|










| |
Electrical Stimulation And Wound
Healing References
Adobe Reader Version
Agren M.S., Engel M.A., and
Mertz P.M. (1994) Collagenase during burn wound healing: influence of a hydrogel
dressing and pulsed electrical stimulation. Plast. Reconstr. Surg. 94,
518-524.
Abstract: Epithelialization of second-degree burn wounds is known to be
accelerated by topical treatment with hydrogel dressings and further enhanced by
pulsed electrical stimulation compared with no treatment (air exposure). Tissue
collagenase has been proposed to be involved during the process of
epithelialization. In the present study collagenase levels were examined in
partial-thickness burn wounds in the skin of four domestic pigs. Collagenase
levels, assayed on postburn days 1 to 10, were substantially reduced in
deblistered and air-exposed burn wounds compared with excisional
partial-thickness wounds. Early application of hydrogel dressing to the burn
wounds was accompanied by elevated collagenase activities and an increased
inflammatory reaction in dermis. Addition of pulsed electrical stimulation
increased (p < 0.001) collagenase levels twofold above those with hydrogel alone
during initiation of epithelialization (postburn days 3 and 4). These results
suggest that collagenase is closely linked to wound epithelialization
Ahl T., Andersson G.,
Herberts P., and Kalen R. (1984) Electrical treatment of non-united fractures.
Acta Orthop. Scand. 55, 585-588.
Abstract: The semi-invasive technique for electrical stimulation of bone healing
developed by Brighton et al. (1977) was used in 23 patients with nonunited
fractures of the tibia (14 cases), humerus (4 cases), scaphoid, femur and fibula
as well as one failed arthrodesis of the ankle. The fractures were clinically
not healed and not operated on within a minimum of 6 months. The mean period
from fracture to treatment was 18 months. Electrical stimulation led to solid
bone healing in 10 cases. Two deep infections occurred during the treatment. Of
13 cases that did not unite, a great range of motion in the nonunion area was an
obvious cause of failure in seven cases. The results in this series cannot
compete with those of bone graft surgery for nonunions
Ahmed A.N., Islam K.M.,
Rahman M.F., Islam M.S., and Rabbani K.S. (1987) Effect of electrical
stimulation on the early phase of healing in induced fracture in rat tibiae.
Bangladesh Med. Res. Counc. Bull. 13, 69-79.
Akai M., Oda H., Shirasaki
Y., and Tateishi T. (1988) Electrical stimulation of ligament healing. An
experimental study of the patellar ligament of rabbits. Clin. Orthop.
296-301.
Abstract: To examine the effects of direct electric current on ligament healing
in rabbits, a full-thickness defect of the patellar ligament was electrically
stimulated for time periods of up to seven weeks. The rabbits were randomly
assigned to biomechanical and biochemical studies, and healing was evaluated by
these parameters. Electrical stimulation was shown to restore tensile stiffness
in a short period of time and to decrease the relative proportion of Type III
collagen more rapidly than in the control group. However, electrical stimulation
did not change the collagen content of newly formed tissue. Electricity enhances
the repair process of the ligament by changing the ratio of collagen types
Akai M., Wadano Y., Yabuki
T., Oda H., Sirasaki Y., and Tateishi T. (1991) [Effect of a direct electric
current on modification of bone and ligament repair processes--experimental
investigation of a rabbit model]. Nippon Seikeigeka Gakkai Zasshi 65,
196-206.
Abstract: Investigations of the effect of direct current on 1) fracture healing,
and 2) ligament healing was conducted by applying 10 microA to 1) the defect of
the fibula, and 2) that of the patellar ligament of adult rabbits. After time
periods for stimulation all specimens were tested with combinations of
roentgenological, histological, biomechanical and biochemical methods. The
results were analyzed and compared with the non-stimulated, opposite side and
with the normal tissue. The electricity produced 1) a more massive callus with
normal histological features in an early stages at the fracture site, and 2)
higher tensile stiffness and earlier change of the collagen types in the
newly-formed tissue, though no significant differences were observed as to 1)
the mechanical parameters of callus and bone material, and 2) histological
findings of repairing tissue. Electrical stimulation was indicated not only on
bone tissue but also on non-osseous tissues and their components
al Holou N., Benghuzzi H.,
and Forbes K. (1997) Development of a microcomputer-based system to monitor
healing from injury. Biomed. Sci. Instrum. 34, 181-185.
Abstract: It is well documented that induction of electric current in bone not
only prevents the bone loss of functional disuse, but also induces new bone
formation. Moreover, the literature suggests that the skeletal response is
optimal at a distinct frequency range 10-30 Hz. Indeed, even at peak strains,
well below those typical of habitual physiological loading, applications of 30
Hz were shown to be osteogenic. This evidence supports the concept that inducing
even very low strains may generate an effective osteogenic stimulus, provided
that they are induced at optimal frequency (10 to 30 Hz). Bone appears to
respond with greater selectivity and sensitivity to this frequency range of
electrical stimulation. Inducing insulin-like growth factors, which are
negatively charged, will provide the required electrical stimulus.
Traditionally, the progression of the cellular events during trauma is normally
followed by x-ray to determine a healing rate. Frequent use of this method can
result in serious side effects to the vital and reproductive organs. The
objective of this study is to develop a microcomputer-based system to monitor
the cellular events associated with healing. The system is capable of
transmitting an electrical signal directly to the site of injury to improve the
healing process and to monitor the progress of osteogenesis. The system consists
of a base unit and implanted units. One implanted unit will be inserted in the
femur with induced trauma and the other implant will be in the control femur.
The base unit will transmit low frequency electromagnetic waves to the implanted
units as well as receive periodic information about the ion movement in both
femurs
Albert S.F. and Wong E.
(1991) Electrical stimulation of bone repair. Clin. Podiatr. Med. Surg.
8, 923-935.
Abstract: Interest in methods of accelerating bone healing persists. Electrical
stimulation has demonstrated consistently high success rates in recalcitrant,
complicated nonunions. The promise of successful noninvasive alternatives for
treating nonunions continues to be realized. Given the rapidity of advances in
this field, it appears likely that acceleration of fracture repair by electrical
stimulation will become more widespread in the future
Alexander L.G. (1997) HCFA's
decision to not cover electrical stimulation for the treatment of wounds is
delayed 60 days. Ostomy. Wound. Manage. 43, 62.
Ammer K. (1994)
[Electrotherapy]. Wien. Med. Wochenschr. 144, 60-65.
Abstract: Electrotherapy is defined as the sum of therapeutic modalities of
physical medicine capable to change the threshold of elicitation of nerve or
muscle. Classification due to applied pulse frequencies, way of action of
transcutaneous nerve stimulation (= TENS) and of iontophoresis is described.
Pain syndromes, muscle atrophy by loss of activity and support of wound healing
are named as accepted indications for electrotherapy. The difficulties of
electrical stimulation of paretic muscles and the problem, whether different
indications for certain forms of electrotherapy exist or not, is discussed
Aro H., Aho A.J.,
Vaahtoranta K., and Ekfors T. (1980) Asymmetric biphasic voltage stimulation of
the osteotomized rabbit bone. Acta Orthop. Scand. 51, 711-718.
Abstract: An experimental study was performed to determine the effect of
electric current on the healing of osteotomies in the antebrachium of the
rabbit. Starting with the assumption that the waveform of biphasic asymmetric
voltage simulates the asymmetric pattern of stress-induced physiological
electrical potentials in normal bone, biphasic asymmetric voltage was applied to
the osteotomized radius or ulna. The effects of the electrical stimulation were
evaluated by means of X-rays and histological studies. The voltage supplied
induced periosteal proliferation whether implanted, insulated electrodes were
employed or uninsulated external transfixation pins were used as electrodes. The
stimulation had not only osteogenic but also chondrogenic effect. The external
callus formation at the osteotomy sites and around the transfixation pins proved
to be greater in the stimulated animals than in the controls
Baker L.L., Chambers R.,
DeMuth S.K., and Villar F. (1997) Effects of electrical stimulation on wound
healing in patients with diabetic ulcers. Diabetes Care 20, 405-412.
Abstract: OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the effects of two stimulation waveforms on
healing rates in patients with diabetes and open ulcers. The hypothesis was that
stimulus waveforms with minimal polar characteristics would provide significant
healing for this patient sample. RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS: This was a
prospective study that enrolled 80 patients with open ulcers. Patients received
stimulation with either an asymmetric biphasic (A) or symmetric biphasic (B)
square-wave pulse. Amplitudes were set to activate intact peripheral nerves in
the skin. Two other groups received either very low levels of stimulation
current (MC), or no electrical stimulation (C). When combined these groups were
referred to as the control group. Treatment was carried out daily until the
wound healed, the patient withdrew from the study, or the physician changed the
overall wound management program. Average healing rates were calculated from
weekly measures of the wound perimeter and were used for statistical comparison
through a one-way analysis of variance. RESULTS: Stimulation with the A protocol
significantly increased the healing rate, enhancing healing by nearly 60% over
the control rate of healing. Stimulation with the B protocol did not increase
the healing rate when compared with control subjects. CONCLUSIONS: Electrical
stimulation, given daily with a short pulsed, asymmetric biphasic waveform, was
effective for enhancement of healing rates for patients with diabetes and open
ulcers
Bassett C.A., Becker R.O.,
Brighton C.T., Lavine L., and Rowley B.A. (1974) Panel discussion: To what
extent can electrical stimulation be used in the treatment of human disorders?
Ann. N. Y. Acad. Sci. 238, 586-593.
Bauerle J. and Neander K.D.
(1996) [Use of pulsed electrical stimulation in the therapy of decubitus
ulcers]. Krankenpfl. J. 34, 270-275.
Becker M.H., Lassner F.,
Dagtekin F.Z., Walter G.F., and Berger A. (1995) Morphometric changes in free
neurovascular latissimus dorsi flaps: an experimental study. Microsurgery
16, 786-792.
Abstract: This study was designed to investigate regeneration of reinnervated,
free transplanted muscles. We used a rat model, consisting of eight rats per
group, in which the latissimus dorsi muscle was transplanted orthotopically and
then harvested and evaluated after 2 and 12 weeks. Age-matched control animals
were used to oppose non-operated muscles. At date of removal the patency of the
vascular anastomoses was checked clinically and histologically.
Electrophysiological measurements were also performed and conventional and
enzyme histochemical histological slides manufactured. Two weeks after the free
neurovascular flap transfer the muscle was not yet innervated, and
histologically a dissolved pattern of type 1 and type IIA muscle fibres was
found. The muscle fibres demonstrated a decrease of more than 50%
cross-sectional area. After 12 weeks the muscles were reinnervated again; muscle
contraction was positive with electrical stimulation and the cross- sectional
area had regained 80% of the activity of normal muscle fibres. With enzyme
histochemical staining the typical type grouping of reinnervated muscles could
be demonstrated
Beer L., Hintner J.,
Kleditzsch J., and Lorenz T. (1990) [Behavior of alkaline serum phosphatase (AP)
and its bone isoenzyme in healing of the osteotomized tibia in rabbits--an
animal experimental study]. Z. Exp. Chir Transplant. Kunstliche. Organe.
