rates being reported to range from 30% to
50%, and from 6% to 90%, respectively. However, clinical application of this
treatment is not common because there is little physiological and technical
information. Electrodes for electrical stimulation are divided into two types:
external (non-implantable) and internal (implantable), and there are two methods
of stimulation: chronic (long-term, continuous) and short-term. Frequencies of
20-50 Hz, with a pulse duration of 1-5 ms, have been reported to be effective
for urethral closure. The effectiveness of the treatment should be verified with
placebo-controlled double-blinded trials, and four such studies using an active
and a sham device have been reported. Two of these verified the superiority of
the active device over the sham device, but the others did not demonstrate any
significant difference between the two with regard to efficacy. Electrical
stimulation has been reported to result in a long-term continuation of
therapeutic effect. The effect has been explained as a re-education or a
reactivation of lost functions of the pelvic floor muscles. As to adverse
effects, there may be some complications in relation to anesthesia or surgical
procedures, such as infection, pain and bleeding with implantable electrodes.
The incidence of adverse effects in short- term electrical stimulation is less
than 14%. In conclusion, short-term electrical stimulation using non-implantable
anal or vaginal electrodes is the most recommendable because of safety and ease
of use
Yamanishi T., Sakakibara R.,
Uchiyama T., Suda S., Hattori T., Ito H., and Yasuda K. (2000) Comparative study
of the effects of magnetic versus electrical stimulation on inhibition of
detrusor overactivity. Urology 56, 777-781.
Abstract: OBJECTIVES: To perform a randomized comparative study investigating
the urodynamic effects of functional magnetic stimulation (FMS) and functional
electrical stimulation (FES) on the inhibition of detrusor overactivity.
METHODS: Thirty-two patients with urinary incontinence due to detrusor
overactivity (15 men, 17 women; age 62. 3 +/- 16.6 years) were randomly assigned
to two treatment groups (15 patients in the FMS group and 17 in the FES group).
Stimulation was applied continuously at 10 Hz in both groups. For FMS, the
magnetic stimulator unit was set on an armchair type seat and had a
concave-shaped coil, so that the patients could sit during stimulation. For FES,
a vaginal electrode was used in the women and a surface electrode on the dorsal
part of the penis was used in the men. Cystometry was performed before and
during the stimulation. RESULTS: The bladder capacity at the first desire to
void and the maximum cystometric capacity increased significantly during
stimulation compared with prestimulation levels in both groups (P = 0.0054 and
0.0026, respectively, in the FMS group and P = 0.0015 and 0.0229, respectively,
in the FES group). However, the increase in the maximum cystometric capacity was
significantly (P = 0.0135) greater in the FMS group (114.2 +/- 124.1 mL or an
increase of 105. 5% +/- 130.4% compared with the pretreatment level) than that
in the FES group (32.3 +/- 56.6 mL or an increase of 16.3% +/- 33.9%). Detrusor
overactivity was abolished in 3 patients in the FMS group but not in any patient
in the FES group. CONCLUSIONS: Although both treatments were effective, the
inhibition of detrusor overactivity appeared greater in the FMS group than in
the FES group
Yamanishi T., Yasuda K.,
Sakakibara R., Hattori T., and Suda S. (2000) Randomized, double-blind study of
electrical stimulation for urinary incontinence due to detrusor overactivity.
Urology 55, 353-357.
Abstract: OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the usefulness of electrical stimulation for
urinary incontinence due to detrusor overactivity in a randomized, double-blind
manner. METHODS: Sixty-eight patients (29 men, 39 women, 70.0 +/- 11.2 years)
were studied. Detrusor overactivity was urodynamically defined as involuntary
detrusor contractions of more than 15 cm H(2)O during the filling phase.
Ten-hertz square waves of 1- ms pulse duration were used. A vaginal electrode
was used in the women and an anal or surface electrode in the men. The
stimulation was given for 15 minutes twice daily for 4 weeks. The efficacy was
evaluated on the basis of a frequency/volume chart and urodynamic study before
and after treatment. RESULTS: Thirty-two patients in the active group and 28 in
the sham group completed the study. The patient impressions were very good or
good in 59% and 39% of the active and the sham group, respectively (P = 0.0354).