23, 230-232.
Abstract: The effectiveness of the electrical stimulation on the healing of an
osteotomy was proved by determining the total alkaline phosphatase (AP) in the
serum and its bone isoenzyme in rabbits. A non-stimulated animal group served as
control. The changes appeared more distinctly by interference stimulation than
by stimulation with bipolar rectangle impulses
Bertsch V. (1980) [The
treatment of Dupuytren's contracture from the medical gymnastic standpoint].
Handchirurgie. 12, 119-123.
Abstract: A special treatment program has been developed for each individual
patient. Each day the patient receives three different treatment
modalities--active exercises, passive exercises and electrical stimulation. On
days when X-ray therapy is administered, the patient performs only active
exercises and receives no electrical stimulation. The patient is also directed
to perform certain exercises at home. Patients are advised strongly against the
use of hot baths. Dynamic splints are adjusted regularly. In winter and during
cold weather, patients are instructed to wear gloves. This therapy, combined
with meticulous surgical technique, permits the rehabilitation of most hands
affected by Dupuytren's contracture. The goal of rehabilitation is tailored to
the needs of the patient and should include a sufficiently strong grasp, chuck
pinch and possibly a good pulp pinch. When necessary, the therapy should be
continued for long periods of time because a small gain in mobility may
represent a significant improvement in overall function of the hand
Biedebach M.C. (1989)
Accelerated healing of skin ulcers by electrical stimulation and the
intracellular physiological mechanisms involved. Acupunct. Electrother. Res.
14, 43-60.
Abstract: Evidence is reviewed (8 studies involving 215 clinical patients with
ischemic skin ulcers and 7 animal tissue or tissue culture studies) that
electrical stimulation of fibroblast cells accelerates the intracellular
biosynthesis necessary to form new granulation tissue in a healing wound, and
that both a direct local tissue effect and a circulatory improvement occur. A
model is presented in which transmembrane currents open voltage-controlled
calcium channels in fibroblast cells, causing ATP resynthesis, activation of
protein kinase mechanisms to synthesize new cellular protein, and the DNA
replication necessary for mitotic cell division. Stimulation efficacy appears to
be determined by a number of basic electrical parameters, and judicious waveform
control is desirable
Black J. (1985) Electrical
stimulation of hard and soft tissues in animal models. Clin. Plast. Surg.
12, 243-257.
Abstract: Studies in animals have clearly established that various forms of
electrical stimulation positively affect the growth, repair, and remodeling of
hard and soft tissue. Although the various electrical stimulation modalities
(faradic, capacitive, and inductive) are different in their physics and
biochemistry, each produces a variety of biological responses in a wide range of
animal models. The level of interest in animal studies of electrical stimulation
is rising rapidly, and new understanding, in parallel with studies in vitro and
in the clinic, will continue to be gained. The future holds the promise of a
wide range of hard and soft tissue conditions being routinely treated by
electrical stimulation, based in part on progress in studies in animals
Bogie K.M., Reger S.I.,
Levine S.P., and Sahgal V. (2000) Electrical stimulation for pressure sore
prevention and wound healing. Assist. Technol. 12, 50-66.
Abstract: This paper reviews applications of therapeutic electrical stimulation
(ES) specific to wound healing and pressure sore prevention. The application of
ES for wound healing has been found to increase the rate of healing by more than
50%. Furthermore, the total number of wounds healed is also increased. However,
optimal delivery techniques for ES therapy have not been established to date. A
study of stimulation current effects on wound healing in a pig model has shown
that direct current (DC) stimulation is most effective in wound area reduction
and alternating current (AC) stimulation for wound volume reduction at current
densities of 127 microA/cm2 and 1,125 microA/cm2, respectively. Preliminary
studies have been carried out at two research centers to assess the role of ES
in pressure sore prevention. Surface stimulation studies have shown that ES can
produce positive short-term changes in tissue health variables such as regional
blood flow and pressure distribution. The use of an implanted stimulation system
consisting of intramuscular electrodes with percutaneous leads has been found to
produce additional long-term changes. Specifically, gluteal muscle thickness
increased by 50% with regular long-term ES application concurrent with a 20%
decrease in regional interface pressures and increased tissue oxygen levels.
These findings indicate that an implantable ES system may have great potential
for pressure sore prevention, particularly for individuals who lack sensation or
who are physically unable to perform regular independent pressure relief
Bogie K.M., Reger S.I.,
Levine S.P., and Sahgal V. (2000) Electrical stimulation for pressure sore
prevention and wound healing. Assist. Technol. 12, 50-66.
Abstract: This paper reviews applications of therapeutic electrical stimulation
(ES) specific to wound healing and pressure sore prevention. The application of
ES for wound healing has been found to increase the rate of healing by more than
50%. Furthermore, the total number of wounds healed is also increased. However,
optimal delivery techniques for ES therapy have not been established to date. A
study of stimulation current effects on wound healing in a pig model has shown
that direct current (DC) stimulation is most effective in wound area reduction
and alternating current (AC) stimulation for wound volume reduction at current
densities of 127 microA/cm2 and 1,125 microA/cm2, respectively. Preliminary
studies have been carried out at two research centers to assess the role of ES
in pressure sore prevention. Surface stimulation studies have shown that ES can
produce positive short-term changes in tissue health variables such as regional
blood flow and pressure distribution. The use of an implanted stimulation system
consisting of intramuscular electrodes with percutaneous leads has been found to
produce additional long-term changes. Specifically, gluteal muscle thickness
increased by 50% with regular long-term ES application concurrent with a 20%
decrease in regional interface pressures and increased tissue oxygen levels.
These findings indicate that an implantable ES system may have great potential
for pressure sore prevention, particularly for individuals who lack sensation or
who are physically unable to perform regular independent pressure relief
Braddock M., Campbell C.J.,
and Zuder D. (1999) Current therapies for wound healing: electrical stimulation,
biological therapeutics, and the potential for gene therapy. Int. J. Dermatol.
38, 808-817.
Branham G.B., Triplett R.G.,
Yeandle S., and Vieras F. (1985) The effect of electrical current on the healing
of mandibular freeze- dried bone allografts in dogs. J. Oral Maxillofac. Surg.
43, 403-407.
Abstract: Low levels of electrical current have been shown to affect the process
of osseous repair. This study experimentally evaluated the effect of electrical
stimulation on the healing of freeze-dried mandibular allogeneic bone grafts in
dogs. Healing of the grafts was monitored by sequential submento-occlusal
radiographs and radionuclide bone imaging at two, four, six, and eight weeks
after grafting. Results indicated no significant difference in the osseous
repair of stimulated and nonstimulated freeze-dried allogeneic bone grafts
Brighton C.T., Hozack W.J.,
Brager M.D., Windsor R.E., Pollack S.R., Vreslovic E.J., and Kotwick J.E. (1985)
Fracture healing in the rabbit fibula when subjected to various capacitively
coupled electrical fields. J. Orthop. Res. 3, 331-340.
Abstract: The effect of capacitively coupled electrical stimulation on the
healing of midshaft transverse osteotomies of the rabbit fibula is assessed
roentgenographically, mechanically, and histologically. The results show that a
dose-response curve for capacitive coupling and fracture healing exists and that
a 220 mV, 250 microA, 60 kHz applied electrical signal (0.33 V/cm internal
electric field) is the most effective signal for fracture stimulation in this
model
Brondbo K., Jacobsen E.,
Gjellan M., and Refsum H. (1992) Recurrent nerve/ansa cervicalis nerve
anastomosis: a treatment alternative in unilateral recurrent nerve paralysis.
Acta Otolaryngol. 112, 353-357.
Abstract: Sectioning of the right recurrent nerve was done in 5 mongrel dogs
under general anaesthesia. The distal stump was anastomosed with the ansa
cervicalis nerve branch to the sternothyroid muscle. Three to 5 months later the
vocal cord movements during light and very light anaesthesia were videorecorded.
Under light anaesthesia contraction and medial bulging of the reinnervated right
vocal cord occurred in 4 of the dogs. Under very light anaesthesia there was
also some adduction of the right vocal cord in these 4 dogs. The right recurrent
nerve was then sectioned proximally to the anastomosis and stimulated
electrically. In all 5 dogs we observed that electrical stimulation produced a
strong adduction of the right vocal cord. Histochemistry of the right vocal and
posterior cricoarytenoid muscles showed that reinnervation had taken place. The
study indicates that in cases of unilateral vocal cord paralysis an anastomosis
between the ansa cervalalis and the recurrent nerve will result in improved
phonatory function of the affected vocal cord
Brown M., McDonnell M.K.,
and Menton D.N. (1988) Electrical stimulation effects on cutaneous wound healing
in rabbits. A follow-up study. Phys. Ther. 68, 955-960.
Abstract: The purpose of this study was to determine the effects of high voltage
monophasic pulsed electrical stimulation on wound healing using positive
polarity. Forty-four rabbits were assigned to experimental or control groups and
followed for four or seven days. We classified the groups as Exp4, Con4, Exp7,
and Con7, respectively. Each animal was anesthetized, and a full-thickness
incision, 3.5-cm long, was made on its back. After 24 hours, the Exp4 and Exp7
rabbits received high voltage electrical stimulation for two hours twice daily.
Wound closure for the Exp4 rabbits (50%) was significantly less than that of the
Con4 rabbits (78%). After seven days, however, the Exp7 and Con7 rabbits had
similar wound-closure values (80% and 82%, respectively). Tensile- strength
values for the control and experimental animals were comparable at both time
periods. Histologic examination of the wounds suggested a more rapid rate of
epithelization between the Exp4 and Exp7 rabbits compared with the Con4 and Con7
rabbits. The results of this study are inconclusive, but may indicate that
positive-polarity stimulation enhanced wound closure between four and seven days
of treatment
Buntine J.A. and Johnstone
B.R. (1988) The contributions of plastic surgery to care of the spinal cord
injured patient. Paraplegia 26, 87-93.
Abstract: Plastic surgeons have contributed to the understanding of pressure
sore pathophysiology and prophylaxis. Increasingly sophisticated surgical
techniques such as myocutaneous or innervated flaps add to the reliability and
durability of repairs. The majority of quadriplegics may benefit from surgical
restoration of active elbow extension, lateral pinch and grasp. Prolonged
postoperative care in bed or immobilisation of the upper limb demands that
patients should understand fully all that the reconstructive procedure involves.
The nature and importance of subsequent rehabilitation must be appreciated by
the patient so that he will be motivated to achieve the best possible result.
Functional electrical stimulation may find an increasing role in the years to
come
Caliskan M.K. (1993) Success
of pulpotomy in the management of hyperplastic pulpitis. Int. Endod. J.
26, 142-148.
Abstract: Hyperplastic pulpitis is a variety of chronic open pulpitis which is
regarded as irreversible. This condition is usually treated by root canal
treatment, unless coronal damage does not permit restoration, in which case
extraction is indicated. In the present study, 24 permanent teeth of
individuals, aged 10-22 years and diagnosed as hyperplastic pulpitis were
treated by pulpotomy using an atraumatic surgical technique with calcium
hydroxide alone. The treatment was successful in 22 teeth, according to the
following criteria: absence of clinical symptoms, absence of any intraradicular
or periradicular radiographic pathological changes, presence of dentine bridge
detected by clinical examination and sometimes observed radiographically, and
sensitivity to electrical stimulation. The follow-up examination ranged from 12
to 48 months. The high frequency of clinical healing in this study appears to
justify recommending pulpotomy as the treatment regime in selected cases of
chronic hyperplastic pulpitis
Carr R.W., Delaney C.A.,
Westerman R.A., and Roberts R.G. (1993) Denervation impairs cutaneous
microvascular function and blister healing in the rat hindlimb. Neuroreport
4, 467-470.
Abstract: Skin sensory nerve nocifensor functions were investigated non-
invasively in rats by measuring neurogenic inflammation and blister healing-rate
after unilateral hindlimb denervation. Axon reflexes were evoked by transdermal
iontophoresis of acetylcholine (ACh) or noxious electrical stimulation (TNS).
Sodium nitroprusside (SNP) evoked direct dilator responses. Resultant changes in
skin microvascular blood flux were measured by laser Doppler flowmetry. Compared
with their sham- operated control limbs, denervation reduced inflammatory
responses (ACh or TNS) by more than 85% and SNP responses by 28% (p < 0.05).
Healing of dry-ice blisters raised on the hindpaw 14d post-denervation was
significantly slower to complete healing (42d) than controls (26d) and initial
inflammation was attenuated, confirming that innervation is important for
inflammation and blister-healing
Castillo E., Sumano H.,
Fortoul T.I., and Zepeda A. (1995) The influence of pulsed electrical
stimulation on the wound healing of burned rat skin. Arch. Med. Res. 26,
185-189.
Abstract: Electrostimulation of wounds caused healing to proceed in a thoroughly
organized manner. A trial using rats subjected to second degree burns was
conducted to evaluate, under scanning electron microscopy (SEM), the healing
capabilities of skin to which an antiseptic (iodine) and referred electrical
stimulation were applied. Untreated, unharmed skin was also studied as control.
Images obtained using SEM revealed that only the repaired skin of the
electrostimulated group had an appearance similar to that of the control skin
(kappa = 1), and that the overall appearance of the repaired skin was compatible
with a well organized healing process
Chakkalakal D.A., Lippiello
L., Shindell R.L., and Connolly J.F. (1990) Electrophysiology of direct current
stimulation of fracture healing in canine radius. IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng
37, 1048-1058.
Abstract: Electrophysiological mechanisms involved in the electrical stimulation
of fracture healing remain largely unknown. The purpose of the present study was
to establish relationships between osteogenetic response and intraosseous
measures of electrical dose in experimental fractures (osteotomies) of canine
radii stimulated by direct currents. The response was determined postmortem at
seven weeks after osteotomy by measuring the bending rigidity and four
physicochemical properties: tissue density, mineral density, matrix density, and
mineral-to-matrix ratio. The currents measured in bone ranged from 0.1 to 17
microA. Three regions of enhanced osteogenetic response were observed at
approximately 1, 7, and 13 microA, separated by regions of unstimulated
response. Evidence presented in this paper suggests that enhanced response
resulted mainly from electrical modulation of early events in the fracture
repair sequence
Chakkalakal D.A., Lippiello
L., Wilson R.F., Shindell R., and Connolly J.F. (1990) Mineral and matrix
contributions to rigidity in fracture healing. J. Biomech. 23, 425-434.
Abstract: The purpose of this study was to investigate the relationships among
selected properties of fracture callus: bending rigidity, tissue density,
mineral density, matrix density and mineral-to-matrix ratio. The experimental
model was an osteotomized canine radius in which the development of the fracture
callus was modified by electrical stimulation with various levels of direct
current. This resulted in a range of values for the selected properties of the
callus, determined post mortem at 7 weeks after osteotomy. We found that the
rigidity (R) of the bone-callus combination obeyed relationships of the form R =
axb, where x is the tissue density, mineral density, matrix density or the
mineral-to-matrix ratio of the repair tissue. These are analogous to power-law
relationships found in studies of compact and cancellous bone. The results
suggest that fracture callus at 7 weeks after osteotomy in canine radius behaves
more like immature compact bone than cancellous bone in its mechanical and
physicochemical properties. The present study demonstrates the feasibility of
developing non-invasive in vivo densitometric methods to monitor fracture
healing, since models may be developed that can predict mechanical properties
from densitometric data. Further studies are needed to develop a refined model
based on experimental data on the mechanical and physicochemical properties and
microstructure of fracture callus at different stages of healing
Chang W.H., Hwang I.M., and
Liu H.C. (1991) Enhancement of fracture healing by specific pulsed capacitively-coupled
electric field stimulation. Front Med. Biol. Eng 3, 57-64.
Abstract: The histologic procedure technique was used to evaluate the bone
fracture healing rate of manually fractured fibulae after they were submitted to
several different types of capacitively-coupled electric field stimulation,
classified depending on the parameters of peak-to- peak voltage, frequency and
duration. Using a completely randomized design, 30 New Zealand male rabbits were
divided into six different groups: a control group, a 60 kHz and 220 mVp-p sine
wave group as proposed by Brighton in 1985, and four special parameters of pulse
wave groups. After comparing these different types of electrical stimulation,
the group with the parameters of a pulse train repetition frequency of 15 Hz, a
pulse frequency of 10 kHz and 5 V peak-to-peak intensity experienced the same
enhancement of bone fracture healing as the group with the parameters suggested
by Brighton in 1985
Cheng K., Tarjan P.P., and
Mertz P.M. (1993) Theoretical study of rectangular pulse electrical stimulation
(RPES) onskin cells (in vivo) under conforming electrodes. Biomed. Sci.
Instrum. 29, 349-354.
Abstract: Our previous in vivo experimental results have shown RPES can enhance
skin wound healing by using conforming electrodes. Based on an equation of
polarization transmembrane voltage [Cole, K. S. 1972], two equations were
derived to describe the peak RPES intensity on skin cells in vivo: (1) U = 1.5 a
J/sigma, (2) Jm = 1.5 a (J/sigma) (Cm/tau). Where U: polarization transmembrane
voltage. a: radius (R) for spherical cells or semi-length (L) for long fibers
parallel to the electrical field. J: external imposed pulse current density
under the electrode. sigma: average conductivity of skin tissue. Jm:
transmembrane displacement current density. Cm: membrane capacitance per unit
area and tau: time constant. Calculations indicated that the sensory fibers (SF)
would receive the strongest stimulation compared to other cells in skin since
generally LSF > or = 100 R. The sensitivity of SF to the stimulation could
enhance skin wound healing as well as protect normal skin cells from harmful
electroporation. From these theoretical calculations. We proposed a theoretical
range of the pulse current density as: U1 sigma/(1.5 L) < or = J z or = U2
sigma/(1.5 L), where U1 and U2 are the excitation threshold voltage (about 0.01
V) and polarization electroporation voltage (about 0.1 V) for a SF respectively,
for RPES to enhance skin wound healing
Cho M.R., Thatte H.S., Lee
R.C., and Golan D.E. (2000) Integrin-dependent human macrophage migration
induced by oscillatory electrical stimulation. Ann. Biomed. Eng 28,
234-243.
Abstract: Electrical stimulation has been used to promote wound healing. The
mechanisms by which such stimulation could interact with biological systems to
accelerate healing have not been elucidated. One potential mechanism could
involve stimulation of macrophage migration to the site of a wound. Here we
report that oscillatory electric fields induce human macrophage migration.
Macrophages exposed to a 1 Hz, 2 V/cm field show an induced migration velocity
of 5.2+/-0.4 x 10(-2) microm/min and a random motility coefficient of 4.8+/-1.4
x 10(-2) microm2/min on a glass substrate. Electric field exposure induces
reorganization of microfilaments from ring-like structures at the cell periphery
to podosomes that are confined to the contact sites between cell and substrate,
suggesting that the cells are crawling on glass. Treatment of cells with
monoclonal antibodies directed against beta2-integrins prior to field exposure
prevents cell migration, indicating that integrin-dependent signaling pathways
are involved. Electric fields cause macrophage migration on laminin or
fibronectin coated substrates without inducing podosome formation or changes in
cellular morphology. The migration velocity is not significantly altered but the
random movement is suppressed, suggesting that cell movements on a lam
Cochran G.V., Johnson M.W.,
Kadaba M.P., Palmieri V.R., and Mahaffey G. (1987) Design considerations in
development of a prototype, piezoelectric internal fixation plate: a preliminary
report. J. Rehabil. Res. Dev. 24, 39-50.
Abstract: The piezoelectric internal fixation plate represents a new concept in
orthopaedic implants. The purpose of this device is to provide stable bone
fixation while delivering internally generated, microampere direct currents to
prevent or treat nonunion of a fracture or osteotomy. Clinically, currents of
this type have been effective in treatment of nonunion, but application has
required separate, implanted, or external battery or radiofrequency powered
circuits. The "piezoplate" being developed contains an integral piezoelectric
element that generates current in response to either physiological loading such
as weightbearing or to externally applied ultrasound. Currents are processed by
a rectifying circuit for delivery to bone by electrodes. Specially designed
series/parallel piezoelectric elements and dual processing circuits are required
to generate optimum rectified currents from the low-frequency, high-voltage
signals generated by weightbearing, as well as the high-frequency, low-voltage
signals produced by ultrasound. This paper reports on the current status of
development and describes design parameters of this device which combines the
modalities of mechanical fixation and electrical stimulation in a single implant
Collier J.H., Camp J.P.,
Hudson T.W., and Schmidt C.E. (2000) Synthesis and characterization of
polypyrrole-hyaluronic acid composite biomaterials for tissue engineering
applications. J. Biomed. Mater. Res. 50, 574-584.
Abstract: New tissue engineering technologies will rely on biomaterials that
physically support tissue growth and stimulate specific cell functions. The goal
of this study was to create a biomaterial that combines inherent biological
properties which can specifically trigger desired cellular responses (e.g.,
angiogenesis) with electrical properties which have been shown to improve the
regeneration of several tissues including bone and nerve. To this end,
composites of the biologically active polysaccharide hyaluronic acid (HA) and
the electrically conducting polymer polypyrrole (PP) were synthesized and
characterized. Electrical conductivity of the composite biomaterial (PP/HA) was
measured by a four-point probe technique, scanning electron microscopy was used
to characterize surface topography, X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy and
reflectance infrared spectroscopy were used to evaluate surface and bulk
chemistry, and an assay with biotinylated hyaluronic acid binding protein was
used to determine surface HA content. PP/HA materials were also evaluated for in
vitro cell compatibility and tissue response in rats. Smooth, conductive, HA-
containing PP films were produced; these films retained HA on their surfaces for
several days in vitro and promoted vascularization in vivo. PP/HA composite
biomaterials are promising candidates for tissue engineering and wound-healing
applications that may benefit from both electrical stimulation and enhanced
vascularization
Collier M.A., Kallfelz F.A.,
Rendano V.T., Krook L.P., and Schryver H.F. (1985) Capacitively coupled
electrical stimulation of bone healing in the horse: in vivo study with a Salter
type IV osteotomy model with stainless steel surface electrodes. Am. J. Vet.