On the cystometrogram, the bladder capacity at the first desire to void and the
maximum desire to void increased significantly (P = 0.0104 and P = 0.0046,
respectively) in the active group, but not in the sham group. Seven patients in
the active group and 1 patient in the sham group were cured (P = 0.0324); 26
patients (81.3%) in the active group and 9 (32.1%) in the sham group improved (P
= 0.0001). Of 17 patients in the active group, 13 remained cured or improved for
an average of 8.4 months after completion of the 4-week treatment; in the sham
group, 3 of 6 patients were cured or improved for an average of 4.7 months after
completion of the 4-week treatment. CONCLUSIONS: Electrical stimulation was
useful in treating urinary incontinence due to detrusor overactivity
Yokoyama O., Miyazaki K.,
Ishida T., Nango O., Fujita Y., Nagano K., Kawaguchi K., Koshida K., and
Hisazumi H. (1992) [Experimental and clinical evaluation of functional
electrical stimulation of the anal sphincter]. Hinyokika Kiyo 38, 1109-1115.
Abstract: To determine the most effective parameter of functional electrical
stimulation of the anal sphincter (FES), the present study was carried out in
female mongrel dogs anesthetized with alpha-chloralose urethane. When
spontaneous and rhythmic micturition contractions of the bladder were present,
they were more effectively inhibited by the stimulation with low frequency (5 to
10 Hz). Based on the results of this experiment 18 patients with urge
incontinence were treated by maximal electrical stimulation with the following
parameters. The duration for each stimulus was 0.2 msec, frequency 5 Hz,
amplitude 30 to 150 volts. Every patient received ten treatments for two weeks,
each lasting for 30 minutes. A clinical cure for urge incontinence was noted in
12 patients. As for urodynamic studies, FES increased significantly the volumes
of the first desire to void (FDV) and maximum desire to void (MDV); however, it
did not increase significantly the maximum urethral closure pressure or residual
urine volume. Eighteen patients were divided into two groups; an unstable
bladder group and a neurogenic bladder group. In the latter, the increases in
volumes of FDV and MDV were significant. Second, 18 patients were divided into
two groups according to the administration of lack of anticholinergic agents.
For subjective symptoms, the rate of improvement of urge incontinence was
significantly higher in the group administered the agents. These findings
suggested that FES was very useful for the treatment of urge incontinence, with
its efficacy augmented by the administration of anticholinergic agents
Zollner-Nielsen M. and
Samuelsson S.M. (1992) Maximal electrical stimulation of patients with
frequency, urgency and urge incontinence. Report of 38 cases. Acta Obstet.
Gynecol. Scand. 71, 629-631.
Abstract: Thirty-eight consecutive female patients with frequency, urgency or
urge incontinence were treated with maximal electrical pelvic floor stimulation.
Diagnostic cystometry was performed in 34 cases. Detrusor instability was found
in 13 patients, sensory urgency in 13 and hyperreflexia in eight cases. The
effect of the treatment was evaluated by subjective assessment and micturition
charts filled in for 48 hours. 63% were cured or improved. The success rate was
the same among elderly and younger patients. Detrusor instability and
hyperreflexia improved in about 75% of the cases. A good correlation was found
between the subjective assessment and the micturition chart recordings. Maximal
electrical stimulation has a good effect on certain types of lower urinary tract
dysfunction with few side-effects. It is well tolerated even by elderly patients
Zonnevijlle E.D., Somia N.N.,
Abadia G.P., Stremel R.W., Maldonado C.J., Werker P.M., Kon M., and Barker J.H.
(2000) Sequential segmental neuromuscular stimulation reduces fatigue and
improves perfusion in dynamic graciloplasty. Ann. Plast. Surg. 45, 292-297.
Abstract: Dynamic graciloplasty is used as a treatment modality for total
urinary incontinence caused by a paralyzed sphincter. A problem with this
application is undesirable fatigue of the muscle caused by continuous electrical
stimulation. Therefore, the neosphincter must be trained via a rigorous regimen
to transform it from a fatigue-prone state to a fatigue-resistant state. To
avoid or shorten this training period, the application of sequential segmental
neuromuscular stimulation (SSNS) was examined. This form of stimulation proved
previously to be highly effective in acutely reducing fatigue caused by
electrical stimulation. The contractile function and perfusion of gracilis
muscles employed as neosphincters were compared between conventional,
single-channel, continuous stimulation, and multichannel sequential stimulation
in 8 dogs. The sequentially stimulated neosphincter proved to have an endurance
2.9 times longer (as measured by halftime to fatigue) than continuous
stimulation and a better blood perfusion during stimulation (both of which were
significant changes, p < 0.05). Clinically, this will not antiquate training of
the muscle, but SSNS could reduce the need for long and rigorous training
protocols, making dynamic graciloplasty more attractive as a method of treating
urinary or fecal incontinence
|