Res. 46, 622-631.
Abstract: The use of capacitively coupled low-voltage signals for stimulation of
osteogenesis has been reported in a variety of animal models. Electrically
induced osteogenesis was investigated with a capacitively coupled electric field
on a radius (distal-lateral orientation) osteotomy model, in conjunction with
internal fixation and postoperative loading. Twelve adult horses of either sex
were allotted to 2 groups of 6; 1 group was given electrical stimulation and the
other served as controls. A low-voltage high-frequency capacitively coupled
electrical signal was locally and continuously applied to the electrically
stimulated group for 60 days through external, bare stainless steel surface
electrodes which were placed on the skin in circuit with a small, portable power
source. Harness compatibility and stimulator and battery durability were
excellent. However, stainless steel electrodes required a rigid maintenance
schedule to maintain consistent current levels. Synovial fluid evaluation
demonstrated intra- articular inflammation (decreased viscosity, hyaluronic
acid, and increased protein concentration) 1 week postoperatively that generally
improved during subsequent weeks and no distinction between groups was observed
at 60 days. Radiographically, there was no difference in the appearance of the
healing process of control and that of stimulated horses during the 60 days.
Angiography showed bridging blood vessels in both groups. Uptake of a bone
seeking radiopharmaceutical peaked at 3 weeks in both groups and was 1.92 +/-
0.6 cps/pixel/mCi and 1.26 +/- 0.40 csp/pixel/mCi for control and stimulated
horses, respectively. At any given observation period, uptake in the lesion area
was greater in the control group. Ultimate strengths of trabecular bone in
60-day control radii and stimulated radii were 12.64 +/- 3.013 and 9.60 +/- 3.95
MN/m2, and the flexural moduli of elasticity were 698.0 +/- 423 and 402.0 +/-
523 MN/m2, respectively. Porosity index was similar for all specimens. Gross,
histologic, and microradiographic evaluations indicated that controls healed
more efficiently than stimulated horses. A capacitively coupled applied voltage
of 2.2 V RMS (mean) producing a current of 17.32 mA (mean) did not stimulate
sufficient bone production in a metaphyseal osteotomy model to affect the
mechanical properties of the bone or accelerate the healing process
Collier M.A., Brighton C.T.,
Norrdin R., Twardock A.R., and Rendano V.T. (1985) Direct current stimulation of
bone production in the horse: preliminary study with a "gap healing" model.
Am. J. Vet. Res. 46, 610-621.
Abstract: The effect of a 20-microA direct-current implantable bone growth
stimulator (BGS) on bone production with a "gap healing" model in the horse was
evaluated. The right and left 4th metatarsal bones (Mt-4) were used in 7 adult
horses to create the "gap healing" model. A 4-mm section of the Mt-4 bone was
resected bilaterally in each horse. The BGS was surgically placed into the 7
left Mt-4 defects. The 7 right Mt- 4 defects served as controls. Six horses
survived the 16-week experimental period. Signs of pain, decreased range of limb
motion, or lameness was not observed in any animal during the 16 weeks. None of
the animals showed complete healing radiographically. Four stimulated sites
showed less periosteal reaction and 2 showed greater reaction than the 6
controls. The greatest amount of periosteal reaction or bone resorption was seen
around the screws and plates in both groups. Uptakes of 99mTc-MDP in
counts/pixel for control sites and stimulated sites were 7.90 and 8.25 in the
"gap defect" and 5.19 and 5.06 in the areas adjacent to the gap defect. The
ratio of uptake between the gap defect and adjacent area was 1.5 and 1.58
respectively. Biocompatability of the BGS was excellent; however, 1 horse had a
broken cathode wire 5 cm from the generator capsule at 6 weeks. All polyethylene
cathode sheaths were fluid filled at 16 weeks. The average mineralization rates
were 1.57 +/- 0.34, 1.71 +/- 0.28 mm/day and bone formation activity was 0.0182
+/- 0.171, and 0.0168 +/- 0.0149 mm2/day for control limbs and stimulated limbs,
respectively. There was no significant difference between groups in any of the
histomorphometric values measured. Direct current (20 microA) did not increase
bone production in this experiment. Methods to objectively evaluate electrically
induced osteogenesis and a "gap defect" model for BGS research on the horse are
discussed. The results provide a basis for additional research on electrical
stimulation of fractures in the horse and for dose-response studies
Connolly J.F. (1981)
Selection, evaluation and indications for electrical stimulation of ununited
fractures. Clin. Orthop. 39-53.
Abstract: Management of nonunions requires careful and critical assessment of
the true biologic status of the fracture. The mere radiographic persistence of a
fracture line does not invariably indicate nonunion. Ten percent of fractures
considered initially to be ununited in this series healed spontaneously without
further treatment. The patient who has no pain with weight-bearing and no
demonstrable motion on careful stress studies does not usually require further
treatment, except for protection against reinjury. Intraosseous venography may
be useful to distinguish the delayed from the nonunion in order to institute
appropriate and early treatment. Percutaneous direct-current electrostimulation
is proving to be a reliable and effective method of managing the most common
nonunion of the tibia or distal femur. It appears less satisfactory for the more
proximal femoral fractures and for fractures of the humerus. Electrical
stimulation does not eliminate the need to stabilize the nonunion of either the
femur or the upper limb. Electrical stimulation also does not eliminate the need
for bone grafting in approximately 15% to 20% of nonunions. The fractures'
biologic inability to respond may be identifiable by 99MTc diphosphonate bone
scan. The implantable direct-current electrical stimulatory device proved
ineffective in this series. Hopefully, further development of this technology
may produce more consistent results in the future. The electromagnetic
noninvasive stimulator appears to be a useful alternative method to the
semi-invasive system. This, of course, should depend on the individual needs of
the patient and the nature and location of the fracture. Continued technologic
improvement in all electrical stimulatory methods should broaden their
usefulness and applicability. However, the healing status of the fracture and
the processes by which each fracture responds must be carefully assessed to
appreciate what is being effected by electrical stimulation. Critical evaluation
and clarification of indications are essential if the patient is to be offered
the most effective therapy available
Davis R., Houdayer T.,
Andrews B., and Barriskill A. (1999) Paraplegia: prolonged standing using
closed-loop functional electrical stimulation and Andrews ankle-foot orthosis.
Artif. Organs 23, 418-420.
Abstract: One T10 paraplegic male (CS) implanted in 1991 with a Nucleus FES-22
stimulator has been able to achieve closed-loop standing for 1 h. The knee
angles are monitored by electrogoniometers, resulting in the quadriceps
stimulation time being less than 10%. Stance stability is achieved by the
Andrews anterior ankle-foot orthosis (AFO). The use of accelerometers for trunk
inclination and vertical acceleration during controlled stand-to-sit, diminishes
slamming onto the seat. CS does one- handed tasks with objects of 2.2 kg. In
another T10 paraplegic male (FR), surface stimulation was applied over 1.5 years
to both femoral nerves at the groin for conditioning and prolonged standing.
With quadricep conditioning, 55 Nm at 45 degrees of knee flexion is produced.
With the AFO and knee monitoring, FR can stand uninterrupted for up to 70 min
and perform one-handed tasks. In August 1998, he was implanted with the
multifunctional Praxis FES 24-A stimulator for restoration of limb movements,
bladder and bowel function, and pressure sore prevention
Davis S.C. and Ovington L.G.
(1993) Electrical stimulation and ultrasound in wound healing. Dermatol. Clin.
11, 775-781.
Abstract: The events that lead to tissue repair are very complex. Because our
understanding of these processes is increasing in scope, the use of
nontraditional treatment therapies should be considered. Evidence is reported in
the literature that both electrical stimulation and ultrasound therapies may be
beneficial in certain circumstances to heal various wound types. Owing to
clinicians' unfamiliarity with the current research and general understanding of
such therapies, many patients receive only traditional treatment and remain
unexposed to the potential benefits of the nontraditional. With continued
research to better define optimal treatment parameters, improved wound healing
will result
Dayton P.D. and Palladino
S.J. (1989) Electrical stimulation of cutaneous ulcerations. A literature
review. J. Am. Podiatr. Med. Assoc. 79, 318-321.
Abstract: The effect of electrical currents on living cellular systems has been
studied by many researchers and is becoming useful in clinical medicine.
Alteration of cellular activity with externally applied currents can positively
or negatively influence the status of a healing tissue, thereby directing the
healing process to a desired outcome. A review of the literature pertaining to
the effect of electrical currents on tissue healing is presented and the
relevance of this modality to ulcer healing is discussed
de Haas W.G., Lazarovici
M.A., and Morrison D.M. (1979) The effect of low frequency magnetic fields on
the healing of the osteotomized rabbit radius. Clin. Orthop. 245-251.
Abstract: The object of this experimental work was to evaluate the effect of a
noninvasive method of electrical stimulation on the healing of freshly- created
osteotomies of the rabbit radius. The apparatus consisted of a solid core
electromagnet energized by a square wave unidirectional current. The magnetic
field was pulsed transversely across the osteotomy site of the radius while the
animal was confined to a restraining device 6 hours daily for 5 days per week.
In one group of animals the influence of different pulse frequencies, using 0.1
Hz, 1 Hz, and 4 Hz, was evaluated, while the period of stimulation was kept
constant at 2 weeks. In another group of animals, exposure was continued for 3
and 4 weeks while the pulse frequency was kept constant at 1 Hz. Histologic and
radiologic comparison with control animals revealed that the initiation of the
healing process can be accelerated in magnetic fields pulsed at 1 Hz, but that
this effect is not maintained, and that the total period of time required for
union is not significantly shortened. In view of these findings, this form of
treatment is not recommended for clinical use in the treatment of recent
fractures of long bones
de Haas W.G., Watson J., and
Morrison D.M. (1980) Non-invasive treatment of ununited fractures of the tibia
using electrical stimulation. J. Bone Joint Surg. Br. 62-B, 465-470.
Abstract: A non-invasive method of electrical stimulation of healing in ununited
fractures of the tibia by pulsed magnetic fileds has been evaluated. In a series
of 17 patients all but two of the fractures united within 4 to 10 months, with
an average time of just under six months. The method is sufficiently promising
to merit further clinical investigation
de Haas W.G., Beaupre A.,
Cameron H., and English E. (1986) The Canadian experience with pulsed magnetic
fields in the treatment of ununited tibial fractures. Clin. Orthop.
55-58.
Abstract: A clinical survey of 56 patients was conducted at four different
centers in Canada to evaluate the effect of extremely low frequency pulsed
magnetic fields (PMF) on ununited fractures of the tibia. All ten patients with
delayed union and 84% of the 44 patients with nonunion healed. One case with a
traumatic pseudarthrosis and one with a congenital pseudarthrosis failed to
respond to treatment. These results compare favorably to those reported by
others using a system with different pulse characteristics. Prolonged
immobilization is necessary and poses problems of rehabilitation. Nonunions with
a gap between the tibial fragments and pseudarthroses are better treated with
bone grafting and internal fixation prior to electrical stimulation
Dunn A.W. and Rush G.A., III
(1984) Electrical stimulation in treatment of delayed union and nonunion of
fractures and osteotomies. South. Med. J. 77, 1530-1534.
Abstract: This study reviews the cases of 52 patients with 52 ununited fractures
and osteotomies who were treated with two methods of electrical stimulation, one
surgical, the other nonsurgical. Seventeen patients, 14 of whom had concomitant
bone grafting, had implantation of a bone growth stimulator. There were three
synovial pseudarthroses but no active infection in this group. The overall
success rate in healing of the fractures was 82%. Thirty-five patients, of whom
four had initial concomitant bone grafting, were treated with pulsing
electromagnetic fields (PEMF). There were six draining infections but no
pseudarthrosis in this group. Two nonunions healed after bone grafting was
combined with PEMF treatment, when the latter alone had failed. Eighty-one
percent of the fractures united, and drainage ceased in five of the six
infections
Dunn M.G., Doillon C.J.,
Berg R.A., Olson R.M., and Silver F.H. (1988) Wound healing using a collagen
matrix: effect of DC electrical stimulation. J. Biomed. Mater. Res. 22,
191-206.
Abstract: Rapid fibroblast ingrowth and collagen deposition occurs in a
reconstituted type I collagen matrix that is implanted on full- thickness
excised animal dermal wounds. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the
effects of direct current stimulation on dermal fibroblast ingrowth using carbon
fiber electrodes incorporated into a collagen sponge matrix. Preliminary results
suggest that fibroblast ingrowth and collagen fiber alignment are increased in
collagen sponges stimulated with direct currents between 20 and 100 microA.
Maximum fibroblast ingrowth into the collagen sponge is observed near the
cathode at a current of 100 microA. These results suggest that electrical
stimulation combined with a collagen matrix may be a method to enhance the
healing of chronic dermal wounds
Enneking W.F., Eady J.L.,
and Burchardt H. (1980) Autogenous cortical bone grafts in the reconstruction of
segmental skeletal defects. J. Bone Joint Surg. Am. 62, 1039-1058.
Abstract: The results of using segmental cortical autogenous bone grafts to
reconstruct defects created by resection of tumors were analyzed in forty
patients. Thirty-three patients had dual grafts while seven had a single fibular
graft. Dual grafts were used for major bones (humerus, femur, and tibia without
fibula) while single grafts were used for the radius and for the tibia when the
ipsilateral fibula was intact. Thirty patients had good or excellent results;
seven, fair; and three, poor results. In twenty-five patients primary union was
achieved within tweleve months and in two, in twenty months, while twelve
patients required a second, supplementary cancellous graft at the site of non-
union to obtain stability. One patient required removal of an infected graft and
had a poor result. Stress fractures of the grafts occurred in eighteen of the
forty patients after union had occurred. The stress fractures healed in fifteen
of these patients: in six with no treatment (the fracture was identified
retrospectively), in seven with external immobilization, and in two after
bone-grafting of the ununited fracture. There were three persistent non-unions
of stress fractures despite bone-grafting, internal fixation, and electrical
stimulation, and these account for two of the three poor results. The length of
the defect did not affect the incidence of non-union but it did affect the
number of fatigue fractures. The shorter grafts (7.5 to twelve centimeters) were
associated with a 33 per cent incidence of non-union (four non-unions of twelve
grafts) while the longer grafts (twelve to twenty-five centimeters) had a 32 per
cent rate of non-union (nine non- unions of twenty-eight grafts). The incidence
of fatigue fractures in the longer grafts (58 per cent) was much greater than
that in the shorter grafts (17 per cent). The grafts decreased in density during
the first six months but gradually regained their mass and were generally
comparable to normal cortical bone at two years. As the patients became
functiona, most (55 per cent) of the the grafts became more dense than normal,
some (34 per cent) remained the same, and a few (11 per cent) became less dense.
Similarly, some (32 per cent) hypertrophied, most (58 per cent) remained the
same size, and a few (9 per cent) atrophied. There was little morbidity (three
of forty patients) associated with graft procurement. In twelve patients an
additional graft was implanted experimentally, labeled with tetracycline, and
subsequently removed at the time of a secondary procedure. These grafts were
analyzed to determine if human grafts were repaired in the same fashion as
grafts in experimental animals. The studies showed that human grafts are
repaired in the same fashion, but that the sequence takes approximately twice as
long as it does in the dog
Enwemeka C.S. (1989)
Inflammation, cellularity, and fibrillogenesis in regenerating tendon:
implications for tendon rehabilitation. Phys. Ther. 69, 816-825.
Abstract: The initial three weeks of tendon healing were followed via electron
microscopy to elucidate the process of inflammation, fibrillogenesis, and the
cellular and subcellular events in tenotomized Achilles tendons, a model that is
commonly used to determine the biomechanical effects of electrical stimulation,
physical activity, ultrasound, and other forms of physical therapy. The right
Achilles tendons of 18 rabbits were tenotomized, sutured, and immobilized. On
each of postoperative days 5, 7, 12, 15, 18, and 21, the right Achilles tendons
of three experimental rabbits were excised and processed for electron
microscopy. To compare these tendons to normal tendons, the Achilles tendons of
three control rabbits were excised bilaterally without prior tenotomy and
processed for electron microscopy. Electron micrographs thus obtained revealed
1) an initial period of inflammation lasting at least five days, 2) a subsequent
period of fibroplasia and fibrillogenesis, and 3) a third period of progressive
alignment and organization of the collagen fibrils into bundles that were
oriented in the longitudinal axis of the tendon. Although healing in rabbits may
not translate directly to healing in humans, the findings of this study indicate
that healing begins soon after tenotomy and that the regenerating Achilles
tendon undergoes different stages of healing. Because each stage entails a
different set of ultrastructural events, therapeutic interventions should be
modified to address the specific events of each stage
Esterhai J.L., Jr., Brighton
C.T., Heppenstall R.B., and Thrower A. (1986) Nonunion of the humerus. Clinical,
roentgenographic, scintigraphic, and response characteristics to treatment with
constant direct current stimulation of osteogenesis. Clin. Orthop.
228-234.
Abstract: Forty-six trauma patients who had developed non-union of the humerus
were evaluated from 1972 through 1981 as part of a large prospective study on
nonunion. The average age of the 46 patients was 55 years. Women outnumbered men
(29 women and 17 men). Seventy-one percent of the fractures occurred below the
midpoint of the humerus. Inadequate immobilization and/or distraction and
failure of internal fixation devices to obtain and maintain fracture fragment
contiguity and stability was noted. Of the 46 patients referred, 39 were treated
with constant direct current, using percutaneously inserted electrodes. Senile
and disuse osteoporosis (62%), synovial pseudarthrosis (42%), obesity (20%), and
osteomyelitis (5%) in this older patient population made this a difficult
treatment problem. Seventeen patients' nonunions healed (46%). Electrical
stimulation of nonunion of the humerus is not a panacea. Patient selection is
critical
Evans R.D., Foltz D., and
Foltz K. (2001) Electrical stimulation with bone and wound healing. Clin.
Podiatr. Med. Surg. 18, 79-95, vi.
Abstract: Electrical stimulation has been used to heal fractures and ulcers and
reduce pain through modulation of local body processes. It has been recognized
that mechanical forces and bioelectricity have an intimate relationship in
influencing the production of bone. Science has developed techniques to affect
change in the electrical charge of fractures to positively affect the healing
process. Electrical stimulation, through invasive and noninvasive applications,
has produced excellent results in the treatment of nonunions and ulcer care. A
thorough review of the electrical properties of bone and soft tissue and the
influence of electrical stimulation on healing is presented here
Farkas L.G., Herbert M.A.,
and James J.S. (1980) Peritendinous healing after early movement of repaired
flexor tendon: anatomical study. Ann. Plast. Surg. 5, 298-304.
Abstract: In 64 chickens the deep flexor tendon of the third toe was divided and
resutured, preserving the sheath and flexor sublimis tendon. The leg was placed
in a cast for 35 days postoperatively; in some birds minimal flexion of the toes
was induced by electrical stimulation of the deep flexor muscle in the last 17
days of cast immobilization. At day 35 the cast was removed, and the return of
flexion carried out in the third toe was measured up to day 60. Assessment of
the tendon repair site was at 18, 35, and 60 days. Restored peritendinous
connections in specific areas were similar to those in controls. Early movement
resulted in fewer adhesions, a significantly higher incidence of free
intertendinous spaces (standard error of difference = 6.3, difference = 14.5%),
and significant lengthening of bridges between the flexor profundus and phalanx
(p = 0.01). The effect of early movement gradually decreased from the dorsal to
the ventral structures
Feedar J.A., Kloth L.C., and
Gentzkow G.D. (1991) Chronic dermal ulcer healing enhanced with monophasic
pulsed electrical stimulation. Phys. Ther. 71, 639-649.
Abstract: The purposes of this randomized, double-blind, multicenter study were
to compare healing of chronic dermal ulcers treated with pulsed electrical
stimulation with healing of similar wounds treated with sham electrical
stimulation and to evaluate patient tolerance to the therapeutic protocol.
Forty-seven patients, aged 29 to 91 years, with 50 stage II, III, and IV ulcers
were randomly assigned to either a treatment group (n = 26) or a control (sham
treatment) group (n = 24). Treated wounds received 30 minutes of pulsed cathodal
electrical stimulation twice daily at a pulse frequency of 128 pulses per second
(pps) and a peak amplitude of 29.2 mA if the wound contained necrotic tissue or
any drainage that was not serosanguinous. A saline-moistened nontreatment
electrode was applied 30.5 cm (12 in) cephalad from the wound. This protocol was
continued for 3 days after the wound was debrided or exhibited serosanguinous
drainage. Thereafter, the polarity of the treatment electrode on the wound was
changed every 3 days until the wound progressed to a stage II classification.
The pulse frequency was then reduced to 64 pps, and the treatment electrode
polarity was changed daily until the wound was healed. Patients in the control
group were treated with the same protocol, except they received sham electrical
stimulation. After 4 weeks, wounds in the treatment and control groups were 44%
and 67% of their initial size, respectively. The healing rates per week for the
treatment and control groups were 14% and 8.25%, respectively. The results of
this study indicate that pulsed electrical stimulation has a beneficial effect
on healing stage II, III, and IV chronic dermal ulcers
Ferguson A.C., Keating J.F.,
Delargy M.A., and Andrews B.J. (1992) Reduction of seating pressure using FES in
patients with spinal cord injury. A preliminary report. Paraplegia 30,
474-478.
Abstract: The aim of this study was to investigate the use of functional
electrical stimulation (FES) as a means of pressure sore prevention in seated
spinal cord injured (SCI) subjects. Nine SCI subjects took part in tests in
which electrical stimulation was applied to the quadriceps with the lower legs
restrained. Ischial pressures were measured during periods of quiet sitting and
FES application. A strain gauged lever arm was used to measure the knee moment
during quadriceps stimulation. The average pressure drop at the right and left
buttocks was 44 mmHg and 27 mmHg respectively. In general the greatest
reductions occurred in subjects with larger knee moments; however, there was no
direct relationship between the pressure reduction obtained and the quadriceps
strength. This form of FES may be useful as a prophylactic aid in the management
of pressure sores in SCI subjects
Fitzgerald G.K. and Newsome
D. (1993) Treatment of a large infected thoracic spine wound using high voltage
pulsed monophasic current. Phys. Ther. 73, 355-360.
Abstract: This case report describes the use of electrical stimulation with high
voltage pulsed monophasic current for treatment of a large, infected wound of
the thoracic spine, following a surgical debridement procedure. The patient was
a 21-year-old man with spastic quadriplegic cerebral palsy who was dependent for
all self-care and was severely mentally retarded. The initial wound size was as
follows: length = 17 cm, top width = 7.5 cm, middle width = 5.5 cm, bottom width
= 2 cm, and depth = 5 cm. The wound was infected with Staphylococcus aureus. The
initial treatment consisted of 60 minutes of electrical stimulation (20 minutes
of negative polarity followed by 40 minutes of positive polarity) once daily.
The frequency of treatment was increased to twice daily after 2 weeks. Total
treatment duration was 10 weeks. The patient received antibiotic treatment and
daily nursing wound care in addition to electrical stimulation treatment. The
wound was completely closed after 10 weeks of treatment. The possible role of
high voltage pulsed monophasic current in accelerating the wound-healing process
is discussed
Fleischli J.G. and Laughlin
T.J. (1997) Electrical stimulation in wound healing. J. Foot Ankle Surg.
36, 457-461.
Abstract: The authors present a review of the current literature regarding
electrical stimulation with special focus on the merits of its uses in wound
healing. Literature from a basic science, animal studies and clinical
investigations are reviewed. The literature seems to suggest that electrical
stimulation can effect wound healing, but the method of delivery remains
uncertain
Fontanesi G., Traina G.C.,
Giancecchi F., Tartaglia I., Rotini R., Virgili B., Cadossi R., Ceccherelli G.,
and Marino A.A. (1986) Slow healing fractures: can they be prevented? (Results
of electrical stimulation in fibular osteotomies in rats and in diaphyseal
fractures of the tibia in humans). Ital. J. Orthop. Traumatol. 12,
371-385.
Abstract: The purpose of the study was to evaluate the possibility of preventing
delayed union in fractures by the use of low-frequency pulsing electromagnetic
fields (PEMFs). The study was conducted in two parts, both with control groups.
Fibular osteotomies in rats and diaphyseal fractures of the tibia in humans were
treated with and without electrical stimulation (PEMF). The rats were sacrificed
on the 8th and 23rd days respectively in order to evaluate the histological
picture of the repair callus and its mechanical resistance. In the human
subjects, the clinical and radiological follow-up took into account various
factors known to affect the rate of union in the various fracture groups. The
results obtained suggest that PEMF stimulation is capable of accelerating and
modulating the physiological process of union by its favourable effect on
osteogenesis
Forsted D.L., Dalinka M.K.,
Mitchell E., Brighton C.T., and Alavi A. (1978) Radiologic evaluation of the
treatment of nonunion of fractures by electrical stimulation. Radiology
128, 629-634.
Abstract: A procedure is described in which nonunion of fractures is treated by
implantation of electrodes with direct electric current at the site of fracture.
Of 107 patients treated with electrode stimulation, 71 (66%) healed. If one
eliminates 9 cases of congenital pseudoarthrosis and 11 patients treated with
only 10 microamperes of current, 70 of 87 patients (8095%) healed. Severe
osteoporosis and sclerosis were common radiologic findings, but had no value in
predicting which patients would respond to therapy
Frank C., Schachar N.,
Dittrich D., Shrive N., deHaas W., and Edwards G. (1983) Electromagnetic
stimulation of ligament healing in rabbits. Clin. Orthop. 263-272.
Abstract: To evaluate the effect of a specific noninvasive method of electrical
stimulation on ligament healing in rabbits, a solid core electromagnet energized
by a square wave unidirectional current was applied to injured and repaired
medial collateral ligaments seven hours per day, five days per week for
intervals of up to six weeks. Healing was evaluated by gross, histologic,
biochemical, and biomechanical parameters. Stimulation was shown to increase
histologic maturity relatively, restore stiffness and failure strength earlier,
and return collagen content toward normal unoperated values sooner in these
healing ligaments. It is uncertain whether the end point of healing is affected
by this technique, but at six weeks both histologic and biochemical evidence of
acceleration remains. Further investigation into the effect of electromagnetic
stimulation by this and other fields on non-osseous tissues and their components
is indicated
Frenzel P., Kleditzsch J.,
and Kienemund A. (1990) [A procedure for quantitative roentgen image analysis
for follow-up of Harrington scoliosis surgery]. Beitr. Orthop. Traumatol.
37, 117-122.
Abstract: A photometric procedure for evaluating non-standardized X-ray films is
described. The X-ray series of a total of 23 patients operated on because of
idiopathic scoliosis have been measured out. In 16 patients Harrington's method
with dorsal spondylodesis was applied and in 7 patients an electrical
stimulation with an implanted stimulator was additionally employed. A
time-saving effect of about 30 per cent for the osseous consolidation is
obtained by this method. The fundamental suitability of the photometric
procedure can be demonstrated
Fujita M., Hukuda S., and
Doida Y. (1992) The effect of constant direct electrical current on intrinsic
healing in the flexor tendon in vitro. An ultrastructural study of differing
attitudes in epitenon cells and tenocytes. J. Hand Surg. [Br. ] 17,
94-98.
Abstract: Light and electron microscopy were performed in a study of the effects
of electrical stimulation upon the reparative processes in flexor tendons
cultured in vitro. After one or two weeks of incubation, the unstimulated
control tendons were covered with fibroblastic surface cells, thought to have
originated from the epitenon. In contrast, the tendons subjected to electrical
stimulation had no proliferation of the epitenon cells in the surface layer. The
results indicate that electrical currents of low amperage suppress
adhesion-causing synovial proliferation in the epitenon and promote active
collagen synthesis in the tenocytes. This suggests the potential value of
electrical stimulation in the control of adhesion formation after flexor tendon
repair
Gardner S.E., Frantz R.A.,
and Schmidt F.L. (1999) Effect of electrical stimulation on chronic wound
healing: a meta- analysis. Wound. Repair Regen. 7, 495-503.
Abstract: The purpose of this meta-analysis was to quantify the effect of
electrical stimulation on chronic wound healing. Fifteen studies, which included
24 electrical stimulation samples and 15 control samples, were analyzed. The
average rate of healing per week was calculated for the electrical stimulation
and control samples. Ninety-five percentage confidence intervals were also
calculated. The samples were then grouped by type of electrical stimulation
device and chronic wound and reanalyzed. Rate of healing per week was 22% for
electrical stimulation samples and 9% for control samples. The net effect of
electrical stimulation was 13% per week, an increase of 144% over the control
rate. The 95% confidence intervals of the electrical stimulation (18- 26%) and
control samples (3.8-14%) did not overlap. Electrical stimulation was most
effective on pressure ulcers (net effect = 13%). Findings regarding the relative
effectiveness of different types of electrical stimulation device were
inconclusive. Although electrical stimulation produces a substantial improvement
in the healing of chronic wounds, further research is needed to identify which
electrical stimulation devices are most effective and which wounds respond best
to this treatment
Gentzkow G.D. and Miller K.H.
(1991) Electrical stimulation for dermal wound healing. Clin. Podiatr. Med.
Surg. 8, 827-841.
Abstract: The investigations of biologic actions (in vitro, animal, and human)
demonstrated several effects that help explain why electrical stimulation works.
Based on the latest scientific understanding of the wound healing process, one
would expect that a therapy that decreases edema, debrides necrotic tissue,
attracts neutrophils and macrophages, stimulates receptor sites for growth
factors, stimulates growth of fibroblasts and granulation tissue, increases
blood flow, stimulates neurite growth, induces epidermal cell migration,
prevents postischemic oxygen radical-mediated damage, inhibits bacteria, and
reduces numbers of mast cells ought to be beneficial for wound healing. Numerous
human and animal efficacy studies confirm that electrical stimulation of the
proper charge, density, and total energy causes dramatically improved healing of
dermal wounds. As of this writing, no devices have yet been approved by the FDA
for use in wound healing, although several devices approved for other
indications are being used for this purpose. One device (the Staodyn Dermapulse)
has undergone controlled animal and human testing, and an application requesting
approval for treating dermal ulcers has been submitted to FDA. Taken together,
the efficacy studies and the "mechanism of action" studies provide compelling,
scientific evidence that electrical stimulation is safe and effective for
promoting the healing of dermal wounds
Gentzkow G.D. (1993)
Electrical stimulation to heal dermal wounds. J. Dermatol. Surg. Oncol.
19, 753-758.
Abstract: BACKGROUND. Numerous human and animal efficacy studies have
demonstrated that electrical stimulation of the correct charge, density and
total energy causes dramatically improved healing of dermal wounds. The
investigations of biological actions (in vitro, animal, and human) demonstrate
several effects that go a long way to explaining why electrical stimulation
works. OBJECTIVE. To discuss recent research and advances in electrical
stimulation of wound healing. RESULTS. Based on the latest scientific
understanding of the wound healing process, one would expect a beneficial
outcome from a therapy what decreases edema, debrides necrotic tissue, attracts
neutrophils and macrophages, stimulates receptor sites for growth factors,
stimulates growth of fibroblasts and granulation tissue, increases blood flow,
stimulates neurite growth, induces epidermal cell migration, prevents post-
ischemic oxygen radical-mediated damage, inhibits bacteria, and reduces numbers
of mast cells. CONCLUSION. Taken together, the efficacy studies and the
"mechanism of action" studies provide compelling, scientific evidence that
electrical stimulation is safe and effective for promoting the healing of dermal
wounds
Gilcreast D.M., Stotts N.A.,
Froelicher E.S., Baker L.L., and Moss K.M. (1998) Effect of electrical
stimulation on foot skin perfusion in persons with or at risk for diabetic foot
ulcers. Wound. Repair Regen. 6, 434-441.
Abstract: The failure of foot wounds to heal results in 54,000 people with
diabetes having to undergo extremity amputations annually. Therefore, treatment
is needed to speed healing in people with diabetes in order to reduce the need
for amputation. This study tested the effect of high- voltage pulsed current on
foot blood flow in human beings who are at risk for diabetic foot ulcers.
Neuropathy, vascular disease, Wagner Class, glucose, gender, ethnicity, and age
were measured. A sample of 132 subjects was tested using a repeated-measures
design. A baseline transcutaneous oxygen level was obtained; stimulation was
applied, and transcutaneous oxygen measurements were recorded at 30- and 60-
minute time intervals. The grouped foot transcutaneous oxygen levels decreased
(F = 5.66, p =. 0039) following electrical stimulation. Analysis of variance (Scheffe,
p <.05) showed that initial transcutaneous oxygen was significantly higher than
subsequent readings. However, oxygen response was distributed bimodally: 35
(27%) subjects showed increased transcutaneous oxygen (mean 14.8 mm Hg), and 97
(73%) experienced a decreased transcutaneous oxygen reading (mean 12.2 mm Hg).
Logistic regression analysis did not explain these differences. Although this
treatment appears to increase blood flow in a subset of patients, further study
is needed to identify probable mechanisms for this response
Gogia P.P. (1996) Physical
therapy modalities for wound management. Ostomy. Wound. Manage. 42, 46-2,
54.
Abstract: As part of a multidisciplinary team approach to the management of
chronic wounds, physical therapists can add certain physical modalities to the
care plan. Whirlpool, electrical stimulation, ultrasound, low- energy laser and
compression therapy are physical therapy modalities that have been used to
enhance wound healing. All of these modalities are used as adjunct treatments
that, when appropriate, may help shorten the length of treatment and reduce
patient suffering. Because the efficacy of some of these modalities remains to
be established in controlled clinical trials, conventional wound care continues
to be an important part of the team approach
Goh J.C., Bose K., Kang Y.K.,
and Nugroho B. (1988) Effects of electrical stimulation on the biomechanical
properties of fracture healing in rabbits. Clin. Orthop. 268-273.
Abstract: One hundred fifteen white rabbits with an average weight of 2.0 kg
were used to study the influence of electrical stimulation on osteogenesis. They
were divided into three groups: Group I was electrically stimulated with a
constant direct current of 20 microamperes delivered to the fracture site; Group
II was the control group having the same protocol as Group I except that the
stimulator was not switched on; and Group III was the normal fracture healing
group (no introduction of electrodes to the fracture site). Roentgenologic and
histologic assessment showed that new bone formation in the electrical
stimulation group was more exuberant than those in the other two groups in
observation periods from three to eight weeks. However, at 12 weeks no
difference was observed among the three groups. Biomechanical analysis showed
definite increases in the breaking strength and bending stiffness of the
fracture healing tibia in Group I, especially at six weeks after surgery.
However, at 12 weeks no significant difference was observed among the three
groups. Therefore, electrical stimulation of fracture healing has a positive
effect only at the midphase of the healing process, and it does not lead to
faster fracture healing
Gum S.L., Reddy G.K.,
Stehno-Bittel L., and Enwemeka C.S. (1997) Combined ultrasound, electrical
stimulation, and laser promote collagen synthesis with moderate changes in
tendon biomechanics. Am. J. Phys. Med. Rehabil. 76, 288-296.
Abstract: The biomechanical, biochemical, and ultrastructural effects of a
multitherapeutic protocol were studied using regenerating rabbit Achilles
tendons. The multitherapeutic protocol was composed of low- intensity Ga:As
laser photostimulation, low intensity ultrasound, and electrical stimulation.
Achilles tendons of 63 male New Zealand rabbits were tenotomized, sutured,
immobilized, and subjected to the multitherapeutic protocol for five days, after
which casts were removed and the therapy was continued for nine more days
without electrical stimulation. The tendons were excised and compared with
control tendons. Multitherapy treatment produced a 14% increase in maximal
strength, a 42% increase in load-at-break, a 20% increase in maximal stress, a
45% increase in stress-at-break, a 21% increase in maximal strain, and a 14%
increase in strain-at-break. Similarly, multitherapy treatment was associated
with an increase in Young's modulus of elasticity of 31%, an increase in energy
absorption at maximum load of 9%, and an increase in energy absorption at
load-at-break of 11%. Biochemical analysis of the tendons showed an increase of
23% in the total amount of collagen in the multitherapy-treated tendons, with
fewer mature crosslinks (decrease of 6%). Electron micrographs revealed no
ultrastructural or morphologic changes in the tendon fibroblasts or in the
extracellular matrix. The improvements measured in tendons receiving
multitherapy were consistent but less remarkable compared with our earlier works
with single modality protocols. The results warrant the hypothesis that the
beneficial effects of ultrasound and laser photostimulation on tendon healing
may counteract one another when applied simultaneously
Gupta T.D., Jain V.K., and
Tandon P.N. (1991) Comparative study of bone growth by pulsed electromagnetic
fields. Med. Biol. Eng Comput. 29, 113-120.
Abstract: Pulsed electromagnetic fields have been widely used for treatment of
non-united fractures and congenital pseudarthrosis. Several electrical
stimulation systems such as air-cored and iron-cored coils and solenoids have
been used the world over and claimed to be effective. Electrical parameters such
as pulse shape, magnitude and frequency differ widely, and the exact
bone-healing mechanism is still not clearly understood. The study attempts to
analytically investigate the effectiveness of various parameters and suggests an
optimal stimulation waveform. Mathematical analysis of electric fields inside
the bone together with Fourier analysis of induced voltage waveforms produced by
commonly used electrical stimulation wave-forms has been performed. A hypothesis
based on assigning different weightings to different frequencies for osteogenic
response has been proposed. Using this hypothesis astonishingly similar
effective values of electric fields have been found in different systems. It is
shown that effective electric field rather than peak electric field is the main
parameter responsible for osteogenesis. The results are in agreement with
experimental findings made on human beings by different investigators
Guttler P., Kleditzsch J.,
and Schieche A. (1980) [The control of the effect of the electrical stimulation
for the callus formation by means of conductance measurement in the rabbit tibia
after osteotomy]. Z. Exp. Chir 13, 290-296.
Abstract: The measurement of the resistance between the electrodes for
stimulation during the operation shows the electrical field strength in the
osteotomie. This one will recommend for the comparison of the results of
stimulation experiments. The measurement in the course of healing shows faults
at the electrodes and the contacts, whereas as the assertions about the process
of healing are slightly
Han Z.F. and Zhang Y.C.
(1985) [Electrical stimulation in promoting healing of mandibular defects in the
rabbit]. Zhonghua Kou Qiang. Ke. Za Zhi. 20, 32-4, 64.
Hanaoka T. (1983) [The
effects of pulsed micro-electrical currents on internal remodeling in long
tubular bone and bone healing]. Nippon Seikeigeka Gakkai Zasshi 57,
151-166.
Abstract: The effects of pulsed micro-electrical currents on internal remodeling
in the cortex of long tubular bone were evaluated by the following three
experiments. 1. Electrodes were inserted in both femora of 14 adult mongrel
dogs, 15 mm apart, and pulsed micro-electrical current was applied in the right
femoral cortex for 4 weeks, but not in the left femur, which was left as a
control. Dogs were divided into 4 groups; in each of these groups current with
1Hz-10 microA, 0.1 Hz-10 microA, 50 Hz-10 microA and 1Hz-20 microA was applied.
The effects were evaluated by histometric parameters, i.e. number of resorption
cavities (Ar), osteons with osteoid seam (osAf), mineralization rate of osteoid
seam (Mo), and perimeter of osteoid seam (Sf). Number of Ar and osAf increased.
Bone formation rate (Vf) which is the product of osAf, Mo and Sf increased,
especially in the group in which current with 1Hz-10 microA was applied. The
main reason for increase of Vf was considered due to that the activation
frequency in internal remodeling increased by electrical stimulation. 2. A metal
plate was placed on the right humerus, not on the left humerus, both femora of 5
dogs, and electrical current of 1Hz-10 microA was applied in the right femur for
either 12 or 16 weeks. Decrease of internal remodeling tended to take place in
the mid-portion of the plated area of femur, whereas Vf increased by pulsed
micro-electrical currents. Decrease of internal remodeling thus caused by
placing a plate and screws increased by pulsed micro- electrical current. 3.
Number of osteons in the newly formed bone in the osteotomized gap and in the
cortex adjacent to the gap of femora of 7 dogs, which were plated for either 4
or 6 weeks, was measured in longitudinal sections labelled by tetracycline. The
number of osteons increased more in the right femur in which current of 1Hz-10
microA was applied than in the left femur. Based on the results above described,
it was concluded that bone healing was enhanced by pulsed micro- electrical
currents
Harris W.H., Moyen B.J.,
Thrasher E.L., Davis L.A., Cobden R.H., MacKenzie D.A., and Cywinski J.K. (1977)
Differential response to electrical stimulation: a distinction between induced
osteogenesis in intact tibiae and the effect on fresh fracture defects in radii.
Clin. Orthop. 31-40.
Haupt H.A. (1984) Electrical
stimulation of osteogenesis. South. Med. J. 77, 56-64.
Abstract: The three electrical stimulation systems available for treating
nonunion of long bones are successful in approximately 85% of cases. The
percutaneous direct current bone growth stimulator is partially invasive, allows
patient mobility, can be used with magnetic fixation devices, and can be
monitored for proper function, but it requires an operation, cannot be used
where infection exists, and is subject to breakage. The implantable direct
current bone growth stimulator is similar, but is totally invasive. The external
pulsing electromagnetic field bone growth stimulator is noninvasive and can be
used where infection exists, but it requires long, exact patient compliance and
cannot be used with magnetic fixation devices or at certain sites. None of the
systems can be used where synovial pseudarthrosis or a sizeable gap between bone
ends exists, nor are they more effective than bone grafting. Whether their use
might evoke malignant transformation or might accelerate or retard epiphyseal
growth patterns is not known. Many controlled studies are needed before it is
clear how commonly electrical stimulation should be used to treat bony ununion
Hellinger J. and Kleditzsch
J. (1980) Electrical stimulation of the callus formation by means of bipolar
rectangular pulse sequences. Arch. Orthop. Trauma Surg. 96, 241-246.
Abstract: The clinical application of the electrical stimulation, lasting
several weeks, for the callus formation is reported in 11 patients. Bipolar
rectangular pulse sequences were used for the stimulation at a frequency of 1 Hz
and a current intensity of +/-20mu amp. The electrical stimulation was
successfully employed after distraction osteotomies with a KDA-apparatus in
shortening of the leg provoked by different causes or in the treatment of
pseudarthroses. The realignment of the newly formed callus and the osseous
consolidation are stimulated and speeded up by the bipolar rectangular pulse
sequences as it is also shown in the light of the roentgenograms of a case
Houghton P.E. and Campbell
K.E. (1999) Choosing an adjunctive therapy for the treatment of chronic wounds.
Ostomy. Wound. Manage. 45, 43-52.
Abstract: Adjunctive therapies such as ultrasound, laser, ultraviolet light,
superficial heating, pulsed electromagnetic fields, and electrical stimulation
have all been indicated in the treatment of chronic wounds. The purpose of this
article is to outline the issues a healthcare professional must consider when
choosing the best adjunctive therapy for a chronic wound. It summarizes the
effects of therapeutic modalities on the wound healing process, analyzes the
clinical research evidence, discusses practical considerations, and reviews
indications, contraindications, precautions, and safety considerations. Finally,
an algorithm is presented to help guide the clinician in selecting a modality.
In summary, research evidence exists in the literature that suggests these
adjunctive therapies can directly stimulate new tissue growth, augment wound
tissue strength, improve local circulation and oxygenation, reduce edema, and/or
inhibit bacterial growth. Electrical stimulation and ultrasound are the only
therapeutic modalities that currently have sufficient clinical research evidence
to support their use in the treatment of chronic wounds. Practical issues such
as cost, time and training required, and patient and therapist safety concerns,
will ultimately influence the selection of these modalities
Il'inskii O.B., Lebedev
V.P., Savchenko A.B., Solov'eva A.I., and Spevak S.E. (1987) [Effect of
transcranial non-invasive stimulation of the antinociceptive structures of the
brain on processes of repair]. Fiziol. Zh. SSSR Im I. M. Sechenova 73,
223-229.
Abstract: Transcranial electrical stimulation (AC + DC) of antinociceptive brain
structures causing the maximal analgetic effect accelerated skin-wound healing
in rats. The effect being completely blocked with naloxone. Participation of
opioidergic, antinociceptive brain structures in wound healing and maintenance
of structural homeostasis, is discussed
Jivegard L., Augustinsson
L.E., Carlsson C.A., and Holm J. (1987) Long-term results by epidural spinal
electrical stimulation (ESES) in patients with inoperable severe lower limb
ischaemia. Eur. J. Vasc. Surg. 1, 345-349.
Abstract: Arterial reconstruction is the treatment of choice for patients with
severe lower limb ischaemia, but may at times be technically impossible.
Thirty-two consecutive patients with impending (n = 24) or already established
(n = 8) distal arteriosclerotic or diabetic lower limb gangrene, in whom
vascular surgery was either technically impossible or had failed, were treated
with epidural spinal electrical stimulation (ESES) for 27 +/- 16 (S.D.) months.
All patients had severe rest pain, which was reduced by ESES in 91% of the
cases. Improved ulcer healing was noted in 58% of the patients who had skin
ulceration. Eighty-three percent of those patients who did not have established
gangrene when ESES was started, retained their leg after 1 year, and 54% after 3
years. These results suggest that ESES often provides pain relief and improves
skin healing in patients with impending arteriosclerotic or diabetic gangrene in
whom vascular surgery is impossible or has failed. Epidural spinal electrical
stimulation (ESES) does not affect the progression of established gangrene but
may provide pain relief. The observed outcome of severe limb ischaemia in this
study could be used to compare with those after arterial reconstruction
performed in patients with poor run-off vessels, and may allow us to examine the
natural history of this disease when adequate pain relief is provided. The
results reported here and the previously reported enhancement of cutaneous blood
flow in severely ischaemic extremities by ESES may suggest, that ESES enhances
limb salvage by improving skin blood flow
Johnson E.E., Urist M.R.,
and Finerman G.A. (1992) Resistant nonunions and partial or complete segmental
defects of long bones. Treatment with implants of a composite of human bone
morphogenetic protein (BMP) and autolyzed, antigen-extracted, allogeneic (AAA)
bone. Clin. Orthop. 229-237.
Abstract: Twenty-five patients with resistant nonunions including partial or
complete segmental defects were treated with a composite alloimplant of human
bone morphogenetic protein (h-BMP) and autolyzed, antigen-free, allogeneic bone
(AAA). The series consisted of 16 females and nine males; average age was 45
years. Preoperative symptoms averaged 30 months (range, five to 83 months); 22
of 25 patients had failed multiple attempts at electrical stimulation.
Twenty-three of 25 patients had an average of three prior failed surgical
attempts at union (range, one to ten). There were ten segmental defects with an
average length of 4 cm (range, 2-9 cm). The composite implant was incorporated
as an onlay in 15 extremities and as an inlay graft supported by internal
fixation in ten extremities. Seven patients received supplementary autogeneic
cancellous bone grafting. Average healing time was six months (range, three to
14 months). Average follow- up time was 21 months (range, five to 82 months).
Functional results were rated as excellent, 14; good, five; and fair, five. One
failed to unite because of a recurrent infection. Union was obtained in 24 of 25
patients. There were five failures of the original operation that required
reoperations; union eventually occurred in four of five extremities by repeat
composite grafting and replacement of the failed internal fixation. Bony union
between host bone and the composite implant began at an average of eight weeks
postoperatively. Present results indicate that h-BMP/AAA composite implants
represent adjunctive treatment of difficult nonunions. The h-BMP/AAA composite
implants may be implanted in either partial or complete segmental defects of
long bones.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
Jorgensen T.E. (1977)
Electrical stimulation of human fracture healing by means of a slow pulsating,
asymmetrical direct current. Clin. Orthop. 124-127.
Abstract: Twenty-eight tibial fractures were treated with external fixation by
means of a Hoffmann apparatus. Through two electrode-screws in the Hoffmann
apparatus a slowly pulsating, asymmetrical direct current was applied to the
fracture site in each patient. The stimulated patients experienced a 30 per cent
acceleration in healing as determined by mechanically stressing the Hoffmann
apparatus used for immobilization of the fracture
Kahanovitz N. and Arnoczky
S.P. (1990) The efficacy of direct current electrical stimulation to enhance
canine spinal fusions. Clin. Orthop. 295-299.
Abstract: A prospective experimental study was devised to examine the effect of
direct current electrical stimulation on the healing of lumbar spinal fusions.
Twelve mongrel dogs had posterior facet fusion bilaterally at L1-L2 and L4-L5. A
direct current electrical stimulator was placed through each facet fusion.
One-half of the electrodes were functional, while the remainder served as
controls. Two animals were killed at two and four weeks, and four animals were
killed at six and 12 weeks, postoperatively. Each facet fusion was evaluated
using high-resolution roentgenograms and routine histology. In the two-, four-,
and six-week specimens, there was little difference in the roentgenographic or
histologic appearance of the control and stimulated fusions. However, by 12
weeks, all eight stimulated facet joints showed roentgenographic and histologic
evidence of solid bony fusion, but none of the eight control facet joints
demonstrated osseous bridging of the fusion site. The results of this study
suggest that direct current electrical stimulation appears to enhance the bony
union of facet fusions in the canine lumbar spine
Kahanovitz N. (1996) Spine
update. The use of adjunctive electrical stimulation to enhance the healing of
spine fusions. Spine 21, 2523-2525.
Abstract: The use of electrical stimulation as an adjunct to enhance lumbar
spinal fusion continues to gain popularity. The different types of electrical
stimulation and their varying effects on posterior and anterior spinal fusion
are discussed. The selection of an electrical stimulation device should be based
on the clinical and experimental evidence of efficacy
Kambic H.E., Reyes E.,
Manning T., Waters K.C., and Reger S.I. (1993) Influence of AC and DC electrical
stimulation on wound healing in pigs: a biomechanical analysis. J. Invest
Surg. 6, 535-543.
Abstract: To evaluate the effects of electrical stimulation on the mechanical
properties of healing skin, 20 Hanford mini-pigs weighing 10-15 kg with
trochanteric pressure ulcers were subjected to electrical stimulation.
Examination of the biomechanical properties of the skin and changes in wound
area and volume was done on previously wounded and healing pigskin subject to AC
or DC electrical stimulation. The behavior of normal pigskin was compared to (1)
denervated controls, (2) denervated AC-stimulated skin, and (3) denervated
DC-stimulated skin. A denervated limb trochanteric pressure sore model developed
in house permitted the use of a 6.5-mm percutaneous cancellous screw for wound
formation and a 3-cm-diameter spring compression indentor to create reproducible
and uniformly controlled grade 3 or higher tissue ulcers in the monoplegic hind
limbs. Denervation was accomplished by right unilateral extradural rhizotomies
from L2 to S1 nerve roots. Electrodes were placed 1 cm distal and proximal to
the wound periphery, and wounds were stimulated 2 h/day, 5 days/week for 30
days. Dumbbell-shaped skin specimens with a length to width ratio of 3:1 were
uniaxially loaded in tension until failure at an extension rate of 150 mm/min.
The stiffness values for skin samples oriented parallel to the current flow were
reduced by nearly half the values obtained for normal controls. Statistical
differences (P < .05) were found for stress, Young modulus, and stiffness when
compared to normal skin. Samples oriented in the perpendicular direction were
comparable to normal skin (P = NS).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
Kambic H.E., Reyes E.,
Manning T., Waters K.C., and Reger S.I. (1993) Influence of AC and DC electrical
stimulation on wound healing in pigs: a biomechanical analysis. J. Invest
Surg. 6, 535-543.
Abstract: To evaluate the effects of electrical stimulation on the mechanical
properties of healing skin, 20 Hanford mini-pigs weighing 10-15 kg with
trochanteric pressure ulcers were subjected to electrical stimulation.
Examination of the biomechanical properties of the skin and changes in wound
area and volume was done on previously wounded and healing pigskin subject to AC
or DC electrical stimulation. The behavior of normal pigskin was compared to (1)
denervated controls, (2) denervated AC-stimulated skin, and (3) denervated
DC-stimulated skin. A denervated limb trochanteric pressure sore model developed
in house permitted the use of a 6.5-mm percutaneous cancellous screw for wound
formation and a 3-cm-diameter spring compression indentor to create reproducible
and uniformly controlled grade 3 or higher tissue ulcers in the monoplegic hind
limbs. Denervation was accomplished by right unilateral extradural rhizotomies
from L2 to S1 nerve roots. Electrodes were placed 1 cm distal and proximal to
the wound periphery, and wounds were stimulated 2 h/day, 5 days/week for 30
days. Dumbbell-shaped skin specimens with a length to width ratio of 3:1 were
uniaxially loaded in tension until failure at an extension rate of 150 mm/min.
The stiffness values for skin samples oriented parallel to the current flow were
reduced by nearly half the values obtained for normal controls. Statistical
differences (P # .05) were found for stress, Young modulus, and stiffness when
compared to normal skin. Samples oriented in the perpendicular direction were
comparable to normal skin (P = NS).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
Kernahan D.A. (1978) Muscle
repair in unilateral cleft lip, based on findings on electrical stimulation.
Ann. Plast. Surg. 1, 48-53.
Abstract: The appearances, distribution, and direction of muscle in the
unilateral cleft lip as indicated by electrical stimulation are described. The
findings differ from those reported by Fara and associates in their dissections
in that functionally the fibers do not appear to parallel the margin of the
cleft. Based on these findings, a method of layer-by-layer, step-by-step closure
of the unilateral cleft lip is described that attempts to split the orbicularis
bulge and advance the lateral muscle into the philtrum to a position more nearly
imitating the direction and extent of the muscle in a normal lip
Khalil Z. and Merhi M.
(2000) Effects of aging on |